Heuristics in Medical and Non-Medical Decision-Making

Pairs of hypothetical medical and non-medical problems were given to 44 pediatric residents at three levels of hospital training. Each problem was designed to detect a specific heuristic-based bias in making diagnoses. Discounting, disregarding base rate, and over-confidence in contextually embedded redundant information were more evident on medical than on non-medical problems. In particular, a greater number of third-year residents disregarded base-rate information than did first- and second-year residents on medical but not on non-medical problems. On medical problems, a greater number of first-year residents expressed greater confidence in redundant information that was contextually embedded than in information that was presented in a listed format. Over one-third of the residents confused prospective and retrospective probabilities; three-fourths showed evidence of augmentation; virtually all residents expressed greater confidence in a diagnosis based on redundant rather than on non-redundant listed information. These latter effects were consistent across training level and occurred on both medical and non-medical problems. The results are discussed in terms of prototype theory and the nature of medical training.

[1]  A. Tversky,et al.  On the psychology of prediction , 1973 .

[2]  Stuart Oskamp,et al.  The relationship of clinical experience and training methods to several criteria of clinical prediction. , 1962 .

[3]  H. Kelley.  Causal schemata and the attribution process , 1972 .

[4]  G. Murphy,et al.  Changes in conceptual structure with expertise: Differences between real-world experts and novices. , 1984 .

[5]  E. Smith,et al.  Psychiatric diagnosis as prototype categorization. , 1980, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[6]  W. Mischel,et al.  Traits as prototypes: Effects on recognition memory. , 1977 .

[7]  A. Kruglanski,et al.  Lay persons' sensitivity to statistical information: The case of high perceived applicability. , 1984 .

[8]  Dutch.  ROGET'S THESAURUS , 1979 .

[9]  L. J. Chapman,et al.  Illusory correlation as an obstacle to the use of valid psychodiagnostic signs. , 1969, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[10]  A. Tversky,et al.  Judgments of and by Representativeness , 1981 .

[11]  I. Levi.  Who commits the base rate fallacy? , 1983, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[12]  V. Patel,et al.  Domain Knowledge and Hypothesis Genenation in Diagnostic Reasoning , 1990, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[13]  A. Tversky,et al.  Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases , 1974, Science.

[14]  L. J. Chapman,et al.  Genesis of popular but erroneous psychodiagnostic observations. , 1967, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[15]  Vimla L. Patel,et al.  Knowledge Based Solution Strategies in Medical Reasoning , 1986, Cogn. Sci..

[16]  Michael J. Prietula,et al.  Expertise and error in diagnostic reasoning , 1981 .

[17]  M. Chi,et al.  The Nature of Expertise , 1988 .

[18]  Merriam-Webster,et al.  The Merriam Webster Dictionary , 1983 .

[19]  T. K. Srull,et al.  Handbook of Social Cognition , 1993 .

[20]  E. Rosch,et al.  Family resemblances: Studies in the internal structure of categories , 1975, Cognitive Psychology.

[21]  Betty Kirkpatrick,et al.  Roget's Thesaurus , 1852 .

[22]  D M Chaput de Saintonge,et al.  Clinical judgment in rheumatoid arthritis. II. Judging 'current disease activity' in clinical practice. , 1983, Annals of the rheumatic diseases.

[23]  Michael J. Prietula,et al.  Expertise and Error in Diagnostic Reasoning , 1981, Cogn. Sci..

[24]  D. O'brien,et al.  Evaluations of Causal and Conditional Hypotheses , 1986, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.

[25]  D. Eddy.  Judgment under uncertainty: Probabilistic reasoning in clinical medicine: Problems and opportunities , 1982 .

[26]  D M Chaput de Saintonge,et al.  Clinical judgment in rheumatoid arthritis. I. Rheumatologists' opinions and the development of 'paper patients'. , 1983, Annals of the rheumatic diseases.

[27]  I. Ajzen.  Intuitive theories of events and the effects of base-rate information on prediction. , 1977 .

[28]  A. Pepitone,et al.  Social roles and strategies in prediction: Some determinants of the use of base-rate information. , 1984 .

[29]  Tooru Takahashi.  Psychiatric Diagnosis , 1994, Springer New York.