The vibratory innocent heart murmur in schoolchildren: Difference in auscultatory findings between school medical officers and a pediatric cardiologist

SummaryIn 810 schoolchildren heart auscultation was performed by both a school medical officer (SMO) and a pediatric cardiologist (PC). The prevalence for a grade 1, 2, or 3 vibratory innocent heart murmur (VIHM), a grade 2 or 3 VIHM, and a grade 3 VIHM heard by the PC was 41%, 13%, and 1%, respectively. The SMO noted such murmurs in 26%, 9%, and 1%, respectively. In 30% of the cases in which the PC had noted a grade 2 or 3 VIHM, the SMO agreed; in 30% of such cases the SMO did not hear any heart murmur. If the PC heard a grade 2 or 3 VIHM phonocardiography was performed in a case-control study in which the controls did not have a heart murmur (94 pairs). In four children with a grade 2 or 3 VIHM no heart murmur could be registered and in three other children the murmur did not have the typical diamond shape. In contrast, in three children without a heart murmur at school a VIHM was seen on the phonocardiogram. In 26 children with a phonocardiographically proven grade 2 or 3 VIHM the SMO did not hear any heart murmur. One child with a grade 3 VIHM (both by the PC and SMO) had a minor subvalvular aortic stenosis. There is quite a difference in auscultatory detection of a venous hum: 9% (PC) and 2% (SMO). The prevalence of the pulmonary ejection murmur is identical at 4%. The carotid bruit is heard in 4% (PC) and 2% (SMO). Pathologic murmurs were heard in 12 children by the PC, agreed by the SMO in two cases. Eight of the 12 pathologic murmurs were confirmed by further cardiologic examination and one was decided to be an innocent pulmonary ejection murmur. The auscultatory findings of 4 SMOs, who examined >100 children each, differ remarkably when compared separately to the results of the PC. Variation in intensity of the heart murmurs and difference in auscultatory skills explain the great difference in ausculatory findings between the PC and the SMO. Specialized training of SMO to recognize (pathological) heart murmurs is advocated.

[1]  A. R. Freeman,et al.  The Clinical Significance of the Systolic Murmur: A Study of 1000 Consecutive Non-Cardiac Cases , 1933 .

[2]  D Brahams,et al.  Mentally incapable adults: consent to treatment. , 1987, Lancet.

[3]  J. Beneken,et al.  Studies on innocent praecordial vibratory murmurs in children. 3. Follow-up study of children with an innocent praecordial vibratory murmur. , 1973, British heart journal.

[4]  J. Sampson,et al.  Incidence of heart disease and rheumatic fever in school children in three climatically different california communities , 1945 .

[5]  A. Luisada,et al.  Murmurs in children: a clinical and graphic study in 500 children of school age. , 1958, Annals of internal medicine.

[6]  W. Doig,et al.  Diagnostic problems with innocent murmurs in children. , 1970, Lancet.

[7]  T. Harris,et al.  Phonocardiographic differentiation of vibratory (functional) murmurs from those of valvular insufficiency: further observations and application to the diagnosis of rheumatic heart disease. , 1952, American heart journal.

[8]  B. Segal,et al.  AUSCULTATORY AND PHONOCARDIOGRAPHIC FINDINGS IN HEALTHY CHILDREN WITH SYSTOLIC MURMURS , 1963, British heart journal.

[9]  M. B. Rappaport,et al.  Physiologic and physical laws that govern auscultation, and their clinical application , 1941 .

[10]  E. Lincoln.  THE HEARTS OF NORMAL CHILDREN: I. CLINICAL STUDIES, INCLUDING NOTES ON EFFORT SYNDROME , 1928 .

[11]  C. Marienfeld,et al.  A 20-year follow-up study of "innocent" murmurs. , 1962, Pediatrics.

[12]  S. Paulin,et al.  The Physiological Heart Murmur in Children , 1957, Acta paediatrica.

[13]  Still's-like innocent murmur can be produced by increasing aortic velocity to a threshold value. , 1991, The American journal of cardiology.

[14]  N. Epstein.  The heart in normal infants and children , 1948 .

[15]  M J McLaren,et al.  Innocent murmurs and third heart sounds in Black schoolchildren. , 1980, British heart journal.

[16]  D H FOGEL,et al.  The innocent systolic murmur in children: a clinical study of its incidence and characteristics. , 1960, American heart journal.

[17]  D. Stuckey,et al.  CARDIAC MURMURS IN SCHOOL CHILDREN , 1957, The Medical journal of Australia.

[18]  B WELLS,et al.  THE GRAPHIC CONFIGURATION OF INNOCENT SYSTOLIC MURMURS , 1957, British heart journal.