Consolidating the State of Knowledge: A Synoptical Review of Wind Energy’s Wildlife Effects

Abstract Wind energy development contributes substantially to achieve climate protection goals. Unintended side effects, especially on wildlife, have long been discussed and substantial research has evolved over the last decade. At this stage, it is important to identify what we have learnt so far, as well as which predominant uncertainties and gaps remain. This review article aims to consolidate the state of knowledge, providing a qualitative analysis of the main effects of wind energy development on- and offshore, focusing on frequently studied species groups (bats, breeding and resting birds, raptors, migratory birds, marine mammals). We reviewed over 220 publications from which we identified predominant hypotheses that were summarized and displayed in tables. Journal publications, conference contributions, and further studies have been considered. We found that research focusing on offshore wind energy within the last couple of years has increased significantly as well, catching up with the vast amount of onshore studies. Some hypotheses have been verified by numerous publications and a consensus has been reached (e.g., correlation between bat activity and weather factors), while others are still being debated more (e.g., determination of migratory corridors) or remain unknown (e.g., effect on population level). Factors influencing potential effects were mainly related to species characteristics (morphology, phenology, abundance, behavior, and response to turbines) or site characteristics (landscape features, weather, and habitat quality). Consolidating the state of research provides the groundwork for the identification of mitigation measures and advanced planning approaches. However, the quantification of effects remains challenging and uncertainties will always persist.

[1]  J. Tougaard,et al.  Wind turbine underwater noise and marine mammals: implications of current knowledge and data needs , 2006 .

[2]  A. Hawkins,et al.  The Effects of Noise on Aquatic Life , 2012, Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology.

[3]  Stefan Garthe,et al.  Scaling possible adverse effects of marine wind farms on seabirds: developing and applying a vulnerability index , 2004 .

[4]  D. Olivieri.  Environmental Management , 2006 .

[5]  Klaus-Michael Exo,et al.  Bird migration studies and potential collision risk with offshore wind turbines , 2006 .

[6]  D. Gerlich,et al.  Cdk1 Inactivation Terminates Mitotic Checkpoint Surveillance and Stabilizes Kinetochore Attachments in Anaphase , 2014, Current Biology.

[7]  J. A. Cabral,et al.  Differential mortality of birds killed at wind farms in Northern Portugal , 2014 .

[8]  J. A. Bright,et al.  Assessing the cumulative impacts of wind farms on peatland birds: a case study of golden plover Pluvialis apricaria in Scotland , 2009 .

[9]  D. Drake,et al.  Bat mortality at a wind‐energy facility in southeastern Wisconsin , 2012 .

[10]  Jesper Madsen,et al.  Effects of wind turbines and other physical elements on field utilization by pink-footed geese (Anser brachyrhynchus): A landscape perspective , 2000, Landscape Ecology.

[11]  Robin Gransier,et al.  Behavioral responses of a harbor porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) to playbacks of broadband pile driving sounds. , 2013, Marine environmental research.

[12]  S. Hoover.  The Response of Red-Tailed Hawks and Golden Eagles to Topographical Features, Weather, and Abundance of a Dominant Prey Species at the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area, California , 2002 .

[13]  K. S. Smallwood,et al.  Burrowing Owl Mortality in the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area , 2007 .

[14]  C. Hooper,et al.  A review of offshore windfarm related underwater noise sources , 2004 .

[15]  Luciano Picarelli,et al.  Final Report 2008 , 2008 .

[16]  D. Whitfield,et al.  Upland raptors and the assessment of wind farm impacts , 2006 .

[17]  Mark J. Whittingham,et al.  Minimal effects of wind turbines on the distribution of wintering farmland birds , 2008 .

[18]  R. Langston,et al.  Assessing the impacts of wind farms on birds , 2006 .

[19]  Wallace P. Erickson,et al.  Patterns of Bat Fatalities at Wind Energy Facilities in North America , 2008 .

[20]  M. Carrete,et al.  Mortality at wind-farms is positively related to large-scale distribution and aggregation in griffon vultures , 2012 .

[21]  A. Jain.  Bird and bat behavior and mortality at a northern Iowa windfarm , 2005 .

[22]  Charles M. Francis,et al.  Canadian Estimate of Bird Mortality Due to Collisions and Direct Habitat Loss Associated with Wind Turbine Developments , 2013 .

[23]  The effect of pile driving on harbour porpoises in Belgian waters , 2012 .

[24]  M. Dale Strickland,et al.  Ecological Impacts of Wind Energy Development on Bats: Questions, Research Needs, and Hypotheses , 2007 .

[25]  L. Rodrigues,et al.  Factors Influencing Bat Activity and Mortality at a Wind Farm in the Mediterranean Region , 2012 .

[26]  Jeffrey E. Lovich,et al.  Assessing the state of knowledge of utility-scale wind energy development and operation on non-volant terrestrial and marine wildlife , 2013 .

[27]  O. Hüppop,et al.  Climate change and timing of spring migration in the long-distance migrant Ficedula hypoleuca in central Europe: the role of spatially different temperature changes along migration routes , 2006, Journal of Ornithology.

[28]  Roel May,et al.  White‐tailed eagles (Haliaeetus albicilla) at the Smøla wind‐power plant, Central Norway, lack behavioral flight responses to wind turbines , 2013 .

[29]  Erin F. Baerwald,et al.  Barotrauma is a significant cause of bat fatalities at wind turbines , 2008, Current Biology.

[30]  J. Burger,et al.  Using a shore bird (red knot) fitted with geolocators to evaluate a conceptual risk model focusing on offshore wind , 2012 .

[31]  G. Ellis,et al.  Behavioural reactions of free-ranging porpoises and seals to the noise of a simulated 2 MW windpower generator , 2003 .

[32]  M. Ferrer,et al.  A Bird and Small Mammal BACI and IG Design Studies in a Wind Farm in Malpica (Spain) , 2005, Biodiversity & Conservation.

[33]  Corinne Le Quéré,et al.  Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis , 2013 .

[34]  Ac Doty,et al.  Assessment of bat and avian mortality at a pilot wind turbine at Coega, Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South Africa , 2013 .

[35]  Elizabeth A. Masden,et al.  Assessing vulnerability of marine bird populations to offshore wind farms. , 2013, Journal of environmental management.

[36]  Patterns of pre-construction bat activity at a proposed wind facility in northwest Massachusetts , 2007 .

[37]  Hermann Hötker,et al.  Impacts on biodiversity of exploitation of renewable energy , 2006 .

[38]  Michael L. Morrison,et al.  Influence of Behavior on Bird Mortality in Wind Energy Developments , 2009 .

[39]  Rowena H. W. Langston,et al.  Greater impacts of wind farms on bird populations during construction than subsequent operation: results of a multi-site and multi-species analysis , 2012 .

[40]  E. Arnett,et al.  Impacts of Wind Energy Development on Bats: Implications for Conservation , 2013 .

[41]  Richard Barham,et al.  Framework for assessing impacts of pile-driving noise from offshore wind farm construction on a harbour seal population , 2013 .

[42]  Paul A. Lepper,et al.  Auditory studies on harbour porpoises in relation to offshore wind turbines , 2008 .

[43]  Rowena H. W. Langston,et al.  The distribution of breeding birds around upland wind farms , 2009 .

[44]  Scott E. Stephens,et al.  The effects of a large‐scale wind farm on breeding season survival of female mallards and blue‐winged teal in the Prairie Pothole Region , 2013 .

[45]  Miguel Ferrer,et al.  The effects of a wind farm on birds in a migration point: the Strait of Gibraltar , 2004, Biodiversity & Conservation.

[46]  G. D. Johnson,et al.  Mortality of Bats at a Large-scale Wind Power Development at Buffalo Ridge, Minnesota , 2003 .

[47]  Jr Nedwell,et al.  Measurement and interpretation of underwater noise during construction and operation of offshore windfarms in UK waters , 2007 .

[48]  S. Wisely,et al.  Effects of wind energy development on survival of female greater prairie-chickens , 2014 .

[49]  Kennan W. Rapp,et al.  Greening the Wind: Environmental and Social Considerations for Wind Power Development , 2011 .

[50]  Kjetil Modolv Bevanger,et al.  Reduced breeding success in white-tailed eagles at Smøla windfarm, western Norway, is caused by mortality and displacement , 2012 .

[51]  J. Tougaard,et al.  Behavioral reactions of harbor porpoise to pile-driving noise. , 2012, Advances in experimental medicine and biology.

[52]  M. Patten,et al.  Avoidance Behavior by Prairie Grouse: Implications for Development of Wind Energy , 2009, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[53]  T. Alerstam,et al.  DO PARTIAL AND REGULAR MIGRANTS DIFFER IN THEIR RESPONSES TO WEATHER? , 2006 .

[54]  Pinhas Alpert,et al.  Is there a connection between weather at departure sites, onset of migration and timing of soaring‐bird autumn migration in Israel? , 2006 .

[55]  J. Furmankiewicz,et al.  Migration of Bats along a Large River Valley in Southwestern Poland , 2009 .

[56]  V. Bennett,et al.  An analysis of displacement from wind turbines in a wintering grassland bird community , 2013, Biodiversity and Conservation.

[57]  F. Korner‐Nievergelt,et al.  Wind turbine fatalities approach a level of concern in a raptor population , 2013 .

[58]  M. Simmonds,et al.  Is there a conflict between cetacean conservation and marine renewable-energy developments? , 2010 .

[59]  Elizabeth A. Masden,et al.  Barriers to movement: impacts of wind farms on migrating birds , 2009 .

[60]  S. Degraer,et al.  Offshore wind farms in the Belgian part of the North Sea: Heading for an understanding of environmental impacts , 2012 .

[61]  R. Fijn,et al.  Habitat use, disturbance and collision risks for Bewick , 2012 .

[62]  P. Thompson,et al.  Assessing underwater noise levels during pile-driving at an offshore windfarm and its potential effects on marine mammals. , 2010, Marine pollution bulletin.

[63]  Tobias Dittmann,et al.  Of birds, blades and barriers: Detecting and analysing mass migration events at alpha ventus , 2014 .

[64]  Paul M. Cryan,et al.  Causes of Bat Fatalities at Wind Turbines: Hypotheses and Predictions , 2009 .

[65]  P. Cryan.  Mating Behavior as a Possible Cause of Bat Fatalities at Wind Turbines , 2008 .

[66]  A. Pullin,et al.  Poor evidence-base for assessment of windfarm impacts on birds , 2007, Environmental Conservation.

[67]  Adam C. Brown,et al.  Migration of bats past a remote island offers clues toward the problem of bat fatalities at wind turbines , 2007 .

[69]  J. Teilmann,et al.  Pile driving zone of responsiveness extends beyond 20 km for harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena (L.)). , 2009, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[70]  Lothar Bach,et al.  Behavior of Scandinavian Bats during Migration and Foraging at Sea , 2009 .

[71]  J. Teilmann,et al.  Impacts of offshore wind farm construction on harbour porpoises: acoustic monitoring of echolocation activity using porpoise detectors (T-PODs) , 2006 .

[72]  G. Corten,et al.  Aerodynamics: Insects can halve wind-turbine power , 2001, Nature.

[73]  S. Percival.  BIRDS AND WIND FARMS IN IRELAND: A REVIEW OF POTENTIAL ISSUES AND IMPACT ASSESSMENT , 2003 .

[74]  J. Gates,et al.  Offshore Activity of Bats Along the Mid-Atlantic Coast , 2014 .

[75]  Erin F. Baerwald,et al.  A Large-Scale Mitigation Experiment to Reduce Bat Fatalities at Wind Energy Facilities , 2009 .

[76]  M. Desholm,et al.  Avian collision risk at an offshore wind farm , 2005, Biology Letters.

[77]  P. Sassone-Corsi,et al.  RNA granules in germ cells. , 2011, Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology.

[78]  Turbine Rotor Blades.  Wind turbines and bat mortality: interactions of bat echolocation pulses with moving turbine rotor blades , 2009 .

[79]  Jakob Tougaard,et al.  Harbour Porpoises on Horns Reef-Effects of the Horns Reef Wind Farm Annual Status Report 2004 to Elsam Engineering , 2005 .

[80]  Erin F. Baerwald,et al.  Patterns of Activity and Fatality of Migratory Bats at a Wind Energy Facility in Alberta, Canada , 2011 .

[81]  Peter P. Marra,et al.  Estimates of bird collision mortality at wind facilities in the contiguous United States , 2013 .

[82]  S. Wisely,et al.  Space use by female Greater Prairie‐Chickens in response to wind energy development , 2014 .

[83]  Michael R. Schirmacher,et al.  Altering turbine speed reduces bat mortality at wind‐energy facilities , 2011 .

[84]  Erin F. Baerwald,et al.  Variation in bat and bird fatalities at wind energy facilities: assessing the effects of rotor size and tower height , 2007 .

[85]  Thomas H. Kunz,et al.  Behavioral Responses of Bats to Operating Wind Turbines , 2008 .

[86]  Lukas H. Meyer,et al.  Summary for Policymakers , 2022, The Ocean and Cryosphere in a Changing Climate.

[87]  Cris D. Hein,et al.  Behavior of bats at wind turbines , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[88]  Tricia A. Miller,et al.  Topography drives migratory flight altitude of golden eagles: implications for on‐shore wind energy development , 2012 .

[89]  W. Erickson.  Synthesis and Comparison of Baseline Avian and Bat Use, Raptor Nesting and Mortality Information from Proposed and Existing Wind Developments: Final Report. , 2002 .

[90]  J. Everaert.  Collision risk and micro-avoidance rates of birds with wind turbines in Flanders , 2014 .

[91]  S. Hoover.  Response of Red-Tailed Hawks and Golden Eagles to Topographical Features, Weather, and Abundance of a Dominant Prey Species at the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area, California: April 1999-December 2000 , 2002 .

[92]  T. O’Connell,et al.  Spatial Pattern of Summer Bat Mortality from Collisions with Wind Turbines in Mixed-grass Prairie , 2010 .

[93]  Wallace P. Erickson,et al.  A summary and comparison of bird mortality from anthropogenic causes with an emphasis on collisions , 2005 .

[94]  Yngve Steinheim,et al.  Pre- and post-construction studies of conflicts between birds and wind turbines in coastal Norway (BirdWind). Report on findings 2007-2010 , 2010 .

[95]  Klaus Lucke,et al.  Marine mammals and windfarms: Effects of alpha ventus on harbour porpoises , 2014 .

[96]  A. Skarin,et al.  The impacts of wind power on terrestrial mammals- A synthesis ISBN 978-91-620-6510-2 , 2012 .

[97]  Joanna Burger,et al.  Risk evaluation for federally listed (roseate tern, piping plover) or candidate (red knot) bird species in offshore waters: A first step for managing the potential impacts of wind facility development on the Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf , 2011 .

[98]  E. Stienen,et al.  Trapped within the corridor of the Southern North Sea: the potential impact of offshore wind farms on seabirds , 2007 .

[99]  L. Miller,et al.  Underwater noise from three types of offshore wind turbines: estimation of impact zones for harbor porpoises and harbor seals. , 2009, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[100]  David Lusseau,et al.  Assessing the responses of coastal cetaceans to the construction of offshore wind turbines. , 2010, Marine pollution bulletin.

[101]  Anders Hedenström,et al.  Mortality of bats at wind turbines links to nocturnal insect migration? , 2010, European Journal of Wildlife Research.

[102]  Klaus Lucke,et al.  Too loud to talk?: Do wind turbine-related sounds affect harbour seal communication? , 2008 .

[103]  Steven M. Grodsky,et al.  Investigating the causes of death for wind turbine-associated bat fatalities , 2011 .

[104]  Karin Sinclair,et al.  DEVELOPING METHODS TO REDUCE BIRD MORTALITY IN THE ALTAMONT PASS WIND RESOURCE AREA , 2004 .

[105]  K. Shawn Smallwood,et al.  Bird Mortality in the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area, California , 2008 .

[106]  Christopher A Ollson,et al.  Health effects and wind turbines: A review of the literature , 2011, Environmental health : a global access science source.

[107]  Ralf Seppelt,et al.  Model-Based Estimation of Collision Risks of Predatory Birds with Wind Turbines , 2012 .

[108]  E. Rees,et al.  Impacts of wind farms on swans and geese: a review , 2012 .

[109]  张静,et al.  Banana Ovate family protein MaOFP1 and MADS-box protein MuMADS1 antagonistically regulated banana fruit ripening , 2015 .

[110]  Gregory White,et al.  Risk Assessment and Mitigation , 1999 .

[111]  C. Hull,et al.  Bat fatalities at two wind farms in Tasmania, Australia: bat characteristics, and spatial and temporal patterns , 2013 .

[112]  Jonas Lembcke Andersen,et al.  Minimizing Collision Risk Between Migrating Raptors and Marine Wind Farms: Development of a Spatial Planning Tool , 2010, Environmental management.

[113]  David Boertmann,et al.  Animal behavioral adaptation to changing landscapes: spring-staging geese habituate to wind farms , 2008, Landscape Ecology.

[114]  География.  Prairie Pothole Region , 2010 .

[115]  M. Dale Strickland,et al.  Bat activity, composition, and collision mortality at a large wind plant in Minnesota , 2004 .

[116]  W. Courtens,et al.  Offshore wind farms in the Belgian part of the North Sea: Heading for an understanding of environmental impacts , 2012 .

[117]  U. Siebert,et al.  Effects of pile-driving on harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) at the first offshore wind farm in Germany , 2013 .

[118]  Steven M. Grodsky,et al.  Response of raptors to a windfarm , 2011 .

[119]  J. Teilmann,et al.  Harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) and wind farms: a case study in the Dutch North Sea , 2011 .

[120]  Brett T. McClintock,et al.  Marine mammals trace anthropogenic structures at sea , 2014, Current Biology.

[121]  G. D. Johnson,et al.  Short‐term impacts of wind energy development on greater sage‐grouse fitness , 2014 .

[122]  Helen M. Regan,et al.  Effects of wind farms and food scarcity on a large scavenging bird species following an epidemic of bovine spongiform encephalopathy , 2012 .

[123]  C. Hull,et al.  Behavior and turbine avoidance rates of eagles at two wind farms in Tasmania, Australia , 2013 .

[124]  Miguel Ferrer,et al.  Griffon vulture mortality at wind farms in southern Spain: Distribution of fatalities and active mitigation measures , 2012 .

[125]  Kjetil Modolv Bevanger,et al.  Collision risk in white-tailed eagles. Modelling kernel-based collision risk using satellite telemetry data in Smøla wind power plant , 2011 .

[126]  H. Mouritsen,et al.  Weather significantly influences the migratory behaviour of night-migratory songbirds tested indoors in orientation cages , 2010, Journal of Ornithology.

[127]  Anders Hedenström,et al.  Bat Mortality at Wind Turbines in Northwestern Europe , 2010 .

[128]  P. Ross,et al.  Vitamin A physiology and its application as a biomarker of contaminant-related toxicity in marine mammals: a review , 2000, Toxicology and industrial health.

[129]  Cris D. Hein,et al.  Evaluating the Effectiveness of an Ultrasonic Acoustic Deterrent for Reducing Bat Fatalities at Wind Turbines , 2013, PloS one.

[130]  Ivo Niermann,et al.  The catchment area of wind farms for European bats: A plea for international regulations , 2012 .

[131]  J. Köppel,et al.  Cautious but Committed: Moving Toward Adaptive Planning and Operation Strategies for Renewable Energy’s Wildlife Implications , 2014, Environmental Management.

[132]  D. Naugle,et al.  EFFECTS OF WIND TURBINES ON UPLAND NESTING BIRDS IN CONSERVATION RESERVE PROGRAM GRASSLANDS , 1999 .

[133]  M. Ferrer,et al.  Using Wind Tunnels to Predict Bird Mortality in Wind Farms: The Case of Griffon Vultures , 2012, PloS one.

[134]  Klaus Betke,et al.  Measurements of Construction Noise During Pile Driving of Offshore Research Platforms and Wind Farms , 2009 .

[135]  D. Revel.  Greening the wind , 2012 .

[136]  S. Solomon.  The Physical Science Basis : Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change , 2007 .

[137]  D. P. Whitfield,et al.  Collision fatality of raptors in wind farms does not depend on raptor abundance , 2008 .

[138]  U. Siebert,et al.  Temporary shift in masked hearing thresholds in a harbor porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) after exposure to seismic airgun stimuli. , 2009, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[139]  Luis J. Barrios,et al.  Behavioural and environmental correlates of soaring-bird mortality at on-shore wind turbines , 2004 .

[140]  Virgil Brack,et al.  Bats are not birds and other problems with Sovacool’s (2009) analysis of animal fatalities due to electricity generation , 2010 .

[141]  G. D. Johnson,et al.  A Forensic Investigation Into the Etiology of Bat Mortality at a Wind Farm: Barotrauma or Traumatic Injury? , 2012, Veterinary pathology.

[142]  K. Betke,et al.  Responses of harbour porpoises to pile driving at the Horns Rev II offshore wind farm in the Danish North Sea , 2011 .

[143]  A. Gill.  Offshore renewable energy - ecological implications of generating electricity in the coastal zone. , 2005 .

[144]  Erin F. Baerwald,et al.  Geographic Variation in Activity and Fatality of Migratory Bats at Wind Energy Facilities , 2009 .

[145]  M. Patten,et al.  It's Not Easy Being Green: Wind Energy and a Declining Grassland Bird , 2009 .

[146]  Kathryn A. Williams,et al.  Offshore Observations of Eastern Red Bats (Lasiurus borealis) in the Mid-Atlantic United States Using Multiple Survey Methods , 2013, PloS one.

[147]  S. Wisely,et al.  Effects of Wind Energy Development on Nesting Ecology of Greater Prairie-Chickens in Fragmented Grasslands , 2014, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[148]  Pawel Plonczkier,et al.  Radar monitoring of migrating pink‐footed geese: behavioural responses to offshore wind farm development , 2012 .

[149]  Scott C. Pedersen,et al.  Bat Evolution, Ecology, and Conservation , 2013, Springer New York.

[150]  V. Bennett,et al.  Red aviation lights on wind turbines do not increase bat–turbine collisions , 2014 .