Secure merge with O(n log log n) secure operation

Data-oblivious algorithms are a key component of many secure computation protocols. In this work, we show that advances in secure multiparty shuffling algorithms can be used to increase the efficiency of several key cryptographic tools. The key observation is that many secure computation protocols rely heavily on secure shuffles. The best data-oblivious shuffling algorithms require O(n log n), operations, but in the two-party or multiparty setting, secure shuffling can be achieved with only O(n) communication. Leveraging the efficiency of secure multiparty shuffling, we give novel algorithms that improve the efficiency of securely sorting sparse lists, secure stable compaction, and securely merging two sorted lists. Securely sorting private lists is a key component of many larger secure computation protocols. The best data-oblivious sorting algorithms for sorting a list of n elements require O(n log n) comparisons. Using black-box access to a linear-communication secure shuffle, we give a secure algorithm for sorting a list of length n with t n nonzero elements with communication O(t log n+n), which beats the best oblivious algorithms when the number of nonzero elements, t, satisfies t < n/ log n. Secure compaction is the problem of removing dummy elements from a list, and is essentially equivalent to sorting on 1-bit keys. The best oblivious compaction algorithms run in O(n)-time, but they are unstable, i.e., the order of the remaining elements is not preserved. Using black-box access to a linear-communication secure shuffle, we give a stable compaction algorithm with only O(n) communication. Our main result is a novel secure merge protocol. The best previous algorithms for securely merging two sorted lists into a sorted whole required O(n log n) secure operations. Using blackbox access to an O(n)-communication secure shuffle, we give the first secure merge algorithm that requires only O(n log log n) communication. Our algorithm takes as input n secret-shared values, and outputs a secret-sharing of the sorted list. All our algorithms are generic, i.e., they can be implemented using generic secure computations techniques and make black-box access to a secure shuffle. Our techniques extend naturally to the multiparty situation (with a constant number of parties) as well as to handle malicious adversaries without changing the asymptotic efficiency. These algorithm have applications to securely computing database joins and order statistics on private data as well as multiparty Oblivious RAM protocols. Patent pending fbrett@cis.upenn.edu Work done while consulting for Stealth Software Technologies, Inc. rafail@cs.ucla.edu Work done while consulting for Stealth Software Technologies, Inc.