Examining the presence, consequences, and reduction of implicit bias in health care: A narrative review

Recent evidence suggests that one possible cause of disparities in health outcomes for stigmatized groups is the implicit biases held by health care providers. In response, several health care organizations have called for, and developed, new training in implicit bias for their providers. This review examines current evidence on the role that provider implicit bias may play in health disparities, and whether training in implicit bias can effectively reduce the biases that providers exhibit. Directions for future research on the presence and consequences of provider implicit bias, and best practices for training to reduce such bias, will be discussed.

[1]  Frederick P Rivara,et al.  Physician Implicit Attitudes and Stereotypes About Race and Quality of Medical Care , 2008, Medical care.

[2]  M. van Ryn,et al.  The effect of patient race and socio-economic status on physicians' perceptions of patients. , 2000, Social science & medicine.

[3]  S. Saha,et al.  Reducing Racial Bias Among Health Care Providers: Lessons from Social-Cognitive Psychology , 2007, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[4]  G. Moskowitz,et al.  Implicit stereotyping and medical decisions: unconscious stereotype activation in practitioners' thoughts about African Americans. , 2012, American journal of public health.

[5]  J. Steiner,et al.  Unconscious (implicit) bias and health disparities: where do we go from here? , 2011, The Permanente journal.

[6]  N. Powe,et al.  Race, gender, and partnership in the patient-physician relationship. , 1999, JAMA.

[7]  M. Molinari,et al.  Don't look at my wheelchair! The plasticity of longlasting prejudice , 2015, Medical education.

[8]  T. Finucane,et al.  Racial bias in presentation of cases , 1990, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[9]  Ileana Arias,et al.  Physical and mental health effects of intimate partner violence for men and women. , 2002, American journal of preventive medicine.

[10]  S. Nolen-Hoeksema,et al.  Gender Differences in Depression , 2001 .

[11]  Laurie A. Rudman,et al.  "Unlearning" automatic biases: the malleability of implicit prejudice and stereotypes. , 2001, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[12]  Tessa V. West,et al.  Racial attitudes, physician-patient talk time ratio, and adherence in racially discordant medical interactions. , 2013, Social science & medicine.

[13]  Sandra E. Ward,et al.  Reducing racial disparities in pain treatment: The role of empathy and perspective-taking , 2011, PAIN.

[14]  I. Stepanikova,et al.  Racial-Ethnic Biases, Time Pressure, and Medical Decisions , 2012, Journal of health and social behavior.

[15]  R. Lipton,et al.  Attitudes and Issues in Treating Latino Patients With Type 2 Diabetes: Views of Healthcare Providers , 1998, The Diabetes educator.

[16]  M. Perugini,et al.  Prediction of behavior , 2010 .

[17]  A. Green,et al.  Helping medical learners recognise and manage unconscious bias toward certain patient groups , 2012, Medical education.

[18]  A. Galinsky,et al.  Perspective‐Taking as a Strategy for Improving Intergroup Relations: Evidence, Mechanisms, and Qualifications , 2014 .

[19]  B. Pizacani,et al.  Demonstrating the importance and feasibility of including sexual orientation in public health surveys: health disparities in the Pacific Northwest. , 2010, American journal of public health.

[20]  D. Buchwald,et al.  Clinicians' Implicit and Explicit Attitudes about Weight and Race and Treatment Approaches to Overweight for American Indian Children. , 2015, Childhood obesity.

[21]  Molly Carnes,et al.  Physicians and Implicit Bias: How Doctors May Unwittingly Perpetuate Health Care Disparities , 2013, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[22]  A. Galinsky,et al.  Does Perspective-Taking Increase Patient Satisfaction in Medical Encounters? , 2010, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[23]  R. Hardeman,et al.  Medical School Experiences Associated with Change in Implicit Racial Bias Among 3547 Students: A Medical Student CHANGES Study Report , 2015, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[24]  Laura Smart Richman,et al.  Perceived discrimination and health: a meta-analytic review. , 2009, Psychological bulletin.

[25]  V. Shavers,et al.  Knowledge of the Tuskegee study and its impact on the willingness to participate in medical research studies. , 2000, Journal of the National Medical Association.

[26]  D. Roter,et al.  Genetic counselors' implicit racial attitudes and their relationship to communication. , 2015, Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[27]  B. Teachman,et al.  Implicit anti-fat bias among health professionals: is anyone immune? , 2001, International Journal of Obesity.

[28]  M. Boninger,et al.  Examining implicit bias of physicians who care for individuals with spinal cord injury: A pilot study and future directions , 2015, The journal of spinal cord medicine.

[29]  N. Adler,et al.  U.S. disparities in health: descriptions, causes, and mechanisms. , 2008, Annual review of public health.

[30]  Adrienne Y. Stith,et al.  Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care , 2005 .

[31]  Brian A. Nosek,et al.  Do Physicians' Implicit Views of African Americans Affect Clinical Decision Making? , 2014, The Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine.

[32]  Brian Rubineau,et al.  Bias in White: A Longitudinal Natural Experiment Measuring Changes in Discrimination , 2012, Manag. Sci..

[33]  Mahzarin R. Banaji,et al.  Implicit Bias among Physicians and its Prediction of Thrombolysis Decisions for Black and White Patients , 2007, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[34]  J. Steiner,et al.  Assessment of biases against Latinos and African Americans among primary care providers and community members. , 2013, American journal of public health.

[35]  M. Ryn,et al.  Research on the provider contribution to race/ethnicity disparities in medical care. , 2002 .

[36]  Thomas S Inui,et al.  The associations of clinicians' implicit attitudes about race with medical visit communication and patient ratings of interpersonal care. , 2012, American journal of public health.

[37]  T. Koepsell,et al.  Patient-physician racial concordance and the perceived quality and use of health care. , 1999, Archives of internal medicine.

[38]  N. Kressin,et al.  Racial Differences in the Use of Invasive Cardiovascular Procedures: Review of the Literature and Prescription for Future Research , 2001, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[39]  M. van Ryn,et al.  Paved with good intentions: do public health and human service providers contribute to racial/ethnic disparities in health? , 2003, American journal of public health.

[40]  M. Mehl,et al.  The Hispanic health paradox: From epidemiological phenomenon to contribution opportunities for psychological science , 2016 .

[41]  Celeste M Condit,et al.  Genetic research and health disparities. , 2004, JAMA.

[42]  A. Greenwald,et al.  The influence of implicit bias on treatment recommendations for 4 common pediatric conditions: pain, urinary tract infection, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and asthma. , 2012, American journal of public health.

[43]  Debra L Roter,et al.  Patient-Centered Communication, Ratings of Care, and Concordance of Patient and Physician Race , 2003, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[44]  Brian A. Nosek,et al.  of Experimental Psychology : General Reducing Implicit Racial Preferences : I . A Comparative Investigation of 17 Interventions , 2014 .

[45]  M. Doty,et al.  DIVERSE COMMUNITIES, COMMON CONCERNS: ASSESSING HEALTH CARE QUALITY FOR MINORITY AMERICANS FINDINGS FROM THE COMMONWEALTH FUND 2001 HEALTH CARE QUALITY SURVEY , 2002 .

[46]  Peter R Harris,et al.  Self-affirmation reduces smokers' defensiveness to graphic on-pack cigarette warning labels. , 2007, Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[47]  K. Schulman,et al.  Race and sex differences in the management of coronary artery disease. , 2000, American heart journal.

[48]  Brian A. Nosek,et al.  Implicit and Explicit Stigma of Mental Illness: Links to Clinical Care , 2008, The Journal of nervous and mental disease.

[49]  G. Moskowitz,et al.  Non‐conscious bias in medical decision making: what can be done to reduce it? , 2011, Medical education.

[50]  Elizabeth S. Focella,et al.  Evidence of Nonconscious Stereotyping of Hispanic Patients by Nursing and Medical Students , 2013, Nursing research.

[51]  John F. Steiner,et al.  Clinicians’ Implicit Ethnic/Racial Bias and Perceptions of Care Among Black and Latino Patients , 2013, The Annals of Family Medicine.

[52]  Y. Paradies,et al.  A Systematic Review of the Extent and Measurement of Healthcare Provider Racism , 2014, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[53]  Britta M. Thompson,et al.  When Best Intentions Aren’t Enough: Helping Medical Students Develop Strategies for Managing Bias about Patients , 2010, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[54]  J. Dovidio,et al.  Disparities and distrust: the implications of psychological processes for understanding racial disparities in health and health care. , 2008, Social science & medicine.

[55]  David R. Williams,et al.  Discrimination and racial disparities in health: evidence and needed research , 2009, Journal of Behavioral Medicine.

[56]  Tsveti Markova,et al.  Aversive Racism and Medical Interactions with Black Patients: A Field Study. , 2010, Journal of experimental social psychology.

[57]  J. Dovidio,et al.  The effects of racial attitudes on affect and engagement in racially discordant medical interactions between non-Black physicians and Black patients , 2016, Group processes & intergroup relations : GPIR.

[58]  Mimi Y. Kim,et al.  Implicit Bias and Its Relation to Health Disparities: A Teaching Program and Survey of Medical Students , 2014, Teaching and learning in medicine.

[59]  A. Greenwald,et al.  Measuring individual differences in implicit cognition: the implicit association test. , 1998, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[60]  M. Graham,et al.  Scientific Diversity Interventions , 2014, Science.

[61]  Brian A. Nosek,et al.  Physicians’ Implicit and Explicit Attitudes About Race by MD Race, Ethnicity, and Gender , 2009, Journal of health care for the poor and underserved.

[62]  J. Freischlag,et al.  Unconscious race and social class bias among acute care surgical clinicians and clinical treatment decisions. , 2015, JAMA surgery.

[63]  W. von Hippel,et al.  Implicit Prejudice Toward Injecting Drug Users Predicts Intentions to Change Jobs Among Drug and Alcohol Nurses , 2008, Psychological science.

[64]  T. Laveist,et al.  Attitudes about Racism, Medical Mistrust, and Satisfaction with Care among African American and White Cardiac Patients , 2000, Medical care research and review : MCRR.

[65]  Brian A. Nosek,et al.  Implicit and Explicit Anti-Fat Bias among a Large Sample of Medical Doctors by BMI, Race/Ethnicity and Gender , 2012, PloS one.

[66]  C. Lampman,et al.  Assessing bias against overweight individuals among nursing and psychology students: an implicit association test. , 2012, Journal of clinical nursing.

[67]  K. Brownell,et al.  Weight bias among health professionals specializing in obesity. , 2003, Obesity research.

[68]  Peter J Pronovost,et al.  Association of unconscious race and social class bias with vignette-based clinical assessments by medical students. , 2011, JAMA.

[69]  J. Shepperd,et al.  Reducing Information Avoidance Through Affirmation , 2012, Psychological science.

[70]  Patrick S. Forscher,et al.  Long-term reduction in implicit race bias: A prejudice habit-breaking intervention. , 2012, Journal of experimental social psychology.

[71]  S. Quinn,et al.  African Americans' views on research and the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. , 2001, Social science & medicine.

[72]  J. Steiner,et al.  An Investigation of Associations Between Clinicians’ Ethnic or Racial Bias and Hypertension Treatment, Medication Adherence and Blood Pressure Control , 2014, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[73]  R. Fazio,et al.  Variability in automatic activation as an unobtrusive measure of racial attitudes: a bona fide pipeline? , 1995, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[74]  Heather M. Tavel,et al.  Sociodemographic and Clinical Characteristics Are Not Clinically Useful Predictors of Refill Adherence in Patients With Hypertension , 2009, Circulation. Cardiovascular quality and outcomes.

[75]  J. Dovidio,et al.  Implicit and explicit prejudice and interracial interaction. , 2002, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[76]  F. Pratto,et al.  Encouraging majority support for immigrant access to health services: Multiple categorization and social identity complexity as antecedents of health equality , 2016 .

[77]  R. Hardeman,et al.  Do Contact and Empathy Mitigate Bias Against Gay and Lesbian People Among Heterosexual First-Year Medical Students? A Report From the Medical Student CHANGE Study , 2015, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[78]  J. McLeod,et al.  The Social Psychology of Health Disparities , 2005 .

[79]  J. Freischlag,et al.  Unconscious Race and Class Biases among Registered Nurses: Vignette-Based Study Using Implicit Association Testing. , 2015, Journal of the American College of Surgeons.

[80]  J. Dovidio,et al.  Reducing Racial Health Care Disparities , 2014, Policy insights from the behavioral and brain sciences.

[81]  Brian A. Nosek,et al.  Health Care Providers' Implicit and Explicit Attitudes Toward Lesbian Women and Gay Men. , 2015, American journal of public health.