A proposed change to astronaut exposures limits is a giant leap backwards for radiation protection.

Addressing the uncertainties in assessing health risks from cosmic ray heavy ions is a major scientific challenge recognized by many previous reports by the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) and the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (NCRP) advising the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA). These reports suggested a series of steps to pursue the scientific basis for space radiation protection, including the implementation of age and sex dependent risk assessments and exposure limits appropriate for a small population of radiation workers, the evaluation of uncertainties in risk projections, and developing a vigorous research program in heavy ion radiobiology to reduce uncertainties and discover effective countermeasures. The assessment of uncertainties in assessing risk provides protection against changing assessments of risk, reveals limitations in information used in space mission operations, and provides the impetus to reduce uncertainties and discover the true level of risk and possible effectiveness of countermeasures through research. However, recommendations of a recent NAS report, in an effort to minimize differences in age and sex on flight opportunities, suggest a 600 mSv career effective dose limit based on a median estimate to reach 3% cancer fatality for 35-year old females. The NAS report does not call out examples where females would be excluded from space missions planned in the current decade using the current radiation limits at NASA. In addition, there are minimal considerations of the level of risk to be encountered at this exposure level with respect to the uncertainties of heavy ion radiobiology, and risks of cancer, as well as cognitive detriments and circulatory diseases. Furthermore, their recommendation to limit Sieverts and not risk in conjunction with a waiver process is essentially a recommendation to remove radiation limits for astronauts. We discuss issues with several of the NAS recommendations with the conclusion that the recommendations could have negative impacts on crew health and safety, and violate the three principles of radiation protection (to prevent clinically significant deterministic effects, limit stochastic effects, and practice ALARA), which would be a giant leap backwards for radiation protection.

[1]  Leif E. Peterson,et al.  NASA Study of Cataract in Astronauts (NASCA). Report 1: Cross-Sectional Study of the Relationship of Exposure to Space Radiation and Risk of Lens Opacity , 2009, Radiation research.

[2]  M. C. Angulo,et al.  Sex-Specific Cognitive Deficits Following Space Radiation Exposure , 2020, Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience.

[3]  Francis A. Cucinotta,et al.  How Safe Is Safe Enough? Radiation Risk for a Human Mission to Mars , 2013, PloS one.

[4]  Non-Targeted Effects Models Predict Significantly Higher Mars Mission Cancer Risk than Targeted Effects Models , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[5]  A. Fornace,et al.  Heavy Ion Radiation Exposure Triggered Higher Intestinal Tumor Frequency and Greater β-Catenin Activation than γ Radiation in APCMin/+ Mice , 2013, PloS one.

[6]  Francis A. Cucinotta,et al.  Physical and Biological Organ Dosimetry Analysis for International Space Station Astronauts , 2008, Radiation research.

[7]  D. Fairchild,et al.  Harderian Gland Tumorigenesis: Low-Dose and LET Response , 2016, Radiation Research.

[8]  Javier Gómez-Elvira,et al.  Comparison of Martian surface ionizing radiation measurements from MSL‐RAD with Badhwar‐O'Neill 2011/HZETRN model calculations , 2014 .

[9]  W Schimmerling,et al.  Dose and dose rate effectiveness of space radiation. , 2006, Radiation protection dosimetry.

[10]  P. Powers-Risius,et al.  The relative biological effect of high-Z, high-LET charged particles for spermatogonial killing. , 1981, Radiation research.

[11]  Cécile Huin-Schohn,et al.  Could spaceflight‐associated immune system weakening preclude the expansion of human presence beyond Earth's orbit? , 2009, Journal of leukocyte biology.

[12]  D. Hoel.  Comments on the DDREF Estimate of the BEIR VII Committee , 2015, Health physics.

[13]  N. Hamada,et al.  Occupational exposure to chronic ionizing radiation increases risk of Parkinson's disease incidence in Russian Mayak workers. , 2019, International journal of epidemiology.

[14]  P. Powers-Risius,et al.  Tumorigenic potential of high-Z, high-LET charged-particle radiations. , 1993, Radiation research.

[15]  F. Cucinotta,et al.  Predictions of space radiation fatality risk for exploration missions. , 2017, Life sciences in space research.

[16]  David J Brenner,et al.  Biological effects in unirradiated human tissue induced by radiation damage up to 1 mm away. , 2005, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[17]  David B Richardson,et al.  Ionising radiation and risk of death from leukaemia and lymphoma in radiation-monitored workers (INWORKS): an international cohort study , 2015, The Lancet. Haematology.

[18]  J. Little,et al.  Induction of sister chromatid exchanges by extremely low doses of alpha-particles. , 1992, Cancer research.

[19]  Ianik Plante,et al.  Ionization and excitation cross sections for the interaction of HZE particles in liquid water and application to Monte Carlo simulation of radiation tracks , 2008 .

[20]  J. Baulch,et al.  What happens to your brain on the way to Mars , 2015, Science Advances.

[21]  Dale L Preston,et al.  Solid Cancer Incidence among the Life Span Study of Atomic Bomb Survivors: 1958–2009 , 2017, Radiation Research.

[22]  R. Ullrich,et al.  Neutron carcinogenesis. Dose and dose-rate effects in BALB/c mice. , 1977, Radiation research.

[23]  Mi-Ae Park,et al.  Space-like 56Fe irradiation manifests mild, early sex-specific behavioral and neuropathological changes in wildtype and Alzheimer’s-like transgenic mice , 2019, Scientific Reports.

[24]  C. Lushbaugh.  Guidance on Radiation Received in Space Activities , 1990 .

[25]  F. Cucinotta.  A New Approach to Reduce Uncertainties in Space Radiation Cancer Risk Predictions , 2015, PloS one.

[26]  Francis A. Cucinotta,et al.  Space Radiation Risks for Astronauts on Multiple International Space Station Missions , 2014, PloS one.

[27]  F. Cucinotta,et al.  Space Radiation Quality Factors and the Delta Ray Dose and Dose-Rate Reduction Effectiveness Factor , 2016, Health physics.

[28]  David B Richardson,et al.  Risk of cancer from occupational exposure to ionising radiation: retrospective cohort study of workers in France, the United Kingdom, and the United States (INWORKS) , 2015, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[29]  Michael M. Weil,et al.  Incidence of Acute Myeloid Leukemia and Hepatocellular Carcinoma in Mice Irradiated with 1 GeV/nucleon 56Fe Ions , 2009, Radiation research.

[30]  G. Lawson,et al.  Charged-Iron-Particles Found in Galactic Cosmic Rays are Potent Inducers of Epithelial Ovarian Tumors , 2018, Radiation Research.

[31]  H. Sugiyama,et al.  Incidence of Breast Cancer in the Life Span Study of Atomic Bomb Survivors: 1958–2009 , 2018, Radiation Research.

[32]  Vipan K. Parihar,et al.  Cosmic radiation exposure and persistent cognitive dysfunction , 2016, Scientific Reports.

[33]  Premkumar B. Saganti,et al.  Benchmarking risk predictions and uncertainties in the NSCR model of GCR cancer risks with revised low let risk coefficients. , 2020, Life sciences in space research.

[34]  J. Clayton,et al.  Applying the new SABV (sex as a biological variable) policy to research and clinical care , 2017, Physiology & Behavior.

[35]  K. Kodama,et al.  Heart Disease Mortality in the Life Span Study, 1950–2008 , 2017, Radiation Research.

[36]  B. Carnes,et al.  The Comparative Tumorigenic Effects of Fission Neutrons and Cobalt-60 γ Rays in the B6CF1 Mouse , 1992 .

[37]  E. Wright,et al.  Radiation-induced genomic instability and bystander effects: inter-related nontargeted effects of exposure to ionizing radiation , 2003, Oncogene.

[38]  Premkumar B. Saganti,et al.  Relative Biological Effectiveness of HZE Particles for Chromosomal Exchanges and Other Surrogate Cancer Risk Endpoints , 2016, PloS one.

[39]  E. J. Ainsworth,et al.  High-LET radiation carcinogenesis. , 1985 .

[40]  Bahram Parvin,et al.  Targeted and nontargeted effects of ionizing radiation that impact genomic instability. , 2008, Cancer research.

[41]  A. Jemal,et al.  Cancer Statistics, 2021 , 2021, CA: a cancer journal for clinicians.

[42]  J. Coggle.  Lung tumour induction in mice after X-rays and neutrons. , 1988, International journal of radiation biology and related studies in physics, chemistry, and medicine.

[43]  M. Little,et al.  Non-targeted effects of ionising radiation--implications for low dose risk. , 2013, Mutation research.

[44]  F. Cucinotta,et al.  Risks of cognitive detriments after low dose heavy ion and proton exposures , 2019, International journal of radiation biology.

[45]  F. Cucinotta,et al.  Safe days in space with acceptable uncertainty from space radiation exposure. , 2015, Life sciences in space research.

[46]  F A Cucinotta,et al.  The effects of delta rays on the number of particle-track traversals per cell in laboratory and space exposures. , 1998, Radiation research.

[47]  Premkumar B. Saganti,et al.  NON-TARGETED EFFECTS LEAD TO A PARIDIGM SHIFT IN RISK ASSESSMENT FOR A MISSION TO THE EARTH'S MOON OR MARTIAN MOON PHOBOS. , 2018, Radiation protection dosimetry.

[48]  Walter Schimmerling.  Accepting space radiation risks , 2010, Radiation and environmental biophysics.

[49]  Francis A. Cucinotta,et al.  Cancer and circulatory disease risks for a human mission to Mars: Private mission considerations , 2020 .

[50]  A. Fornace,et al.  Relative Biological Effectiveness of Energetic Heavy Ions for Intestinal Tumorigenesis Shows Male Preponderance and Radiation Type and Energy Dependence in APC(1638N/+) Mice. , 2016, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[51]  M. Hada,et al.  Induction of Chromosomal Aberrations at Fluences of Less Than One HZE Particle per Cell Nucleus , 2014, Radiation research.

[52]  F A Cucinotta,et al.  Space Radiation and Cataracts in Astronauts , 2001, Radiation research.

[53]  R. Ullrich,et al.  Effects of 28Si Ions, 56Fe Ions, and Protons on the Induction of Murine Acute Myeloid Leukemia and Hepatocellular Carcinoma , 2014, PloS one.

[54]  M. Barcellos-Hoff,et al.  HZE Radiation Non-Targeted Effects on the Microenvironment That Mediate Mammary Carcinogenesis , 2016, Front. Oncol..

[55]  A. Wyrobek,et al.  Spatial Memory Performance of Socially Mature Wistar Rats is Impaired after Exposure to Low (5 cGy) Doses of 1 GeV/n 48Ti Particles , 2017, Radiation Research.

[56]  Xiang Wang,et al.  Relative Effectiveness at 1 Gy after Acute and Fractionated Exposures of Heavy Ions with Different Linear Energy Transfer for Lung Tumorigenesis , 2015, Radiation research.

[57]  A. Fornace,et al.  Enhanced intestinal tumor multiplicity and grade in vivo after HZE exposure: mouse models for space radiation risk estimates , 2010, Radiation and environmental biophysics.

[58]  Michael L. Gatza,et al.  Aggressive Mammary Cancers Lacking Lymphocytic Infiltration Arise in Irradiated Mice and Can Be Prevented by Dietary Intervention , 2019, Cancer Immunology Research.

[59]  D. Goodhead,et al.  Track structure analysis of ultrasoft X-rays compared to high- and low-LET radiations. , 1989, International journal of radiation biology.

[60]  D. Richardson,et al.  Site-specific Solid Cancer Mortality After Exposure to Ionizing Radiation: A Cohort Study of Workers (INWORKS) , 2018, Epidemiology.

[61]  Francis A. Cucinotta,et al.  Space Radiation Cancer Risk Projections and Uncertainties - 2010 , 2011 .

[62]  S. Demaria,et al.  Densely ionizing radiation acts via the microenvironment to promote aggressive Trp53-null mammary carcinomas. , 2014, Cancer research.

[63]  R. Fry,et al.  Extrapolation of the relative risk of radiogenic neoplasms across mouse strains and to man. , 1988, Radiation research.

[64]  R. Fry.  Experimental radiation carcinogenesis: what have we learned? , 1981, Radiation research.

[65]  J. Raber,et al.  Sex- and dose-dependent effects of calcium ion irradiation on behavioral performance of B6D2F1 mice during contextual fear conditioning training. , 2016, Life sciences in space research.

[66]  Y. Shimada,et al.  High relative biologic effectiveness of carbon ion radiation on induction of rat mammary carcinoma and its lack of H-ras and Tp53 mutations. , 2007, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[67]  T. Akiyama,et al.  How does spaceflight affect the acquired immune system? , 2020, npj Microgravity.

[68]  Francis A. Cucinotta,et al.  Space radiation risks to the central nervous system , 2014 .

[69]  H. Sugiyama,et al.  Radiation Exposure and the Risk of Mortality from Noncancer Respiratory Diseases in the Life Span Study, 1950–2005 , 2013, Radiation research.

[70]  R. Ullrich,et al.  The influence of dose and dose rate on the incidence of neoplastic disease in RFM mice after neutron irradiation. , 1976, Radiation research.

[71]  M. Weil,et al.  Personalized Cancer Risk Assessments for Space Radiation Exposures , 2016, Front. Oncol..