Analysing livestock network data for infectious disease control: an argument for routine data collection in emerging economies

Livestock movements are an important mechanism of infectious disease transmission. Where these are well recorded, network analysis tools have been used to successfully identify system properties, highlight vulnerabilities to transmission, and inform targeted surveillance and control. Here we highlight the main uses of network properties in understanding livestock disease epidemiology and discuss statistical approaches to infer network characteristics from biased or fragmented datasets. We use a ‘hurdle model’ approach that predicts (i) the probability of movement and (ii) the number of livestock moved to generate synthetic ‘complete’ networks of movements between administrative wards, exploiting routinely collected government movement permit data from northern Tanzania. We demonstrate that this model captures a significant amount of the observed variation. Combining the cattle movement network with a spatial between-ward contact layer, we create a multiplex, over which we simulated the spread of ‘fast’ (R0 = 3) and ‘slow’ (R0 = 1.5) pathogens, and assess the effects of random versus targeted disease control interventions (vaccination and movement ban). The targeted interventions substantially outperform those randomly implemented for both fast and slow pathogens. Our findings provide motivation to encourage routine collection and centralization of movement data to construct representative networks. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Modelling infectious disease outbreaks in humans, animals and plants: epidemic forecasting and control’. This theme issue is linked with the earlier issue ‘Modelling infectious disease outbreaks in humans, animals and plants: approaches and important themes’.

[1]  K. Bardosh,et al.  Cattle movements and trypanosomes: restocking efforts and the spread of Trypanosoma brucei rhodesiense sleeping sickness in post-conflict Uganda , 2013, Parasites & Vectors.

[2]  Gerardo Chowell,et al.  Characterizing the Transmission Dynamics and Control of Ebola Virus Disease , 2015, PLoS biology.

[3]  David Lusseau,et al.  Taking sociality seriously: the structure of multi-dimensional social networks as a source of information for individuals , 2012, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[4]  D. Baker,et al.  Linking smallholders to livestock markets: Combining market and household survey data in Tanzania , 2011 .

[5]  R. Kao,et al.  Developing a framework for risk-based surveillance of tuberculosis in cattle: a case study of its application in Scotland , 2012, Epidemiology and Infection.

[6]  Rowland R. Kao,et al.  The UK foot-and-mouth disease outbreak — the aftermath , 2004, Nature Reviews Microbiology.

[7]  Peter I. Corke,et al.  Monitoring Animal Behaviour and Environmental Interactions Using Wireless Sensor Networks, GPS Collars and Satellite Remote Sensing , 2009, Sensors.

[8]  J. Pradère Improving animal health and livestock productivity to reduce poverty. , 2014, Revue scientifique et technique.

[9]  M E J Newman,et al.  Predicting epidemics on directed contact networks. , 2006, Journal of theoretical biology.

[10]  Steven J. M. Jones,et al.  Whole-genome sequencing and social-network analysis of a tuberculosis outbreak. , 2011, The New England journal of medicine.

[11]  Mark A. Miller,et al.  Synchrony, Waves, and Spatial Hierarchies in the Spread of Influenza , 2006, Science.

[12]  Gavin J. Gibson,et al.  A Systematic Bayesian Integration of Epidemiological and Genetic Data , 2015, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[13]  Suzanne M. O’Regan,et al.  Ebola Cases and Health System Demand in Liberia , 2014, PLoS biology.

[14]  David A. Rasmussen,et al.  Phylodynamic Inference for Structured Epidemiological Models , 2014, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[15]  Petter Holme,et al.  Bursty Communication Patterns Facilitate Spreading in a Threshold-Based Epidemic Dynamics , 2012, PloS one.

[16]  V. Jansen,et al.  Modelling the influence of human behaviour on the spread of infectious diseases: a review , 2010, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[17]  R. Kao,et al.  A metapopulation model for highly pathogenic avian influenza: implications for compartmentalization as a control measure , 2013, Epidemiology and Infection.

[18]  J Wallinga,et al.  Unravelling transmission trees of infectious diseases by combining genetic and epidemiological data , 2012, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[19]  Andrew J. Tatem,et al.  Virus evolution and transmission in an ever more connected world , 2015, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[20]  M. Hoelscher,et al.  High Seroprevalence of Rift Valley Fever and Evidence for Endemic Circulation in Mbeya Region, Tanzania, in a Cross-Sectional Study , 2012, PLoS neglected tropical diseases.

[21]  Ginestra Bianconi,et al.  Percolation in multiplex networks with overlap. , 2013, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[22]  S. Rushton,et al.  Where diseases and networks collide: lessons to be learnt from a study of the 2001 foot-and-mouth disease epidemic , 2005, Epidemiology and Infection.

[23]  Esteban Moro Egido,et al.  Branching Dynamics of Viral Information Spreading , 2011, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[24]  Xiaoming Xu,et al.  Percolation of a general network of networks. , 2013, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[25]  L. Allen Animal source foods to improve micronutrient nutrition and human function in developing countries. Proceedings of a conference. June 24-26, 2002. Washington, DC, USA. , 2003, The Journal of nutrition.

[26]  Alessandro Vespignani,et al.  Multiscale mobility networks and the spatial spreading of infectious diseases , 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[27]  D. Grace,et al.  The impacts of livestock diseases and their control on growth and development processes that are pro-poor , 2009, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[28]  Y. Xia,et al.  Measles Metapopulation Dynamics: A Gravity Model for Epidemiological Coupling and Dynamics , 2004, The American Naturalist.

[29]  Theodore Kypraios,et al.  Reconstructing transmission trees for communicable diseases using densely sampled genetic data. , 2014, The annals of applied statistics.

[30]  H. M. Munang'andu,et al.  The contribution of veterinary medicine to public health and poverty reduction in developing countries. , 2014, Veterinaria italiana.

[31]  I. Okike,et al.  Improving livestock marketing and intra-regional trade in West Africa: determining appropriate economic incentives and policy framework , 2006 .

[32]  Assessment of the likelihood of the introduction of foot-and-mouth disease through importation of live animals into the Malaysia-Thailand-Myanmar peninsula. , 2008, American journal of veterinary research.

[33]  C Dubé,et al.  Comparing network analysis measures to determine potential epidemic size of highly contagious exotic diseases in fragmented monthly networks of dairy cattle movements in Ontario, Canada. , 2008, Transboundary and emerging diseases.

[34]  Peter B. Coppolillo,et al.  The Landscape Ecology of Pastoral Herding: Spatial Analysis of Land Use and Livestock Production in East Africa , 2000 .

[35]  Nicola De Maio,et al.  SCOTTI: Efficient Reconstruction of Transmission within Outbreaks with the Structured Coalescent , 2016, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[36]  H. Steinfeld,et al.  Livestock's long shadow: environmental issues and options. , 2006 .

[37]  H. Prins,et al.  Disease transmission in animal transfer networks. , 2017, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[38]  R. Morris,et al.  A description of cattle movements in two departments of Buenos Aires province, Argentina. , 2006, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[39]  Joachim Krieter,et al.  Efficient Interruption of Infection Chains by Targeted Removal of Central Holdings in an Animal Trade Network , 2013, PloS one.

[40]  R. Smith,et al.  Minimization of bovine tuberculosis control costs in US dairy herds. , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[41]  M. Konschake,et al.  On the Robustness of In- and Out-Components in a Temporal Network , 2013, PloS one.

[42]  D. Macdonald,et al.  A restatement of the natural science evidence base relevant to the control of bovine tuberculosis in Great Britain† , 2013, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[43]  F. Natale,et al.  Network analysis of Italian cattle trade patterns and evaluation of risks for potential disease spread. , 2009, Preventive Veterinary Medicine.

[44]  J. Webster,et al.  Who acquires infection from whom and how? Disentangling multi-host and multi-mode transmission dynamics in the ‘elimination’ era , 2017, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[45]  David C. Bell,et al.  Centrality measures for disease transmission networks , 1999, Soc. Networks.

[46]  O. Pybus,et al.  Measurably evolving pathogens in the genomic era. , 2015, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[47]  Sandra Mounier-Jack,et al.  Towards a conceptual framework to support one-health research for policy on emerging zoonoses , 2011, The Lancet Infectious Diseases.

[48]  Albert-László Barabási,et al.  Universal resilience patterns in complex networks , 2016, Nature.

[49]  D. Green,et al.  Data quality of the Cattle Tracing System in Great Britain , 2007, Veterinary Record.

[50]  Colin J. Worby,et al.  Within-Host Bacterial Diversity Hinders Accurate Reconstruction of Transmission Networks from Genomic Distance Data , 2014, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[51]  M. Keeling,et al.  The effects of local spatial structure on epidemiological invasions , 1999, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[52]  Istvan Z Kiss,et al.  Parameterization of individual-based models: comparisons with deterministic mean-field models. , 2006, Journal of theoretical biology.

[53]  Joshua M. Epstein,et al.  Coupled Contagion Dynamics of Fear and Disease: Mathematical and Computational Explorations , 2007, PloS one.

[54]  Matthew Hall,et al.  Epidemic Reconstruction in a Phylogenetics Framework: Transmission Trees as Partitions of the Node Set , 2014, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[55]  R. Christley,et al.  Infection in social networks: using network analysis to identify high-risk individuals. , 2005, American journal of epidemiology.

[56]  A. Kelly,et al.  Veterinary medicine, global health. , 2007, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association.

[57]  Jacco Wallinga,et al.  Relating Phylogenetic Trees to Transmission Trees of Infectious Disease Outbreaks , 2013, Genetics.

[58]  Rowland R. Kao,et al.  Implications of within-farm transmission for network dynamics: Consequences for the spread of avian influenza , 2013, Epidemics.

[59]  J. Lindahl,et al.  A study of Rift Valley fever virus in Morogoro and Arusha regions of Tanzania – serology and farmers’ perceptions , 2015, Infection ecology & epidemiology.

[60]  V. Chevalier,et al.  Description and analysis of the cattle trade network in the Madagascar highlands: potential role in the diffusion of Rift Valley fever virus. , 2013, Acta tropica.

[61]  John A. Bartlett,et al.  Etiology of Severe Non-malaria Febrile Illness in Northern Tanzania: A Prospective Cohort Study , 2013, PLoS neglected tropical diseases.

[62]  Duncan J. Watts,et al.  Collective dynamics of ‘small-world’ networks , 1998, Nature.

[63]  Luca Bolzoni,et al.  The Potential Role of Direct and Indirect Contacts on Infection Spread in Dairy Farm Networks , 2017, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[64]  M. Gilbert,et al.  Towards the description of livestock mobility in Sahelian Africa: Some results from a survey in Mauritania , 2018, PloS one.

[65]  M. Craft,et al.  Seasonality and pathogen transmission in pastoral cattle contact networks , 2017, Royal Society Open Science.

[66]  Rowland R Kao,et al.  The role of mathematical modelling in the control of the 2001 FMD epidemic in the UK. , 2002, Trends in microbiology.

[67]  B. Durand,et al.  Role of Cattle Movements in Bovine Tuberculosis Spread in France between 2005 and 2014 , 2016, PloS one.

[68]  M. Craft,et al.  Optimal surveillance strategies for bovine tuberculosis in a low-prevalence country , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[69]  Monika Böhm,et al.  Contact Networks in a Wildlife-Livestock Host Community: Identifying High-Risk Individuals in the Transmission of Bovine TB among Badgers and Cattle , 2009, PloS one.

[70]  Brenda McCowan,et al.  Linking social and pathogen transmission networks using microbial genetics in giraffe (Giraffa camelopardalis). , 2014, The Journal of animal ecology.

[71]  Younjung Kim,et al.  Livestock trade network: potential for disease transmission and implications for risk-based surveillance on the island of Mayotte , 2018, Scientific Reports.

[72]  Ricard V. Solé,et al.  Complexity and fragility in ecological networks , 2000, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[73]  Jukka Corander,et al.  Two-phase importance sampling for inference about transmission trees , 2014, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[74]  R. Kao,et al.  Generating social network data using partially described networks: an example informing avian influenza control in the British poultry industry , 2011, BMC veterinary research.

[75]  Trevor Bedford,et al.  Eight challenges in phylodynamic inference , 2015, Epidemics.

[76]  S. Kasemsuwan,et al.  Social network analysis used to assess the relationship between the spread of avian influenza and movement patterns of backyard chickens in Ratchaburi, Thailand. , 2013, Research in veterinary science.

[77]  J. Anderies,et al.  From Metaphor to Measurement: Resilience of What to What? , 2001, Ecosystems.

[78]  Albert-László Barabási,et al.  Modeling bursts and heavy tails in human dynamics , 2005, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[79]  B. Bonfoh,et al.  Potential Risk of Regional Disease Spread in West Africa through Cross-Border Cattle Trade , 2013, PloS one.

[80]  Mason A. Porter,et al.  Multilayer networks , 2013, J. Complex Networks.

[81]  R. Kao,et al.  Risk-based strategies for surveillance of tuberculosis infection in cattle for low-risk areas in England and Scotland , 2017, Epidemiology and Infection.

[82]  Daniel T. Haydon,et al.  Transmission Pathways of Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus in the United Kingdom in 2007 , 2008, PLoS pathogens.

[83]  T. Geisel,et al.  The scaling laws of human travel , 2006, Nature.

[84]  Ethan Romero-Severson,et al.  Timing and order of transmission events is not directly reflected in a pathogen phylogeny. , 2014, Molecular biology and evolution.

[85]  Pavol Bauer,et al.  SimInf: An R Package for Data-Driven Stochastic Disease Spread Simulations , 2016, Journal of Statistical Software.

[86]  Tiziana Lembo,et al.  Bringing together emerging and endemic zoonoses surveillance: shared challenges and a common solution , 2012, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[87]  C Dubé,et al.  Introduction to network analysis and its implications for animal disease modelling. , 2011, Revue scientifique et technique.

[88]  Massimo Marchiori,et al.  Error and attacktolerance of complex network s , 2004 .

[89]  K. Goh,et al.  Spreading dynamics following bursty human activity patterns. , 2010, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[90]  B T Grenfell,et al.  Individual-based perspectives on R(0). , 2000, Journal of theoretical biology.

[91]  Fabrizio Natale,et al.  Evaluation of risk and vulnerability using a Disease Flow Centrality measure in dynamic cattle trade networks. , 2011, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[92]  L. Danon,et al.  Demographic structure and pathogen dynamics on the network of livestock movements in Great Britain , 2006, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[93]  A. Barabasi,et al.  Human dynamics: Darwin and Einstein correspondence patterns , 2005, Nature.

[94]  C. S. Holling Engineering Resilience versus Ecological Resilience , 1996 .

[95]  Samuel Soubeyrand,et al.  A Bayesian Inference Framework to Reconstruct Transmission Trees Using Epidemiological and Genetic Data , 2012, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[96]  M C M de Jong,et al.  Eight challenges in modelling infectious livestock diseases. , 2015, Epidemics.

[97]  Rowland R Kao,et al.  Supersize me: how whole-genome sequencing and big data are transforming epidemiology , 2014, Trends in Microbiology.

[98]  Anke Huss,et al.  Human–livestock contacts and their relationship to transmission of zoonotic pathogens, a systematic review of literature , 2016, One Health.

[99]  M. Nöremark,et al.  Network analysis of cattle and pig movements in Sweden: measures relevant for disease control and risk based surveillance. , 2011, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[100]  David Lusseau,et al.  Formalising the multidimensional nature of social networks , 2011, ArXiv.

[101]  Péter Érdi,et al.  Challenges in complex systems science , 2012, ArXiv.

[102]  N. Knowles,et al.  Combining livestock trade patterns with phylogenetics to help understand the spread of foot and mouth disease in sub-Saharan Africa, the Middle East and Southeast Asia. , 2011, Revue scientifique et technique.

[103]  Elisabeta Vergu,et al.  Characteristics of the spatio-temporal network of cattle movements in France over a 5-year period. , 2014, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[104]  D C Cole,et al.  Invited review: Role of livestock in human nutrition and health for poverty reduction in developing countries. , 2007, Journal of animal science.

[105]  M. Bigras-Poulin,et al.  Network analysis of Danish cattle industry trade patterns as an evaluation of risk potential for disease spread. , 2006, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[106]  Albert-László Barabási,et al.  The origin of bursts and heavy tails in human dynamics , 2005, Nature.

[107]  I. Kiss,et al.  Estimates for local and movement-based transmission of bovine tuberculosis in British cattle , 2008, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[108]  C. S. Holling Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems , 1973 .

[109]  M. Everett,et al.  Recent network evolution increases the potential for large epidemics in the British cattle population , 2007, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[110]  J. Crump,et al.  Leptospirosis and human immunodeficiency virus co-infection among febrile inpatients in northern Tanzania. , 2013, Vector borne and zoonotic diseases.

[111]  M. Batty,et al.  Gravity versus radiation models: on the importance of scale and heterogeneity in commuting flows. , 2012, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[112]  Petter Holme,et al.  The Basic Reproduction Number as a Predictor for Epidemic Outbreaks in Temporal Networks , 2014, PloS one.

[113]  D. Croft,et al.  Quantifying direct and indirect contacts for the potential transmission of infection between species using a multilayer contact network , 2018 .

[114]  Rowland R. Kao,et al.  Networks and Models with Heterogeneous Population Structure in Epidemiology , 2010, Network Science.

[115]  M. Craft Infectious disease transmission and contact networks in wildlife and livestock , 2015, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[116]  Jari Saramäki,et al.  Small But Slow World: How Network Topology and Burstiness Slow Down Spreading , 2010, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[117]  L. H. Taylor,et al.  Identifying Reservoirs of Infection: A Conceptual and Practical Challenge , 2002, Emerging infectious diseases.

[118]  Tanja Stadler,et al.  The relationship between transmission time and clustering methods in Mycobacterium tuberculosis epidemiology , 2018, bioRxiv.

[119]  Caroline O Buckee,et al.  Connecting Mobility to Infectious Diseases: The Promise and Limits of Mobile Phone Data. , 2016, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[120]  Luca Bolzoni,et al.  Modelling farm-to-farm disease transmission through personnel movements: from visits to contacts, and back , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[121]  R. Kazwala,et al.  Epidemiology of Brucella infection in the human, livestock and wildlife interface in the Katavi-Rukwa ecosystem, Tanzania , 2015, BMC Veterinary Research.

[122]  Mercedes Pascual,et al.  The multilayer nature of ecological networks , 2015, Nature Ecology &Evolution.

[123]  Meggan E Craft,et al.  Network analysis of cattle movements in Uruguay: Quantifying heterogeneity for risk-based disease surveillance and control. , 2016, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[124]  L. Schoonman,et al.  Herd- and animal-level risk factors for bovine leptospirosis in Tanga region of Tanzania , 2010, Tropical Animal Health and Production.

[125]  Marta C. González,et al.  A universal model for mobility and migration patterns , 2011, Nature.

[126]  Thibaut Jombart,et al.  Spatiotemporal dynamics in the early stages of the 2009 A/H1N1 influenza pandemic , 2009, PLoS currents.

[127]  T. Geisel,et al.  Forecast and control of epidemics in a globalized world. , 2004, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[128]  J. Rushton,et al.  The economic impacts of foot and mouth disease – What are they, how big are they and where do they occur? , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[129]  S. Cleaveland,et al.  Integrating serological and genetic data to quantify cross-species transmission: brucellosis as a case study , 2016, Parasitology.

[130]  W. Kalpravidh,et al.  Social network analysis of cattle movement in Kampong Cham, Kampong Speu and Takeo, Cambodia. , 2016, Acta tropica.

[131]  J. Crump,et al.  Epidemiology of Coxiella burnetii Infection in Africa: A OneHealth Systematic Review , 2014, PLoS neglected tropical diseases.

[132]  Rowland R Kao,et al.  Disease dynamics over very different time-scales: foot-and-mouth disease and scrapie on the network of livestock movements in the UK , 2007, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[133]  Iain Douglas-Hamilton,et al.  Feasibility study on the spatial and temporal movement of Samburu's cattle and wildlife in Kenya using GPS radio-tracking, remote sensing and GIS. , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[134]  T Jombart,et al.  Reconstructing disease outbreaks from genetic data: a graph approach , 2010, Heredity.

[135]  Ian Handel,et al.  Implications of the cattle trade network in Cameroon for regional disease prevention and control , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[136]  Massimiliano Zanin,et al.  Modeling the multi-layer nature of the European Air Transport Network: Resilience and passengers re-scheduling under random failures , 2012, ArXiv.

[137]  J. W. Wilesmith,et al.  Descriptive epidemiology of the 2001 foot-and-mouth disease epidemic in Great Britain: the first five months , 2001, Veterinary Record.

[138]  J. Crump,et al.  Risk Factors for Human Brucellosis in Northern Tanzania , 2017, The American journal of tropical medicine and hygiene.

[139]  C. Dubé,et al.  A review of network analysis terminology and its application to foot-and-mouth disease modelling and policy development. , 2009, Transboundary and emerging diseases.

[140]  Jessica Enright,et al.  Epidemics on dynamic networks. , 2018, Epidemics.

[141]  R. May,et al.  Modelling vaccination strategies against foot-and-mouth disease , 2003, Nature.

[142]  I. Kiss,et al.  The network of sheep movements within Great Britain: network properties and their implications for infectious disease spread , 2006, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[143]  L. Amaral,et al.  The web of human sexual contacts , 2001, Nature.

[144]  E. Thiry,et al.  Inter-epidemic Acquisition of Rift Valley Fever Virus in Humans in Tanzania , 2015, PLoS neglected tropical diseases.

[145]  A. Barrat,et al.  Dynamical Patterns of Cattle Trade Movements , 2011, PloS one.

[146]  Uno Wennergren,et al.  A Bayesian Approach for Modeling Cattle Movements in the United States: Scaling up a Partially Observed Network , 2013, PloS one.

[147]  G. Mgode,et al.  Leptospirosis in animals and humans in selected areas of Tanzania , 1997 .