The Settlement Date of Iceland Revisited: Evaluation of 14C Dates from Sites of Early Settlers in Iceland by Bayesian Statistics

Abstract The settlement time of Iceland has been debated for years as radiocarbon dates of bulk wood samples have been interpreted to set a timing 150–200 yr earlier than indicated by tephrochronology (later than AD 871±2) and the Sagas (AD 874). This early date is also in conflict with the dating results on extensive series of short-lived material such as grain and domestic animal and human bone remains of early settlers. The old-wood effect for the charcoal and bulk wood samples has been suggested to explain this controversy. This study uses a Bayesian model, implemented in the OxCal program, to show that the charcoal data combined with short-lived material (grain/bone) suggest ages anywhere in the interval AD 854–922 (95.4% probability), indicating that the available 14C data cannot be taken as compelling evidence that there was a settlement any earlier than AD 922. The Bayesian model shows that the observed exponential distribution of the excess age of the bulk wood samples is exactly as expected if there was an old-wood effect evident in the samples.

[1]  P. Ascough,et al.  Reservoirs and Radiocarbon: 14C Dating Problems in Mývatnssveit, Northern Iceland , 2007, Radiocarbon.

[2]  F. McCormac,et al.  Tephra-dated lowland landscape history of the north of Ireland, A.D. 750-1150. , 1993, The New phytologist.

[3]  T. H. Jónsson.  Stature of sub-arctic birch in relation to growth rate, lifespan and tree form. , 2004, Annals of botany.

[4]  M. Lawson,et al.  DENDROCLIMATIC ANALYSIS OF BIRCH IN SOUTH GREENLAND , 1982 .

[5]  R. Govaerts,et al.  World Checklist and Bibliography of Fagales (Betulaceae, Corylaceae, Fagaceae and Ticodendraceae) , 1998 .

[6]  P. Ascough,et al.  Temporal and Spatial Variations in Freshwater 14C Reservoir Effects: Lake Mývatn, Northern Iceland , 2010, Radiocarbon.

[7]  J. Heinemeier,et al.  14C Dating of the Settlement of Iceland , 2004, Radiocarbon.

[8]  M. D. Germani,et al.  Volcanic Aerosol Records and Tephrochronology of the Summit, Greenland, Ice Cores , 1997 .

[9]  P. Theodórsson.  Norse settlement of Iceland — close to ad 700? , 1998 .

[10]  E. Bard,et al.  Ash layers from Iceland in the Greenland GRIP ice core correlated with oceanic and land sediments , 1995 .

[11]  W. F. Libby,et al.  Age determinations by radiocarbon content; checks with samples of known age. , 1949, Science.

[12]  P. Ascough,et al.  An Icelandic freshwater radiocarbon reservoir effect: Implications for lacustrine 14C chronologies , 2011 .

[13]  J. Huebert,et al.  Short-Lived Plant Materials, Long-Lived Trees, and Polynesian 14C Dating: Considerations for 14C Sample Selection and Documentation , 2014, Radiocarbon.

[14]  N. Lynnerup,et al.  Dietary Reconstruction and Reservoir Correction of 14C Dates on Bones from Pagan and Early Christian Graves in Iceland , 2010, Radiocarbon.

[15]  C. Bronk Ramsey.  Dealing with Outliers and Offsets in Radiocarbon Dating , 2009, Radiocarbon.

[16]  Michael W. Dee,et al.  High-Precision Bayesian Modeling of Samples Susceptible to Inbuilt Age , 2014, Radiocarbon.

[17]  C. Buck,et al.  IntCal13 and Marine13 Radiocarbon Age Calibration Curves 0–50,000 Years cal BP , 2013, Radiocarbon.

[18]  Christopher Bronk,et al.  Radiocarbon Calibration and Analysis of Stratigraphy: The OxCal Program , 1995, Radiocarbon.

[19]  P. Ascough,et al.  Radiocarbon reservoir effects in human bone collagen from northern Iceland , 2012 .

[20]  Niels Lynnerup,et al.  Change of Diet of the Greenland Vikings Determined from Stable Carbon Isotope Analysis and 14C Dating of Their Bones , 1999, Radiocarbon.