Systematic review of the effectiveness of health-related behavioral interventions using portable activity sensing devices (PASDs)

Background Portable activity sensing devices (PASDs) have received significant interest as tools for objectively measuring activity-related parameters and promoting health-related outcomes. Studies of PASDs suggest the potential value of integrating them with behavioral interventions to improve intermediate and downstream clinical outcomes. Objectives This systematic review describes and evaluates evidence from controlled studies of interventions using PASDs on their effectiveness in health-related outcomes. Study quality was also assessed. Methods A systematic literature search was performed of MEDLINE, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, PsycINFO, EMBASE, and CINAHL databases. We included English-language papers of controlled trials through 2015 reporting the effectiveness of PASDs in improving health-related outcomes in any population. We extracted and analyzed data on study characteristics including design, target population, interventions, and findings. Results Seventeen trials met the inclusion criteria from a total of 9553 unique records. Study objectives varied greatly, but most sought to increase physical activity. Studies with a "passive" intervention arm using a PASD with minimal behavioral support generally did not demonstrate effectiveness in improving health-related outcomes. Interventions integrating PASDs with multiple behavioral change techniques were more likely to be effective, particularly for intermediate outcomes such as physical activity and weight loss. Trials had small sample sizes but were generally free of bias, except for blinding and selection bias. Conclusion There is insufficient evidence to draw a conclusion about the general health-related benefits of PASD interventions. PASD interventions may improve intermediate outcomes when coupled with multiple behavioral change techniques. Devices alone or with minimal behavioral change support are insufficient to change health-related outcomes.

[1]  K. Volpp,et al.  Accuracy of smartphone applications and wearable devices for tracking physical activity data. , 2015, JAMA.

[2]  K. Newton,et al.  Pedometers and Text Messaging to Increase Physical Activity , 2009, Diabetes Care.

[3]  A. Bauman,et al.  Effects of a Pedometer‐Based Intervention on Physical Activity Levels After Cardiac Rehabilitation: A RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL , 2009, Journal of cardiopulmonary rehabilitation and prevention.

[4]  Upkar Varshney,et al.  Pervasive Healthcare and Wireless Health Monitoring , 2007, Mob. Networks Appl..

[5]  Heidi Sveistrup,et al.  Motor rehabilitation using virtual reality , 2004, Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation.

[6]  B. Djulbegovic,et al.  Bad reporting does not mean bad methods for randomised trials: observational study of randomised controlled trials performed by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group , 2004, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[7]  C. Matthews,et al.  Best practices for using physical activity monitors in population-based research. , 2012, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[8]  P. Krebs,et al.  Health App Use Among US Mobile Phone Owners: A National Survey , 2015, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[9]  Catrine Tudor-Locke,et al.  A Catalog of Rules, Variables, and Definitions Applied to Accelerometer Data in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 2003–2006 , 2012, Preventing chronic disease.

[10]  M. Dew,et al.  A Randomized Controlled Trial of a Mobile Health Intervention to Promote Self‐Management After Lung Transplantation , 2016, American journal of transplantation : official journal of the American Society of Transplantation and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons.

[11]  B. Ainsworth,et al.  The current state of physical activity assessment tools. , 2015, Progress in cardiovascular diseases.

[12]  D. Moher,et al.  CONSORT 2010 Statement: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials , 2010, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[13]  M. Decramer,et al.  Quantifying physical activity in daily life with questionnaires and motion sensors in COPD , 2006, European Respiratory Journal.

[14]  Misha Pavel,et al.  Behavioral Informatics and Computational Modeling in Support of Proactive Health Management and Care , 2015, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[15]  J. Coresh,et al.  mActive: A Randomized Clinical Trial of an Automated mHealth Intervention for Physical Activity Promotion , 2015, Journal of the American Heart Association.

[16]  D. Gustafson,et al.  Impact of a patient-centered, computer-based health information/support system. , 1999, American journal of preventive medicine.

[17]  D. Moher,et al.  Use of the CONSORT statement and quality of reports of randomized trials: a comparative before-and-after evaluation. , 2001, JAMA.

[18]  B. Winblad,et al.  Leisure-time physical activity at midlife and the risk of dementia and Alzheimer's disease , 2005, The Lancet Neurology.

[19]  Judith Wylie-Rosett,et al.  Diet and Lifestyle Recommendations Revision 2006: A Scientific Statement From the American Heart Association Nutrition Committee , 2006, Circulation.

[20]  Michael Catt,et al.  Effects of a Web-Based Intervention on Physical Activity and Metabolism in Older Adults: Randomized Controlled Trial , 2013, Journal of medical Internet research.

[21]  Ashok Balasubramanyam,et al.  Accelerometer Feedback to Promote Physical Activity in Adults with Type 2 Diabetes: A Pilot Study , 2005, Perceptual and motor skills.

[22]  Mark A Pereira,et al.  Physical Activity, Falls, and Fractures Among Older Adults: A Review of the Epidemiologic Evidence , 2000, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[23]  Todd R. Johnson,et al.  A user-centered framework for redesigning health care interfaces , 2005, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[24]  Yoshimi Fukuoka,et al.  mHealth Physical Activity Intervention: A Randomized Pilot Study in Physically Inactive Pregnant Women , 2016, Maternal and Child Health Journal.

[25]  J. Sterne,et al.  The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials , 2011, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[26]  L. Kolonel,et al.  Associations of sedentary lifestyle, obesity, smoking, alcohol use, and diabetes with the risk of colorectal cancer. , 1997, Cancer research.

[27]  Michael Schwenk,et al.  Sensor-Based Interactive Balance Training with Visual Joint Movement Feedback for Improving Postural Stability in Diabetics with Peripheral Neuropathy: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2015, Gerontology.

[28]  Renee F Wilson,et al.  Enabling patient-centered care through health information technology. , 2012, Evidence report/technology assessment.

[29]  P. Abedi,et al.  Effect of physical activity intervention based on a pedometer on physical activity level and anthropometric measures after childbirth: a randomized controlled trial , 2011, BMC pregnancy and childbirth.

[30]  Josette F. Jones,et al.  The Impact of Information Technology on Patient Engagement and Health Behavior Change: A Systematic Review of the Literature , 2016, JMIR medical informatics.

[31]  Stephen B. Johnson,et al.  Grounding a new information technology implementation framework in behavioral science: a systematic analysis of the literature on IT use , 2003, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[32]  J. Prochaska,et al.  A meta-analysis of computer-tailored interventions for health behavior change. , 2010, Preventive medicine.

[33]  L. Piwek,et al.  The Rise of Consumer Health Wearables: Promises and Barriers , 2016, PLoS medicine.

[34]  Andrew Milat,et al.  Computer-tailored physical activity behavior change interventions targeting adults: a systematic review , 2009, The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity.

[35]  Audie A Atienza,et al.  A review of eHealth interventions for physical activity and dietary behavior change. , 2007, American journal of preventive medicine.

[36]  Morwenna Kirwan,et al.  Diabetes Self-Management Smartphone Application for Adults With Type 1 Diabetes: Randomized Controlled Trial , 2013, Journal of medical Internet research.

[37]  Elizabeth J Lyons,et al.  Behavior Change Techniques Implemented in Electronic Lifestyle Activity Monitors: A Systematic Content Analysis , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[38]  M. Marcus,et al.  Effect of Wearable Technology Combined With a Lifestyle Intervention on Long-term Weight Loss: The IDEA Randomized Clinical Trial. , 2016, JAMA.

[39]  Michael Schwenk,et al.  Interactive Sensor-Based Balance Training in Older Cancer Patients with Chemotherapy-Induced Peripheral Neuropathy: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2015, Gerontology.

[40]  Peter Jüni,et al.  Quality of reporting of randomized trials as a measure of methodologic quality. , 2002, JAMA.

[41]  J Brug,et al.  The application and impact of computer-generated personalized nutrition education: a review of the literature. , 1999, Patient education and counseling.

[42]  A. Haines,et al.  The Effectiveness of Mobile-Health Technology-Based Health Behaviour Change or Disease Management Interventions for Health Care Consumers: A Systematic Review , 2013, PLoS medicine.

[43]  Belong Cho,et al.  The Effectiveness of Mobile Phone-Based Care for Weight Control in Metabolic Syndrome Patients: Randomized Controlled Trial , 2015, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[44]  Robert L Kane,et al.  Reporting in randomized clinical trials improved after adoption of the CONSORT statement. , 2007, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[45]  G A Colditz,et al.  Physical activity and television watching in relation to risk for type 2 diabetes mellitus in men. , 2001, Archives of internal medicine.

[46]  F. Pitta,et al.  Short-Term Effects of Using Pedometers to Increase Daily Physical Activity in Smokers: A Randomized Trial , 2012, Respiratory Care.

[47]  Yvonne Rogers,et al.  Interaction Design: Beyond Human-Computer Interaction , 2002 .

[48]  David R Bassett,et al.  Device-based monitoring in physical activity and public health research , 2012, Physiological measurement.

[49]  P. Scheltens,et al.  Association of gait and balance disorders with age-related white matter changes , 2008, Neurology.

[50]  J. Bruce German,et al.  A Feasibility Study of Wearable Activity Monitors for Pre-Adolescent School-Age Children , 2014, Preventing chronic disease.

[51]  J F Sallis,et al.  Behavioral science research in diabetes: lifestyle changes related to obesity, eating behavior, and physical activity. , 2001, Diabetes care.

[52]  Blair T. Johnson,et al.  Computer-delivered interventions for health promotion and behavioral risk reduction: a meta-analysis of 75 randomized controlled trials, 1988-2007. , 2008, Preventive medicine.

[53]  Audie A Atienza,et al.  Mobile health technology evaluation: the mHealth evidence workshop. , 2013, American journal of preventive medicine.

[54]  T. Bickmore,et al.  A Randomized Controlled Trial of an Automated Exercise Coach for Older Adults , 2013, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[55]  Laura Rocchi,et al.  Feasibility and effects of home-based smartphone-delivered automated feedback training for gait in people with Parkinson's disease: A pilot randomized controlled trial. , 2016, Parkinsonism & related disorders.

[56]  S. Cummings,et al.  Correlates of Impaired Function in Older Women , 1994 .

[57]  W. Zijlstra,et al.  Wearable systems for monitoring mobility-related activities in older people: a systematic review , 2008, Clinical rehabilitation.

[58]  J. Hardin,et al.  Electronic feedback in a diet- and physical activity-based lifestyle intervention for weight loss: a randomized controlled trial , 2011, The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity.

[59]  Catrine Tudor-Locke,et al.  Utility of Pedometers for Assessing Physical Activity , 2004, Sports medicine.

[60]  M. Tremblay,et al.  A comparison of direct versus self-report measures for assessing physical activity in adults: a systematic review , 2008, The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity.

[61]  A. Fader,et al.  Endometrial cancer and obesity: epidemiology, biomarkers, prevention and survivorship. , 2009, Gynecologic oncology.

[62]  W. McIlroy,et al.  Use of Accelerometer-Based Feedback of Walking Activity for Appraising Progress With Walking-Related Goals in Inpatient Stroke Rehabilitation , 2015, Neurorehabilitation and neural repair.

[63]  W. van Mechelen,et al.  Clinimetric review of motion sensors in children and adolescents. , 2006, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[64]  I. Olkin,et al.  Using pedometers to increase physical activity and improve health: a systematic review. , 2007, JAMA.

[65]  Lora Giangregorio,et al.  Behavior Change Techniques Present in Wearable Activity Trackers: A Critical Analysis , 2016, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[66]  J. Després,et al.  Abdominal obesity and metabolic syndrome , 2006, Nature.

[67]  D. Johnston,et al.  Do Pedometers Increase Physical Activity in Sedentary Older Women? A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2010, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[68]  M. Adams,et al.  An Adaptive Physical Activity Intervention for Overweight Adults: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2013, PloS one.

[69]  D. Moher,et al.  Does the CONSORT checklist improve the quality of reports of randomised controlled trials? A systematic review , 2006, The Medical journal of Australia.

[70]  Kathleen M. Griffiths,et al.  Effectiveness of mobile technologies delivering Ecological Momentary Interventions for stress and anxiety: a systematic review , 2016, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[71]  C. Quinn,et al.  WellDoc mobile diabetes management randomized controlled trial: change in clinical and behavioral outcomes and patient and physician satisfaction. , 2008, Diabetes technology & therapeutics.

[72]  ANNETTE DE VITO DABBS,et al.  User-Centered Design and Interactive Health Technologies for Patients , 2009, Computers, informatics, nursing : CIN.

[73]  W. Nilsen,et al.  Health behavior models in the age of mobile interventions: are our theories up to the task? , 2011, Translational behavioral medicine.

[74]  J. Cafazzo,et al.  Design of an mHealth App for the Self-management of Adolescent Type 1 Diabetes: A Pilot Study , 2012, Journal of medical Internet research.

[75]  Merryn J Mathie,et al.  Accelerometry: providing an integrated, practical method for long-term, ambulatory monitoring of human movement , 2004, Physiological measurement.