Changing defaults in biobank research could save lives too

In an effort to increase the amount of organs available for transplantation, many countries have implemented presumed consent for organ donation. Presuming a wish to contribute to medical advances through biobank research on previously taken tissue samples could similarly improve health and wellbeing. In this article we analyze common arguments for and against presumed consent for organ donation and assess their relevance in the context of biobank research. In spite of obvious differences between biobank research and organ transplantation the cases for implementing presumption of a positive attitude appear quite analogous. It has repeatedly been shown that a majority of the general population supports these projects and selecting informed consent as the default position decreases the amount of organs and samples available and thus reduces the prospect of promoting health. We conclude that instead of presuming that individuals do not wish to contribute to the advancement of healthcare through biobank research on previously taken samples, ethics committees should presume that they do.

[1]  Joan Costa-Font,et al.  Does organ donation legislation affect individuals' willingness to donate their own or their relative's organs? Evidence from European Union survey data , 2008, BMC health services research.

[2]  M. Hansson,et al.  Biobanks as Resources for Health , 2003 .

[3]  Alberto Abadie,et al.  The Impact of Presumed Consent Legislation on Cadaveric Organ Donation: A Cross Country Study , 2004, Journal of health economics.

[4]  K. Hoeyer,et al.  Informed consent and biobanks: a population-based study of attitudes towards tissue donation for genetic research , 2004, Scandinavian journal of public health.

[5]  Margareta A Sanner,et al.  Two perspectives on organ donation: experiences of potential donor families and intensive care physicians of the same event. , 2007, Journal of critical care.

[6]  Bartha Maria Knoppers,et al.  Biobanking: International Norms , 2005, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[7]  T. Murray Gifts of the body and the needs of strangers. , 1987, The Hastings Center report.

[8]  S. Eriksson,et al.  sectional study of samples in Swedish biobanks: cross Patients' refusal to consent to storage and use , 2008 .

[9]  Liam Glynn,et al.  Selection bias resulting from the requirement for prior consent in observational research: a community cohort of people with ischaemic heart disease , 2007, Heart.

[10]  David Wendler,et al.  One-time general consent for research on biological samples , 2006, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[11]  K. Gundle Presumed Consent: An International Comparison and Possibilities for Change in the United States , 2005, Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics.

[12]  Daniel G. Goldstein,et al.  Defaults and Donation Decisions , 2004, Transplantation.

[13]  H. Bonatti Impact of New Legislation on Presumed Consent on Organ Donation on Liver Transplant in Singapore: A Preliminary Analysis , 2008 .

[14]  L. Ring,et al.  Perceptions of potential donors in the Swedish public towards information and consent procedures in relation to use of human tissue samples in biobanks: A population-based study , 2007, Scandinavian journal of public health.

[15]  M. Hansson,et al.  Ethics and biobanks , 2008, British Journal of Cancer.

[16]  V. English,et al.  Presumed consent for transplantation: a dead issue after Alder Hey? , 2003, Journal of medical ethics.

[17]  M. Jacob Another Look at the Presumed-versus-Informed Consent Dichotomy in Postmortem Organ Procurement , 2006 .

[18]  Eric J. Johnson,et al.  The Construction of Preference: Do Defaults Save Lives? , 2006 .

[19]  Joakim Dillner,et al.  Ethical framework for previously collected biobank samples , 2007, Nature Biotechnology.

[20]  T. Scalea,et al.  Impact of culture and policy on organ donation: a comparison between two urban trauma centers in developed nations. , 2003, The Journal of trauma.

[21]  V. Salomaa,et al.  Total and cause specific mortality among participants and non-participants of population based health surveys: a comprehensive follow up of 54 372 Finnish men and women , 2005, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health.

[22]  Michael B. Gill Presumed consent, autonomy, and organ donation. , 2004, The Journal of medicine and philosophy.