Performance of low‐cost monitors to assess household air pollution

&NA; Exposure to household air pollution is a leading cause of morbidity and mortality globally. However, due to the lack of validated low‐cost monitors with long‐lasting batteries in indoor environments, most epidemiologic studies use self‐reported data or short‐term household air pollution assessments as proxies of long‐term exposure. We evaluated the performance of three low‐cost monitors measuring fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and carbon monoxide (CO) in a wood‐combustion experiment conducted in one household of Spain for 5 days (including the co‐location of 2 units of HAPEX and 3 units of TZOA‐R for PM2.5 and 3 units of EL‐USB‐CO for CO; a total of 40 unit‐days). We used Spearman correlation (&rgr;) and Concordance Correlation Coefficient (CCC) to assess accuracy of low‐cost monitors versus equivalent research‐grade devices. We also conducted a field study in India for 1 week (including HAPEX in 3 households and EL‐USB‐CO in 4 households; a total of 49 unit‐days). Correlation and agreement at 5‐min were moderate‐high for one unit of HAPEX (&rgr; = 0.73 / CCC = 0.59), for one unit of TZOA‐R (&rgr; = 0.89 / CCC = 0.62) and for three units of EL‐USB‐CO (&rgr; = 0.82–0.89 / CCC = 0.66–0.91) in Spain, although the failure or malfunction rate among low‐cost units was high in both settings (60% of unit‐days in Spain and 43% in India). Low‐cost monitors tested here are not yet ready to replace more established exposure assessment methods in long‐term household air pollution epidemiologic studies. More field validation is needed to assess evolving sensors and monitors with application to health studies. HighlightsWe assessed PM2.5 and CO low‐cost monitors in semi‐controlled and field studies.Devices experienced high failure rate and susceptibility to environmental changes.Low‐cost monitors tested may not be ready to replace more established methods.

[1]  Majid Sarrafzadeh,et al.  Temperature and humidity calibration of a low-cost wireless dust sensor for real-time monitoring , 2017, 2017 IEEE Sensors Applications Symposium (SAS).

[3]  Carlo Ratti,et al.  End-user perspective of low-cost sensors for outdoor air pollution monitoring. , 2017, The Science of the total environment.

[4]  Jonathan E. Thompson,et al.  Portable, Ambient PM2.5 Sensor for Human and/or Animal Exposure Studies , 2017 .

[5]  Markus Steiner,et al.  Using a new, low-cost air quality sensor to quantify second-hand smoke (SHS) levels in homes , 2013, Tobacco Control.

[6]  Grant R. McKercher,et al.  Characteristics and applications of small, portable gaseous air pollution monitors. , 2017, Environmental pollution.

[7]  Gustavo Olivares,et al.  The Outdoor Dust Information Node (ODIN) – development and performance assessment of a low cost ambient dust sensor , 2015 .

[8]  Gb Stewart,et al.  The use of electrochemical sensors for monitoring urban air quality in low-cost, high-density networks , 2013 .

[9]  J. Graziano,et al.  A cross-sectional study of exhaled carbon monoxide as a biomarker of recent household air pollution exposure. , 2015, Environmental research.

[10]  E. Snyder,et al.  The changing paradigm of air pollution monitoring. , 2013, Environmental science & technology.

[11]  Nadine Locoge,et al.  Development of a normalized multi-sensors system for low cost on-line atmospheric pollution detection , 2017 .

[12]  K. Balakrishnan,et al.  Respiratory risks from household air pollution in low and middle income countries. , 2014, The Lancet. Respiratory medicine.

[13]  P. Hopke,et al.  Laboratory assessment of low-cost PM monitors , 2016 .

[14]  T. Eck,et al.  A review of biomass burning emissions part III: intensive optical properties of biomass burning particles , 2004 .

[15]  Kwaku Poku Asante,et al.  Association of Carbon Monoxide exposure with blood pressure among pregnant women in rural Ghana: Evidence from GRAPHS. , 2016, International journal of hygiene and environmental health.

[16]  Matthias Budde,et al.  Investigating the use of commodity dust sensors for the embedded measurement of particulate matter , 2012, 2012 Ninth International Conference on Networked Sensing (INSS).

[17]  R. T. Lie,et al.  Function with Measured Carbon Monoxide Concentrations among Nonsmoking Women Exposed to Household Air Pollution: The RESPIRE Trial, Guatemala , 2014 .

[18]  K. Balakrishnan,et al.  Integrated assessment of exposure to PM2.5 in South India and its relation with cardiovascular risk: Design of the CHAI observational cohort study. , 2017, International journal of hygiene and environmental health.

[19]  V. Louis,et al.  Biomass smoke in Burkina Faso: what is the relationship between particulate matter, carbon monoxide, and kitchen characteristics? , 2014, Environmental Science and Pollution Research.

[20]  Rufus Edwards,et al.  An Inexpensive Dual-Chamber Particle Monitor: Laboratory Characterization , 2006, Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association.

[21]  Ashutosh Kumar Singh,et al.  Global, regional, and national comparative risk assessment of 79 behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks or clusters of risks, 1990–2015: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015 , 2016, Lancet.

[22]  M. Brauer,et al.  Woodsmoke Health Effects: A Review , 2007, Inhalation toxicology.

[23]  S. Zeger,et al.  Humidity and Gravimetric Equivalency Adjustments for Nephelometer-Based Particulate Matter Measurements of Emissions from Solid Biomass Fuel Use in Cookstoves , 2014, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[24]  Lidia Morawska,et al.  Real-time sensors for indoor air monitoring and challenges ahead in deploying them to urban buildings. , 2016, The Science of the total environment.

[25]  N. Bruce,et al.  Longitudinal Relationship between Personal CO and Personal PM2.5 among Women Cooking with Woodfired Cookstoves in Guatemala , 2013, PloS one.

[26]  R. Vermeulen,et al.  Personal and Indoor PM2.5 Exposure from Burning Solid Fuels in Vented and Unvented Stoves in a Rural Region of China with a High Incidence of Lung Cancer , 2014, Environmental science & technology.

[27]  Steven N. Chillrud,et al.  Health and Household Air Pollution from Solid Fuel Use: The Need for Improved Exposure Assessment , 2013, Environmental health perspectives.

[28]  A. Lewis,et al.  Validate personal air-pollution sensors , 2016, Nature.

[29]  R. C. Macridis A review , 1963 .

[30]  Anondo Mukherjee,et al.  Assessing the Utility of Low-Cost Particulate Matter Sensors over a 12-Week Period in the Cuyama Valley of California , 2017, Sensors.

[31]  C. Feldman Faculty Opinions recommendation of Estimates of the global, regional, and national morbidity, mortality, and aetiologies of lower respiratory tract infections in 195 countries: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015. , 2018, Faculty Opinions – Post-Publication Peer Review of the Biomedical Literature.

[32]  Constantinos Sioutas,et al.  Performance evaluation of the active-flow personal DataRAM PM2.5 mass monitor (Thermo Anderson pDR-1200) designed for continuous personal exposure measurements , 2004 .

[33]  Erich Barke,et al.  Hierarchical partitioning , 1996, Proceedings of International Conference on Computer Aided Design.

[34]  Chen Chen,et al.  Estimating Indoor PM2.5 and CO Concentrations in Households in Southern Nepal: The Nepal Cookstove Intervention Trials , 2016, PloS one.

[35]  Manuel Aleixandre,et al.  Review of Small Commercial Sensors for Indicative Monitoring of Ambient Gas , 2012 .

[36]  Xihui Gao,et al.  Indoor air pollution from solid biomass fuels combustion in rural agricultural area of Tibet, China. , 2009, Indoor air.

[37]  M. Bates,et al.  PM2.5 in household kitchens of Bhaktapur, Nepal, using four different cooking fuels , 2015 .

[38]  Alena Bartonova,et al.  Can commercial low-cost sensor platforms contribute to air quality monitoring and exposure estimates? , 2017, Environment international.

[39]  Michael Johnson,et al.  Small, Smart, Fast, and Cheap: Microchip-Based Sensors to Estimate Air Pollution Exposures in Rural Households , 2017, Sensors.

[40]  K. Koehler,et al.  Evaluation of consumer monitors to measure particulate matter. , 2017, Journal of aerosol science.

[41]  P. Hopke,et al.  Evaluation of new low-cost particle monitors for PM2.5 concentrations measurements , 2017 .

[42]  Yang Wang,et al.  Laboratory Evaluation and Calibration of Three Low-Cost Particle Sensors for Particulate Matter Measurement , 2015 .

[43]  Nigel Bruce,et al.  Impact of improved stoves, house construction and child location on levels of indoor air pollution exposure in young Guatemalan children , 2004, Journal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental Epidemiology.

[44]  Jo U. Smith,et al.  Impact of partial fuel switch on household air pollutants in sub-Sahara Africa. , 2017, Environmental pollution.

[45]  Thomas M. Peters,et al.  New Methods for Personal Exposure Monitoring for Airborne Particles , 2015, Current Environmental Health Reports.

[46]  Sumi Mehta,et al.  Indoor air pollution from household use of solid fuels , 2004 .

[47]  E. Seto,et al.  A distributed network of low-cost continuous reading sensors to measure spatiotemporal variations of PM2.5 in Xi'an, China. , 2015, Environmental pollution.

[48]  R. F. Brown,et al.  PERFORMANCE EVALUATION , 2019, ISO 22301:2019 and business continuity management – Understand how to plan, implement and enhance a business continuity management system (BCMS).

[49]  K. R. Smith,et al.  Carbon monoxide as a tracer for assessing exposures to particulate matter in wood and gas cookstove households of highland Guatemala. , 2001, Environmental science & technology.

[50]  P. Kinney,et al.  Personal exposures to fine particulate matter and black carbon in households cooking with biomass fuels in rural Ghana. , 2013, Environmental research.

[51]  D. Holstius,et al.  Field calibrations of a low-cost aerosol sensor at a regulatory monitoring site in California , 2014 .

[52]  R. Piedrahita On the Assessment of Air Pollution and Behavior within a Cookstove Intervention Study in Northern Ghana and Development of Improved Measurement Techniques , 2017 .

[53]  Roderic L. Jones,et al.  Validating novel air pollution sensors to improve exposure estimates for epidemiological analyses and citizen science , 2017, Environmental research.

[54]  M. Bell,et al.  A Comparison of Particulate Matter from Biomass-Burning Rural and Non-Biomass-Burning Urban Households in Northeastern China , 2008, Environmental health perspectives.

[55]  P. S. Praveen,et al.  Black carbon emissions from biomass and fossil fuels in rural India , 2011 .

[56]  Sumi Mehta,et al.  Indoor air pollution associated with household fuel use in India : an exposure assessment and modeling exercise in rural districts of Andhra Pradesh , 2004 .

[57]  A. Bartoňová,et al.  On the use of small and cheaper sensors and devices for indicative citizen-based monitoring of respirable particulate matter. , 2015, Environmental pollution.

[58]  S Vardoulakis,et al.  Are rocket mud stoves associated with lower indoor carbon monoxide and personal exposure in rural Kenya? , 2013, Indoor air.

[59]  A. Petrie,et al.  Method agreement analysis: a review of correct methodology. , 2010, Theriogenology.

[60]  B. Brunekreef,et al.  Outdoor, indoor, and personal black carbon exposure from cookstoves burning solid fuels. , 2016, Indoor air.

[61]  Geb Thomas,et al.  Inter-comparison of low-cost sensors for measuring the mass concentration of occupational aerosols , 2016, Aerosol science and technology : the journal of the American Association for Aerosol Research.

[62]  J. Miranda,et al.  Low correlation between household carbon monoxide and particulate matter concentrations from biomass-related pollution in three resource-poor settings. , 2015, Environmental research.

[63]  A. Hansell,et al.  Patterns of domestic exposure to carbon monoxide and particulate matter in households using biomass fuel in Janakpur, Nepal , 2017, Environmental pollution.

[64]  L. Naeher,et al.  Exposure of Pregnant Women to Cookstove-Related Household Air Pollution in Urban and Periurban Trujillo, Peru , 2015, Archives of environmental & occupational health.