Samurai project: Verifying the consistency of black-hole-binary waveforms for gravitational-wave detection

We quantify the consistency of numerical-relativity black-hole-binary waveforms for use in gravitational-wave (GW) searches with current and planned ground-based detectors. We compare previously published results for the ([script-l]=2,|m|=2) mode of the gravitational waves from an equal-mass nonspinning binary, calculated by five numerical codes. We focus on the 1000M (about six orbits, or 12 GW cycles) before the peak of the GW amplitude and the subsequent ringdown. We find that the phase and amplitude agree within each code's uncertainty estimates. The mismatch between the ([script-l]=2,|m|=2) modes is better than 10^(-3) for binary masses above 60M_([sun]) with respect to the Enhanced LIGO detector noise curve, and for masses above 180M_([sun]) with respect to Advanced LIGO, Virgo, and Advanced Virgo. Between the waveforms with the best agreement, the mismatch is below 2×10^(-4). We find that the waveforms would be indistinguishable in all ground-based detectors (and for the masses we consider) if detected with a signal-to-noise ratio of less than [approximate]14, or less than [approximate]25 in the best cases.

[1]  Spin Flips and Precession in Black-Hole-Binary Mergers , 2006, gr-qc/0612076.

[2]  Lawrence E. Kidder,et al.  A new generalized harmonic evolution system , 2005, gr-qc/0512093.

[3]  J. D. Brown.  Puncture evolution of Schwarzschild black holes , 2007, 0705.1359.

[4]  Y. Zlochower,et al.  Extra-large remnant recoil velocities and spins from near-extremal-Bowen-York-spin black-hole binaries , 2008, 0803.0351.

[5]  D. Gottlieb,et al.  Spectral methods for hyperbolic problems , 2001 .

[6]  José A. González,et al.  Inspiral, merger, and ringdown of unequal mass black hole binaries: A multipolar analysis , 2007, gr-qc/0703053.

[7]  J. D. Brown,et al.  Evolving a Puncture Black Hole with Fixed Mesh Refinement , 2004, gr-qc/0403048.

[8]  José A. González,et al.  Maximum kick from nonspinning black-hole binary inspiral. , 2007, Physical review letters.

[9]  Circular orbits and spin in black-hole initial data , 2006, gr-qc/0605053.

[10]  H. Pfeiffer,et al.  Extrinsic curvature and the Einstein constraints , 2002, gr-qc/0207095.

[11]  N. Murchadha,et al.  Trapped surfaces in vacuum spacetimes , 1993, gr-qc/9304034.

[12]  Richard A. Matzner,et al.  Binary black holes: Spin dynamics and gravitational recoil , 2007, 0706.2541.

[13]  Dae-Il Choi,et al.  Gravitational-wave extraction from an inspiraling configuration of merging black holes. , 2005, Physical review letters.

[14]  Owen.  Search templates for gravitational waves from inspiraling binaries: Choice of template spacing. , 1996, Physical review. D, Particles and fields.

[15]  Frans Pretorius,et al.  High-energy collision of two black holes. , 2008, Physical review letters.

[16]  Michael Boyle,et al.  High-accuracy comparison of numerical relativity simulations with post-Newtonian expansions , 2007, 0710.0158.

[17]  Modeling gravitational radiation from coalescing binary black holes , 2002, astro-ph/0202469.

[18]  Improved filters for gravitational waves from inspiraling compact binaries , 1997, gr-qc/9708034.

[19]  S. Shapiro,et al.  Black Hole Spin Evolution , 2003, astro-ph/0310886.

[20]  Well-posedness of formulations of the Einstein equations with dynamical lapse and shift conditions , 2006, gr-qc/0604035.

[21]  S. Teukolsky,et al.  Ineffectiveness of Padé resummation techniques in post-Newtonian approximations , 2008, 0805.2390.

[22]  S. Klimenko,et al.  A comparison of methods for gravitational wave burst searches from LIGO and Virgo , 2007, gr-qc/0701026.

[23]  D. Shoemaker,et al.  Unequal mass binary black hole plunges and gravitational recoil , 2006, gr-qc/0601026.

[24]  Marcus Ansorg,et al.  Single-domain spectral method for black hole puncture data , 2004 .

[25]  A. Sintes,et al.  LISA observations of supermassive black holes: Parameter estimation using full post-Newtonian inspiral waveforms , 2007, 0707.4434.

[26]  B. Bruegmann,et al.  Multipolar analysis of spinning binaries , 2007, 0711.1097.

[27]  P. C. Peters.  Gravitational Radiation and the Motion of Two Point Masses , 1964 .

[28]  Harald P. Pfeiffer,et al.  Solving Einstein's equations with dual coordinate frames , 2006, gr-qc/0607056.

[29]  S. McWilliams,et al.  Modeling Kicks from the Merger of Generic Black Hole Binaries , 2008, 0802.0416.

[30]  On the rarity of double black hole binaries : Consequences for gravitational wave detection , 2006, astro-ph/0612032.

[31]  Last orbit of binary black holes , 2006, gr-qc/0601091.

[32]  Bernd Bruegmann,et al.  A Simple Construction of Initial Data for Multiple Black Holes , 1997 .

[33]  S. McWilliams,et al.  Consistency of post-Newtonian waveforms with numerical relativity. , 2006, Physical review letters.

[34]  E. Phinney,et al.  AN OVERVIEW OF GRAVITATIONAL-WAVE SOURCES , 2022 .

[35]  Gravitational radiation from inspiralling compact binaries completed at the third post-Newtonian order. , 2004, Physical review letters.

[36]  Finn,et al.  Observing binary inspiral in gravitational radiation: One interferometer. , 1993, Physical review. D, Particles and fields.

[37]  D. Shoemaker,et al.  Binary-black-hole encounters, gravitational bursts, and maximum final spin. , 2008, Physical review letters.

[38]  Erik Schnetter,et al.  Recoil velocities from equal-mass binary-black-hole mergers. , 2007 .

[39]  Spin-orbit interactions in black-hole binaries , 2006, astro-ph/0608275.

[40]  M. Vallisneri,et al.  LISA detections of massive black hole inspirals: Parameter extraction errors due to inaccurate template waveforms , 2007, 0707.2982.

[41]  Conformal ``thin sandwich'' data for the initial-value problem of general relativity , 1998, gr-qc/9810051.

[42]  Karsten Danzmann,et al.  LISA technology - concept, status, prospects , 2003 .

[43]  Y. Zlochower,et al.  Large Merger Recoils and Spin Flips from Generic Black Hole Binaries , 2007, gr-qc/0701164.

[44]  J. Bardeen,et al.  Numerical Tests of Evolution Systems, Gauge Conditions, and Boundary Conditions for 1D Colliding Gravitational Plane Waves , 2002 .

[45]  Duncan A. Brown,et al.  Model waveform accuracy standards for gravitational wave data analysis , 2008, 0809.3844.

[46]  L. Lehner,et al.  Dealing with delicate issues in waveform calculations , 2007, 0706.1319.

[47]  Wormholes and trumpets: Schwarzschild spacetime for the moving-puncture generation , 2008, 0804.0628.

[48]  Erik Schnetter,et al.  Recoil velocities from equal-mass binary-black-hole mergers. , 2007, Physical review letters.

[49]  Harald P. Pfeiffer,et al.  Reducing orbital eccentricity in binary black hole simulations , 2007 .

[50]  Harald P. Pfeiffer,et al.  Boundary conditions for the Einstein evolution system , 2005 .

[51]  S. Shapiro,et al.  On the numerical integration of Einstein's field equations , 1998, gr-qc/9810065.

[52]  Finn.  Detection, measurement, and gravitational radiation. , 1992, Physical review. D, Particles and fields.

[53]  M. Scheel,et al.  Testing outer boundary treatments for the Einstein equations , 2007, 0704.0782.

[54]  Martin M. Fejer,et al.  Analysis of LIGO data for gravitational waves from binary neutron stars , 2004 .

[55]  Sascha Husa,et al.  Comparison between numerical-relativity and post-Newtonian waveforms from spinning binaries: The orbital hang-up case , 2007, 0712.3787.

[56]  Spin, accretion, and the cosmological growth of supermassive black holes , 2004, astro-ph/0411156.

[57]  M. Scheel,et al.  Gauge Drivers for the Generalized Harmonic Einstein Equations , 2007, 0711.2084.

[58]  Frans Pretorius,et al.  Numerical relativity using a generalized harmonic decomposition , 2005 .

[59]  S. McWilliams,et al.  Toward faithful templates for non-spinning binary black holes using the effective-one-body approach , 2007, 0706.3732.

[60]  Well-Posed Initial-Boundary Evolution in General Relativity , 2002, gr-qc/0205044.

[61]  P. Marronetti,et al.  Binary black hole mergers: Large kicks for generic spin orientations , 2007, gr-qc/0703075.

[62]  Sascha Husa,et al.  Calibration of moving puncture simulations , 2008 .

[63]  Binary black-hole evolutions of excision and puncture data , 2006, gr-qc/0606079.

[64]  Excision boundary conditions for black-hole initial data , 2004, gr-qc/0407078.

[65]  Aaas News,et al.  Book Reviews , 1893, Buffalo Medical and Surgical Journal.

[66]  Boundary conditions in linearized harmonic gravity , 2001, gr-qc/0106026.

[67]  Luciano Rezzolla,et al.  Gauge-invariant non-spherical metric perturbations of Schwarzschild black-hole spacetimes , 2005 .

[68]  L. Rezzolla,et al.  PREDICTING THE DIRECTION OF THE FINAL SPIN FROM THE COALESCENCE OF TWO BLACK HOLES , 2007, 0904.2577.

[69]  M. Loupias,et al.  The Virgo status , 2006 .

[70]  José A. González,et al.  Where post-Newtonian and numerical-relativity waveforms meet , 2007, 0706.1305.

[71]  Roger Penrose,et al.  An Approach to Gravitational Radiation by a Method of Spin Coefficients , 1962 .

[72]  S. Husa,et al.  Geometry and regularity of moving punctures. , 2006, Physical review letters.

[73]  Y. Zlochower,et al.  Accurate evolutions of orbiting black-hole binaries without excision. , 2006, Physical review letters.

[74]  Carlos O. Lousto,et al.  Modeling gravitational recoil from precessing highly spinning unequal-mass black-hole binaries , 2008, 0805.0159.

[75]  Towards absorbing outer boundaries in general relativity , 2006, gr-qc/0608051.

[76]  P. Marronetti,et al.  Final mass and spin of black-hole mergers , 2008, 0807.2985.

[77]  J. Stewart,et al.  Advanced General Relativity , 1991 .

[78]  Zhoujian Cao,et al.  Reinvestigation of moving punctured black holes with a new code , 2008 .

[79]  S. McWilliams,et al.  Anatomy of the Binary Black Hole Recoil: A Multipolar Analysis , 2007, 0707.0301.

[80]  Saul A. Teukolsky,et al.  Perturbations of a rotating black hole. I. Fundamental equations for gravitational, electromagnetic, and neutrino-field perturbations , 1973 .

[81]  Ernst Nils Dorband,et al.  Spin Diagrams for Equal-Mass Black Hole Binaries with Aligned Spins , 2007, 0708.3999.

[82]  Masaru Shibata,et al.  High-velocity collision of two black holes , 2008, 0810.4735.

[83]  M. Ansorg,et al.  Eccentric binary black-hole mergers: The transition from inspiral to plunge in general relativity , 2007, 0710.3823.

[84]  J. Centrella,et al.  Recoiling from a kick in the head-on collision of spinning black holes , 2007, gr-qc/0702016.

[85]  I. Hinder,et al.  Constraint damping in the Z4 formulation and harmonic gauge , 2005, gr-qc/0504114.

[86]  G. B. Cook.  Corotating and irrotational binary black holes in quasicircular orbits , 2001, gr-qc/0108076.

[87]  C. Broeck,et al.  Higher signal harmonics, LISA's angular resolution, and dark energy , 2007, 0707.3920.

[88]  David Merritt,et al.  Maximum gravitational recoil. , 2007, Physical review letters.

[89]  H. Friedrich,et al.  Asymptotically Flat Initial Data¶with Prescribed Regularity at Infinity , 2001, gr-qc/0102047.

[90]  José A. González,et al.  Reducing phase error in long numerical binary black hole evolutions with sixth-order finite differencing , 2007, 0706.0740.

[91]  D. Shoemaker,et al.  Superkicks in hyperbolic encounters of binary black holes. , 2008, Physical review letters.

[92]  José A. González,et al.  Reducing eccentricity in black-hole binary evolutions with initial parameters from post-Newtonian inspiral , 2007, 0706.0904.

[93]  Modeling Kicks from the Merger of Nonprecessing Black Hole Binaries , 2007, astro-ph/0702390.

[94]  Bernard F. Schutz,et al.  The Geo-Project. A Long-Baseline Laser Interferometer for the Detection of Gravitational Waves , 1992 .

[95]  Dae-Il Choi,et al.  Getting a Kick Out of Numerical Relativity , 2006, astro-ph/0603204.

[96]  The Cauchy problem for the Einstein equations , 2000, gr-qc/0002074.

[97]  Spinning-black-hole binaries: The orbital hang-up , 2006, gr-qc/0604012.

[98]  T. Damour,et al.  Faithful Effective-One-Body waveforms of equal-mass coalescing black-hole binaries , 2007, 0712.3003.

[99]  José A González,et al.  Supermassive recoil velocities for binary black-hole mergers with antialigned spins. , 2007, Physical review letters.

[100]  M. M. Casey,et al.  Joint LIGO and TAMA300 search for gravitational waves from inspiralling neutron star binaries , 2006 .

[101]  Helmut Friedrich,et al.  On the hyperbolicity of Einstein's and other gauge field equations , 1985 .

[102]  P. Marronetti,et al.  High-spin binary black hole mergers , 2007, 0709.2160.

[103]  Y. Zlochower,et al.  Further insight into gravitational recoil , 2007, 0708.4048.

[104]  The Distribution and cosmic evolution of massive black hole spins , 2004, astro-ph/0410342.

[105]  Matched filtering of numerical relativity templates of spinning binary black holes , 2007, 0705.3829.

[106]  Dae-Il Choi,et al.  How to move a black hole without excision: Gauge conditions for the numerical evolution of a moving puncture , 2006 .

[107]  J. York,et al.  Time-asymmetric initial data for black holes and black-hole collisions , 1980 .

[108]  E. Seidel,et al.  Gauge conditions for long-term numerical black hole evolutions without excision , 2002, gr-qc/0206072.

[109]  S. McWilliams,et al.  Binary black hole late inspiral: Simulations for gravitational wave observations , 2006, gr-qc/0612117.

[110]  Lawrence E. Kidder,et al.  High-accuracy waveforms for binary black hole inspiral, merger, and ringdown , 2008, 0810.1767.

[111]  Flanagan,et al.  Gravitational waves from merging compact binaries: How accurately can one extract the binary's parameters from the inspiral waveform? , 1994, Physical review. D, Particles and fields.

[112]  Nakamura,et al.  Evolution of three-dimensional gravitational waves: Harmonic slicing case. , 1995, Physical review. D, Particles and fields.

[113]  Formation of double compact objects , 2006, astro-ph/0612144.

[114]  O. Rinne.  Stable radiation-controlling boundary conditions for the generalized harmonic Einstein equations , 2006, gr-qc/0606053.

[115]  A. Sengupta,et al.  Binary black hole spectroscopy , 2006, gr-qc/0610126.

[116]  Bernard J. Kelly,et al.  Mergers of non-spinning black-hole binaries: Gravitational radiation characteristics , 2008, 0805.1428.

[117]  Andrew G. Glen,et al.  APPL , 2001 .

[118]  Kostas D. Kokkotas,et al.  Quasi-Normal Modes of Stars and Black Holes , 1999, Living reviews in relativity.

[119]  D. Brown,et al.  Detailed comparison of LIGO and Virgo inspiral pipelines in preparation for a joint search , 2008 .

[120]  Well Posed Constraint-Preserving Boundary Conditions for the Linearized Einstein Equations , 2002, gr-qc/0209017.

[121]  J. Stewart.  The Cauchy problem and the initial boundary value problem in numerical relativity , 1998 .

[122]  Jan S. Hesthaven,et al.  Spectral penalty methods , 2000 .

[123]  E. Seidel,et al.  First order hyperbolic formalism for numerical relativity , 1997, gr-qc/9709016.

[124]  G. G. Stokes.  "J." , 1890, The New Yale Book of Quotations.

[125]  Lawrence E. Kidder,et al.  High-accuracy numerical simulation of black-hole binaries: Computation of the gravitational-wave energy flux and comparisons with post-Newtonian approximants , 2008, 0804.4184.

[126]  Frans Pretorius,et al.  Evolution of binary black-hole spacetimes. , 2005, Physical review letters.

[127]  Edward Seidel,et al.  Accurate evolution of orbiting binary black holes. , 2006, Physical review letters.

[128]  T. Damour,et al.  Accurate effective-one-body waveforms of inspiralling and coalescing black-hole binaries , 2008, 0803.3162.

[129]  S. McWilliams,et al.  A data-analysis driven comparison of analytic and numerical coalescing binary waveforms: nonspinning case , 2007, 0704.1964.

[130]  et al,et al.  Search for gravitational waves from binary inspirals in S3 and S4 LIGO data , 2007, 0704.3368.

[131]  et al,et al.  Search for gravitational waves from galactic and extra-galactic binary neutron stars , 2005, gr-qc/0505041.

[132]  Frank Herrmann,et al.  Circularization and final spin in eccentric binary-black-hole inspirals , 2007, 0710.5167.

[133]  T. Damour,et al.  Comparing effective-one-body gravitational waveforms to accurate numerical data , 2007, 0711.2628.

[134]  A. Buonanno,et al.  Inspiral, merger and ring-down of equal-mass black-hole binaries , 2006, gr-qc/0610122.

[135]  H. Friedrich,et al.  The Initial Boundary Value Problem for Einstein's Vacuum Field Equation , 1999 .

[136]  José A. González,et al.  Exploring black hole superkicks , 2007, 0707.0135.

[137]  C. Will,et al.  Gravitational-wave spectroscopy of massive black holes with the space interferometer LISA , 2005, gr-qc/0512160.

[138]  P. Ajith,et al.  Template bank for gravitational waveforms from coalescing binary black holes: Nonspinning binaries , 2008 .

[139]  Dae-Il Choi,et al.  Binary black hole merger dynamics and waveforms , 2006, gr-qc/0602026.

[140]  P. Ajith.  Gravitational-wave data analysis using binary black-hole waveforms , 2007, 0712.0343.

[141]  Scott H. Hawley,et al.  Dynamical evolution of quasicircular binary black hole data , 2004, Physical Review D.