Solved problems for Granger causality in neuroscience: A response to Stokes and Purdon

Granger-Geweke causality (GGC) is a powerful and popular method for identifying directed functional ('causal') connectivity in neuroscience. In a recent paper, Stokes and Purdon (2017b) raise several concerns about its use. They make two primary claims: (1) that GGC estimates may be severely biased or of high variance, and (2) that GGC fails to reveal the full structural/causal mechanisms of a system. However, these claims rest, respectively, on an incomplete evaluation of the literature, and a misconception about what GGC can be said to measure. Here we explain how existing approaches resolve the first issue, and discuss the frequently-misunderstood distinction between functional and effective neural connectivity which underlies Stokes and Purdon's second claim.

[1]  A. Seth,et al.  Granger causality and transfer entropy are equivalent for Gaussian variables. , 2009, Physical review letters.

[2]  Hualou Liang,et al.  Granger-Geweke causality: Estimation and interpretation , 2018, NeuroImage.

[3]  Adam B. Barrett,et al.  Granger causality is designed to measure effect, not mechanism , 2013, Front. Neuroinform..

[4]  M. Boly,et al.  Granger Causality Analysis of Steady-State Electroencephalographic Signals during Propofol-Induced Anaesthesia , 2012, PloS one.

[5]  C. Granger.  Time Series Analysis, Cointegration, and Applications , 2003 .

[6]  Leiba Rodman,et al.  Algebraic Riccati equations , 1995 .

[7]  J. Geweke,et al.  Measurement of Linear Dependence and Feedback between Multiple Time Series , 1982 .

[8]  A. Seth,et al.  Granger causality for state-space models. , 2015, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[9]  P. Whittle.  On the fitting of multivariate autoregressions, and the approximate canonical factorization of a spectral density matrix , 1963 .

[10]  A. Seth,et al.  Multivariate Granger causality and generalized variance. , 2010, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[11]  S. Bressler,et al.  Frequency decomposition of conditional Granger causality and application to multivariate neural field potential data , 2006, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[12]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Ten simple rules for dynamic causal modeling , 2010, NeuroImage.

[13]  Anil K. Seth,et al.  The MVGC multivariate Granger causality toolbox: A new approach to Granger-causal inference , 2014, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[14]  A. Seth,et al.  Granger Causality Analysis in Neuroscience and Neuroimaging , 2015, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[15]  Mingzhou Ding,et al.  Analyzing information flow in brain networks with nonparametric Granger causality , 2008, NeuroImage.

[16]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Effective connectivity: Influence, causality and biophysical modeling , 2011, NeuroImage.

[17]  C. Granger.  Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods , 1969 .

[18]  W. Hesse,et al.  The use of time-variant EEG Granger causality for inspecting directed interdependencies of neural assemblies , 2003, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[19]  Anil K. Seth,et al.  Detectability of Granger causality for subsampled continuous-time neurophysiological processes , 2016, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[20]  S. Bressler,et al.  Granger Causality: Basic Theory and Application to Neuroscience , 2006, q-bio/0608035.

[21]  Schreiber,et al.  Measuring information transfer , 2000, Physical review letters.

[22]  C. Granger.  Some properties of time series data and their use in econometric model specification , 1981 .

[23]  A. Seth,et al.  Solved problems and remaining challenges for Granger causality analysis in neuroscience: A response to Stokes and Purdon (2017) , 2017, 1708.08001.

[24]  Rainer Goebel,et al.  Mapping directed influence over the brain using Granger causality and fMRI , 2005, NeuroImage.

[25]  Patrick L Purdon,et al.  A study of problems encountered in Granger causality analysis from a neuroscience perspective , 2017, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[26]  Mingzhou Ding,et al.  Estimating Granger causality from fourier and wavelet transforms of time series data. , 2007, Physical review letters.

[27]  Bruce L. McNaughton,et al.  Laminar organization of encoding and memory reactivation in the parietal cortex , 2017 .

[28]  Steven L. Bressler,et al.  Wiener–Granger Causality: A well established methodology , 2011, NeuroImage.

[29]  Rebecca Saxe,et al.  Empathic control through coordinated interaction of amygdala, theory of mind and extended pain matrix brain regions , 2015, NeuroImage.

[30]  Katarzyna J. Blinowska,et al.  A new method of the description of the information flow in the brain structures , 1991, Biological Cybernetics.

[31]  G. Wilson.  The Factorization of Matricial Spectral Densities , 1972 .

[32]  Luca Faes,et al.  On the interpretability and computational reliability of frequency-domain Granger causality , 2017, F1000Research.

[33]  E. Hannan,et al.  The statistical theory of linear systems , 1989 .

[34]  M Palus,et al.  Synchronization as adjustment of information rates: detection from bivariate time series. , 2001, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[35]  Ralf D. Wimmer,et al.  Thalamic amplification of cortical connectivity sustains attentional control , 2017, Nature.

[36]  A. Seth,et al.  Behaviour of Granger causality under filtering: Theoretical invariance and practical application , 2011, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[37]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Analysing connectivity with Granger causality and dynamic causal modelling , 2013, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[38]  B. McNaughton,et al.  Laminar Organization of Encoding and Memory Reactivation in the Parietal Cortex , 2017, Neuron.

[39]  C. W. J. Granger,et al.  Economic Processes Involving Feedback , 1963, Inf. Control..

[40]  P. Stokes,et al.  Fundamental problems in Granger causality analysis of neuroscience data , 2015 .

[41]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modelling , 2003, NeuroImage.

[42]  Victor Solo,et al.  State-Space Analysis of Granger-Geweke Causality Measures with Application to fMRI , 2016, Neural Computation.

[43]  Rafael Malach,et al.  Coupling between pupil fluctuations and resting-state fMRI uncovers a slow build-up of antagonistic responses in the human cortex , 2015, NeuroImage.

[44]  J. Geweke,et al.  Measures of Conditional Linear Dependence and Feedback between Time Series , 1984 .

[45]  T. Bossomaier,et al.  Transfer entropy as a log-likelihood ratio. , 2012, Physical review letters.

[46]  Luiz A. Baccalá,et al.  Partial directed coherence: a new concept in neural structure determination , 2001, Biological Cybernetics.

[47]  Howard Eichenbaum,et al.  Bidirectional prefrontal-hippocampal interactions support context-guided memory , 2016, Nature Neuroscience.

[48]  Anil K. Seth,et al.  Granger causality analysis of fMRI BOLD signals is invariant to hemodynamic convolution but not downsampling , 2013, NeuroImage.