Not all brains are created equal: the relevance of individual differences in responsiveness to transcranial electrical stimulation

A current issue in the research of augmentation of brain functions using transcranial electrical stimulation (tES) is the diversity and inconsistency in outcome results. Similar studies often report different results, depending on the parameters and tasks used. Such inconsistencies have led to significant doubts about the efficacy of the method in the broader scientific community, despite its promising potential for patient recovery and treatment. Evidence on the large variability in individual cortical excitability and response to tES suggests that stimulation may affect individuals differently, depending on the subject’s age, gender, brain state, hormonal levels, and pre-existing regional excitability. Certain factors might even lead to the reversal of polarity-dependent effects, and therefore have crucial implications for neurorehabilitation and cognitive enhancement. Research paradigms may have to be refined in the future to avoid the confounding effects of such factors.

[1]  A. Belousov Novel model for the mechanisms of glutamate-dependent excitotoxicity: Role of neuronal gap junctions , 2012, Brain Research.

[2]  A. Antal,et al.  Electrode-distance dependent after-effects of transcranial direct and random noise stimulation with extracephalic reference electrodes , 2010, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[3]  M. Bikson,et al.  Computational Models of Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation , 2012, Clinical EEG and neuroscience.

[4]  Michal Lavidor,et al.  When Less Is More: Evidence for a Facilitative Cathodal tDCS Effect in Attentional Abilities , 2012, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[5]  Sarah H. Lisanby,et al.  Fundamentals of transcranial electric and magnetic stimulation dose: Definition, selection, and reporting practices , 2012, Brain Stimulation.

[6]  M. Nitsche,et al.  Serotonin Affects Transcranial Direct Current–Induced Neuroplasticity in Humans , 2009, Biological Psychiatry.

[7]  D. Price,et al.  Loss of NMDA, but not GABA-A, binding in the brains of aged rats and monkeys , 1991, Neurobiology of Aging.

[8]  David G. Jones,et al.  Development of human visual cortex: a balance between excitatory and inhibitory plasticity mechanisms. , 2005, Developmental psychobiology.

[9]  L. Parra,et al.  Low-Intensity Electrical Stimulation Affects Network Dynamics by Modulating Population Rate and Spike Timing , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[10]  B. Greenberg,et al.  Menstrual cycle effects on cortical excitability , 1999, Neurology.

[11]  Abhishek Datta,et al.  Physiological and modeling evidence for focal transcranial electrical brain stimulation in humans: A basis for high-definition tDCS , 2013, NeuroImage.

[12]  L. Parra,et al.  Inter-Individual Variation during Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation and Normalization of Dose Using MRI-Derived Computational Models , 2012, Front. Psychiatry.

[13]  C. Herrmann,et al.  Finite-Element Model Predicts Current Density Distribution for Clinical Applications of tDCS and tACS , 2012, Front. Psychiatry.

[14]  David A. Balota,et al.  White matter integrity and reaction time intraindividual variability in healthy aging and early-stage Alzheimer disease , 2012, Neuropsychologia.

[15]  C. Herrmann,et al.  Orchestrating neuronal networks: sustained after-effects of transcranial alternating current stimulation depend upon brain states , 2013, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[16]  R. Yoshimura,et al.  Reduction of brain γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) concentrations in early-stage schizophrenia patients: 3T Proton MRS study , 2009, Schizophrenia Research.

[17]  R. Vink,et al.  The role of excitatory amino acids and NMDA receptors in traumatic brain injury. , 1989, Science.

[18]  P. Brown,et al.  Tremor Suppression by Rhythmic Transcranial Current Stimulation , 2013, Current Biology.

[19]  J. D. Hilliard,et al.  Behavioral/systems/cognitive Effective Deep Brain Stimulation Suppresses Low-frequency Network Oscillations in the Basal Ganglia by Regularizing Neural Firing Patterns , 2022 .

[20]  Lars A. Ross,et al.  Improved proper name recall by electrical stimulation of the anterior temporal lobes , 2010, Neuropsychologia.

[21]  V Menon,et al.  Cerebral Cortex doi:10.1093/cercor/bhi055 Developmental Changes in Mental Arithmetic: Evidence for Increased Functional Specialization in the Left Inferior Parietal Cortex , 2005 .

[22]  R. Cohen Kadosh,et al.  Long-Term Enhancement of Brain Function and Cognition Using Cognitive Training and Brain Stimulation , 2013, Current Biology.

[23]  Yoshikazu Ugawa,et al.  High‐frequency rTMS over the supplementary motor area for treatment of Parkinson's disease , 2008, Movement disorders : official journal of the Movement Disorder Society.

[24]  K. Hugdahl,et al.  Resting-state glutamate level in the anterior cingulate predicts blood-oxygen level-dependent response to cognitive control , 2012, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[25]  B. Cheeran,et al.  Inter-individual Variability in Response to Non-invasive Brain Stimulation Paradigms , 2014, Brain Stimulation.

[26]  E. Wassermann Variation in the response to transcranial magnetic brain stimulation in the general population , 2002, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[27]  C. Finocchi,et al.  Female reproductive steroids and neuronal excitability , 2011, Neurological Sciences.

[28]  L. Parra,et al.  Cellular effects of acute direct current stimulation: somatic and synaptic terminal effects , 2013, The Journal of physiology.

[29]  A. Antal,et al.  Increasing Human Brain Excitability by Transcranial High-Frequency Random Noise Stimulation , 2008, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[30]  A. Antal,et al.  Close to threshold transcranial electrical stimulation preferentially activates inhibitory networks before switching to excitation with higher intensities , 2012, Brain Stimulation.

[31]  M. Nitsche,et al.  Partially non‐linear stimulation intensity‐dependent effects of direct current stimulation on motor cortex excitability in humans , 2013, The Journal of physiology.

[32]  John H Krystal,et al.  Cortical gamma-aminobutyric acid levels across the menstrual cycle in healthy women and those with premenstrual dysphoric disorder: a proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy study. , 2002, Archives of general psychiatry.

[33]  Alvaro Pascual-Leone,et al.  Is neuroenhancement by noninvasive brain stimulation a net zero-sum proposition? , 2014, NeuroImage.

[34]  F. Tecchio,et al.  Regional Personalized Electrodes to Select Transcranial Current Stimulation Target , 2013, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[35]  J. Rothwell,et al.  The role of interneuron networks in driving human motor cortical plasticity. , 2013, Cerebral cortex.

[36]  B. Rosen,et al.  A functional MRI study of subjects recovered from hemiparetic stroke. , 1997, Stroke.

[37]  W. Mcentee,et al.  Glutamate: its role in learning, memory, and the aging brain , 2005, Psychopharmacology.

[38]  Jong H. Yoon,et al.  GABA Concentration Is Reduced in Visual Cortex in Schizophrenia and Correlates with Orientation-Specific Surround Suppression , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[39]  Janet L. Taylor,et al.  Daily transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) leads to greater increases in cortical excitability than second daily transcranial direct current stimulation , 2012, Brain Stimulation.

[40]  J. Rothwell,et al.  Preconditioning with transcranial direct current stimulation sensitizes the motor cortex to rapid-rate transcranial magnetic stimulation and controls the direction of after-effects , 2004, Biological Psychiatry.

[41]  M. Ridding,et al.  Age-related changes in short-latency motor cortex inhibition , 2009, Experimental Brain Research.

[42]  Emiliano Santarnecchi,et al.  State-Dependent Effects of Transcranial Oscillatory Currents on the Motor System: What You Think Matters , 2013, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[43]  Paul B. Fitzgerald,et al.  Investigating the Role of Current Strength in tDCS Modulation of Working Memory Performance in Healthy Controls , 2011, Front. Psychiatry.

[44]  Christophe Tandonnet,et al.  Age-related Differences in Corticomotor Excitability and Inhibitory Processes during a Visuomotor RT Task , 2012, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[45]  Yu Huang,et al.  An automated method for high-definition transcranial direct current stimulation modeling , 2012, 2012 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[46]  J. Rothwell,et al.  Preconditioning of Low-Frequency Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation with Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation: Evidence for Homeostatic Plasticity in the Human Motor Cortex , 2004, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[47]  M. Bikson,et al.  Computational modeling of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) in obesity: Impact of head fat and dose guidelines☆ , 2013, NeuroImage: Clinical.

[48]  J. Krystal,et al.  Sex, GABA, and nicotine: The impact of smoking on cortical GABA levels across the menstrual cycle as measured with proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy , 2005, Biological Psychiatry.

[49]  Y. Dan,et al.  Spike timing-dependent plasticity: a Hebbian learning rule. , 2008, Annual review of neuroscience.

[50]  R. C. Kadosh Using transcranial electrical stimulation to enhance cognitive functions in the typical and atypical brain , 2013 .

[51]  P. Matthews,et al.  Rapid modulation of GABA concentration in human sensorimotor cortex during motor learning. , 2006, Journal of neurophysiology.

[52]  L. Cohen,et al.  Efficacy of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation/transcranial direct current stimulation in cognitive neurorehabilitation , 2008, Brain Stimulation.

[53]  Derek K. Jones,et al.  Resting GABA concentration predicts peak gamma frequency and fMRI amplitude in response to visual stimulation in humans , 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[54]  J. Bizon,et al.  Blockade of GABA(B) receptors completely reverses age-related learning impairment , 2009, Neuroscience.

[55]  Y. Joanette,et al.  Hemispheric Asymmetry Reduction in Older Adults during Access to Semantic Memory , 2011 .

[56]  H. Johansen-Berg,et al.  The Role of GABA in Human Motor Learning , 2011, Current Biology.

[57]  J. Donoghue,et al.  Long-term potentiation of horizontal connections provides a mechanism to reorganize cortical motor maps. , 1994, Journal of neurophysiology.

[58]  Chang-hyun Park,et al.  Transcranial direct current stimulation increases resting state interhemispheric connectivity , 2013, Neuroscience Letters.

[59]  S. Nelson,et al.  Hebb and homeostasis in neuronal plasticity , 2000, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[60]  S. Ge,et al.  Nicotinic Acetylcholine Receptors at Glutamate Synapses Facilitate Long-Term Depression or Potentiation , 2005, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[61]  J. Walecki,et al.  Metabolite alterations in autistic children: a 1H MR spectroscopy study. , 2012, Advances in medical sciences.

[62]  V. Walsh,et al.  Modulating Neuronal Activity Produces Specific and Long-Lasting Changes in Numerical Competence , 2010, Current Biology.

[63]  David G. Jones,et al.  Frontiers in Cellular Neuroscience Cellular Neuroscience , 2022 .

[64]  Rolf Gruetter,et al.  MR spectroscopy of the human brain with enhanced signal intensity at ultrashort echo times on a clinical platform at 3T and 7T , 2009, Magnetic resonance in medicine.

[65]  Roi Cohen Kadosh,et al.  The effect of transcranial direct current stimulation: a role for cortical excitation/inhibition balance? , 2013, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[66]  J. Krystal,et al.  Cortical γ-Aminobutyric Acid Levels Across the Menstrual Cycle in Healthy Women and Those With Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder: A Proton Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy Study , 2002 .

[67]  Felipe Fregni,et al.  Classification of methods in transcranial Electrical Stimulation (tES) and evolving strategy from historical approaches to contemporary innovations , 2013, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[68]  Cheryl L. Dahle,et al.  Regional brain changes in aging healthy adults: general trends, individual differences and modifiers. , 2005, Cerebral cortex.

[69]  F. Hummel,et al.  Brain Stimulation and its Role in Neurological Diseases , 2014 .

[70]  D. Rubinow,et al.  Effects of ovarian hormones on human cortical excitability , 2002, Annals of neurology.

[71]  E. Knudsen Sensitive Periods in the Development of the Brain and Behavior , 2004, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[72]  J. Brasil-Neto Learning, Memory, and Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation , 2012, Front. Psychiatry.

[73]  M. Stryker,et al.  Local GABA circuit control of experience-dependent plasticity in developing visual cortex. , 1998, Science.

[74]  M. Nitsche,et al.  Sustained excitability elevations induced by transcranial DC motor cortex stimulation in humans , 2001, Neurology.

[75]  Daphne Bavelier,et al.  Removing Brakes on Adult Brain Plasticity: From Molecular to Behavioral Interventions , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[76]  R. Cohen Kadosh,et al.  Can transcranial electrical stimulation improve learning difficulties in atypical brain development? A future possibility for cognitive training , 2013, Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience.

[77]  H. Möller,et al.  Prefrontal Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Changes Connectivity of Resting-State Networks during fMRI , 2011, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[78]  S. Muthukumaraswamy,et al.  Individual variability in the shape and amplitude of the BOLD‐HRF correlates with endogenous GABAergic inhibition , 2012, Human brain mapping.

[79]  Takao K. Hensch,et al.  Re-opening Windows: Manipulating Critical Periods for Brain Development , 2012, Cerebrum : the Dana forum on brain science.

[80]  P. Matthews,et al.  Polarity-Sensitive Modulation of Cortical Neurotransmitters by Transcranial Stimulation , 2009, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[81]  J. Jefferys,et al.  Effects of uniform extracellular DC electric fields on excitability in rat hippocampal slices in vitro , 2004, The Journal of physiology.

[82]  Juha Silvanto,et al.  Neural adaptation reveals state‐dependent effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation , 2007, The European journal of neuroscience.

[83]  Gregor Thut,et al.  Resting electroencephalogram alpha-power over posterior sites indexes baseline visual cortex excitability , 2008, Neuroreport.

[84]  T. Sanger,et al.  Harnessing neuroplasticity for clinical applications , 2011, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[85]  G. Tononi,et al.  Human cortical excitability increases with time awake. , 2013, Cerebral cortex.

[86]  R. Cabeza Hemispheric asymmetry reduction in older adults: the HAROLD model. , 2002, Psychology and aging.

[87]  S. Nelson,et al.  Homeostatic plasticity in the developing nervous system , 2004, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[88]  Huiquan Wang,et al.  Edited magnetic resonance spectroscopy detects an age-related decline in brain GABA levels , 2013, NeuroImage.

[89]  R. Racine,et al.  GABAergic modulation of neocortical long‐term potentiation in the freely moving rat , 2000, Synapse.

[90]  Juha Silvanto,et al.  Double Dissociation of Format-Dependent and Number-Specific Neurons in Human Parietal Cortex , 2010, Cerebral cortex.

[91]  J. Donoghue,et al.  Long-term potentiation and long-term depression of horizontal connections in rat motor cortex. , 1996, Acta neurobiologiae experimentalis.

[92]  H. Kubo,et al.  Measurement of variation in the human cerebral GABA level by in vivo MEGA‐editing proton MR spectroscopy using a clinical 3 T instrument and its dependence on brain region and the female menstrual cycle , 2011, Human brain mapping.

[93]  J. Strelau The Contribution of Pavlov's Typology of CNS Properties to Personality Research , 1997 .

[94]  N. Bolognini,et al.  Brain polarization of parietal cortex augments training-induced improvement of visual exploratory and attentional skills , 2010, Brain Research.

[95]  N. Birbaumer,et al.  Enhancement of Planning Ability by Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation , 2009, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[96]  S. Eichler,et al.  E-I Balance and Human Diseases – from Molecules to Networking , 2008, Frontiers in molecular neuroscience.

[97]  V. Walsh,et al.  State-dependency in brain stimulation studies of perception and cognition , 2008, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[98]  R. Cohen Kadosh,et al.  The Mental Cost of Cognitive Enhancement , 2013, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[99]  Christoph E. Schreiner,et al.  Developmental sensory experience balances cortical excitation and inhibition , 2010, Nature.

[100]  J. Rothwell,et al.  Level of action of cathodal DC polarisation induced inhibition of the human motor cortex , 2003, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[101]  F. Fregni,et al.  Noninvasive Brain Stimulation with Low-Intensity Electrical Currents: Putative Mechanisms of Action for Direct and Alternating Current Stimulation , 2010, The Neuroscientist : a review journal bringing neurobiology, neurology and psychiatry.

[102]  Walter Paulus,et al.  Circadian modulation of GABA-mediated cortical inhibition. , 2011, Cerebral cortex.

[103]  Donald C. Rojas,et al.  Decreased left perisylvian GABA concentration in children with autism and unaffected siblings , 2014, NeuroImage.

[104]  Richard L. Huganir,et al.  AMPARs and Synaptic Plasticity: The Last 25 Years , 2013, Neuron.

[105]  François Bellavance,et al.  Proton Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy Measurement of Brain Glutamate Levels in Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder , 2008, Biological Psychiatry.

[106]  Xin Zheng,et al.  Effects of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) on human regional cerebral blood flow , 2011, NeuroImage.

[107]  Á. Pascual-Leone,et al.  Contribution of axonal orientation to pathway-dependent modulation of excitatory transmission by direct current stimulation in isolated rat hippocampus. , 2012, Journal of neurophysiology.

[108]  Ulf Ziemann,et al.  Suppression of LTP-like plasticity in human motor cortex by the GABAB receptor agonist baclofen , 2007, Experimental Brain Research.

[109]  Vincent Walsh,et al.  Frequency-Dependent Electrical Stimulation of the Visual Cortex , 2008, Current Biology.

[110]  Ingrid R. Olson,et al.  Improved Proper Name Recall in Aging after Electrical Stimulation of the Anterior Temporal Lobes , 2011, Front. Ag. Neurosci.

[111]  Debora Brignani,et al.  Is Transcranial Alternating Current Stimulation Effective in Modulating Brain Oscillations? , 2013, PloS one.

[112]  Ethan R. Buch,et al.  Noninvasive cortical stimulation enhances motor skill acquisition over multiple days through an effect on consolidation , 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[113]  W. Paulus,et al.  Towards unravelling task-related modulations of neuroplastic changes induced in the human motor cortex , 2008, Brain Stimulation.

[114]  M. Johnston,et al.  Plasticity in the developing brain: implications for rehabilitation. , 2009, Developmental disabilities research reviews.