The comet assay in nanotoxicology research

Nanoscale particles can have impressive and useful characteristics, but the same properties may be problematic for human health. From this perspective it is critical to assess the ability of nanoparticles to cause DNA damage. This review focuses on the use of the comet assay in nanotoxicology research. In the alkaline version of the assay, DNA strand breaks and alkali-labile sites are detected and oxidatively damaged DNA can be analyzed using the enzyme formamidopyrimidine glycosylase. The article reviews studies that have used the comet assay to investigate the toxicity of manufactured nanoparticles. It is shown that at least 46 cellular in vitro studies and several in vivo studies have used the comet assay and that the majority of the nanoparticles tested cause DNA strand breaks or oxidative DNA lesions. This is not surprising considering the sensitivity of the method and the reactivity of many nanomaterials. Interactions between the particles and the assay cannot be totally excluded and need further consideration. It is concluded that studies including several particle types, to enable the assessment of their relative potency, are valuable as are studies focusing both on comet assay end points and mutagenicity. Finally, the article discusses the potential future use of the comet assay in human biomonitoring studies, which could provide valuable information for hazard identification of nanoparticles.

[1]  K. Jan,et al.  Ultrafine titanium dioxide particles in the absence of photoactivation can induce oxidative damage to human bronchial epithelial cells. , 2005, Toxicology.

[2]  H. Karlsson,et al.  Copper oxide nanoparticles are highly toxic: a comparison between metal oxide nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes. , 2008, Chemical research in toxicology.

[3]  Jing Chen,et al.  Toxicological effects of TiO2 and ZnO nanoparticles in soil on earthworm Eisenia fetida. , 2010 .

[4]  Steffen Loft,et al.  An ECVAG† trial on assessment of oxidative damage to DNA measured by the comet assay , 2009, Mutagenesis.

[5]  J Fisher,et al.  The effect of nano- and micron-sized particles of cobalt-chromium alloy on human fibroblasts in vitro. , 2007, Biomaterials.

[6]  Vincent Castranova,et al.  Single-walled Carbon Nanotubes: Geno- and Cytotoxic Effects in Lung Fibroblast V79 Cells , 2007, Journal of toxicology and environmental health. Part A.

[7]  A. Lankoff,et al.  Aluminum‐induced micronuclei and apoptosis in human peripheral‐blood lymphocytes treated during different phases of the cell cycle , 2005, Environmental toxicology.

[8]  Takashi Omori,et al.  Statistical issues in the use of the comet assay. , 2008, Mutagenesis.

[9]  Min Chen,et al.  Formation of nucleoplasmic protein aggregates impairs nuclear function in response to SiO2 nanoparticles. , 2005, Experimental cell research.

[10]  A. Collins,et al.  DNA oxidation: investigating its key role in environmental mutagenesis with the comet assay. , 2009, Mutation research.

[11]  S. Doak,et al.  NanoGenotoxicology: the DNA damaging potential of engineered nanomaterials. , 2009, Biomaterials.

[12]  M. Fenech,et al.  An increased micronucleus frequency in peripheral blood lymphocytes predicts the risk of cancer in humans. , 2006, Carcinogenesis.

[13]  W. Whong,et al.  Detection of mineral-dust-induced DNA damage in two mammalian cell lines using the alkaline single cell gel/comet assay. , 1997, Mutation research.

[14]  Gunnar Brunborg,et al.  The comet assay: topical issues. , 2008, Mutagenesis.

[15]  F. Rossi,et al.  Genotoxicity and morphological transformation induced by cobalt nanoparticles and cobalt chloride: an in vitro study in Balb/3T3 mouse fibroblasts. , 2009, Mutagenesis.

[16]  R. Tice,et al.  Single cell gel/comet assay: Guidelines for in vitro and in vivo genetic toxicology testing , 2000, Environmental and molecular mutagenesis.

[17]  Awadhesh N Jha,et al.  Hydroxyl radicals (*OH) are associated with titanium dioxide (TiO(2)) nanoparticle-induced cytotoxicity and oxidative DNA damage in fish cells. , 2008, Mutation research.

[18]  Mark R Wiesner,et al.  In vitro interactions between DMSA-coated maghemite nanoparticles and human fibroblasts: A physicochemical and cyto-genotoxical study. , 2006, Environmental science & technology.

[19]  Antonio Marcomini,et al.  Genotoxicity, cytotoxicity, and reactive oxygen species induced by single‐walled carbon nanotubes and C60 fullerenes in the FE1‐Muta™Mouse lung epithelial cells , 2008, Environmental and molecular mutagenesis.

[20]  Christofer Leygraf,et al.  Surface characteristics, copper release, and toxicity of nano- and micrometer-sized copper and copper(II) oxide particles: a cross-disciplinary study. , 2009, Small.

[21]  S. Tsuda,et al.  The Comet Assay with Multiple Mouse Organs: Comparison of Comet Assay Results and Carcinogenicity with 208 Chemicals Selected from the IARC Monographs and U.S. NTP Carcinogenicity Database** , 2000, Critical reviews in toxicology.

[22]  E Sabbioni,et al.  Comparative genotoxicity of cobalt nanoparticles and ions on human peripheral leukocytes in vitro. , 2008, Mutagenesis.

[23]  Lih-Yuan Lin,et al.  Comparison of organic and inorganic germanium compounds in cellular radiosensitivity and preparation of germanium nanoparticles as a radiosensitizer , 2009, International journal of radiation biology.

[24]  H. Lindberg,et al.  Genotoxic effects of nanosized and fine TiO2 , 2009, Human & experimental toxicology.

[25]  Su Jin Kang,et al.  Titanium dioxide nanoparticles trigger p53‐mediated damage response in peripheral blood lymphocytes , 2008, Environmental and molecular mutagenesis.

[26]  Mark D. Hoover,et al.  Raw Single-Wall Carbon Nanotubes Induce Oxidative Stress and Activate MAPKs, AP-1, NF-κB, and Akt in Normal and Malignant Human Mesothelial Cells , 2008, Environmental health perspectives.

[27]  Chao Liu,et al.  Comparative study of cytotoxicity, oxidative stress and genotoxicity induced by four typical nanomaterials: the role of particle size, shape and composition , 2009, Journal of applied toxicology : JAT.

[28]  V. Scarcelli,et al.  Genotoxic potential of TiO2 on bottlenose dolphin leukocytes , 2010, Analytical and bioanalytical chemistry.

[29]  Anant Kumar Singh,et al.  Effect of Surface Coating on the Toxicity of Silver Nanomaterials on Human Skin Keratinocytes. , 2010, Chemical physics letters.

[30]  E. Dopp,et al.  Titanium dioxide nanoparticles induce oxidative stress and DNA-adduct formation but not DNA-breakage in human lung cells , 2009, Particle and Fibre Toxicology.

[31]  David H Phillips,et al.  Variation in the measurement of DNA damage by comet assay measured by the ECVAG inter-laboratory validation trial. , 2010, Mutagenesis.

[32]  Andrew Collins,et al.  Establishing the background level of base oxidation in human lymphocyte DNA: results of an interlaboratory validation study , 2005, FASEB journal : official publication of the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology.

[33]  Mark R. Wiesner,et al.  CeO2 nanoparticles induce DNA damage towards human dermal fibroblasts in vitro , 2009 .

[34]  Awadhesh N. Jha,et al.  Genotoxic and cytotoxic potential of titanium dioxide (TiO2) nanoparticles on fish cells in vitro , 2008, Ecotoxicology.

[35]  Steffen Loft,et al.  Ultrafine particulate matter and high-level benzene urban air pollution in relation to oxidative DNA damage. , 2004, Carcinogenesis.

[36]  Robert H Schiestl,et al.  Titanium dioxide nanoparticles induce DNA damage and genetic instability in vivo in mice. , 2009, Cancer research.

[37]  David B Warheit,et al.  How meaningful are the results of nanotoxicity studies in the absence of adequate material characterization? , 2008, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[38]  Amir Amani,et al.  The effect of zinc oxide and titanium dioxide nanoparticles in the Comet assay with UVA photoactivation of human sperm and lymphocytes , 2009 .

[39]  W. MacNee,et al.  Nanoparticle carbon black driven DNA damage induces growth arrest and AP-1 and NFkappaB DNA binding in lung epithelial A549 cell line. , 2007, Journal of physiology and pharmacology : an official journal of the Polish Physiological Society.

[40]  Takehiko Nohmi,et al.  Genotoxicity of nano/microparticles in in vitro micronuclei, in vivo comet and mutation assay systems , 2009, Particle and Fibre Toxicology.

[41]  R. Tice,et al.  A simple technique for quantitation of low levels of DNA damage in individual cells. , 1988, Experimental cell research.

[42]  A. Collins,et al.  Direct enzymic detection of endogenous oxidative base damage in human lymphocyte DNA. , 1993, Carcinogenesis.

[43]  Roel P F Schins,et al.  Inhaled particles and lung cancer. Part A: Mechanisms , 2004, International journal of cancer.

[44]  N. Tanaka,et al.  The photogenotoxicity of titanium dioxide particles. , 1997, Mutation research.

[45]  Alok Dhawan,et al.  Stable colloidal dispersions of C60 fullerenes in water: evidence for genotoxicity. , 2006, Environmental science & technology.

[46]  P. Møller,et al.  Oxidatively damaged DNA and inflammation in the liver of dyslipidemic ApoE-/- mice exposed to diesel exhaust particles. , 2007, Toxicology.

[47]  Sung-Man Kim,et al.  Genotoxicity and ecotoxicity assays using the freshwater crustacean Daphnia magna and the larva of the aquatic midge Chironomus riparius to screen the ecological risks of nanoparticle exposure. , 2009, Environmental toxicology and pharmacology.

[48]  P. M. Williams,et al.  Confounding experimental considerations in nanogenotoxicology. , 2009, Mutagenesis.

[49]  Jennifer A. Higgins,et al.  DNA damage of macrophages at an air-tissue interface induced by metal nanoparticles , 2009 .

[50]  H. Norppa,et al.  Chromosomal aberrations in lymphocytes predict human cancer: a report from the European Study Group on Cytogenetic Biomarkers and Health (ESCH). , 1998, Cancer research.

[51]  Nicklas Raun Jacobsen,et al.  Increased mutant frequency by carbon black, but not quartz, in the lacZ and cII transgenes of muta™mouse lung epithelial cells , 2007, Environmental and molecular mutagenesis.

[52]  H. Karlsson,et al.  Comparison of genotoxic and inflammatory effects of particles generated by wood combustion, a road simulator and collected from street and subway. , 2006, Toxicology letters.

[53]  Stefan Bräse,et al.  Cellular uptake of platinum nanoparticles in human colon carcinoma cells and their impact on cellular redox systems and DNA integrity. , 2009, Chemical research in toxicology.

[54]  Hui Li,et al.  Nanoparticle-driven DNA damage mimics irradiation-related carcinogenesis pathways , 2008, European Respiratory Journal.

[55]  Iseult Lynch,et al.  Reproducible comet assay of amorphous silica nanoparticles detects no genotoxicity. , 2008, Nano letters.

[56]  L. J. Terry,et al.  Crossing the Nuclear Envelope: Hierarchical Regulation of Nucleocytoplasmic Transport , 2007, Science.

[57]  Nicklas Raun Jacobsen,et al.  Lung inflammation and genotoxicity following pulmonary exposure to nanoparticles in ApoE-/- mice , 2009, Particle and Fibre Toxicology.

[58]  Laetitia Gonzalez,et al.  Genotoxicity of engineered nanomaterials: A critical review , 2008 .

[59]  Steffen Loft,et al.  Personal Exposure to Ultrafine Particles and Oxidative DNA Damage , 2005, Environmental health perspectives.

[60]  A. Rapp,et al.  A direct view by immunofluorescent comet assay (IFCA) of DNA damage induced by nicking and cutting enzymes, ionizing (137)Cs radiation, UV-A laser microbeam irradiation and the radiomimetic drug bleomycin. , 2008, Mutagenesis.

[61]  A. A. Yasseen,et al.  Nanoceria have no genotoxic effect on human lens epithelial cells , 2010, Nanotechnology.

[62]  Helinor Johnston,et al.  Development of in vitro systems for nanotoxicology: methodological considerations , 2009, Critical reviews in toxicology.

[63]  V. Castranova,et al.  Oxidative and molecular interactions of multi-wall carbon nanotubes (MWCNT) in normal and malignant human mesothelial cells , 2008 .

[64]  Peter Møller,et al.  The alkaline comet assay: towards validation in biomonitoring of DNA damaging exposures. , 2006, Basic & clinical pharmacology & toxicology.

[65]  H. Karlsson,et al.  Size-dependent toxicity of metal oxide particles--a comparison between nano- and micrometer size. , 2009, Toxicology letters.

[66]  Stephen Mann,et al.  Nanoparticles can cause DNA damage across a cellular barrier. , 2009, Nature nanotechnology.

[67]  Ritesh K Shukla,et al.  DNA damaging potential of zinc oxide nanoparticles in human epidermal cells. , 2009, Toxicology letters.

[68]  B. Sanderson,et al.  Cyto- and genotoxicity of ultrafine TiO2 particles in cultured human lymphoblastoid cells. , 2007, Mutation research.

[69]  L. Verschaeve,et al.  Genotoxic effects of carbon black particles, diesel exhaust particles, and urban air particulates and their extracts on a human alveolar epithelial cell line (A549) and a human monocytic cell line (THP‐1) , 2001, Environmental and molecular mutagenesis.

[70]  M. Hande,et al.  Cytotoxicity and genotoxicity of silver nanoparticles in human cells. , 2009, ACS nano.

[71]  A. Collins,et al.  Inter-individual differences in repair of DNA base oxidation, measured in vitro with the comet assay. , 2001, Mutagenesis.

[72]  H. Karlsson,et al.  Genotoxicity of airborne particulate matter: the role of cell-particle interaction and of substances with adduct-forming and oxidizing capacity. , 2004, Mutation research.

[73]  Markus Schulz,et al.  Genotoxicity investigations on nanomaterials: methods, preparation and characterization of test material, potential artifacts and limitations--many questions, some answers. , 2009, Mutation research.

[74]  Masato Yasuhara,et al.  Physicochemical Properties and Cellular Toxicity of Nanocrystal Quantum Dots Depend on Their Surface Modification , 2004 .

[75]  Robert N Grass,et al.  Exposure of engineered nanoparticles to human lung epithelial cells: influence of chemical composition and catalytic activity on oxidative stress. , 2007, Environmental science & technology.

[76]  Steffen Loft,et al.  Air pollution, oxidative damage to DNA, and carcinogenesis. , 2008, Cancer letters.

[77]  Peter Wåhlin,et al.  Exposure to Ultrafine Particles from Ambient Air and Oxidative Stress–Induced DNA Damage , 2007, Environmental health perspectives.

[78]  Paramjit Grover,et al.  In vivo genotoxicity assessment of aluminium oxide nanomaterials in rat peripheral blood cells using the comet assay and micronucleus test. , 2009, Mutagenesis.

[79]  A. Salinaro,et al.  Chemical oxidation and DNA damage catalysed by inorganic sunscreen ingredients , 1997, FEBS letters.

[80]  Romeo Bernini,et al.  Cytotoxicity Investigation on Cultured Human Blood Cells Treated with Single-Wall Carbon Nanotubes , 2008, Sensors.

[81]  Peter Møller,et al.  Assessment of reference values for DNA damage detected by the comet assay in human blood cell DNA. , 2006, Mutation research.

[82]  K J Johanson,et al.  Microelectrophoretic study of radiation-induced DNA damages in individual mammalian cells. , 1984, Biochemical and biophysical research communications.

[83]  Minnamari Vippola,et al.  Genotoxicity of nanomaterials: DNA damage and micronuclei induced by carbon nanotubes and graphite nanofibres in human bronchial epithelial cells in vitro. , 2009, Toxicology letters.

[84]  Hossein Mozdarani,et al.  Study of apoptosis in labeled mesenchymal stem cells with superparamagnetic iron oxide using neutral comet assay. , 2007, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[85]  P. Schwarze,et al.  Oxidative damage to DNA and repair induced by Norwegian wood smoke particles in human A549 and THP-1 cell lines. , 2009, Mutation research.

[86]  Roel P F Schins,et al.  MECHANISMS OF GENOTOXICITY OF PARTICLES AND FIBERS , 2002, Inhalation toxicology.

[87]  Julia Xiaojun Zhao,et al.  Toxicity of luminescent silica nanoparticles to living cells. , 2007, Chemical research in toxicology.

[88]  Kirsten Gerloff,et al.  Cytotoxicity and oxidative DNA damage by nanoparticles in human intestinal Caco-2 cells , 2009 .

[89]  Lennart Möller,et al.  Subway particles are more genotoxic than street particles and induce oxidative stress in cultured human lung cells. , 2005, Chemical research in toxicology.

[90]  T. Xia,et al.  Toxic Potential of Materials at the Nanolevel , 2006, Science.

[91]  A. Collins,et al.  The comet assay in human biomonitoring: gene-environment interactions. , 2008, Mutagenesis.