Limitations of Wada memory asymmetry as a predictor of outcomes after temporal lobectomy

Background: The intracarotid amobarbital (Wada) test can be used to evaluate hemispheric memory capacity before anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL). Most patients demonstrate better memory with injection ipsilateral to planned resection (expected asymmetry [EA]), but a substantial minority show better memory with contralateral injection (unexpected asymmetry [UA]). Both degree and direction of Wada memory asymmetry (WMA) have been associated with worse surgical outcome in small series. Reports also suggest that UA is associated with greater decline in verbal memory after left ATL (L-ATL). Methods: The relationship between WMA and surgical outcome (at 3 months, 1 year, and last follow-up) was examined in a large group of ATL patients (108 L, 119 R) with both EA and UA. Also, memory in a subgroup (96 L, 108 R) was examined, comparing subscores of the Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test obtained preoperatively, at 3 months, and at 1 year. Results: Thirty-six percent of L-ATL and 8% of R-ATL patients had UA. UA was associated with worse surgical outcome at 1 year for R-ATL patients but was not associated with worse outcome for L-ATL patients. There was no correlation between WMA and persistent postoperative verbal memory change for patients with L- or R-ATL. Conclusions: Unexpected asymmetry is uncommon in patients with right anterior temporal lobectomy (R-ATL) and may be a risk marker of poor surgical outcome. This relationship may be obscured by language confounds in patients with L-ATL. The results suggest that Wada asymmetry (using mixed stimuli) does not predict postoperative verbal memory; it is unclear whether this finding is generalizable to centers using only nonverbal stimuli.

[1]  Gregory P. Lee,et al.  Prediction of Verbal Memory Decline after Epilepsy Surgery in Children: Effectiveness of Wada Memory Asymmetries , 2005, Epilepsia.

[2]  G. Alarcón,et al.  Neuropsychological effects associated with temporal lobectomy and amygdalohippocampectomy depending on Wada test failure , 2004, Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry.

[3]  M. Merschhemke,et al.  Memory assessment during the intracarotid amobarbital procedure , 2003, Neurology.

[4]  H. Topka,et al.  Frequency and phenotypic variability of the GAG deletion of the DYT1 gene in an unselected group of patients with dystonia. , 2003, Archives of neurology.

[5]  D. Spencer,et al.  Long-term seizure outcome in patients initially seizure-free after resective epilepsy surgery , 2003, Neurology.

[6]  W. Pilcher,et al.  Predicting verbal memory decline following anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) , 2003, Neurology.

[7]  W. Marsh,et al.  Prognostic Implications of Seizure Recurrence in the First Year after Anterior Temporal Lobectomy , 2003, Epilepsia.

[8]  Gregory P. Lee,et al.  Effect of Wada methodology in predicting lateralized memory impairment in pediatric epilepsy surgery candidates , 2002, Epilepsy & Behavior.

[9]  Stephen T. C. Wong,et al.  Application of Information Technology: Design and Applications of a Multimodality Image Data Warehouse Framework , 2002, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[10]  Mark S. Seidenberg,et al.  Memory Outcome after Left Anterior Temporal Lobectomy in Patients with Expected and Reversed Wada Memory Asymmetry Scores , 2001, Epilepsia.

[11]  N. Chiaravalloti,et al.  Material‐Specific Memory Changes after Anterior Temporal Lobectomy as Predicted by the Intracarotid Amobarbital Test , 2001, Epilepsia.

[12]  K. Kanemoto,et al.  Lateralized memory deficits on the Wada test correlate with the side of lobectomy only for patients with unilateral medial temporal lobe epilepsy , 1999, Seizure.

[13]  David C. Alsop,et al.  Functional MRI and the Wada test provide complementary information for predicting post-operative seizure control , 1999, Seizure.

[14]  Pll Siinksen,et al.  Control , 1999, Netherlands Journal of Plant Pathology.

[15]  C. Wierenga,et al.  Wada difference a day makes , 1999, Neurology.

[16]  R. Kuzniecky,et al.  Individual Memory Change After Anterior Temporal Lobectomy: A Base Rate Analysis Using Regression‐Based Outcome Methodology , 1998, Epilepsia.

[17]  H. Lüders,et al.  Empirical methods for assessing meaningful neuropsychological change following epilepsy surgery , 1996, Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society.

[18]  K. Foley,et al.  Relation Between Intracarotid Amobarbital Memory Asymmetry Scores and Hippocampal Sclerosis in Patients Undergoing Anterior Temporal Lobe Resections , 1996, Epilepsia.

[19]  Gregory P. Lee,et al.  Wada memory asymmetries predict verbal memory decline after anterior temporal lobectomy , 1995, Neurology.

[20]  A. Saykin,et al.  Predictors of outcome after anterior temporal lobectomy , 1994, Neurology.

[21]  Gregory P. Lee,et al.  Wada memory performance predicts seizure outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy , 1994, Neurology.

[22]  H. Lüders,et al.  Intracarotid Amobarbital Procedure: II. Lateralizing Value in Evaluation for Temporal Lobectomy , 1991, Epilepsia.

[23]  H. Lüders,et al.  Intracarotid Amobarbital Procedure: I. Prediction of Decreased Modality‐Specific Memory Scores After Temporal Lobectomy , 1991, Epilepsia.

[24]  J. Zentner,et al.  Surgical treatment of epilepsies. , 2002, Acta neurochirurgica. Supplement.

[25]  G. Chelune.  Hippocampal adequacy versus functional reserve: predicting memory functions following temporal lobectomy. , 1995, Archives of clinical neuropsychology : the official journal of the National Academy of Neuropsychologists.