Pretense, Counterfactuals, and Bayesian Causal Models: Why What Is Not Real Really Matters

Young children spend a large portion of their time pretending about non-real situations. Why? We answer this question by using the framework of Bayesian causal models to argue that pretending and counterfactual reasoning engage the same component cognitive abilities: disengaging with current reality, making inferences about an alternative representation of reality, and keeping this representation separate from reality. In turn, according to causal models accounts, counterfactual reasoning is a crucial tool that children need to plan for the future and learn about the world. Both planning with causal models and learning about them require the ability to create false premises and generate conclusions from these premises. We argue that pretending allows children to practice these important cognitive skills. We also consider the prevalence of unrealistic scenarios in children's play and explain how they can be useful in learning, despite appearances to the contrary.

[1]  R. Byrne Précis of The Rational Imagination: How People Create Alternatives to Reality , 2007, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[2]  J. Tenenbaum,et al.  A tutorial introduction to Bayesian models of cognitive development , 2011, Cognition.

[3]  A. Gopnik,et al.  Causal learning across domains. , 2004, Developmental psychology.

[4]  Shaun Nichols,et al.  The architecture of the imagination : new essays on pretence, possibility, and fiction , 2006 .

[5]  J. Tenenbaum,et al.  Probabilistic models of cognition: exploring representations and inductive biases , 2010, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[6]  A. Lillard,et al.  Pretend play skills and the child's theory of mind. , 1993, Child development.

[7]  Richard J. Gerrig,et al.  What readers bring to the processing of fictional texts , 1997 .

[8]  Paul L. Harris,et al.  Monsters, ghosts and witches: Testing the limits of the fantasy-reality distinction in young children. , 1991 .

[9]  Marjorie Taylor,et al.  Children's ability to distinguish fantasy events from real-life events , 1994 .

[10]  P. Bloom,et al.  What does Batman think about SpongeBob? Children's understanding of the fantasy/fantasy distinction , 2006, Cognition.

[11]  K. Turley-Ames,et al.  Preschoolers' generation of different types of counterfactual statements and theory of mind understanding , 2004 .

[12]  H. Wellman,et al.  Young children's understanding of realities, nonrealities, and appearances. , 1990, Child development.

[13]  Elizabeth J Marsh,et al.  Learning errors from fiction: Difficulties in reducing reliance on fictional stories , 2006, Memory & cognition.

[14]  Claire Golomb,et al.  On the transition from pretence play to reality: What are the rules of the game? , 1996 .

[15]  J. Tenenbaum,et al.  Two proposals for causal grammars , 2007 .

[16]  G. Fein Pretend play in childhood: An integrative review. , 1981 .

[17]  Lisa Zunshine,et al.  Why We Read Fiction: Theory of Mind and the Novel , 2006 .

[18]  A. Gopnik,et al.  Young Children's Understanding of Changes in Their Mental States. , 1991 .

[19]  A. Dickinson,et al.  Planning for the future by western scrub-jays , 2007, Nature.

[20]  Peter Mitchell,et al.  Beyond really and truly: Children’s counterfactual thinking about pretend and possible worlds , 2014 .

[21]  C. Copeland Truth or Fiction , 2011 .

[22]  J. Woolley,et al.  Development of beliefs about storybook reality. , 2007, Developmental science.

[23]  M. Corballis,et al.  The evolution of foresight: What is mental time travel, and is it unique to humans? , 2007, The Behavioral and brain sciences.

[24]  Judy S. DeLoache,et al.  Transfer between Picture Books and the Real World by Very Young Children , 2008 .

[25]  Anna Kostygina,et al.  Narrative impact. Social and cognitive foundations , 2003, Z. für Medienpsychologie.

[26]  T. Heatherton,et al.  Does Watching Smoking in Movies Promote Teenage Smoking? , 2009, Current directions in psychological science.

[27]  M. Svendsen CHILDREN'S IMAGINARY COMPANIONS , 1934 .

[28]  Eric D. Smith,et al.  The impact of pretend play on children's development: a review of the evidence. , 2013, Psychological bulletin.

[29]  T. Griffiths,et al.  NAÏVE THEORIES, AMBIGUOUS EVIDENCE Page 1 Running head: NAÏVE THEORIES AND AMBIGUOUS EVIDENCE Can being scared make your tummy ache? Naive theories, ambiguous evidence and preschoolers’ causal inferences , 2007 .

[30]  C. Glymour,et al.  Preschool children learn about causal structure from conditional interventions. , 2007, Developmental science.

[31]  Kate Wong,et al.  The philosophical baby: What children's minds tell us about truth, love, and the meaning of life. , 2009 .

[32]  A. Leslie,et al.  Is young children’s recognition of pretense metarepresentational or merely behavioral? Evidence from 2- and 3-year-olds’ understanding of pretend sounds and speech , 2010, Cognition.

[33]  J. Singer,et al.  Preschoolers' pretend play and theory of mind: The role of jointly constructed pretence , 1999 .

[34]  A. Gopnik,et al.  Conditional probability versus spatial contiguity in causal learning: Preschoolers use new contingency evidence to overcome prior spatial assumptions. , 2007, Developmental psychology.

[35]  Nicholas J. Mulcahy,et al.  How great apes perform on a modified trap-tube task , 2006, Animal Cognition.

[36]  Paul Bloom,et al.  How pleasure works: The new science of why we like what we like. , 2010 .

[37]  Elizabeth A. Olson,et al.  Eyewitness testimony. , 2003, Annual review of psychology.

[38]  G. Simcock,et al.  Generalization of learning from picture books to novel test conditions by 18- and 24-month-old children. , 2007, Developmental psychology.

[39]  H. Wellman,et al.  Knowledge acquisition in foundational domains. , 1998 .

[40]  M. Seligman,et al.  Navigating Into the Future or Driven by the Past , 2013, Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

[41]  Tom Burr,et al.  Causation, Prediction, and Search , 2003, Technometrics.

[42]  Steven J. Kirsh Cartoon violence and aggression in youth , 2006 .

[43]  T. Griffiths,et al.  Can being scared cause tummy aches? Naive theories, ambiguous evidence, and preschoolers' causal inferences. , 2007, Developmental psychology.

[44]  T. Gendler,et al.  Genuine Rational Fictional Emotions , 2006 .

[45]  A. Gopnik,et al.  Causal learning : psychology, philosophy, and computation , 2007 .

[46]  Franz von Kutschera,et al.  Causation , 1993, J. Philos. Log..

[47]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Young children understand multiple pretend identities in their object play. , 2009, The British journal of developmental psychology.

[48]  Paul,et al.  The Intuitive Cosmology of Fictional Worlds , 2006 .

[49]  Henry L. Roediger,et al.  Learning facts from fiction. , 2003 .

[50]  A. Gopnik,et al.  The power of possibility: causal learning, counterfactual reasoning, and pretend play , 2012, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[51]  A. Leslie Pretense and representation: The origins of "theory of mind." , 1987 .

[52]  Paul L. Harris,et al.  The influence of the imagination on reasoning by young children , 1990 .

[53]  Paul L. Harris,et al.  Young Children's Understanding of Pretense , 1993 .

[54]  D. Weisberg,et al.  What Belongs in a Fictional World , 2009 .

[55]  L. DiLalla,et al.  Differentiation of Fantasy and Reality: Preschoolers' Reactions to Interruptions in Their Play. , 1988 .

[56]  J. Weinberg,et al.  Puzzling over the Imagination: Philosophical Problems, Architectural Solutions , 2006 .

[57]  G. Miller,et al.  Cognitive science. , 1981, Science.

[58]  S. Gelman,et al.  Mapping the Mind: Domain Specificity In Cognition And Culture , 1994 .

[59]  Amy Coplan Simulating Minds: The Philosophy, Psychology, and Neuroscience of Mindreading by goldman, alvin , 2008 .

[60]  A. Leslie Pretending and believing: issues in the theory of ToMM , 1994, Cognition.

[61]  J. Woolley,et al.  Young children's practical reasoning about imagination , 1994 .

[62]  Kevin J. Riggs,et al.  Adaptive modelling and mindreading , 1999 .

[63]  Marcia K. Johnson,et al.  Cognitive and brain mechanisms of false memories and beliefs. , 2000 .

[64]  H. Gardner,et al.  Dragons and dinosaurs: The child's capacity to differentiate fantasy from reality. , 1978 .

[65]  James D. Johnson,et al.  The Influence of Media Violence on Youth , 2003, Psychological science in the public interest : a journal of the American Psychological Society.

[66]  Ina C. Uzgiris,et al.  Assessment in Infancy: Ordinal Scales of Psychological Development , 1989 .

[67]  J. Pearl Causality: Models, Reasoning and Inference , 2000 .

[68]  Lorraine McCune Nicolich,et al.  Beyond Sensorimotor Intelligence: Assessment of Symbolic Maturity Through Analysis of Pretend Play. , 1977 .

[69]  T. Brock,et al.  Journal of Personality and Social Psychology the Role of Transportation in the Persuasiveness of Public Narratives Text Quality Individual Differences and Situational Influences Transportation Scale Items Gender Differences Discriminant Validation: Need for Cognition Effect of Text Manipulation Beli , 2022 .

[70]  Marjorie Taylor,et al.  Imaginary Companions and the Children Who Create Them , 1999 .

[71]  P. Bloom,et al.  Young children separate multiple pretend worlds. , 2009, Developmental science.

[72]  A. Leslie,et al.  Recognition of pretend and real actions in play by 1- and 2-year-olds: Early success and why they fail , 2006 .

[73]  Kathy Hirsh-Pasek,et al.  Play = Learning: How Play Motivates and Enhances Children's Cognitive and Social-Emotional Growth , 2006 .

[74]  Shaun Nichols Imagining and Believing: The Promise of a Single Code , 2004 .

[75]  Shelbie L. Sutherland,et al.  Just pretending can be really learning: children use pretend play as a source for acquiring generic knowledge. , 2013, Developmental psychology.

[76]  R. Baillargeon,et al.  15-month-old infants detect violations in pretend scenarios. , 2007, Acta psychologica.

[77]  A. Lillard,et al.  Pretend Play as Twin Earth: A Social-Cognitive Analysis☆ , 2001 .

[78]  Blakey Vermeule Why Do We Care about Literary Characters , 2010 .

[79]  Max Brockman,et al.  What's Next?: Dispatches on the Future of Science , 2009 .

[80]  Noël Carroll,et al.  Mimesis as Make-Beleive@@@Mimesis as Make-Believe: On the Foundations of the Representational Arts. , 1995 .

[81]  Anne Fernald,et al.  Speech to Infants as Hyperspeech: Knowledge-Driven Processes in Early Word Recognition , 2000, Phonetica.

[82]  M. Uzun The nature of fiction , 2007 .

[83]  A. Davis,et al.  Children's understanding of the pretence–reality distinction: a review of current theory and evidence , 2002 .

[84]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Normativity and context in young children's pretend play , 2009 .

[85]  Distinguishing Imagination from Reality , 2013 .

[86]  David M. Sobel,et al.  A theory of causal learning in children: causal maps and Bayes nets. , 2004, Psychological review.

[87]  Jerome L. Singer,et al.  The House of Make-Believe: Children's Play and the Developing Imagination , 1992 .

[88]  Noah D. Goodman,et al.  Did she jump because she was the big sister or because the trampoline was safe? Causal inference and the development of social attribution. , 2013, Child development.

[89]  S. Stich,et al.  Mindreading: An Integrated Account of Pretence, Self-Awareness, and Understanding Other Minds , 2003 .

[90]  A. Gopnik,et al.  The theory theory. , 1994 .

[91]  P. Harris The work of imagination , 1991 .

[92]  H. Wellman,et al.  Early understanding of mental entities: a reexamination of childhood realism. , 1986, Child development.