Pig and guinea pig skin as surrogates for human in vitro penetration studies: a quantitative review.

Both human and animal skin in vitro models are used to predict percutaneous penetration in humans. The objective of this review is a quantitative comparison of permeability and lag time measurements between human and animal skin, including an evaluation of the intra and inter species variability. We limit our focus to domestic pig and rodent guinea pig skin as surrogates for human skin, and consider only studies in which both animal and human penetration of a given chemical were measured jointly in the same lab. When the in vitro permeability of pig and human skin were compared, the Pearson product moment correlation coefficient (r) was 0.88 (P<0.0001), with an intra species average coefficient of variation of skin permeability of 21% for pig and 35% for human, and an inter species average coefficient of variation of 37% for the set of studied compounds (n=41). The lag times of pig skin and human skin did not correlate (r=0.35, P=0.26). When the in vitro permeability of guinea pig and human skin were compared, r=0.96 (P<0.0001), with an average intra species coefficient of variation of 19% for guinea pig and 24% for human, and an inter species coefficient of variation of permeability of 41% for the set of studied compounds (n=15). Lag times of guinea pig and human skin correlated (r=0.90, P<0.0001, n=12). When permeability data was not reported a factor of difference (FOD) of animal to human skin was calculated for pig skin (n=50) and guinea pig skin (n=25). For pig skin, 80% of measurements fell within the range 0.3<FOD<3. For guinea pig skin, 65% fell within that range. Both pig and guinea pig are good models for human skin permeability and have less variability than the human skin model. The skin model of choice will depend on the final purpose of the study and the compound under investigation.

[1]  P Sartorelli,et al.  In vitro predictions of skin absorption of caffeine, testosterone, and benzoic acid: a multi-centre comparison study. , 2004, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[2]  H. Maibach,et al.  Percutaneous Absorption: Mechanisms-Methodology-Drug Delivery , 1989 .

[3]  LaHann Tr,et al.  Capsaicin analgesia: predictions based on physico-chemical properties. , 1989 .

[4]  P. Crooks,et al.  Flux Across of Microneedle-treated Skin is Increased by Increasing Charge of Naltrexone and Naltrexol In Vitro , 2008, Pharmaceutical Research.

[5]  K. Miyajima,et al.  Effects of Absorption Enhancers and Lipid Composition on Drug Permeability through the Model Membrane Using Stratum Corneum Lipids , 1994 .

[6]  P. Ramarao,et al.  In vitro transdermal iontophoretic transport of timolol maleate: effect of age and species. , 2001, Journal of Controlled Release.

[7]  H. Schaefer,et al.  Percutaneous Absorption of Sunscreens in vitro: Interspecies Comparison, Skin Models and Reproducibility Aspects , 2000, Skin Pharmacology and Physiology.

[8]  J. Fairley,et al.  Comparison of stratum corneum thickness in children and adults. , 1983, Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.

[9]  P. Wertz,et al.  Presence of intact intercellular lipid lamellae in the upper layers of the stratum corneum. , 1987, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[10]  P. Wertz,et al.  Regional variation in content, composition and organization of porcine epithelial barrier lipids revealed by thin-layer chromatography and transmission electron microscopy. , 1995, Archives of oral biology.

[11]  Biana Godin,et al.  Transdermal skin delivery: predictions for humans from in vivo, ex vivo and animal models. , 2007, Advanced drug delivery reviews.

[12]  G. S. Hawkins,et al.  Influence of skin source, penetration cell fluid, and partition coefficient on in vitro skin penetration. , 1986, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[13]  M. Sogorb,et al.  Enzyme concentration as an important factor in the in vitro testing of the stereospecificity of the enzymatic hydrolysis of organophosphorus compounds. , 1999, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[14]  G Lallement,et al.  In vitro percutaneous penetration of organophosphorus compounds using full-thickness and split-thickness pig and human skin. , 2007, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[15]  A LeCornu,et al.  Alternatives to laboratory animals. , 1978, The Australasian nurses journal.

[16]  S. Monstrey,et al.  In vitro permeation of chromium species through porcine and human skin as determined by capillary electrophoresis–inductively coupled plasma–sector field mass spectrometry , 2006, Analytical and bioanalytical chemistry.

[17]  H. Zia,et al.  Transdermal Delivery of Nicardipine: An Approach to In Vitro Permeation Enhancement , 2002, Drug delivery.

[18]  P. Wertz,et al.  Molecular models of the intercellular lipid lamellae in mammalian stratum corneum. , 1989, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[19]  H. Maibach,et al.  Dry skin and moisturizers : chemistry and function , 1999 .

[20]  R Panchagnula,et al.  Animal models for transdermal drug delivery. , 1997, Methods and findings in experimental and clinical pharmacology.

[21]  M. Hussain,et al.  Transdermal oxymorphone formulation development and methods for evaluating flux and lag times for two skin permeation-enhancing vehicles. , 1990, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[22]  Gary A. Lattin,et al.  Iontophoretic delivery of model inorganic and drug ions. , 1989, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[23]  Luis Rodrigues,et al.  EEMCO Guidance to the in vivo Assessment of Tensile Functional Properties of the Skin , 2001, Skin Pharmacology and Physiology.

[24]  G. Nohynek,et al.  Human systemic exposure to a [14C]-para-phenylenediamine-containing oxidative hair dye and correlation with in vitro percutaneous absorption in human or pig skin. , 2004, Food and chemical toxicology : an international journal published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association.

[25]  R. P. Moody,et al.  In vitro dermal absorption of two commercial formulations of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid dimethylamine (2,4-D amine) in rat, guinea pig and human skin. , 1997, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[26]  S. Hotchkiss,et al.  In vitro skin absorption and decontamination of sulphur mustard: comparison of human and pig‐ear skin , 2001, Journal of applied toxicology : JAT.

[27]  L. Schook,et al.  Advances in Swine in Biomedical Research , 1996, Springer US.

[28]  T. Franz,et al.  Comparative percutaneous absorption of lindane and permethrin. , 1996, Archives of dermatology.

[29]  K. Sugibayashi,et al.  Species differences in percutaneous absorption of nicorandil. , 1991, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[30]  L Landmann,et al.  Epidermal permeability barrier: transformation of lamellar granule-disks into intercellular sheets by a membrane-fusion process, a freeze-fracture study. , 1986, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[31]  K. R. Mueller,et al.  Comparisons of in Vitro Nitroglycerin (TNG) Flux Across Yucatan Pig, Hairless Mouse, and Human Skins , 1990, Pharmaceutical Research.

[32]  N. Monteiro-Riviere,et al.  Comparative in vitro percutaneous absorption of nonylphenol and nonylphenol ethoxylates (NPE-4 and NPE-9) through human, porcine and rat skin , 2000, Toxicology and industrial health.

[33]  A. Sakr,et al.  Characterization of Esterase and Alcohol Dehydrogenase Activity in Skin. Metabolism of Retinyl Palmitate to Retinol (Vitamin A) During Percutaneous Absorption , 1994, Pharmaceutical Research.

[34]  H. Alachkar,et al.  Skin Penetration And Lag Times Of Neat And Aqueous Diethyl Phthalate, 1,2-Dichloroethane And Naphthalene , 2007, Cutaneous and ocular toxicology.

[35]  E. Niazy.  Differences in penetration-enhancing effect of Azone through excised rabbit, rat, hairless mouse, guinea pig and human skins , 1996 .

[36]  B. Nadeau,et al.  An automated in vitro dermal absorption procedure: III. In vivo and in vitro comparison with the insect repellent N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide in mouse, rat, guinea pig, pig, human and tissue-cultured skin. , 1993, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[37]  H. Maibach,et al.  The Pig as an Experimental Animal Model of Percutaneous Permeation in Man: Qualitative and Quantitative Observations – An Overview , 2000, Skin Pharmacology and Physiology.

[38]  R. Bronaugh,et al.  Metabolism of xenobiotics during percutaneous penetration: role of absorption rate and cutaneous enzyme activity. , 1990, Fundamental and applied toxicology : official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[39]  D. Friend,et al.  Transdermal delivery of levonorgestrel. VIII. Effect of enhancers on rat skin, hairless mouse skin, hairless guinea pig skin, and human skin , 1990 .

[40]  T. Mandal,et al.  Terbutaline Transdermal Delivery: Preformulation Studies and Limitations of In‐vitro Predictive Parameters , 1996, The Journal of pharmacy and pharmacology.

[41]  R. Tregear.  The permeability of mammalian skin to ions. , 1966, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[42]  R. Tregear.  The permeability of skin to albumin, dextrans and polyvinyl pyrrolidone. , 1966, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[43]  A. Stinchcomb,et al.  In vitro/in vivo correlation studies for transdermal Δ8‐THC development , 2004 .

[44]  P. Crooks,et al.  Transdermal delivery of naltrexone and its active metabolite 6-beta-naltrexol in human skin in vitro and guinea pigs in vivo. , 2005, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[45]  T. Rades,et al.  Investigation of newborn pig skin as an in vitro animal model for transdermal drug delivery , 2003 .

[46]  S. Frokjaer,et al.  Evaluation of Göttingen minipig skin for transdermal in vitro permeation studies. , 2000, European journal of pharmaceutical sciences : official journal of the European Federation for Pharmaceutical Sciences.

[47]  R. P. Moody,et al.  In vivo and in vitro dermal absorption of benzo[a]pyrene in rat, guinea pig, human and tissue-cultured skin. , 1995, Journal of dermatological science.

[48]  A. Bazire,et al.  Percutaneous penetration and distribution of VX using in vitro pig or human excised skin validation of demeton-S-methyl as adequate simulant for VX skin permeation investigations. , 2008, Toxicology.

[49]  H. Sueki,et al.  Cutaneous Toxicity of Chemical Irritants on Hairless Guinea Pigs , 2003, The Journal of dermatology.

[50]  J. Heylings,et al.  Multi-species assessment of electrical resistance as a skin integrity marker for in vitro percutaneous absorption studies. , 2004, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[51]  Jia-You Fang,et al.  In vitro percutaneouus absorption of captopril , 1997 .

[52]  R. Scott,et al.  The in vitro percutaneous absorption of diquat: A species comparison. , 1990, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[53]  R. Scott,et al.  Pig Ear Skin as an In‐vitro Model for Human Skin Permeability , 1992, The Journal of pharmacy and pharmacology.

[54]  S. M. Harrison,et al.  Effects of freezing on human skin permeability , 1984, The Journal of pharmacy and pharmacology.

[55]  Richard T. Tregear,et al.  Physical functions of skin , 1966 .

[56]  H. Maibach,et al.  In Vitro Percutaneous Absorption: Principles, Fundamentals, and Applications , 1991 .

[57]  R. Chilcott,et al.  Absorption of the nerve agent VX (O-ethyl-S-[2(di-isopropylamino)ethyl] methyl phosphonothioate) through pig, human and guinea pig skin in vitro. , 2006, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[58]  Claus-Michael Lehr,et al.  Reconstructed Human Epidermis for Skin Absorption Testing: Results of the German Prevalidation Study , 2006, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[59]  G. P. Martin,et al.  Variability in human skin permeability in vitro: comparing penetrants with different physicochemical properties. , 2007, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[60]  Joop L. M. Hermens,et al.  Determination of octanol/water partition coefficients for hydrophobic organic chemicals with the “slow‐stirring” method , 1989 .

[61]  R. F. Platford.  The octanol-water partitioning of some hydrophobic and hydrophilic compounds , 1983 .

[62]  R. Langer,et al.  Effects of low-frequency ultrasound on the transdermal permeation of mannitol: comparative studies with in vivo and in vitro skin. , 2002, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[63]  R. Bronaugh,et al.  Reduction of azo dyes during in vitro percutaneous absorption. , 1993, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[64]  P. Santi,et al.  Suitability of Excised Rabbit Ear Skin—Fresh and Frozen—for Evaluating Transdermal Permeation of Estradiol , 2007, Drug delivery.

[65]  S. Mitragotri,et al.  Evaluation of chemical enhancers in the transdermal delivery of lidocaine. , 2006, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[66]  R. White,et al.  Glycosphingolipids and ceramides in human and pig epidermis. , 1978, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[67]  Skin absorption of the industrial catalyst dimethylethylamine in vitro in guinea pig and human skin, and of gaseous dimethylethylamine in human volunteers , 1997, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[68]  A. Burlingame,et al.  Human stratum corneum lipids: characterization and regional variations. , 1983, Journal of lipid research.

[69]  A. Sakr,et al.  In Vitro Skin Absorption and Metabolism of Benzoic Acid, p-Aminobenzoic Acid, and Benzocaine in the Hairless Guinea Pig , 1990, Pharmaceutical Research.

[70]  J. Riviere.  Dermal Absorption Models in Toxicology and Pharmacology , 2005 .

[71]  A. Stinchcomb,et al.  Transdermal Delivery of the Synthetic Cannabinoid WIN 55,212-2: In Vitro/in Vivo Correlation , 2004, Pharmaceutical Research.

[72]  P. Elias,et al.  Percutaneous transport in relation to stratum corneum structure and lipid composition. , 1981, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[73]  B. Kemppainen,et al.  Methods for Skin Absorption , 1990 .

[74]  W. Galey,et al.  The in vitro permeability of skin and buccal mucosa to selected drugs and tritiated water. , 1976, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[75]  Jagdish Singh,et al.  IN VITRO PERMEABILITY AND BINDING OF HYDROCARBONS IN PIG EAR AND HUMAN ABDOMINAL SKIN , 2002, Drug and chemical toxicology.

[76]  A. Capt,et al.  Percutaneous penetration and absorption of parathion using human and pig skin models in vitro and human skin grafted onto nude mouse skin model in vivo , 2008, Journal of applied toxicology : JAT.

[77]  C. Heard,et al.  Probing the permeation enhancement of mefenamic acid by ethanol across full-thickness skin, heat-separated epidermal membrane and heat-separated dermal membrane. , 2008, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[78]  R. Bronaugh,et al.  In vitro percutaneous absorption of the fragrance ingredient musk xylol. , 1996, Food and chemical toxicology : an international journal published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association.

[79]  Jia-You Fang,et al.  In vitro permeation study of capsaicin and its synthetic derivatives from ointment bases using various skin types , 1995 .

[80]  E. Calabrese.  Gastrointestinal and dermal absorption: interspecies differences. , 1984, Drug metabolism reviews.

[81]  A. Billich,et al.  Comparison of human skin or epidermis models with human and animal skin in in-vitro percutaneous absorption. , 2001, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[82]  M. Singh,et al.  Percutaneous absorption and skin irritation of JP-8 (jet fuel). , 2001, Toxicology.

[83]  A. Bunge,et al.  Animal Models: A Comparison of Permeability Coefficients for Excised Skin from Humans and Animals , 2005 .

[84]  R. Bronaugh,et al.  Percutaneous absorption of trinitrobenzene: animal models for human skin , 1998, Journal of Applied Toxicology.

[85]  K A Holbrook,et al.  Regional differences in the thickness (cell layers) of the human stratum corneum: an ultrastructural analysis. , 1974, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[86]  Brian W. Barry,et al.  Variations in permeability of human skin within and between specimens , 1984 .

[87]  S. Ollmar,et al.  Inter- and intra-individual differences in human stratum corneum lipid content related to physical parameters of skin barrier function in vivo. , 1999, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[88]  R Schwarz,et al.  The Skin of Domestic Mammals as a Model for the Human Skin, with Special Reference to the Domestic Pig1 , 1978 .

[89]  William I. Higuchi,et al.  Lag time data for characterizing the pore pathway of intact and chemically pretreated human epidermal membrane , 1998 .

[90]  D. Downing,et al.  Lipid organization in pig stratum corneum. , 1995, Journal of lipid research.

[91]  Y. Chien,et al.  Comparative biomembrane permeation of tacrine using Yucatan minipigs and domestic pigs as the animal model. , 1998, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[92]  Lin Sy,et al.  Comparisons of different animal skins with human skin in drug percutaneous penetration studies. , 1992 .

[93]  P. Dugard,et al.  A comparison of the in vitro permeability properties of human and some laboratory animal skins , 1986, International journal of cosmetic science.

[94]  C. Lehr,et al.  Comparison of bovine udder skin with human and porcine skin in percutaneous permeation experiments. , 2006, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[95]  R. Scott,et al.  The influence of skin structure on permeability: an intersite and interspecies comparison with hydrophilic penetrants. , 1990, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[96]  G. K. Jain,et al.  Transdermal controlled administration of verapamil — enhancement of skin permeability , 1996 .

[97]  JAN PŘBORSKÝ,et al.  Evaluation of In‐vitro Percutaneous Absorption across Human Skin and in Animal Models , 1990, The Journal of pharmacy and pharmacology.

[98]  J. Bouwstra,et al.  New Aspects of the Skin Barrier Organization , 2001, Skin Pharmacology and Physiology.

[99]  Sueki.  Hairless guinea pig skin: anatomical basis for studies of cutaneous biology , 2000, European journal of dermatology : EJD.

[100]  C. Lehr,et al.  Influence of Human Skin Specimens Consisting of Different Skin Layers on the Result of in vitro Permeation Experiments , 2008, Skin Pharmacology and Physiology.

[101]  J. J. van de Sandt,et al.  Species-specific cutaneous biotransformation of the pesticide propoxur during percutaneous absorption in vitro. , 1993, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[102]  R. Bronaugh,et al.  Percutaneous absorption/metabolism of phenanthrene in the hairless guinea pig: comparison of in vitro and in vivo results. , 1991, Fundamental and applied toxicology : official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[103]  Ruth K. Freinkel,et al.  The Biology of the Skin , 2001 .

[104]  M. C. Bonner,et al.  Human skin sandwich for assessing shunt route penetration during passive and iontophoretic drug and liposome delivery , 2002, The Journal of pharmacy and pharmacology.

[105]  M. R. Simon,et al.  Methods for in vitro percutaneous absorption studies. VII: Use of excised human skin. , 1986, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[106]  R. Bronaugh,et al.  Methods for in vitro percutaneous absorption studies. II. Animal models for human skin. , 1982, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[107]  J. Heylings,et al.  Percutaneous absorption and metabolism of dinitrochlorobenzene in vitro , 2000, Archives of Toxicology.

[108]  B. Nadeau,et al.  In vitro dermal absorption of pesticides: IV. In vivo and in vitro comparison with the organophosphorus insecticide diazinon in rat, guinea pig, pig, human and tissue-cultured skin. , 1994, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[109]  Ronald C. Wester,et al.  Relevance of animal models for percutaneous absorption , 1980 .

[110]  Rafael Moure-Eraso,et al.  Occupational and Environmental Health , 1991, Journal of public health policy.

[111]  S. E. Cross,et al.  The effects of freezing skin on transdermal drug penetration kinetics. , 2007, Journal of veterinary pharmacology and therapeutics.

[112]  N. Monteiro-Riviere,et al.  The Pig as a Model for Cutaneous Pharmacology and Toxicology Research , 1996 .

[113]  Peter M. Elias,et al.  Epidermal barrier function: intercellular lamellar lipid structures, origin, composition and metabolism , 1991 .

[114]  H. Maibach,et al.  Qualitative and quantitative comparison of heat separated epidermis and dermatomed skin in percutaneous absorption studies , 2007, Archives of Dermatological Research.