Comparison of some approximations for isotropic turbulence

Study of several related turbulence approximations with regard to dynamical properties and agreement of numerical predictions with laboratory and computer experiments. The approximations considered include the direct-interaction equations (Kraichnan, 1964), Herring's (1966) self-consistent-field theory, a generalization of Edwards' (1964) theory, the abridged Lagrangian-history, direct-interaction approximation (Kraichnan, 1966), the test-field model (Kraichnan, 1971), and an approximation, not previously described, in which one velocity field passively suffers convection by another. Most of the cited approximations are representable by stochastic model equations for the velocity amplitude. Explicit constructions are given for the stochastic models, in a form that can be approximated on a digital computer. These constructions are used to discuss the physical and mathematical differences between the model dynamics and actual Navier-Stokes dynamics.-