Does Soil Carbon Loss in Biomass Production Systems Negate the Greenhouse Benefits of Bioenergy?

Interest in bioenergy is growing across the Western world in response to mounting concerns about climate change. There is a risk of depletion of soil carbon stocks in biomass production systems, because a higher proportion of the organic matter and nutrients are removed from the site, compared with conventional agricultural and forestry systems. This paper reviews the factors that influence soil carbon dynamics in bioenergy systems, and utilises the model FullCAM to investigate the likely magnitude of soil carbon change where bioenergy systems replace conventional land uses. Environmental and management factors govern the magnitude and direction of change. Soil C losses are most likely where soil C is initially high, such as where improved pasture is converted to biomass production. Bioenergy systems are likely to enhance soil C where these replace conventional cropping, as intensively cropped soils are generally depleted in soil C. Measures that enhance soil C include maintenance of productivity through application of fertilisers, inclusion of legumes, and retention of nutrient-rich foliage on-site.Modelling results demonstrate that loss of soil carbon in bioenergy systems is associated with declines in the resistant plant matter and humified soil C pools. However, published experimental data and modelling results indicate that total soil C loss in bioenergy systems is generally small. Thus, although there may be some decline in soil carbon associated with biomass production, this is negligible in comparison with the contribution of bioenergy systems towards greenhouse mitigation through avoided fossil fuel emissions.

[1]  L. Janik,et al.  Can mid infrared diffuse reflectance analysis replace soil extractions , 1998 .

[2]  N. Uphoff,et al.  Soil health: research, practice and policy for a more regenerative agriculture , 2000 .

[3]  Rattan Lal,et al.  Residue management, conservation tillage and soil restoration for mitigating greenhouse effect by CO2-enrichment , 1997 .

[4]  J. Tisdall,et al.  Organic matter and water‐stable aggregates in soils , 1982 .

[5]  P. E. Rasmussen,et al.  Long‐Term Effects of Residue Management in Wheat‐Fallow: I. Inputs, Yield, and Soil Organic Matter , 1994 .

[6]  A. Lugo,et al.  Management of tropical soils as sinks or sources of atmospheric carbon , 1993, Plant and Soil.

[7]  G. Blair,et al.  Soil Carbon Fractions Based on their Degree of Oxidation, and the Development of a Carbon Management Index for Agricultural Systems , 1995 .

[8]  David S. Powlson,et al.  Preliminary estimates of the potential for carbon mitigation in European soils through no‐till farming , 1998 .

[9]  G. Nabuurs,et al.  LUCF sector good practice guidance , 2003 .

[10]  Yossi Inbar,et al.  Humic substances formed during the composting of organic matter , 1990 .

[11]  R. Waring,et al.  A generalised model of forest productivity using simplified concepts of radiation-use efficiency, carbon balance and partitioning , 1997 .

[12]  Gu Lb,et al.  Soil carbon stocks and land use change : a meta analysis , 2022 .

[13]  P. Brennan,et al.  Deep may not be meaningful: Cost and effectiveness of various ripping tine configurations in a plantation cultivation trial in eastern Australia , 2001, New Forests.

[14]  J. Kelly,et al.  Carbon forms and functions in forest soils. , 1995 .

[15]  Dale W. Johnson,et al.  Rhizosphere Effects on Decomposition : Controls of Plant Species , Phenology , and Fertilization , 2003 .

[16]  J. Skjemstad,et al.  Calibration of the Rothamsted organic carbon turnover model (RothC ver. 26.3), using measurable soil organic carbon pools , 2004 .

[17]  Dale W. Johnson.  Effects of forest management on soil carbon storage , 1992 .

[18]  N. Scott,et al.  Soil carbon storage in plantation forests and pastures: land-use change implications , 1999 .

[19]  P. Falloon,et al.  Modelling changes in soil organic matter after planting fast‐growing Pinus radiata on Mediterranean agricultural soils , 2000 .

[20]  G. Richards,et al.  The FullCAM Carbon Accounting Model : Development , Calibration and Implementation , 2001 .

[21]  D. F. Grigal,et al.  Soil carbon changes associated with short-rotation systems , 1998 .

[22]  David C. Ditsch,et al.  A review of soil erosion potential associated with biomass crops , 1998 .

[23]  T. Grove,et al.  Influence of nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizers on amount and nutrient content of litterfall in a regrowth eucalypt forest , 1993, New Forests.

[24]  P. Smith.  Monitoring and verification of soil carbon changes under Article 3.4 of the Kyoto Protocol , 2004 .

[25]  J. Knoepp,et al.  Effects of forest management on soil carbon: results of some long-term resampling studies. , 2002, Environmental pollution.

[26]  S. Ledgard.  Transfer of fixed nitrogen from white clover to associated grasses in swards grazed by dairy cows, estimated using 15N methods , 1991, Plant and Soil.

[27]  P. Attiwill,et al.  Forest Soils and Nutrient Cycles , 1987 .

[28]  N. H. Ravindranath,et al.  Land Use, Land-Use Change, and Forestry: A Special Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change , 2000 .

[29]  E. Steen,et al.  Effects of deep ploughing and superficial disc harrowing on physical and chemical soil properties and biomass in a new plantation of Eucalyptus globulus , 1989 .

[30]  F. Wagner,et al.  Good Practice Guidance for Land Use, Land-Use Change and Forestry , 2003 .

[31]  W. M. Post,et al.  Soil carbon sequestration and land‐use change: processes and potential , 2000 .

[32]  N. Scott,et al.  Monitoring land-use change effects on soil carbon in New Zealand: quantifying baseline soil carbon stocks. , 2002, Environmental pollution.

[33]  W. Parton,et al.  Soil pH and organic C dynamics in tropical forest soils : evidence from laboratory and simulation studies , 1995 .

[34]  V. R. Tolbert,et al.  Changes in soil quality and below-ground carbon storage with conversion of traditional agricultural crop lands to bioenergy crop production. , 2002, Environmental pollution.

[35]  J. H. Smith,et al.  Opportunities for short rotation culture and complete utilization of seven northwestern tree species , 1973 .

[36]  Keryn I. Paul,et al.  Predicted change in soil carbon following afforestation or reforestation, and analysis of controlling factors by linking a C accounting model (CAMFor) to models of forest growth (3PG), litter decomposition (GENDEC) and soil C turnover (RothC) , 2003 .

[37]  R. Parfitt,et al.  Soil nitrogen mineralisation changes rapidly when pine is planted into herbicide-treated pasture—the first two years of growth , 2003 .

[38]  David S. Powlson,et al.  Meeting Europe's climate change commitments: quantitative estimates of the potential for carbon mitigation by agriculture , 2000 .

[39]  P. Raven,et al.  Child, Adolescent and Family Refugee Mental Health: A Global Perspective , 1996 .

[40]  S. Saggar,et al.  Soil microbial biomass, metabolic quotient, and carbon and nitrogen mineralisation in 25-year-old Pinus radiata agroforestry regimes , 2001 .

[41]  D. Schimel,et al.  Simulated effects of dryland cropping intensification on soil organic matter and greenhouse gas exchanges using the DAYCENT ecosystem model. , 2002, Environmental pollution.

[42]  D. Resck,et al.  Soil organic carbon as affected by afforestation with Eucalyptus and Pinus in the Cerrado region of Brazil , 2002 .

[43]  Jan Bengtsson,et al.  Effects of different forest harvest intensities on the pools of exchangeable cations in coniferous forest soils , 1996 .

[44]  R. Ceulemans,et al.  The carbon cost of fine root turnover in a Scots pine forest , 2002 .

[45]  W. Parton,et al.  Analysis of factors controlling soil organic matter levels in Great Plains grasslands , 1987 .

[46]  L. K. Porter,et al.  Transformations of added and indigenous nitrogen in gnotobiotic soil: A comment on the priming effect , 1987 .

[47]  Leif T. Jensen,et al.  A comparison of the performance of nine soil organic matter models using datasets from seven long-term experiments , 1997 .

[48]  Sam W. Wood,et al.  A Review of Greenhouse Gas Emission Factors for Fertiliser Production. , 2004 .

[49]  Marcia J. Lambert,et al.  NUTRITION AND NUTRITIONAL RELATIONSHIPS OF PINUS RADIATA , 1986 .

[50]  Ross E. McMurtrie,et al.  Does conversion of forest to agricultural land change soil carbon and nitrogen? a review of the literature , 2002 .

[51]  R. K.,et al.  Soil quality indicator properties-in mid-Atlantic soils as influenced by conservation management , 2022 .

[52]  K. Vogt.  Carbon budgets of temperate forest ecosystems. , 1991, Tree physiology.

[53]  J. Turner,et al.  Change in organic carbon in forest plantation soils in eastern Australia. , 2000 .

[54]  D. Binkley,et al.  Rapid changes in soils following eucalyptus afforestation in Hawaii , 1999 .

[55]  Kristian Kristensen,et al.  Carbon sequestration in soil beneath long-term Miscanthus plantations as determined by 13C abundance , 2004 .

[56]  C. W. Wood,et al.  Soil management impacts on soil carbon sequestration by switchgrass , 2000 .

[57]  D. Jenkinson,et al.  Model estimates of CO2 emissions from soil in response to global warming , 1991, Nature.

[58]  G. Zinati,et al.  Utilization of Compost Increases Organic Carbon And Its Humin, Humic and Fulvic Acid Fractions In Calcareous Soil , 2001 .

[59]  D. Barrett,et al.  The Carbon content of soil and vegetation in selected areas: Changes in soil and plant tissue carbon and nitrogen contents after clearing to pasture and conversion to forest , 1999 .

[60]  G. Marland,et al.  A synthesis of carbon sequestration, carbon emissions, and net carbon flux in agriculture: comparing tillage practices in the United States , 2002 .

[61]  P. Curtis,et al.  Effects of Forest Management on Soil C and N Storage: Meta Analysis , 2001 .

[62]  M. Kononova.  Soil Organic Matter , 1963 .

[63]  Keryn I. Paul,et al.  Change in soil carbon following afforestation , 2002 .

[64]  L. Mann,et al.  CHANGES IN SOIL CARBON STORAGE AFTER CULTIVATION , 1986 .

[65]  K. Paustian,et al.  Spatial variability of soil organic carbon in grasslands: implications for detecting change at different scales. , 2002, Environmental pollution.

[66]  D. Jenkinson,et al.  The effects of clearing and cropping on the organic reserves and biomass of tropical forest soils , 1976 .

[67]  Y. Kuzyakov,et al.  Carbon input by plants into the soil. Review. , 2000 .

[68]  C. Brack,et al.  Carbon accounting model for forests in Australia. , 2002, Environmental pollution.

[69]  Dale W. Johnson,et al.  Rhizosphere Effects on Decomposition , 2003 .

[70]  P. Smethurst,et al.  Changes in soil carbon and nitrogen during the establishment of a second crop of Pinus radiata , 1995 .

[71]  P. Schroeder.  Can intensive management increase carbon storage in forests? , 1991 .

[72]  A. Lugo,et al.  Effects of forest clearing and succession on the carbon and nitrogen content of soils in Puerto Rico and US Virgin Islands , 1990, Plant and Soil.

[73]  R. Dalal,et al.  Soil organic matter in rainfed cropping systems of the Australian cereal belt , 2001 .

[74]  J. Bauhus,et al.  Aboveground and belowground interactions in mixed plantations of Eucalyptus globulus and Acacia mearnsii , 2000 .

[75]  A. Whitbread,et al.  A survey of the impact of cropping on soil physical and chemical properties in north-western New South Wales , 1998 .

[76]  L. Vesterdal,et al.  Change in soil organic carbon following afforestation of former arable land , 2002 .

[77]  Charles T. Garten,et al.  Soil carbon inventories under a bioenergy crop (switchgrass): measurement limitations , 1999 .

[78]  Johnson,et al.  Development of a protocol for monitoring status and trends in forest soil carbon at a national level , 2004 .

[79]  J. Oades,et al.  The retention of organic matter in soils , 1988 .

[80]  J. Kelly,et al.  Soil Carbon, Soil Formation, and Ecosystem Development , 1995 .

[81]  D. Jenkinson,et al.  Modelling the turnover of organic matter in long-term experiments at Rothamsted , 1987 .

[82]  F. Bunnell,et al.  Microbial respiration and substrate weight loss—I , 1977 .

[83]  R. Norby,et al.  Nutrient cycling and fertility management in temperate short rotation forest systems , 1998 .

[84]  M. Henn,et al.  Ectomycorrhizal fungi introduced with exotic pine plantations induce soil carbon depletion , 2001 .

[85]  S. R. Wilkinson,et al.  Soil organic C and N pools under long-term pasture management in the Southern Piedmont USA , 2000 .

[86]  D. Martens.  Plant residue biochemistry regulates soil carbon cycling and carbon sequestration. , 2000 .

[87]  S. Saggar,et al.  Tillage-induced changes to soil structure and organic carbon fractions in New Zealand soils , 2001 .

[88]  Pete Smith,et al.  Soil organic matter , 2013 .

[89]  T. Grove,et al.  Residue management effects on soil carbon and nutrient contents and growth of second rotation eucalypts , 2003 .

[90]  C. W. Wood,et al.  Carbon dynamics subsequent to establishment of switchgrass , 2000 .

[91]  G. Marland,et al.  The role of forest and bioenergy strategies in the global carbon cycle , 1996 .

[92]  Martin Körschens,et al.  Simulating trends in soil organic carbon in long-term experiments using RothC-26.3 , 1997 .

[93]  P. Poulton.  The importance of long-term trials in understanding sustainable farming systems: the Rothamsted experience , 1995 .

[94]  P. Beets,et al.  Response of radiata pine forests to residue management and fertilisation across a fertility gradient in New Zealand , 2000 .

[95]  Pascal Boeckx,et al.  Estimates of N2O and CH4 fluxes from agricultural lands in various regions in Europe , 2001, Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems.