Technical basis for review of high-level waste repository modeling

Both the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) have promulgated regulations regarding the performance of geologic repositories for the disposal of high-level nuclear waste. One of the responsibilities of the US Department of Energy (DOE) is to demonstrate compliance with the appropriate regulations. The DOE will most likely use extensive numerical modeling to show compliance with the various quantitative requirements. These analyses will then be evaluated by the NRC. There are different levels of evaluation: peer review, conservative estimates,used of existing models/codes, and development of models/codes by the NRC. The intensity of the review will vary from analysis to analysis, depending on the importance of the analysis, the acceptability of the conceptual model behind the analysis and the solution technique used, and the potential for increasing confidence in the system description, should the NRC decide to develop its own models/codes. An appropriate level of review can be determined by applying these four criteria in a specific manner. 24 refs.