Traditional Models of Care Delivery: What Have We Learned?

Traditional models of patient care delivery include total patient care and functional, team, and primary nursing. These models differ in clinical decision making, work allocation, communication, and management, with differing social and economic forces driving the choice of model. Studies regarding quality of care, cost, and satisfaction for the models provide little evidence for determining which model of care is most effective in any given situation. Despite lack of evidence, newer models continue to be implemented. This article compares the advantages and disadvantages of models, critiques the existing studies, and offers recommendations regarding the evidence needed to make informed decisions regarding care delivery models.

[1]  T. Kron.  The management of patient care;: Putting leadership skills to work , 1971 .

[2]  M. Manthey.  Primary nursing is alive and well in the hospital. , 1975, The American journal of nursing.

[3]  K. Ciske.  Primary Nursing: An Organization That Promotes Professional Practice , 1974, The Journal of nursing administration.

[4]  M. Manthey,et al.  [Primary nursing: a return to the concept of my nurse and my patient]. , 1974, Hu li za zhi The journal of nursing.

[5]  R. Daeffler.  Patients Perception Of Care Under Team and Primary Nursing , 1975, The Journal of nursing administration.

[6]  G. Felton.  Increasing the Quality of Nursing Care by Introducing the Concept of Primary Nursing: A Model Project , 1975, Nursing research.

[7]  G. Marram.  The Comparative Costs of Operating a Team and Primary Nursing Unit , 1976, The Journal of nursing administration.

[8]  M. Lee.  Towards better care: 'primary nursing'. , 1979, Nursing times.

[9]  L. E. Roberts.  Primary nursing Do patients like it Are nurses satisfied Does it cost more? , 1980, The Canadian nurse.

[10]  R. Shukla.  Structure vs. people in primary nursing: an inquiry. , 1981, Nursing research.

[11]  R. Shukla.  Primary or Team Nursing? Two Conditions Determine the Choice , 1982, The Journal of nursing administration.

[12]  E. Halloran.  Staffing Assignment: By Task or by Patient , 1983, Nursing management.

[13]  R. Shukla.  All-RN model of nursing care delivery: a cost-benefit evaluation. , 1983, Inquiry : a journal of medical care organization, provision and financing.

[14]  K. Sellick,et al.  Primary nursing: an evaluation of its effects on patient perception of care and staff satisfaction. , 2003, International journal of nursing studies.

[15]  Shukla Rk.  Technical and structural support systems and nurse utilization: systems model. , 1983 .

[16]  L. Notter,et al.  Annual Review of Nursing Research , 1984, Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

[17]  K. Chavigny,et al.  Team or primary nursing care? , 1984, Nursing outlook.

[18]  K. Yoshitake.  [Team nursing]. , 1985, [Kango gijutsu] : [Nursing technique].

[19]  P. Giovannetti.  Evaluation of Primary Nursing , 1986, Annual Review of Nursing Research.

[20]  J. Hunt.  Primary nursing. The next challenge. , 1988, Nursing times.

[21]  S. Reed.  A comparison of nurse-related behaviour, philosophy of care and job satisfaction in team and primary nursing. , 1988, Journal of advanced nursing.

[22]  L. Bowers.  The significance of primary nursing. , 1989, Journal of advanced nursing.

[23]  P. Dawson,et al.  A comparison of primary nursing and team nursing in a geriatric long-term care setting. , 1989, International journal of nursing studies.

[24]  G. Glandon,et al.  Nursing Delivery Models and RN Mix: Cost Implications , 1989, Nursing management.

[25]  R. Sherman.  Team Nursing Revisited , 1990, The Journal of nursing administration.

[26]  K. Gardner,et al.  A Summary of Findings of a Five‐Year Comparison Study of Primary and Team Nursing , 1991, Nursing research.

[27]  K. Gardner,et al.  A longitudinal cost analysis of primary and team nursing. , 1991, Nursing economic$.

[28]  L. Thomas,et al.  Outcomes of nursing care: the case of primary nursing. , 1991, International journal of nursing studies.

[29]  D. Rafferty.  Team and primary nursing. , 1992, Senior nurse.

[30]  L. Thomas.  Qualified nurse and nursing auxiliary perceptions of their work environment in primary, team and functional nursing wards. , 1992, Journal of advanced nursing.

[31]  P. Dixon,et al.  Skill mix and the effectiveness of nursing care. , 1992, Nursing standard (Royal College of Nursing (Great Britain) : 1987).

[32]  S. O'connor.  Evaluating the implementation of team nursing in a clinical setting. , 1993, British journal of nursing.

[33]  K. Malkin.  Primary nursing: Job satisfaction and staff retention , 1993 .

[34]  G. Wlody.  Managing Clinical Practice in Critical Care Nursing , 1994 .

[35]  E. Larson,et al.  The impact of unlicensed assistive personnel on nursing care delivery. , 1996, Nursing economic$.

[36]  L. Thomas,et al.  The impact of primary nursing on patient satisfaction. , 1996, Nursing times.

[37]  R. Taylor.  Check your cultural competence. , 1998, Nursing management.

[38]  L. Christman.  The Practice of Primary Nursing , 2003 .