Comparing the Performance of Forest gap Models in North America

Forest gap models have a long history in the study of forest dynamics, including predicting long-term succession patterns and assessing the potential impacts of climate change and air pollution on forest structure and composition. In most applications, existing models are adapted for the specific question at hand and little effort is devoted to evaluating alternative formulations for key processes, although this has the potential to significantly influence model behavior. In the present study, we explore the implications of alternative formulations for selected ecological processes via the comparison of several gap models. Baseline predictions of forest biomass, composition and size structure generated by several gap models are compared to each other and to measured data at boreal and temperate sites in North America. The models ForClim and LINKAGES v2.0 were compared based on simulations of a temperate forest site in Tennessee, whereas FORSKA-2V, BOREALIS and ForClim were compared at four boreal forest sites in central and eastern Canada. Results for present-day conditions were evaluated on their success in predicting forest cover, species composition, total biomass and stand density, and allocation of biomass among species. In addition, the sensitivity of each model to climatic changes was investigated using a suite of six climate change scenarios involving temperature and precipitation. In the temperate forest simulations, both ForClim and LINKAGES v2.0 predicted mixed mesophytic forests dominated by oak species, which is expected for this region of Tennessee. The models differed in their predictions of species composition as well as with respect to the simulated rates of succession. Simulated forest dynamics under the changed climates were qualitatively similar between the two models, although aboveground biomass and species composition in ForClim was more sensitive to drought than in LINKAGES v2.0. Under a warmer climate, the modeled effects of temperature on tree growth in LINKAGES v2.0 led to the unrealistic loss of several key species. In the boreal forest simulations, ForClim predicted significant forest growth at only the most mesic site, and failed to predict a realistic species composition. In contrast, FORSKA-2V and BOREALIS were successful in simulating forest cover, general species composition, and biomass at most sites. In the climate change scenarios, ForClim was highly sensitive, whereas the other two models exhibited sensitivity only at the drier central Canadian sites. Although the studied sites differ strongly with respect to both the climatic regime and the set of dominating species, a unifying feature emerged from these simulation exercises. The major differences in model behavior were brought about by differences in the internal representations of the seasonal water balance, and they point to an important limitation in some gap model formulations for assessing climate change impacts.

[1]  H. Bugmann.  A comparative analysis of forest dynamics in the Swiss Alps and the Colorado Front Range , 2001 .

[2]  Yves Bergeron,et al.  Forest dynamics modelling under natural fire cycles: A tool to define natural mosaic diversity for forest management , 1996, Environmental monitoring and assessment.

[3]  Charles B. Halpern,et al.  Potential response of pacific northwestern forests to climatic change, effects of stand age and initial composition , 1993 .

[4]  Harald Bugmann,et al.  Sensitivity of forests in the European Alps to future climatic change , 1997 .

[5]  M. C. Axelrod,et al.  Analysis of silva: A model for forecasting the effects of SO2 pollution and fire on western coniferous forests , 1984 .

[6]  Y. Bergeron,et al.  CANOPY GAP CHARACTERISTICS AND TREE REPLACEMENT IN THE SOUTHEASTERN BOREAL FOREST , 1998 .

[7]  Carbon dioxide increase: the implications at the ecosystem level , 1985 .

[8]  K. Jon Ranson,et al.  The Boreal Ecosystem-Atmosphere Study (BOREAS) : an overview and early results from the 1994 field year , 1995 .

[9]  H. Bugmann.  A Review of Forest Gap Models , 2001 .

[10]  J. Cayford,et al.  Forest Regions of Canada , 1974 .

[11]  Y. Bergeron,et al.  Postfire stand dynamics in a southern boreal forest (Québec): a dendroecological approach. , 1994 .

[12]  P. Hanson,et al.  Description and field performance of the Walker Branch throughfall displacement experiment: 1993--1996 , 1998 .

[13]  H. Bugmann.  A Simplified Forest Model to Study Species Composition Along Climate Gradients , 1996 .

[14]  C. Priestley,et al.  On the Assessment of Surface Heat Flux and Evaporation Using Large-Scale Parameters , 1972 .

[15]  H. Morin,et al.  Balsam fir mortality following the last spruce budworm outbreak in northwestern Quebec , 1995 .

[16]  S. Pacala,et al.  Forest models defined by field measurements: I. The design of a northeastern forest simulator , 1993 .

[17]  D. Nelson,et al.  WALKER BRANCH WATERSHED PROJECT: OBJECTIVES, FACILITIES, AND ECOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS. , 1968 .

[18]  H. Morin,et al.  Chronology of spruce budworm outbreaks near Lake Duparquet, Abitibi region, Quebec , 1993 .

[19]  Changhui Peng,et al.  Simulating effects of climate change on boreal ecosystem carbon pools in central Canada , 1999 .

[20]  C. W. Thornthwaite,et al.  Instructions and tables for computing potential evapotranspiration and the water balance , 1955 .

[21]  R. Keane,et al.  Fire-BGC: A mechanistic ecological process model for simulating fire succession on coniferous forest landscapes of the northern Rocky Mountains. Forest Service research paper , 2017 .

[22]  Harald Bugmann,et al.  EXPLAINING FOREST COMPOSITION AND BIOMASS ACROSS MULTIPLE BIOGEOGRAPHICAL REGIONS , 2000 .

[23]  Y. Bergeron,et al.  Early response of Abies balsamea seedlings to artificially created openings , 1998 .

[24]  Benjamin Smith,et al.  Tree Species Composition in European Pristine Forests: Comparison of Stand Data to Model Predictions , 2001 .

[25]  Y. Bergeron,et al.  Changes in the understory of Canadian southern boreal forest after fire , 1993 .

[26]  Basil Acock,et al.  Modularity and genericness in plant and ecosystem models , 1997 .

[27]  E. Hogg,et al.  The aspen parkland in western Canada: A dry-climate analogue for the future boreal forest? , 1995 .

[28]  Yves Bergeron,et al.  Above ground biomass accumulation along a 230 year chronosequence in the southern portion of the Canadian boreal forest , 1995 .

[29]  M. Sykes,et al.  A comparison of forest gap models: Model structure and behaviour , 1996 .

[30]  Guofan Shao,et al.  A Comparative Analysis of the Structure and Behavior of Three Gap Models at Sites in Northeastern China , 2001 .

[31]  Y. Bergeron.  SPECIES AND STAND DYNAMICS IN THE MIXED WOODS OF QUEBEC'S SOUTHERN BOREAL FOREST , 2000 .

[32]  V. Dale,et al.  Potential effects of climate change on stand development in the Pacific Northwest , 1989 .

[33]  Michael A. Huston,et al.  Effects of agricultural soil loss on forest succession rates and tree diversity in east Tennessee. , 2000 .

[34]  M. Apps,et al.  The Boreal Forest Transect Case Study: Global change effects on ecosystem processes and carbon dynamics in boreal Canada , 1995 .

[35]  Harald Bugmann,et al.  The use of a European forest model in North America: a study of ecosystem response to climate gradients , 1995 .

[36]  G. Likens,et al.  Pattern and process in a forested ecosystem. , 1979 .

[37]  W. Post,et al.  Development of a linked forest productivity-soil process model , 1985 .

[38]  H. Shugart.  A Theory of Forest Dynamics , 1984 .

[39]  H. Morin.  Dynamics of balsam fir forests in relation to spruce budworm outbreaks in the Boreal Zone of Quebec , 1994 .

[40]  I. C. Prentice,et al.  Boreal forest futures: Modelling the controls on tree species range limits and transient responses to climate change , 1995 .

[41]  J. R. Wallis,et al.  Estimating the effects of carbon fertilization on forest composition by ecosystem simulation. , 1973, Brookhaven symposia in biology.

[42]  A. W. Küchler.  Potential Natural Vegetation of the Conterminous United States , 1965 .

[43]  W. Cramer,et al.  Improving the behaviour of forest gap models along drought gradients , 1998 .

[44]  E. Hogg,et al.  Climate and the southern limit of the western Canadian boreal forest , 1994 .

[45]  Dale W. Johnson,et al.  Analysis of Biogeochemical Cycling Processes in Walker Branch Watershed , 1989, Springer Advanced Texts in Life Sciences.

[46]  Heli Peltola,et al.  Bridging a gap between a gap model and a physiological model for calculating the effect of temperature on forest growth under boreal conditions , 1999 .

[47]  Martin T. Sykes,et al.  Climate change, tree species distributions and forest dynamics: A case study in the mixed conifer/northern hardwoods zone of northern Europe , 1996 .

[48]  M. Apps,et al.  Adapting a patch model to simulate the sensitivity of Central‐Canadian boreal ecosystems to climate variability , 1999 .

[49]  Andreas Huth,et al.  Aboveground Growth and Competition in Forest Gap Models: An Analysis for Studies of Climatic Change , 2001 .

[50]  W. Cramer,et al.  Regional impacts of climatic change on forests in the state of Brandenburg, Germany , 1997 .

[51]  Niklaus E. Zimmermann,et al.  Regeneration in Gap Models: Priority Issues for Studying Forest Responses to Climate Change , 2001 .

[52]  J. Rowe,et al.  Forest regions of Canada. , 1972 .

[53]  J. R. Wallis,et al.  Some ecological consequences of a computer model of forest growth , 1972 .

[54]  H. Bugmann.  Gap models, forest dynamics and the response of vegetation to climate change , 1997 .

[55]  Y. Bergeron,et al.  EFFECTS OF FIRE REGIME ON THE SEROTINY LEVEL OF JACK PINE , 1996 .

[56]  M. Apps,et al.  Boreal forest responses to climate-change scenarios along an ecoclimatic transect in central Canada , 1996 .

[57]  Botkin Db,et al.  Estimating the effects of carbon fertilization on forest composition by ecosystem simulation. , 1973 .

[58]  H. Bugmann,et al.  How physics and biology matter in forest gap models , 1995 .

[59]  Alain Leduc,et al.  Relationships between change in fire frequency and mortality due to spruce budworm outbreak in the southeastern Canadian boreal forest , 1998 .

[60]  Y. Bergeron,et al.  Ecological factors affecting the abondance of advance regeneration in Quebec's southwestern boreal forest , 1996 .

[61]  W. Cramer,et al.  Past and future rapid environmental changes : the spatial and evolutionary responses of terrestrial biota , 1997 .

[62]  Herman H. Shugart,et al.  Semivariograms from a forest transect gap model compared with remotely sensed data , 1992 .

[63]  S. Pacala,et al.  Forest models defined by field measurements : Estimation, error analysis and dynamics , 1996 .

[64]  John Pastor,et al.  Response of northern forests to CO2-induced climate change , 1988, Nature.

[65]  Harald Bugmann,et al.  On the ecology of mountainous forests in a changing climate , 1994 .

[66]  Wolfgang Cramer,et al.  A simulation model for the transient effects of climate change on forest landscapes , 1993 .