Are seemingly physically similar catchments truly hydrologically similar?

[1] This paper discusses the notion of similarity often used in the regionalization studies of hydrological models. We compare two different visions of similarity: the apparent similarity defined on the basis of observable catchment properties, and behavioral similarity judged through the use of hydrological models. These two visions are generally assumed to be merged in regionalization studies: Catchments having apparently similar physical characteristics are assumed to have a similar hydrological behavior. In this paper, we wished to test the validity of this assumption. To this aim, we defined behavioral (hydrological) similarity on the basis of model parameter transferability. Then pools of hydrologically similar catchments are compared with pools of apparently physically similar catchments, as identified on the basis of physiographic catchment descriptors. The overlap between the two pools of similar catchments is analyzed, making it possible to judge the efficiency of the physical similarity measure and to identify hydrologically similar catchments in an ungauged context. The results show that the overlap between the two pools is significant for only 60% of the catchments. For the other catchments, two major reasons were identified as contributing to the lack of overlap: (1) these catchments often have a quite specific hydrological behavior and (2) the role of the underground properties of the catchment on its hydrological behavior was not found to be accurately described by the available physical descriptors, meaning that more relevant catchment descriptors should be sought to better describe the geological and lithological context in hydrological terms.

[1]  Andrew W. Western,et al.  Optimization of a similarity measure for estimating ungauged streamflow , 2009 .

[2]  Jacques Lavabre,et al.  Impact of imperfect rainfall knowledge on the efficiency and the parameters of watershed models , 2001 .

[3]  T. Casadevall,et al.  Computer programs for describing the recession of ground-water discharge and for estimating mean ground-water recharge and discharge from streamflow records-update , 1993 .

[4]  Vazken Andréassian,et al.  Impact of imperfect potential evapotranspiration knowledge on the efficiency and parameters of watershed models , 2004 .

[5]  Thorsten Wagener,et al.  Parameter estimation and regionalization for continuous rainfall-runoff models including uncertainty , 2006 .

[6]  K. Beven,et al.  A physically based, variable contributing area model of basin hydrology , 1979 .

[7]  R. Woods,et al.  Catchment Classification and Hydrologic Similarity , 2006, Geography Compass.

[8]  C. Perrin,et al.  Improvement of a parsimonious model for streamflow simulation , 2003 .

[9]  András Bárdossy,et al.  Calibration of hydrological model parameters for ungauged catchments , 2006 .

[10]  Hoshin Vijai Gupta,et al.  A process‐based diagnostic approach to model evaluation: Application to the NWS distributed hydrologic model , 2008 .

[11]  Vazken Andréassian,et al.  The exponential store: a correct formulation for rainfall—runoff modelling , 2003 .

[12]  Hoshin Vijai Gupta,et al.  Regionalization of constraints on expected watershed response behavior for improved predictions in ungauged basins , 2007 .

[13]  Dominique King,et al.  Development of a soil geographic database from the Soil Map of the European Communities , 1994 .

[14]  M. Sivapalan.  Prediction in ungauged basins: a grand challenge for theoretical hydrology , 2003 .

[15]  J. M. Hollis,et al.  Hydrology of soil types: a hydrologically-based classification of the soils of United Kingdom. , 1995 .

[16]  Vazken Andréassian,et al.  How can rainfall‐runoff models handle intercatchment groundwater flows? Theoretical study based on 1040 French catchments , 2007 .

[17]  Hoshin Vijai Gupta,et al.  Decomposition of the mean squared error and NSE performance criteria: Implications for improving hydrological modelling , 2009 .

[18]  J. Nash,et al.  River flow forecasting through conceptual models part I — A discussion of principles☆ , 1970 .

[19]  Hyosang Lee,et al.  Ensemble predictions of runoff in ungauged catchments , 2005 .

[20]  Thibault Mathevet,et al.  Impact of biased and randomly corrupted inputs on the efficiency and the parameters of watershed models , 2006 .

[21]  Vazken Andréassian,et al.  Spatial proximity, physical similarity, regression and ungaged catchments: A comparison of regionalization approaches based on 913 French catchments , 2008 .

[22]  Yongqiang Zhang,et al.  Relative merits of different methods for runoff predictions in ungauged catchments , 2009 .

[23]  Manuel K. Schneider,et al.  Towards a hydrological classification of European soils: preliminary test of its predictive power for the base flow index using river discharge data , 2007 .

[24]  Hoshin Vijai Gupta,et al.  On the development of regionalization relationships for lumped watershed models: The impact of ignoring sub-basin scale variability , 2009 .

[25]  Marco Franchini,et al.  Physical interpretation and sensitivity analysis of the TOPMODEL , 1996 .

[26]  Florence Habets,et al.  Analysis of Near-Surface Atmospheric Variables: Validation of the SAFRAN Analysis over France , 2008 .

[27]  Nilo Nascimento,et al.  GR3J: a daily watershed model with three free parameters , 1999 .

[28]  Thibault Mathevet,et al.  Dynamic averaging of rainfall‐runoff model simulations from complementary model parameterizations , 2006 .

[29]  Günter Blöschl,et al.  A comparison of regionalisation methods for catchment model parameters , 2005 .

[30]  Anthony J. Jakeman,et al.  Predicting daily flows in ungauged catchments: model regionalization from catchment descriptors at the Coweeta Hydrologic Laboratory, North Carolina , 2003 .

[31]  J. McDonnell,et al.  On the need for catchment classification , 2004 .

[32]  Alison L. Kay,et al.  An investigation of site-similarity approaches to generalisation of a rainfall?runoff model , 2007 .

[33]  L. S. Pereira,et al.  Crop evapotranspiration : guidelines for computing crop water requirements , 1998 .

[34]  H. L. Penman.  Natural evaporation from open water, bare soil and grass , 1948, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences.

[35]  N. Bulygina,et al.  Conditioning rainfall-runoff model parameters for ungauged catchments and land management impacts analysis , 2009 .

[36]  Donald H. Burn,et al.  Estimation of hydrological parameters at ungauged catchments , 1993 .