During the past few years linguists have begun to express doubts about the validity of segmental analysis for the study of child language and have come to feel that it is probable that a child perceives spoken language differently from an adult, e.g. Bellugi & Brown (1964: 113), Ingram (1966: 218), Ladefoged (1967: 148–9), Lenneberg (1967: 279–281), Weir (1962: 30). They are also beginning to realize the importance of treating a child's language as having its own independent system (Carroll, 1961: 332; Fry, 1966: 194). To date, however, investigators of child speech have made their analyses on a segmental and distributional basis and have expressed the child's phonological system in terms of the adult's phonemic system; one may cite for example Cohen (1969), Gregoire (1933, 1947), Jakobson (1941), Jakobson & Halle (1961), Leopold (1939, 1947, 1961), Lewis (1968), Ohnesorg (1959), Velten (1943) and Weir (1962). Such studies, valuable though they be, cannot be said to have succeeded in explaining the relationship between the forms and structures of child and adult and have left many questions unanswered such as:
(1) What governs the choice of sound that the child will use as a ‘substitute’ for an adult sound?
(2) Why does the child ‘drop’ certain sounds of the adult form or ‘substitute’ for them when he is already capable of making such sounds and is in factusing them in some other contexts?
(3) Why does the child use homonyms for adult forms which appear to be quite unlike each other and which have been proved to be semantically clearly differentiated for the child?
(4) What governs the form that reduplicated words take?
[1]
G. Miller,et al.
The Genesis of Language: A Psycholinguistic Approach
,
1966
.
[2]
Dorothea McCarthy,et al.
Language development in children.
,
1946
.
[3]
H. V. Velten.
The growth of phonemic and lexical patterns in infant language
,
1943
.
[4]
Ursula Bellugi,et al.
Control of grammar in imitation, comprehension, and production
,
1963
.
[5]
J. Piaget.
The Language and Thought of the Child
,
1927
.
[6]
R. Brown.
How shall a thing be called.
,
1958,
Psychological review.
[7]
N. Waterson.
SOME SPEECH FORMS OF AN ENGLISH CHILD–A PHONOLOGICAL STUDY
,
1970
.
[8]
R. Weir,et al.
Language in the crib
,
1962
.
[9]
Werner F. Leopold,et al.
PATTERNING IN CHILDREN'S LANGUAGE LEARNING
,
1953
.
[10]
A. C. Gimson,et al.
An introduction to the pronunciation of English
,
1991
.
[11]
E. Lenneberg.
Biological Foundations of Language
,
1967
.
[12]
Noam Chomsky.
Current Issues in Linguistic Theory
,
1964
.
[13]
Eric H. Lenneberg,et al.
New directions in the study of language
,
1964
.
[14]
Eric H. Lenneberg,et al.
A Biological Perspective of Language
,
1972
.
[15]
Daniel Jones.
An outline of English phonetics
,
1956
.
[16]
P. Ladefoged.
Three areas of experimental phonetics
,
1967
.
[17]
J. Katz.
The philosophy of language
,
1967
.
[18]
Kemp Malone,et al.
Speech development of a bilingual child
,
1939
.
[19]
Noam Chomsky,et al.
वाक्यविन्यास का सैद्धान्तिक पक्ष = Aspects of the theory of syntax
,
1965
.
[20]
Roger S. Brown,et al.
The Acquisition Of Language
,
1964
.