A New Condition for Transitivity of Probabilistic Support

As is well known, implication is transitive but probabilistic support is not. Eells and Sober, followed by Shogenji, showed that screening off is a sufficient constraint for the transitivity of probabilistic support. Moreover, this screening off condition can be weakened without sacrificing transitivity, as was demonstrated by Suppes and later by Roche. In this paper we introduce an even weaker sufficient condition for the transitivity of probabilistic support, in fact one that can be made as weak as one wishes. We explain that this condition has an interesting property: it shows that transitivity is retained even though the Simpson paradox reigns. We further show that by adding a certain restriction the condition can be turned into one that is both sufficient and necessary for transitivity.

[1]  Branden Fitelson The Plurality of Bayesian Measures of Confirmation and the Problem of Measure Sensitivity , 1999, Philosophy of Science.

[2]  Tomoji Shogenji Mediated Confirmation , 2017, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science.

[3]  E. H. Simpson,et al.  The Interpretation of Interaction in Contingency Tables , 1951 .

[4]  M. R. Novick,et al.  The Role of Exchangeability in Inference , 1981 .

[5]  S. Julious,et al.  Confounding and Simpson's paradox , 1994, BMJ.

[6]  I. Good,et al.  The Amalgamation and Geometry of Two-by-Two Contingency Tables , 1987 .

[7]  Branden Fitelson,et al.  How Not to Detect Design , 1999, Philosophy of Science.

[8]  William Roche IS EVIDENCE OF EVIDENCE EVIDENCE? SCREENING-OFF VS. NO-DEFEATERS , 2017, Episteme.

[9]  Tomoji Shogenji A Condition for Transitivity in Probabilistic Support , 2003, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science.

[10]  Y. Mittal Homogeneity of Subpopulations and Simpson's Paradox , 1991 .

[11]  P. Suppes Non-Markovian causality in the social sciences with some theorems on transitivity , 1986, Synthese.

[12]  R. William IS EVIDENCE OF EVIDENCE EVIDENCE? SCREENING-OFF VS. NO-DEFEATERS , 2018 .

[13]  C. Charig,et al.  Comparison of treatment of renal calculi by open surgery, percutaneous nephrolithotomy, and extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy. , 1986, British medical journal.

[14]  Rudolf Carnap,et al.  Logical foundations of probability , 1951 .

[15]  E. Eells,et al.  Probabilistic Causality and the Question of Transitivity , 1983, Philosophy of Science.

[16]  G. Yule NOTES ON THE THEORY OF ASSOCIATION OF ATTRIBUTES IN STATISTICS , 1903 .

[17]  Vincenzo Crupi,et al.  On Bayesian Measures of Evidential Support: Theoretical and Empirical Issues* , 2007, Philosophy of Science.

[18]  William Roche A weaker condition for transitivity in probabilistic support , 2012 .