Methionine synthase catalyzes the transfer of a methyl group from methylcobalamin enzyme to homocysteine, generating methionine and cob(I)alamin enzyme, and then from methyltetrahydrofolate to cob(I)alamin enzyme, generating tetrahydrofolate and regenerating the methylcobalamin enzyme. The reactions catalyzed by methionine synthase require deprotonation of the substrate, homocysteine, and protonation of the product tetrahydrofolate, with no net change in proton stoichiometry for a complete turnover cycle. In addition, formation of the intermediate cob(I)alamin enzyme requires a change in the cobalt ligand geometry from 6-coordinate to 4-coordinate, and this rearrangement may require the transient protonation of protein residues to stabilize the cob(I)alamin enzyme. In the E. coli enzyme, the lower face of the methylcobalamin cofactor is coordinated by histidine 759, which is hydrogen bonded to aspartate 757 and then to serine 810, forming a "ligand triad". It has previously been shown that reduction of cob(II)alamin enzyme to cob(I)alamin is associated with the uptake of a proton from solution, and it has been postulated that this proton resides within the His759-Asp757 pair. Cob(I)alamin can also be generated by demethylation of methylcobalamin enzyme by homocysteine; it was not known whether this mode of cob(I)alamin formation was associated with proton uptake. In this paper, we use equilibrium titrations and kinetic analyses in the presence of the pH indicator dye phenol red, along with studies of the pH dependence of oxidation/reduction equilibria, to identify and characterize mechanistic steps associated with proton uptake and release in both the turnover and reactivation of the enzyme. We confirm that cob(I)alamin formation by reduction of cob(II)alamin enzyme is associated with proton uptake and show that mutation of Asp757 to Glu abolishes the pH dependence of this reduction. Demethylation of methylcobalamin enzyme also leads to cob(I)alamin formation and is also shown to be associated with proton uptake. By observing pre-steady-state reactions with homocysteine and methyltetrahydrofolate in the presence of phenol red, we show that this proton uptake occurs at a rate that is equal to the rate of formation of the cob(I)alamin enzyme. In addition, we show that binding of homocysteine to the enzyme results in the rapid release of a proton, presumably the homocysteine thiol proton. In contrast, binding methyltetrahydrofolate to the enzyme does not result in proton uptake, suggesting that the proton destined for the product tetrahydrofolate is already present on the free methylcobalamin enzyme.