Seat belt use among rear passengers: validity of self-reported versus observational measures

BackgroundThe effects of seat belt laws and public education campaigns on seat belt use are assessed on the basis of observational or self-reported data on seat belt use.Previous studies focusing on front seat occupants have shown that self-reports indicate a greater seat belt usage than observational findings.Whether this over-reporting in self reports applies to rear seat belt usage, and to what extent, have yet to be investigated.We aimed to evaluate the over-reporting factor for rear seat passengers and whether this varies by gender and under different compulsory seat belt use conditions.MethodsThe study was conducted in the Veneto Region, an area in the North-East of Italy with a population of 4.7 million.The prevalence of seat belt use among rear seat passengers was determined by means of a cross-sectional self-report survey and an observational study.Both investigations were performed in two time periods: in 2003, when rear seat belt use was not enforced by primary legislation, and in 2005, after rear seat belt use had become compulsory (June 2003).Overall, 8138 observations and 7902 interviews were recorded.Gender differences in the prevalence of rear seat belt use were examined using the chi-square test. The over-reporting factor, defined as the ratio of the self-reported to the observed prevalence of rear seat belt use, was calculated by gender before and after the rear seat belt legislation came into effect.ResultsAmong rear seat passengers, self-reported rates were always higher than the observational findings, with an overall over-reporting factor of 1.4.We registered no statistically significant changes over time in the over-reporting factor, nor any major differences between genders.ConclusionSelf-reported seat belt usage by rear passengers represents an efficient alternative to observational studies for tracking changes in actual behavior, although the reported figures need to be adjusted using an appropriate over-reporting factor in order to gain an idea of genuine seat belt use.

[1]  Jeremy Broughton.  The actual threat posed by unrestrained rear seat car passengers. , 2004, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[2]  L S Robertson,et al.  The validity of self-reported behavioral risk factors: seatbelt and alcohol use. , 1992, The Journal of trauma.

[3]  L S Robertson.  Reduced fatalities related to rear seat shoulder belts , 1999, Injury prevention : journal of the International Society for Child and Adolescent Injury Prevention.

[4]  Alan Blatt,et al.  The effect of unrestrained rear-seat passengers on driver mortality. , 2006, The Journal of trauma.

[5]  M. Marchesan,et al.  Evidence-based policy on road safety: the effect of the demerit points system on seat belt use and health outcomes , 2007, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health.

[6]  Peter Cummings,et al.  Association of rear seat safety belt use with death in a traffic crash: a matched cohort study , 2007, Injury Prevention.

[7]  M A Parada,et al.  The validity of self-reported seatbelt use: Hispanic and non-Hispanic drivers in El Paso. , 2001, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[8]  J. Mayrose,et al.  Influence of the Unbelted Rear-seat Passenger on Driver Mortality , 2004 .

[9]  T S Dee,et al.  Reconsidering the effects of seat belt laws and their enforcement status. , 1998, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[10]  J Ozanne-Smith,et al.  Pattern of seat belt wearing in Nanjing, China , 2007, Injury Prevention.

[11]  Gunilla Fhaner,et al.  Seat belts: The importance of situational factors☆ , 1973 .

[12]  L Evans.  Rear seat restraint system effectiveness in preventing fatalities. , 1988, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[13]  S. Mcilvenny,et al.  Rear seat belt use as an indicator of safe road behaviour in a rapidly developing country , 2004, The journal of the Royal Society for the Promotion of Health.

[14]  L. Zaletel-Kragelj,et al.  Seat-belt use and non-use in adults in Slovenia , 2007, International Journal of Public Health.

[15]  D Shinar,et al.  Self-reports of safe driving behaviors in relationship to sex, age, education and income in the US adult driving population. , 2001, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[16]  Brian Tew,et al.  Economic Co-operation in Europe. A Study of the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe. , 1957 .

[17]  F M Streff,et al.  Are there really shortcuts? Estimating seat belt use with self-report measures. , 1989, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[18]  I B Pless,et al.  A comparison of observed and reported restraint use by children and adults. , 1985, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[19]  James Mayrose,et al.  Influence of the unbelted rear-seat passenger on driver mortality: "the backseat bullet". , 2005, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[20]  S. Wakai,et al.  Mortality of front-seat occupants attributable to unbelted rear-seat passengers in car crashes , 2002, The Lancet.

[21]  D E Nelson,et al.  Validity of self reported data on injury prevention behavior: lessons from observational and self reported surveys of safety belt use in the US. , 1996, Injury prevention : journal of the International Society for Child and Adolescent Injury Prevention.