A quantitative evaluation of a qualitative risk assessment framework: Examining the assumptions and predictions of the Productivity Susceptibility Analysis (PSA)

Qualitative risk assessment frameworks, such as the Productivity Susceptibility Analysis (PSA), have been developed to rapidly evaluate the risks of fishing to marine populations and prioritize management and research among species. Despite being applied to over 1,000 fish populations, and an ongoing debate about the most appropriate method to convert biological and fishery characteristics into an overall measure of risk, the assumptions and predictive capacity of these approaches have not been evaluated. Several interpretations of the PSA were mapped to a conventional age-structured fisheries dynamics model to evaluate the performance of the approach under a range of assumptions regarding exploitation rates and measures of biological risk. The results demonstrate that the underlying assumptions of these qualitative risk-based approaches are inappropriate, and the expected performance is poor for a wide range of conditions. The information required to score a fishery using a PSA-type approach is comparable to that required to populate an operating model and evaluating the population dynamics within a simulation framework. In addition to providing a more credible characterization of complex system dynamics, the operating model approach is transparent, reproducible and can evaluate alternative management strategies over a range of plausible hypotheses for the system.

[1]  R. Tallman,et al.  Small-scale Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus fisheries in Canada's Nunavut: management challenges and options. , 2011, Journal of fish biology.

[2]  J. Koslow.  Fecundity and the Stock–Recruitment Relationship , 1992 .

[3]  R. Phillips,et al.  An assessment of seabird–fishery interactions in the Atlantic Ocean , 2011 .

[4]  D. Heales,et al.  Sustainability of elasmobranchs caught as bycatch in a tropical prawn (shrimp) trawl fishery , 2002 .

[5]  L. Kell,et al.  Vulnerability of teleosts caught by the pelagic tuna longline fleets in South Atlantic and Western Indian Oceans , 2017 .

[6]  Jm Hoenig,et al.  Empirical use of longevity data to estimate mortality rates , 1983 .

[7]  Ulrike Groemping,et al.  Relative Importance for Linear Regression in R: The Package relaimpo , 2006 .

[8]  Alan Hastings,et al.  Ecosystem models for fisheries management: finding the sweet spot , 2016 .

[9]  C. Duarte,et al.  To produce many small or few large eggs: a size-independent reproductive tactic of fish , 1989, Oecologia.

[10]  Kelly L. Ames,et al.  An Approach to Defining Stock Complexes for U.S. West Coast Groundfishes Using Vulnerabilities and Ecological Distributions , 2011 .

[11]  Terence I. Walker,et al.  Hierarchical approach to the assessment of fishing effects on non-target chondrichthyans: case study of Squalus megalops in southeastern Australia , 2006 .

[12]  D. Kirby.  ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR SPECIES CAUGHT IN WCPO TUNA FISHERIES: INHERENT RISK AS DETERMINED BY PRODUCTIVITY-SUSCEPTIBILITY ANALYSIS , 2006 .

[13]  P. Spencer,et al.  Using productivity and susceptibility indices to assess the vulnerability of United States fish stocks to overfishing , 2010 .

[14]  A. L. Jensen.  Beverton and Holt life history invariants result from optimal trade-off of reproduction and survival , 1996 .

[15]  Adrian R. Hordyk,et al.  Revisiting the concept of Beverton -Holt life-history invariants with the aim of informing data-poor fisheries assessment , 2015 .

[16]  Anthony D. M. Smith,et al.  Quantitative ecological risk assessment for fishing effects on diverse data-poor non-target species in a multi-sector and multi-gear fishery , 2011 .

[17]  Alistair J. Hobday,et al.  Ecological risk assessment for the effects of fishing , 2011 .

[18]  P. Spencer,et al.  An assessment of vulnerability in Alaska groundfish , 2011 .

[19]  A. Orio,et al.  Assessing the vulnerability of Mediterranean demersal stocks and predicting exploitation status of un-assessed stocks , 2015 .

[20]  Ray Hilborn,et al.  Inferring Bayesian Priors with Limited Direct Data: Applications to Risk Analysis , 2002 .

[21]  R. Hilborn,et al.  Status and Solutions for the World’s Unassessed Fisheries , 2012, Science.

[22]  R. Fujita,et al.  Assessing and managing data‐limited ornamental fisheries in coral reefs , 2014 .

[23]  D. Milton.  Assessing the susceptibility to fishing of populations of rare trawl bycatch : sea snakes caught by Australia's Northern Prawn Fishery , 2001 .

[24]  Y. Sadovy,et al.  The threat of fishing to highly fecund fishes , 2001 .

[25]  Laurence Smith,et al.  The role of expert opinion in environmental modelling , 2012, Environ. Model. Softw..

[26]  L. Kell,et al.  Productivity and susceptibility analysis for species caught in Atlantic tuna fisheries , 2011 .

[27]  S. Jiménez,et al.  Risk assessment and relative impact of Uruguayan pelagic longliners on seabirds , 2012 .

[28]  Nicholas K Dulvy,et al.  Biology of extinction risk in marine fishes , 2005, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[29]  S. Jennings,et al.  Weak cross‐species relationships between body size and trophic level belie powerful size‐based trophic structuring in fish communities , 2001 .

[30]  J. Ellis,et al.  Having confidence in productivity susceptibility analyses: A method for underpinning scientific advice on skate stocks? , 2015 .

[31]  R Core Team,et al.  R: A language and environment for statistical computing. , 2014 .

[32]  N. Dulvy,et al.  Life-history correlates of the evolution of live bearing in fishes. , 2002, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[33]  Thomas R. Carruthers,et al.  The Data‐Limited Methods Toolkit (DLMtool): An R package for informing management of data‐limited populations , 2018, Methods in Ecology and Evolution.

[34]  D. Reid,et al.  A risk-based approach to rapidly screen vulnerability of cetaceans to impacts from fisheries bycatch , 2013 .

[35]  Max Kuhn,et al.  caret: Classification and Regression Training , 2015 .

[36]  P. Spencer,et al.  Use of Productivity and Susceptibility Indices to Determine Stock Vulnerability, with Example Applications to Six U.S. Fisheries , 2009 .

[37]  Terrance J. Quinn,et al.  Quantitative Fish Dynamics , 1999 .

[38]  E. Gilman,et al.  Ecological risk assessment of the Marshall Islands longline tuna fishery , 2014 .

[39]  Keith Sainsbury,et al.  A flexible and practical framework for reporting on ecologically sustainable development for wild capture fisheries , 2005 .

[40]  N. Dulvy,et al.  Recruitment variation related to fecundity in marine fishes , 2000 .

[41]  K. Winemiller.  Patterns of variation in life history among South American fishes in seasonal environments , 1989, Oecologia.

[42]  S. Jennings,et al.  Life–history correlates of maximum population growth rates in marine fishes , 2002, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[43]  B. Kaunda-Arara,et al.  Catch composition and sustainability of the marine aquarium fishery in Kenya , 2016 .

[44]  M. Heupel,et al.  AN INTEGRATED APPROACH TO DETERMINING THE RISK OF OVER- EXPLOITATION FOR DATA-POOR PELAGIC ATLANTIC SHARKS , 2008 .

[45]  K. Astles,et al.  An ecological method for qualitative risk assessment and its use in the management of fisheries in New South Wales, Australia , 2006 .

[46]  R. Myers,et al.  Influence of fecundity on recruitment variability of marine fish , 1996 .

[47]  Murdoch K. McAllister,et al.  Using demographic methods to construct Bayesian priors for the intrinsic rate of increase in the Schaefer model and implications for stock rebuilding , 2001 .

[48]  Shijie Zhou,et al.  Sustainability Assessment for Fishing Effects (SAFE): A new quantitative ecological risk assessment method and its application to elasmobranch bycatch in an Australian trawl fishery , 2008 .

[49]  F. Micheli,et al.  A risk-based framework for assessing the cumulative impact of multiple fisheries , 2014 .

[50]  J. Hutchings,et al.  Trophic level scales positively with body size in fishes , 2011 .

[51]  Shijie Zhou,et al.  Ecological risk assessments for the effects of fishing: A comparison and validation of PSA and SAFE , 2016 .

[52]  S. Waugh,et al.  Ecological Risk Assessment for seabird interactions in Western and Central Pacific longline fisheries , 2012 .

[53]  E. Charnov,et al.  Evolutionary assembly rules for fish life histories , 2013 .

[54]  E. K. Pikitch,et al.  Ecosystem-Based Fishery Management , 2004, Science.

[55]  W. J. Fletcher.  The application of qualitative risk assessment methodology to prioritize issues for fisheries management , 2005 .

[56]  Andrew Macintosh,et al.  Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act , 2006 .

[57]  Murdoch K. McAllister,et al.  Formulating quantitative methods to evaluate fishery-management systems: what fishery processes should be modelled and what trade-offs should be made? , 1999 .

[58]  Dror G. Feitelson,et al.  From Repeatability to Reproducibility and Corroboration , 2015, OPSR.

[59]  Alistair J. Hobday,et al.  Ecological Risk Assessment for the Effects of Fishing: Methodology. Report R04/1072 for the Australian Fisheries Management Authority , 2007 .

[60]  M. E. Araújo,et al.  A rapid new method for assessing sustainability of ornamental fish by-catch from coral reefs , 2008 .

[61]  F. Carvalho,et al.  Ecological risk assessment of pelagic sharks caught in Atlantic pelagic longline fisheries , 2010 .

[62]  R. Beverton.  Patterns of reproductive strategy parameters in some marine teleost fishes , 1992 .

[63]  L. Watling,et al.  Evaluation of potential sustainability of deep-sea fisheries for grenadiers (Macrouridae) , 2012, Journal of Ichthyology.

[64]  S. Griffiths,et al.  RESOLVING POTENTIAL REDUNDANCY OF PRODUCTIVITY ATTRIBUTES TO IMPROVE ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENTS , 2017 .

[65]  D. Brewer,et al.  Sustainability of fishery bycatch: a process for assessing highly diverse and numerous bycatch , 2001, Environmental Conservation.