Phenotypic plasticity, canalization, and the origins of novelty: Evidence and mechanisms from amphibians.

A growing number of biologists have begun asking whether environmentally induced phenotypic change--'phenotypic plasticity'--precedes and facilitates the origin and canalization of novel, complex phenotypes. However, such 'plasticity-first evolution' (PFE) remains controversial. Here, we summarize the PFE hypothesis and describe how it can be evaluated in natural systems. We then review the evidence for PFE from amphibians (a group in which phenotypic plasticity is especially widespread) and describe how phenotypic plasticity might have facilitated macroevolutionary change. Finally, we discuss what is known about the proximate mechanisms of PFE in amphibians. We close with suggestions for future research. As we describe, amphibians offer some of the best support for plasticity's role in the origin of evolutionary novelties.

[1]  A. Badyaev.  Stress-induced variation in evolution: from behavioural plasticity to genetic assimilation , 2005, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[2]  H Frederik Nijhout,et al.  Evolution of a Polyphenism by Genetic Accommodation , 2006, Science.

[3]  D. Pfennig.  The adaptive significance of an environmentally-cued developmental switch in an anuran tadpole , 1990, Oecologia.

[4]  S. Sultan,et al.  The role of developmental plasticity in evolutionary innovation , 2011, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[5]  M. West-Eberhard,et al.  Developmental plasticity and the origin of species differences , 2005, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[6]  S. Voss,et al.  Evolutionary genetics of metamorphic failure using wild‐caught vs. laboratory axolotls (Ambystoma mexicanum) , 2000, Molecular ecology.

[7]  R. Giblin-Davis,et al.  Large-scale diversification without genetic isolation in nematode symbionts of figs , 2016, Science Advances.

[8]  J. Altmann,et al.  Resource base influences genome‐wide DNA methylation levels in wild baboons (Papio cynocephalus) , 2016, Molecular ecology.

[9]  S. Diamond,et al.  The interplay between plasticity and evolution in response to human-induced environmental change , 2016, F1000Research.

[10]  I. Gomez‐Mestre,et al.  Developmental plasticity mirrors differences among taxa in spadefoot toads linking plasticity and diversity , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[11]  D. Pfennig,et al.  PROXIMATE CAUSES OF CANNIBALISTIC POLYPHENISM IN LARVAL TIGER SALAMANDERS , 1999 .

[12]  T. Hayes,et al.  LARVAL PERIOD COMPARISON FOR THE SPADEFOOT TOADS SCAPHIOPUS COUCHII AND SPEA MULTIPLICATA (PELOBATIDAE: ANURA) , 2000 .

[13]  B. L. Storz.  Reassessment of the environmental mechanisms controlling developmental polyphenism in spadefoot toad tadpoles , 2004, Oecologia.

[14]  D. Chivers,et al.  Predator‐induced life history changes in amphibians: egg predation induces hatching , 2001 .

[15]  D. Pfennig,et al.  An inducible offense: carnivore morph tadpoles induced by tadpole carnivory , 2015, Ecology and evolution.

[16]  R. Denver,et al.  Acceleration of Ambystoma tigrinum metamorphosis by corticotropin-releasing hormone. , 2002, The Journal of experimental zoology.

[17]  R. Denver,et al.  Genetic accommodation via modified endocrine signalling explains phenotypic divergence among spadefoot toad species , 2017, Nature Communications.

[18]  S. Scheiner.  Genetics and Evolution of Phenotypic Plasticity , 1993 .

[19]  M. E. Santos,et al.  Taxon-restricted genes at the origin of a novel trait allowing access to a new environment , 2017, Science.

[20]  M. Pigliucci,et al.  Phenotypic plasticity and evolution by genetic assimilation , 2006, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[21]  A. Meyer,et al.  How plasticity, genetic assimilation and cryptic genetic variation may contribute to adaptive radiations , 2017, Molecular ecology.

[22]  Lynn B. Martin,et al.  Patterns of DNA methylation throughout a range expansion of an introduced songbird. , 2013, Integrative and comparative biology.

[23]  CHARACTER DISPLACEMENT IN POLYPHENIC TADPOLES , 2000, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[24]  A. Moczek,et al.  Developmental capacitance, genetic accommodation, and adaptive evolution , 2007, Evolution & development.

[25]  R. H. Kaplan.  Ovum Size Plasticity and Maternal Effects on the Early Development of the Frog, Bombina orientalis Boulenger, in a Field Population in Korea , 1989 .

[26]  H. Whiteman.  Evolution of Facultative Paedomorphosis in Salamanders , 1994, The Quarterly Review of Biology.

[27]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Evaluating 'Plasticity-First' Evolution in Nature: Key Criteria and Empirical Approaches. , 2016, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[28]  D. Kingsley,et al.  A recurrent regulatory change underlying altered expression and Wnt response of the stickleback armor plates gene EDA , 2015, eLife.

[29]  D. Jablonski.  Approaches to Macroevolution: 1. General Concepts and Origin of Variation , 2017, Evolutionary Biology.

[30]  D. Buchholz,et al.  Beyond synergy: corticosterone and thyroid hormone have numerous interaction effects on gene regulation in Xenopus tropicalis tadpoles. , 2012, Endocrinology.

[31]  S. Foster,et al.  A Test of the “Flexible Stem” Model of Evolution: Ancestral Plasticity, Genetic Accommodation, and Morphological Divergence in the Threespine Stickleback Radiation , 2008, The American Naturalist.

[32]  A. M. Rice,et al.  Genetic variation during range expansion: effects of habitat novelty and hybridization , 2017, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[33]  M. Wund,et al.  Assessing the impacts of phenotypic plasticity on evolution. , 2012, Integrative and comparative biology.

[34]  R. Martienssen,et al.  Transgenerational Epigenetic Inheritance: Myths and Mechanisms , 2014, Cell.

[35]  Annalise B. Paaby,et al.  Cryptic genetic variation: evolution's hidden substrate , 2014, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[36]  C. Mecklin,et al.  Larval growth in polyphenic salamanders: making the best of a bad lot , 2011, Oecologia.

[37]  R. Newman.  Effects of density and predation on Scaphiopus couchi tadpoles in desert ponds , 2004, Oecologia.

[38]  C. Schlichting.  Hidden Reaction Norms, Cryptic Genetic Variation, and Evolvability , 2008, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[39]  Jinyoung Choi,et al.  Higher thyroid hormone receptor expression correlates with short larval periods in spadefoot toads and increases metamorphic rate. , 2011, General and comparative endocrinology.

[40]  W. R. Healy.  Life History Variation and the Growth of Juvenile Notophthalmus viridescens from Massachusetts , 1973 .

[41]  V. Debat,et al.  Mapping phenotypes: canalization, plasticity and developmental stability , 2001 .

[42]  D. Schluter,et al.  The Genetic Architecture of Parallel Armor Plate Reduction in Threespine Sticklebacks , 2004, PLoS biology.

[43]  R. Sommer,et al.  Rapid diversification associated with a macroevolutionary pulse of developmental plasticity , 2015, eLife.

[44]  L. Fanti,et al.  Transposons, environmental changes, and heritable induced phenotypic variability , 2014, Chromosoma.

[45]  O. Leimar,et al.  Genes as leaders and followers in evolution. , 2011, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[46]  Massimo Pigliucci,et al.  PERSPECTIVE: GENETIC ASSIMILATION AND A POSSIBLE EVOLUTIONARY PARADOX: CAN MACROEVOLUTION SOMETIMES BE SO FAST AS TO PASS US BY? , 2003 .

[47]  M. Takahashi,et al.  Life cycle polyphenism as a factor affecting ecological divergence within Notophthalmus viridescens , 2008, Oecologia.

[48]  R. Relyea,et al.  Proximity to agriculture is correlated with pesticide tolerance: evidence for the evolution of amphibian resistance to modern pesticides , 2013, Evolutionary applications.

[49]  M. Whitlock.  The Red Queen Beats the Jack-Of-All-Trades: The Limitations on the Evolution of Phenotypic Plasticity and Niche Breadth , 1996, The American Naturalist.

[50]  N. Levis,et al.  Non-adaptive phenotypic plasticity: the effects of terrestrial and aquatic herbicides on larval salamander morphology and swim speed , 2016 .

[51]  Greg Gibson,et al.  Uncovering cryptic genetic variation , 2004, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[52]  C. Ledón-Rettig,et al.  Diet and hormonal manipulation reveal cryptic genetic variation: implications for the evolution of novel feeding strategies , 2010, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[53]  D. Futuyma.  Can Modern Evolutionary Theory Explain Macroevolution , 2015 .

[54]  C. Waddington.  The strategy of the genes , 1957 .

[55]  Jeremy Schmutz,et al.  Adaptive Evolution of Pelvic Reduction in Sticklebacks by Recurrent Deletion of a Pitx1 Enhancer , 2010, Science.

[56]  C. Ledón-Rettig,et al.  Cryptic genetic variation in natural populations: a predictive framework. , 2014, Integrative and comparative biology.

[57]  Eva Jablonka,et al.  Transgenerational Epigenetic Inheritance: Prevalence, Mechanisms, and Implications for the Study of Heredity and Evolution , 2009, The Quarterly Review of Biology.

[58]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Resource polyphenism increases species richness: a test of the hypothesis , 2010, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[59]  D. Irwin,et al.  The role of phenotypic plasticity in driving genetic evolution , 2003, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[60]  M. Wakahara.  Cannibalism and the Resulting Dimorphism in Larvae of a Salamander Hynobius retardatus, Inhabited in Hokkaido, Japan , 1995 .

[61]  C. Schlichting,et al.  PHENOTYPIC PLASTICITY AND EPIGENETIC MARKING: AN ASSESSMENT OF EVIDENCE FOR GENETIC ACCOMMODATION , 2014, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[62]  D. Pfennig.  Proximate and functional causes of polyphenism in an anuran tadpole , 1992 .

[63]  A. Moczek.  On the origins of novelty in development and evolution. , 2008, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[64]  D. Pfennig,et al.  The role of transgenerational epigenetic inheritance indiversification and speciation , 2013 .

[65]  M. Feldman,et al.  The extended evolutionary synthesis: its structure, assumptions and predictions , 2015, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[66]  R. Lenski,et al.  Mutation and Adaptation: The Directed Mutation Controversy in Evolutionary Perspective , 1995 .

[67]  J. P. Collins,et al.  Ecological Aspects of Amphibian Metamorphosis , 1973, Science.

[68]  M. West-Eberhard.  Developmental plasticity and evolution , 2003 .

[69]  Molly Schumer,et al.  Genetic accommodation and behavioural evolution: insights from genomic studies , 2013, Animal Behaviour.

[70]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Widespread disruptive selection in the wild is associated with intense resource competition , 2012, BMC Evolutionary Biology.

[71]  D. Pfennig,et al.  EVALUATING THE TARGETS OF SELECTION DURING CHARACTER DISPLACEMENT , 2011, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[72]  R. Denver,et al.  Environmental Stress as a Developmental Cue: Corticotropin-Releasing Hormone Is a Proximate Mediator of Adaptive Phenotypic Plasticity in Amphibian Metamorphosis , 1997, Hormones and Behavior.

[73]  Vincent Debat,et al.  Plasticity, Canalization, and Developmental Stability of the Drosophila Wing: Joint Effects of Mutations and Developmental Temperature , 2009, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[74]  N. Levis,et al.  Level of UV-B radiation influences the effects of glyphosate-based herbicide on the spotted salamander , 2015, Ecotoxicology.

[75]  D. Pfennig,et al.  FIELD AND EXPERIMENTAL EVIDENCE FOR COMPETITION'S ROLE IN PHENOTYPIC DIVERGENCE , 2007, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[76]  K. Hughes,et al.  Erratum: Non-adaptive plasticity potentiates rapid adaptive evolution of gene expression in nature , 2018, Nature.

[77]  Scott F. Gilbert,et al.  Ecological Developmental Biology , 2017 .

[78]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Evolution's Wedge: Competition and the Origins of Diversity , 2012 .

[79]  J. Masel,et al.  The Loss of Adaptive Plasticity during Long Periods of Environmental Stasis , 2006, The American Naturalist.

[80]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Increased competition as a cost of specialization during the evolution of resource polymorphism , 2012 .

[81]  D. Schluter,et al.  Does evolutionary theory need a rethink? , 2014, Nature.

[82]  E. Whitelaw,et al.  DNA methylation: A source of random variation in natural populations , 2011, Epigenetics.

[83]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Parallel evolution and ecological selection: replicated character displacement in spadefoot toads , 2009, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[84]  S. Voss,et al.  Thyroid hormone responsive QTL and the evolution of paedomorphic salamanders , 2012, Heredity.

[85]  Tadeusz J. Kawecki,et al.  Accumulation of Deleterious Mutations and the Evolutionary Cost of Being a Generalist , 1994, The American Naturalist.

[86]  D. Schluter,et al.  Evolved tooth gain in sticklebacks is associated with a cis-regulatory allele of Bmp6 , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[87]  R. Barrett,et al.  Epigenetics in natural animal populations , 2017, Journal of evolutionary biology.

[88]  M. West-Eberhard.  Phenotypic Plasticity and the Origins of Diversity , 1989 .

[89]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Analysis of range expansion in two species undergoing character displacement: why might invaders generally ‘win’ during character displacement? , 2008, Journal of evolutionary biology.

[90]  E. Crispo,et al.  THE BALDWIN EFFECT AND GENETIC ASSIMILATION: REVISITING TWO MECHANISMS OF EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE MEDIATED BY PHENOTYPIC PLASTICITY , 2007, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[91]  C. Waddington,et al.  GENETIC ASSIMILATION OF AN ACQUIRED CHARACTER , 1953 .

[92]  R. Relyea,et al.  Pesticide tolerance in amphibians: induced tolerance in susceptible populations, constitutive tolerance in tolerant populations , 2013, Evolutionary applications.

[93]  S. Scheiner.  Selection experiments and the study of phenotypic plasticity 1 , 2002 .

[94]  M. Wade,et al.  Toward a population genetic framework of developmental evolution: the costs, limits, and consequences of phenotypic plasticity , 2010, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[95]  A. Badyaev,et al.  Most Colorful Example of Genetic Assimilation? Exploring the Evolutionary Destiny of Recurrent Phenotypic Accommodation , 2017, The American Naturalist.

[96]  P. Phillips,et al.  Rapid Evolution of Phenotypic Plasticity and Shifting Thresholds of Genetic Assimilation in the Nematode Caenorhabditis remanei , 2014, G3: Genes, Genomes, Genetics.

[97]  Kenneth H. Wolfe,et al.  Turning a hobby into a job: How duplicated genes find new functions , 2008, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[98]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Genetic accommodation in the wild: evolution of gene expression plasticity during character displacement , 2017, Journal of evolutionary biology.

[99]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Towards a gene regulatory network perspective on phenotypic plasticity, genetic accommodation and genetic assimilation , 2014, Molecular ecology.

[100]  D. Gower,et al.  Global patterns of diversification in the history of modern amphibians , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[101]  R. Calsbeek,et al.  Intraspecific variation in Anolis sagrei mirrors the adaptive radiation of Greater Antillean anoles , 2007 .

[102]  Donald D. Brown,et al.  Amphibian metamorphosis. , 2007, Developmental biology.

[103]  R. Lande.  Adaptation to an extraordinary environment by evolution of phenotypic plasticity and genetic assimilation , 2009, Journal of evolutionary biology.

[104]  H. Michimae,et al.  Factors which affect the occurrence of cannibalism and the broad-headed "cannibal" morph in larvae of the salamander Hynobius retardatus , 2001, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology.

[105]  S. Voss,et al.  Adaptive evolution via a major gene effect: paedomorphosis in the Mexican axolotl. , 1997, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[106]  R. Relyea,et al.  The contribution of phenotypic plasticity to the evolution of insecticide tolerance in amphibian populations , 2015, Evolutionary applications.

[107]  R. H. Kaplan,et al.  Developmental plasticity and maternal effects of reproductive characteristics in the frog, Bombina orientalis , 2004, Oecologia.

[108]  D. Pfennig,et al.  A Maternal Effect Mediates Rapid Population Divergence and Character Displacement in Spadefoot Toads , 2009, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[109]  C. Schlichting,et al.  Constraints on the evolution of phenotypic plasticity: limits and costs of phenotype and plasticity , 2015, Heredity.

[110]  C. Ledón-Rettig,et al.  Ancestral variation and the potential for genetic accommodation in larval amphibians: implications for the evolution of novel feeding strategies , 2008, Evolution & development.

[111]  K. Nishimura,et al.  Bulgy tadpoles: inducible defense morph , 2004, Oecologia.

[112]  V. Buskirk,et al.  Functional mechanisms of an inducible defence in tadpoles: morphology and behaviour influence mortality risk from predation , 2000 .

[113]  C. Schlichting,et al.  Phenotypic plasticity's impacts on diversification and speciation. , 2010, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[114]  R. Goldschmidt,et al.  The material basis of evolution , 1941 .

[115]  R. Relyea.  MORPHOLOGICAL AND BEHAVIORAL PLASTICITY OF LARVAL ANURANS IN RESPONSE TO DIFFERENT PREDATORS , 2001 .

[116]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Maternal Investment Influences Expression of Resource Polymorphism in Amphibians: Implications for the Evolution of Novel Resource-Use Phenotypes , 2010, PloS one.

[117]  R. Denver,et al.  Endocrine Mechanisms Underlying Plasticity in Metamorphic Timing in Spadefoot Toads1 , 2003, Integrative and comparative biology.

[118]  D. Pfennig,et al.  HOW FLUCTUATING COMPETITION AND PHENOTYPIC PLASTICITY MEDIATE SPECIES DIVERGENCE , 2002, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[119]  I. Gomez‐Mestre,et al.  Mechanisms and Consequences of Developmental Acceleration in Tadpoles Responding to Pond Drying , 2013, PloS one.

[120]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Field and experimental evidence that competition and ecological opportunity promote resource polymorphism , 2010 .

[121]  J. Bernardo.  The Particular Maternal Effect of Propagule Size, Especially Egg Size: Patterns, Models, Quality of Evidence and Interpretations , 1996 .

[122]  M. Wade,et al.  The Genetic Signature of Conditional Expression , 2010, Genetics.

[123]  I. Schmalhausen.  Factors of evolution : the theory of stabilizing selection , 1946 .

[124]  J. Gibert,et al.  The flexible stem hypothesis: evidence from genetic data , 2017, Development Genes and Evolution.

[125]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Genetic assimilation: a review of its potential proximate causes and evolutionary consequences. , 2016, Annals of botany.

[126]  D. Pfennig,et al.  EVOLUTION OF CHARACTER DISPLACEMENT IN SPADEFOOT TOADS: DIFFERENT PROXIMATE MECHANISMS IN DIFFERENT SPECIES , 2010, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[127]  D. Pfennig.  Cannibalistic tadpoles that pose the greatest threat to kin are most likely to discriminate kin , 1999, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[128]  R. Denver,et al.  ADAPTIVE PLASTICITY IN AMPHIBIAN METAMORPHOSIS: RESPONSE OF SCAPHIOPUS HAMMONDIITADPOLES TO HABITAT DESICCATION , 1998 .

[129]  S. Carroll.  Evo-Devo and an Expanding Evolutionary Synthesis: A Genetic Theory of Morphological Evolution , 2008, Cell.

[130]  Alison Scoville,et al.  Phenotypic plasticity facilitates recurrent rapid adaptation to introduced predators , 2010, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[131]  W. R. Healy.  Population Consequences of Alternative Life Histories in Notophthalmus v. viridescens , 1974 .

[132]  P. Insel,et al.  A Single Amino Acid Mutation Contributes to Adaptive Beach Mouse Color Pattern , 2006, Science.

[133]  S. Voss,et al.  PHYLOGENETIC AND MECHANISTIC ANALYSIS OF A DEVELOPMENTALLY INTEGRATED CHARACTER COMPLEX : ALTERNATE LIFE HISTORY MODES IN AMBYSTOMATID SALAMANDERS , 1996 .

[134]  K. Warkentin.  Adaptive plasticity in hatching age: a response to predation risk trade-offs. , 1995, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[135]  Christine L. Moskalik,et al.  Evolutionary reduction of developmental plasticity in desert spadefoot toads , 2011, Journal of evolutionary biology.

[136]  Günter P. Wagner,et al.  Evolutionary novelties , 2010, Current Biology.

[137]  S. Kikuyama,et al.  Aspects of amphibian metamorphosis: hormonal control. , 1993, International review of cytology.

[138]  F. Bozinovic,et al.  Genetic variation for plasticity in physiological and life-history traits among populations of an invasive species, the terrestrial isopod Porcellio laevis , 2008 .

[139]  R. Denver.  12 – Neuroendocrine Control of Amphibian Metamorphosis , 1996 .

[140]  K. Wells.  The Ecology and Behavior of Amphibians , 2007 .

[141]  J. Cheek,et al.  Effect of Food and Density on Development of Typical and Cannibalistic Salamander Larvae in Ambystoma tigrinum nebulosum , 1983 .

[142]  D. Pfennig.  POLYPHENISM IN SPADEFOOT TOAD TADPOLES AS A LOCALLY ADJUSTED EVOLUTIONARILY STABLE STRATEGY , 1992, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[143]  Juan M. Guayasamin,et al.  Phenotypic plasticity raises questions for taxonomically important traits: a remarkable new Andean rainfrog (Pristimantis) with the ability to change skin texture , 2015 .

[144]  R. Relyea.  New effects of Roundup on amphibians: predators reduce herbicide mortality; herbicides induce antipredator morphology. , 2012, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[145]  J. Leimberger,et al.  Predator-induced morphological changes in an amphibian: predation by dragonflies affects tadpole shape and color , 1997, Oecologia.

[146]  D. Roff,et al.  Modeling the Evolution of Phenotypic Plasticity in Resource Allocation in Wing‐Dimorphic Insects , 2010, The American Naturalist.

[147]  L. Trueb,et al.  Biology of Amphibians , 1986 .

[148]  J. Wiens,et al.  Evolution of Rapid Development in Spadefoot Toads Is Unrelated to Arid Environments , 2014, PloS one.

[149]  Xiangyi Lu,et al.  Evidence for an epigenetic mechanism by which Hsp90 acts as a capacitor for morphological evolution , 2003, Nature Genetics.

[150]  Lex E. Flagel,et al.  Gene duplication and evolutionary novelty in plants. , 2009, The New phytologist.

[151]  M. Pigliucci,et al.  Manipulative Approaches to Testing Adaptive Plasticity: Phytochrome‐Mediated Shade‐Avoidance Responses in Plants , 1999, The American Naturalist.

[152]  C. Ledón-Rettig,et al.  Stress hormones and the fitness consequences associated with the transition to a novel diet in larval amphibians , 2009, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[153]  R. Newman.  ADAPTIVE PLASTICITY IN DEVELOPMENT OF SCAPHIOPUS COUCHII TADPOLES IN DESERT PONDS , 1988, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[154]  V. Laudet,et al.  Pedomorphosis revisited: thyroid hormone receptors are functional in Necturus maculosus , 2006, Evolution & development.

[155]  L. Fanti,et al.  Canalization by Selection of de Novo Induced Mutations , 2017, Genetics.

[156]  D. Pfennig,et al.  Disruptive Selection in Natural Populations: The Roles of Ecological Specialization and Resource Competition , 2009, The American Naturalist.

[157]  M. Pigliucci,et al.  Phenotypic Evolution: A Reaction Norm Perspective , 1998 .