Mentoring in academic medicine: a systematic review.

CONTEXT Mentoring, as a partnership in personal and professional growth and development, is central to academic medicine, but it is challenged by increased clinical, administrative, research, and other educational demands on medical faculty. Therefore, evidence for the value of mentoring needs to be evaluated. OBJECTIVE To systematically review the evidence about the prevalence of mentorship and its relationship to career development. DATA SOURCES MEDLINE, Current Contents, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, PsycINFO, and Scopus databases from the earliest available date to May 2006. STUDY SELECTION AND DATA EXTRACTION We identified all studies evaluating the effect of mentoring on career choices and academic advancement among medical students and physicians. Minimum inclusion criteria were a description of the study population and availability of extractable data. No restrictions were placed on study methods or language. DATA SYNTHESIS The literature search identified 3640 citations. Review of abstracts led to retrieval of 142 full-text articles for assessment; 42 articles describing 39 studies were selected for review. Of these, 34 (87%) were cross-sectional self-report surveys with small sample size and response rates ranging from 5% to 99%. One case-control study nested in a survey used a comparison group that had not received mentoring, and 1 cohort study had a small sample size and a large loss to follow-up. Less than 50% of medical students and in some fields less than 20% of faculty members had a mentor. Women perceived that they had more difficulty finding mentors than their colleagues who are men. Mentorship was reported to have an important influence on personal development, career guidance, career choice, and research productivity, including publication and grant success. CONCLUSIONS Mentoring is perceived as an important part of academic medicine, but the evidence to support this perception is not strong. Practical recommendations on mentoring in medicine that are evidence-based will require studies using more rigorous methods, addressing contextual issues, and using cross-disciplinary approaches.

[1]  C. Underhill,et al.  The effectiveness of mentoring programs in corporate settings: A meta-analytical review of the literature , 2006 .

[2]  G. Wood,et al.  Academics or Private Practice? The Future of Dermatologic Surgery Education , 2006, Dermatologic surgery : official publication for American Society for Dermatologic Surgery [et al.].

[3]  D. Cruess,et al.  Personal Satisfaction and Mentorship are Critical Factors for Today's Resident Surgeons to Seek Surgical Training , 2005, The American surgeon.

[4]  M. Power,et al.  Continuing professional development: Racial and gender differences in obstetrics and gynecology residents' perceptions of mentoring , 2005, The Journal of continuing education in the health professions.

[5]  M. Büchler,et al.  [Careers of women in academic surgery]. , 2005, Der Chirurg; Zeitschrift fur alle Gebiete der operativen Medizen.

[6]  M. Keller,et al.  Karriere im Gegenwind , 2005, Der Chirurg.

[7]  R. Levine,et al.  Brief report: Completing a scholarly project during residency training , 2005, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[8]  R. Levine,et al.  Completing a scholarly project during residency training. Perspectives of residents who have been successful. , 2005, Journal of general internal medicine.

[9]  M. Schuckit,et al.  Informal Mentoring Between Faculty and Medical Students , 2005, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[10]  C. M. Baker,et al.  Mentoring Undergraduate Nursing Students: Assessing the State of the Science , 2004, Nurse educator.

[11]  A. Sciscione,et al.  Factors that affect satisfaction with neonatal-perinatal fellowship training. , 2004, American journal of perinatology.

[12]  D. Wingard,et al.  Facilitating Faculty Success: Outcomes and Cost Benefit of the UCSD National Center of Leadership in Academic Medicine , 2004, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[13]  Catherine D DeAngelis,et al.  Professors not professing. , 2004, JAMA.

[14]  Peter Curtis,et al.  Assessing the Role of Influential Mentors in the Research Development of Primary Care Fellows , 2004, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[15]  A. Paolo,et al.  Keys to career satisfaction: insights from a survey of women pediatric surgeons. , 2004, Journal of pediatric surgery.

[16]  M. Bergen,et al.  Career Advancement for Women Faculty in a U.S. School of Medicine: Perceived Needs , 2004, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[17]  A. Willan,et al.  Factors affecting academic promotion in obstetrics and gynaecology in Canada. , 2004, Journal of obstetrics and gynaecology Canada : JOGC = Journal d'obstetrique et gynecologie du Canada : JOGC.

[18]  J. Gray,et al.  Academic health leadership: looking to the future. Proceedings of a workshop held at the Canadian Institute of Academic Medicine meeting Québec, Que., Canada, Apr. 25 and 26, 2003. , 2003, Clinical and investigative medicine. Medecine clinique et experimentale.

[19]  M. Obeng,et al.  The American Heritage Stedman's Medical Dictionary , 2003 .

[20]  E. Aagaard,et al.  A cross-sectional descriptive study of mentoring relationships formed by medical students , 2003, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[21]  E. Yu.  Regimented research: a recipe for success? , 2003, The Canadian journal of cardiology.

[22]  D. Bodurka,et al.  Mentorship and productivity among gynecologic oncology fellows. , 2003, Journal of cancer education : the official journal of the American Association for Cancer Education.

[23]  J. Steiner,et al.  Building capacity for research in family medicine: is the blueprint faulty? , 2003, Family medicine.

[24]  J. Steiner,et al.  Indicators of early research productivity among primary care fellows , 2002, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[25]  P. Leppert,et al.  A Survey of Past Obstetrics and Gynecology Research Fellows , 2002, The Journal of the Society for Gynecologic Investigation: JSGI.

[26]  E. Paice,et al.  How important are role models in making good doctors? , 2002, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[27]  P. Katz,et al.  The Current State of Geriatric Medicine: A National Survey of Fellowship‐Trained Geriatricians, 1990 to 1998 , 2002, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[28]  D. Stubbe.  Preparation for practice: child and adolescent psychiatry graduates' assessment of training experiences. , 2002, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

[29]  Rosalyn C Richman,et al.  Effective faculty preceptoring and mentoring during reorganization of an academic medical center , 2002, Medical teacher.

[30]  A. Thakur,et al.  Impact of mentor guidance in surgical career selection. , 2001, Journal of pediatric surgery.

[31]  E. Zenni,et al.  Adolescent medicine faculty development needs. , 2001, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[32]  J. Paukert,et al.  msJAMA: from medical student to intern: where are the role models? , 2001, JAMA.

[33]  G. Glover,et al.  A model for faculty mentoring in academic radiology. , 2000, Academic radiology.

[34]  D. Litaker,et al.  Factors influencing the selection of general internal medicine fellowship programs: A national survey , 2000, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[35]  Pamela L. Perrewé,et al.  What Did You Expect? An Examination of Career-Related Support and Social Support Among Mentors and Protégés , 2000 .

[36]  John J. Sosik,et al.  Leadership styles, mentoring functions received, and job‐related stress: a conceptual model and preliminary study , 2000 .

[37]  W. Longmire,et al.  What is the best method of surgical training?: A report of America's leading senior surgeons. , 1998, Archives of surgery.

[38]  A. Sciscione,et al.  FACTORS AFFECTING FELLOWSHIP SATISFACTION, THESIS COMPLETION, AND CAREER DIRECTION AMONG MATERNALFETAL MEDICINE FELLOWS , 1998, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[39]  P. Carr,et al.  Junior faculty members' mentoring relationships and their professional development in U.S. medical schools , 1998, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[40]  Belle Rose Ragins,et al.  Diversified Mentoring Relationships in Organizations: A Power Perspective , 1997 .

[41]  L. Fried,et al.  Career development for women in academic medicine: Multiple interventions in a department of medicine. , 1996, JAMA.

[42]  A. Mainous,et al.  Family medicine research in the community setting: what can we learn from successful researchers? , 1996, The Journal of family practice.

[43]  M. Atkinson,et al.  Research Training and Productivity among Faculty: The Canadian Association of Professors of Psychiatry and the Canadian Psychiatric Association Survey , 1996, Canadian journal of psychiatry. Revue canadienne de psychiatrie.

[44]  M B Donnelly,et al.  Demographic, educational, and psychosocial factors influencing the choices of primary care and academic medical careers , 1995, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[45]  H. Pincus,et al.  The relationship of postdoctoral research training to current research activities of faculty in academic departments of psychiatry. , 1995, The American journal of psychiatry.

[46]  Daniel B. Turban,et al.  Role of protégé personality in receipt of mentoring and career success. , 1994 .

[47]  E. Osborn,et al.  Factors influencing students' choices of primary care or other specialties , 1993, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[48]  V. Ernster,et al.  Women's attitudes toward careers in academic medicine at the University of California, San Francisco , 1992, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[49]  H. Pincus,et al.  Current status of research activity in American child and adolescent psychiatry: II. A developmental analysis by age cohorts. , 1991, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

[50]  H. Pincus,et al.  Current status of research activity in American child and adolescent psychiatry: Part I. , 1991, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

[51]  Charles C. Healy,et al.  Mentoring Relations: A Definition to Advance Research and Practice , 1990 .

[52]  R. Wakeford,et al.  WHERE DO MEDICALLY QUALIFIED RESEARCHERS COME FROM? , 1985, The Lancet.

[53]  R. Mannel,et al.  Gynecologic oncologists' perceptions of fellowship training. , 2005, The Journal of reproductive medicine.

[54]  P. Cresswell,et al.  Dissemination of the work of public health medicine trainees in peer-reviewed publications: an unfulfilled potential. , 1996, Public health.

[55]  S. Flocke,et al.  Factors associated with research productivity in family practice residencies. , 1995, Family medicine.

[56]  W. Levinson,et al.  Mentors and role models for women in academic medicine. , 1991, The Western journal of medicine.