Design of Sustainable Biofuel Processes and Supply Chains: Challenges and Opportunities

The current methodological approach for developing sustainable biofuel processes and supply chains is flawed. Life cycle principles are often retrospectively incorporated in the design phase resulting in incremental environmental improvement rather than selection of fuel pathways that minimize environmental impacts across the life cycle. Further, designing sustainable biofuel supply chains requires joint consideration of economic, environmental, and social factors that span multiple spatial and temporal scales. However, traditional life cycle assessment (LCA) ignores economic aspects and the role of ecological goods and services in supply chains, and hence is limited in its ability for guiding decision-making among alternatives—often resulting in sub-optimal solutions. Simultaneously incorporating economic and environment objectives in the design and optimization of emerging biofuel supply chains requires a radical new paradigm. This work discusses key research opportunities and challenges in the design of emerging biofuel supply chains and provides a high-level overview of the current “state of the art” in environmental sustainability assessment of biofuel production. Additionally, a bibliometric analysis of over 20,000 biofuel research articles from 2000-to-present is performed to identify active topical areas of research in the biofuel literature, quantify the relative strength of connections between various biofuels research domains, and determine any potential research gaps.

[1]  Robert Ries,et al.  Characterizing, Propagating, and Analyzing Uncertainty in Life‐Cycle Assessment: A Survey of Quantitative Approaches , 2007 .

[2]  Q. Hu,et al.  Life-cycle analysis on biodiesel production from microalgae: water footprint and nutrients balance. , 2011, Bioresource technology.

[3]  James A. Dumesic,et al.  An overview of aqueous-phase catalytic processes for production of hydrogen and alkanes in a biorefinery , 2006 .

[4]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  What is the Minimum EROI that a Sustainable Society Must Have , 2009 .

[5]  John R. Benemann,et al.  Microalgal Biomass for Greenhouse Gas Reductions: Potential for Replacement of Fossil Fuels and Animal Feeds , 2009 .

[6]  James A. Dumesic,et al.  Production of renewable petroleum refinery diesel and jet fuel feedstocks from hemicellulose sugar streams , 2013 .

[7]  Navneet R. Singh,et al.  Synergistic routes to liquid fuel for a petroleum‐deprived future , 2009 .

[8]  Gonzalo Guillén-Gosálbez,et al.  Multiobjective Model for More Sustainable Fuel Supply Chains. A Case Study of the Sugar Cane Industry in Argentina , 2011 .

[9]  Michael D. Lepech,et al.  Techno-ecological synergy: a framework for sustainable engineering. , 2015, Environmental science & technology.

[10]  B. Bakshi,et al.  Thermodynamic metrics for aggregation of natural resources in life cycle analysis: insight via application to some transportation fuels. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[11]  David D. Hsu,et al.  Techno-economic comparison of biomass-to-transportation fuels via pyrolysis, gasification, and biochemical pathways , 2010 .

[12]  Dirk Cattrysse,et al.  Methods to optimise the design and management of biomass-for-bioenergy supply chains: A review , 2014 .

[13]  R. O'Neill,et al.  The value of ecosystem services: putting the issues in perspective , 1998 .

[14]  Dong Gu Choi,et al.  Life cycle energy and greenhouse gas emissions for an ethanol production process based on blue-green algae. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[15]  James A. Dumesic,et al.  Production of 5-hydroxymethylfurfural and furfural by dehydration of biomass-derived mono- and poly-saccharides , 2007 .

[16]  P. Pingali,et al.  Millenium Ecosystem Assessment: Ecosystems and human well-being , 2005 .

[17]  Hong Huo,et al.  Methods of dealing with co-products of biofuels in life-cycle analysis and consequent results within the U.S. context , 2011 .

[18]  A. Horvath,et al.  Grand challenges for life-cycle assessment of biofuels. , 2011, Environmental science & technology.

[19]  Philip Owende,et al.  Biofuels from microalgae—A review of technologies for production, processing, and extractions of biofuels and co-products , 2010 .

[20]  T Amon,et al.  Bioenergy from permanent grassland--a review: 1. Biogas. , 2009, Bioresource technology.

[21]  B. Bakshi,et al.  Promise and problems of emergy analysis , 2004 .

[22]  D. Laird,et al.  Impact of biochar amendments on the quality of a typical Midwestern agricultural soil , 2010 .

[23]  Volker H. Hoffmann,et al.  Multiobjective Screening and Evaluation of Chemical Process Technologies , 2001 .

[24]  Carole L. Crumley,et al.  The Anthropocene: From Global Change to Planetary Stewardship , 2011, AMBIO.

[25]  Andres F. Clarens,et al.  Algae biodiesel has potential despite inconclusive results to date. , 2012, Bioresource technology.

[26]  Douglas C. Elliott,et al.  Catalytic hydroprocessing of biomass fast pyrolysis bio‐oil to produce hydrocarbon products , 2009 .

[27]  How to model different socio-economic and environmental aspects of biomass utilisation: Case study in selected regions in Slovenia and Croatia , 2007 .

[28]  B. Mathiesen,et al.  Energy system analysis of marginal electricity supply in consequential LCA , 2010 .

[29]  José Carlos Romero,et al.  Exergy as a global energy sustainability indicator. A review of the state of the art , 2014 .

[30]  George G. Zaimes,et al.  Microalgal biomass production pathways: evaluation of life cycle environmental impacts , 2013, Biotechnology for Biofuels.

[31]  Bhavik R. Bakshi,et al.  A thermodynamic framework for ecologically conscious process systems engineering , 2000 .

[32]  Prasant Kumar Rout,et al.  Production of first and second generation biofuels: A comprehensive review , 2010 .

[33]  Armen Ricardo Kemanian,et al.  Modeling the impacts of soil management practices on runoff, sediment yield, maize productivity, and soil organic carbon using APEX , 2008 .

[34]  Jagadeesh Mosali,et al.  Switchgrass for forage and bioenergy: harvest and nitrogen rate effects on biomass yields and nutrient composition , 2011, Plant and Soil.

[35]  Yigal Elad,et al.  Biochar impact on development and productivity of pepper and tomato grown in fertigated soilless media , 2010, Plant and Soil.

[36]  Russell W Stratton,et al.  Environmental performance of algal biofuel technology options. , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[37]  F. Chapin,et al.  A safe operating space for humanity , 2009, Nature.

[38]  Bruce A. McCarl,et al.  Forest and Agricultural Sector Optimization Model (FASOM): Model structure and policy applications. Forest Service research paper , 1996 .

[39]  S. Carpenter,et al.  Multiscale regime shifts and planetary boundaries. , 2013, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[40]  Tomas Ekvall,et al.  System boundaries and input data in consequential life cycle inventory analysis , 2004 .

[41]  M. Huijbregts Uncertainty and variability in environmental life-cycle assessment , 2002 .

[42]  J. Satrio,et al.  Characterization of biochar from fast pyrolysis and gasification systems , 2009 .

[43]  A. Corma,et al.  Synthesis of transportation fuels from biomass: chemistry, catalysts, and engineering. , 2006, Chemical reviews.

[44]  Enrico Sciubba,et al.  On the Second-Law inconsistency of Emergy Analysis , 2010 .

[45]  Roydon Andrew Fraser,et al.  The Tenuous Use of Exergy as a Measure of Resource Value or Waste Impact , 2009 .

[46]  Kristina M. Weyer,et al.  Theoretical Maximum Algal Oil Production , 2009, BioEnergy Research.

[47]  G. Huber,et al.  Liquid-phase catalytic processing of biomass-derived oxygenated hydrocarbons to fuels and chemicals. , 2007, Angewandte Chemie.

[48]  W. Britz CAPRI Modelling System Documentation COMMON AGRICULTURAL POLICY REGIONAL IMPACT ANALYSIS , 2005 .

[49]  Xuesong Zhang,et al.  Bioenergy crop models: descriptions, data requirements, and future challenges , 2012 .

[50]  S. Czernik,et al.  Catalytic pyrolysis of biomass for biofuels production , 2010 .

[51]  P. Shi,et al.  GEPIC-V-R model: A GIS-based tool for regional crop drought risk assessment , 2014 .

[52]  Jiří Jaromír Klemeš,et al.  Total footprints-based multi-criteria optimisation of regional biomass energy supply chains , 2012 .

[53]  B. E. Vaughan,et al.  Ethanol as Fuel: Energy, Carbon Dioxide Balances, and Ecological Footprint , 2005 .

[54]  Vikas Khanna,et al.  The role of allocation and coproducts in environmental evaluation of microalgal biofuels: How important? , 2014 .

[55]  Saran Sohi,et al.  Biochars in soils: new insights and emerging research needs , 2014 .

[56]  F. Miglietta,et al.  Biochar as a strategy to sequester carbon and increase yield in durum wheat , 2011 .

[57]  D. Resasco,et al.  Ketonization of Carboxylic Acids: Mechanisms, Catalysts, and Implications for Biomass Conversion , 2013 .

[58]  L. Deschen̂es,et al.  Evaluating Holistic Environmental Consequences of Brownfield Management Options Using Consequential Life Cycle Assessment for Different Perspectives , 2007, Environmental management.

[59]  Julie Witcover,et al.  Carbon accounting and economic model uncertainty of emissions from biofuels-induced land use change. , 2015, Environmental science & technology.

[60]  J. Melillo,et al.  Indirect Emissions from Biofuels: How Important? , 2009, Science.

[61]  Brent H Shanks,et al.  Understanding the fast pyrolysis of lignin. , 2011, ChemSusChem.

[62]  James A. Dumesic,et al.  An overview of dehydration, aldol-condensation and hydrogenation processes for production of liquid alkanes from biomass-derived carbohydrates , 2007 .

[63]  Joseph Fiksel,et al.  The quest for sustainability: Challenges for process systems engineering , 2003 .

[64]  B. Shanks,et al.  Product distribution from the fast pyrolysis of hemicellulose. , 2011, ChemSusChem.

[65]  Francisco Jurado,et al.  A Method for Particle Swarm Optimization and its Application in Location of Biomass Power Plants , 2008 .

[66]  N. Shah,et al.  Spatially Explicit Static Model for the Strategic Design of Future Bioethanol Production Systems. 1. Cost Minimization , 2009 .

[67]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  EROI of different fuels and the implications for society , 2014 .

[68]  Christine L. Goodale,et al.  Fate of soil‐applied black carbon: downward migration, leaching and soil respiration , 2010 .

[69]  M. Rosegrant International Model for Policy Analysis of Agricultural Commodities and Trade (IMPACT) Model Description , 2012 .

[70]  Bryce J. Stokes,et al.  U.S. Billion-ton Update: Biomass Supply for a Bioenergy and Bioproducts Industry , 2011 .

[71]  Lorenz T. Biegler,et al.  Nonlinear Waves in Integrable and Nonintegrable Systems , 2018 .

[72]  Yi Zhang,et al.  Accounting for ecosystem services in life cycle assessment, Part I: a critical review. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[73]  Bhavik R Bakshi,et al.  Accounting for ecosystem services in Life Cycle Assessment, Part II: toward an ecologically based LCA. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[74]  G. Huber,et al.  Raney Ni-Sn Catalyst for H2 Production from Biomass-Derived Hydrocarbons , 2003, Science.

[75]  Fu Zhao,et al.  Life cycle assessment of potential biojet fuel production in the United States. , 2011, Environmental science & technology.

[76]  William R. Raun,et al.  Switchgrass Response to Harvest Frequency and Time and Rate of Applied Nitrogen , 2005 .

[77]  James H. Clark,et al.  Green chemistry: challenges and opportunities , 1999 .

[78]  D. Resasco,et al.  Kinetics and mechanism of m-cresol hydrodeoxygenation on a Pt/SiO2 catalyst , 2014 .

[79]  Iddrisu Awudu,et al.  Uncertainties and sustainability concepts in biofuel supply chain management: A review , 2012 .

[80]  Anoop Singh,et al.  Production of liquid biofuels from renewable resources , 2011 .

[81]  Gjalt Huppes,et al.  Life cycle assessment: past, present, and future. , 2011, Environmental science & technology.

[82]  J. Amonette,et al.  Sustainable biochar to mitigate global climate change , 2010, Nature communications.

[83]  Magín Lapuerta,et al.  Key properties and blending strategies of hydrotreated vegetable oil as biofuel for diesel engines , 2011 .

[84]  H. Cai,et al.  Well-to-wheels energy use and greenhouse gas emissions of ethanol from corn, sugarcane and cellulosic biomass for US use , 2012 .

[85]  Ignacio E. Grossmann,et al.  Systematic Methods of Chemical Process Design , 1997 .

[86]  Y. Chisti Biodiesel from microalgae. , 2007, Biotechnology advances.

[87]  Shang-Lien Lo,et al.  Quantifying and reducing uncertainty in life cycle assessment using the Bayesian Monte Carlo method. , 2005, The Science of the total environment.

[88]  A. Bridgwater Review of fast pyrolysis of biomass and product upgrading , 2012 .

[89]  L. Schmidt,et al.  Millisecond reforming of solid biomass for sustainable fuels. , 2007, Angewandte Chemie.

[90]  S. Sadjadi,et al.  Optimization methods applied to renewable and sustainable energy: A review , 2017 .

[91]  Gjalt Huppes,et al.  System boundary selection in life-cycle inventories using hybrid approaches. , 2004, Environmental science & technology.

[92]  Charles A. Mullen,et al.  Life Cycle Environmental and Economic Tradeoffs of Using Fast Pyrolysis Products for Power Generation , 2013 .

[93]  T. Amon,et al.  Bioenergy from permanent grassland--a review: 2. Combustion. , 2009, Bioresource technology.

[94]  Anthony Halog,et al.  Environmental sustainability of wood-derived ethanol: a life cycle evaluation of resource intensity and emissions in Maine, USA , 2013 .

[95]  David Pimentel,et al.  Ethanol production: energy, economic, and environmental losses. , 2007, Reviews of environmental contamination and toxicology.

[96]  Bhavik R. Bakshi,et al.  Sustainable process design by the process to planet framework , 2015 .

[97]  Brenda B. Lin,et al.  Biofuels: Network Analysis of the Literature Reveals Key Environmental and Economic Unknowns , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[98]  Leslie G. Fishbone,et al.  Markal, a linear‐programming model for energy systems analysis: Technical description of the bnl version , 1981 .

[99]  Stijn Bruers,et al.  Exergy: its potential and limitations in environmental science and technology. , 2008, Environmental science & technology.

[100]  Bhavik R Bakshi,et al.  Assessing resource intensity and renewability of cellulosic ethanol technologies using eco-LCA. , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[101]  Robert C. Brown,et al.  Catalytic pyrolysis of corn dried distillers grains with solubles to produce hydrocarbons , 2014 .

[102]  Amy E. Landis,et al.  Re-envisioning the renewable fuel standard to minimize unintended consequences: A comparison of microalgal diesel with other biodiesels , 2013 .

[103]  Ayhan Demirbas,et al.  Political, economic and environmental impacts of biofuels: A review , 2009 .

[104]  S. Oyama,et al.  Hydrodeoxygenation of guaiacol as model compound for pyrolysis oil on transition metal phosphide hydroprocessing catalysts , 2011 .

[105]  Dirk Cattrysse,et al.  A generic mathematical model to optimise strategic and tactical decisions in biomass-based supply chains (OPTIMASS) , 2015, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[106]  B. Bakshi,et al.  Thermodynamic accounting of ecosystem contribution to economic sectors with application to 1992 U.S. economy. , 2004, Environmental science & technology.

[107]  Andreas Ciroth,et al.  ICT for environment in life cycle applications openLCA — A new open source software for life cycle assessment , 2007 .

[108]  Michael Taylor,et al.  An overview of second generation biofuel technologies. , 2010, Bioresource technology.

[109]  G. Heath,et al.  Environmental and sustainability factors associated with next-generation biofuels in the U.S.: what do we really know? , 2009, Environmental science & technology.

[110]  D. Resasco,et al.  Implementation of concepts derived from model compound studies in the separation and conversion of bio-oil to fuel , 2015 .

[111]  Rainer Zah,et al.  Global environmental consequences of increased biodiesel consumption in Switzerland: consequential life cycle assessment , 2009 .

[112]  Amy E. Landis,et al.  The role of sustainability and life cycle thinking in U.S. biofuels policies. , 2014 .

[113]  Fengqi You,et al.  Design under uncertainty of hydrocarbon biorefinery supply chains: Multiobjective stochastic programming models, decomposition algorithm, and a Comparison between CVaR and downside risk , 2012 .

[114]  Zhong-yang Luo,et al.  Environmental life cycle assessment of bio-fuel production via fast pyrolysis of corn stover and hydroprocessing , 2014 .

[115]  Igor Linkov,et al.  Illustrating anticipatory life cycle assessment for emerging photovoltaic technologies. , 2014, Environmental science & technology.

[116]  Andrew B. Riche,et al.  Growth, yield and mineral content of Miscanthus × giganteus grown as a biofuel for 14 successive harvests , 2008 .

[117]  R. Costanza,et al.  SPECIAL ISSUE: The Dynamics and Value of Ecosystem Services: Integrating Economic and Ecological Perspectives Economic and ecological concepts for valuing ecosystem services , 2002 .

[118]  J. Koomey,et al.  Is accurate forecasting of economic systems possible? , 2011 .

[119]  Peter D. Blair,et al.  Input-Output Analysis , 2009 .

[120]  S. Polasky,et al.  Land Clearing and the Biofuel Carbon Debt , 2008, Science.

[121]  Mark A. White,et al.  Environmental impacts of algae-derived biodiesel and bioelectricity for transportation. , 2011, Environmental science & technology.

[122]  Timothy S. Ham,et al.  Metabolic engineering of microorganisms for biofuels production: from bugs to synthetic biology to fuels. , 2008, Current opinion in biotechnology.

[123]  A. Veldkamp,et al.  CLUE: a conceptual model to study the Conversion of Land Use and its Effects , 1996 .

[124]  J. M. Earles,et al.  Consequential life cycle assessment: a review , 2011 .

[125]  Jannick H. Schmidt System delimitation in agricultural consequential LCA , 2008 .

[126]  G. Daily,et al.  Ecosystem Services in Decision Making: Time to Deliver , 2009 .

[127]  Anders Hammer Strømman,et al.  Life cycle assessment of bioenergy systems: state of the art and future challenges. , 2011, Bioresource technology.

[128]  Bo Pedersen Weidema,et al.  Marginal production technologies for life cycle inventories , 1999 .

[129]  C. G. Carrington,et al.  Anaerobic digestion of microalgae residues resulting from the biodiesel production process , 2011 .

[130]  Hiroya Seki,et al.  Two levels decision system for efficient planning and implementation of bioenergy production. , 2007 .

[131]  Mary Ann Curran,et al.  Environmental life-cycle assessment , 1996 .

[132]  Ludo Waltman,et al.  Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping , 2009, Scientometrics.

[133]  Sangwon Suh,et al.  Replacing gasoline with corn ethanol results in significant environmental problem-shifting. , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[134]  Olivier Bernard,et al.  Anaerobic digestion of microalgae as a necessary step to make microalgal biodiesel sustainable. , 2009, Biotechnology advances.

[135]  Joseph Alcamo,et al.  IMAGE 2.0 , 1899 .

[136]  Bruce A. McCarl,et al.  The forest and agricultural sector optimization model (FASOM): Model structure and policy applications , 1996 .

[137]  Benedetto Rugani,et al.  Improvements to Emergy evaluations by using Life Cycle Assessment. , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[138]  Amy E. Landis,et al.  Biofuels via Fast Pyrolysis of Perennial Grasses: A Life Cycle Evaluation of Energy Consumption and Greenhouse Gas Emissions. , 2015, Environmental science & technology.

[139]  R. O'Neill,et al.  The value of the world's ecosystem services and natural capital , 1997, Nature.

[140]  Julie B Zimmerman,et al.  Combinatorial life cycle assessment to inform process design of industrial production of algal biodiesel. , 2011, Environmental science & technology.

[141]  Dong Wang,et al.  Integrated Catalytic Conversion of γ-Valerolactone to Liquid Alkenes for Transportation Fuels , 2010, Science.

[142]  A. Horvath,et al.  Lifecycle greenhouse gas implications of US national scenarios for cellulosic ethanol production , 2012 .

[143]  Jeffrey G. Arnold,et al.  The Soil and Water Assessment Tool: Historical Development, Applications, and Future Research Directions , 2007 .

[144]  John R. Williams,et al.  Development and application of the EPIC model for carbon cycle, greenhouse-gas mitigation, and biofuel studies , 2012 .

[145]  Bhavik R. Bakshi,et al.  Methods and tools for sustainable process design , 2014 .

[146]  Benedetto Rugani,et al.  Integrating emergy into LCA: Potential added value and lingering obstacles , 2014 .

[147]  Bhavik R Bakshi,et al.  Multi‐scale modeling for sustainable chemical production , 2013, Biotechnology journal.

[148]  Christos T. Maravelias,et al.  Production of renewable jet fuel range alkanes and commodity chemicals from integrated catalytic processing of biomass , 2014 .

[149]  Fred J. Sissine,et al.  Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007: A Summary of Major Provisions , 2007 .

[150]  C. Hendrickson,et al.  Using input-output analysis to estimate economy-wide discharges , 1995 .

[151]  Vikas Khanna,et al.  Environmental sustainability of emerging algal biofuels: A comparative life cycle evaluation of algal biodiesel and renewable diesel , 2013 .

[152]  Bhavik R Bakshi,et al.  Expanding exergy analysis to account for ecosystem products and services. , 2004, Environmental science & technology.

[153]  T. Sowlati,et al.  Assessment and optimization of forest biomass supply chains from economic, social and environmental perspectives – A review of literature , 2014 .

[154]  Fengqi You,et al.  Design of Sustainable Product Systems and Supply Chains with Life Cycle Optimization Based on Functional Unit: General Modeling Framework, Mixed-Integer Nonlinear Programming Algorithms and Case Study on Hydrocarbon Biofuels , 2013 .

[155]  G. Huber,et al.  Production of Liquid Alkanes by Aqueous-Phase Processing of Biomass-Derived Carbohydrates , 2005, Science.

[156]  Paul H. Calamai,et al.  Bioenergy Systems Planning Using Location–Allocation and Landscape Ecology Design Principles , 2003, Ann. Oper. Res..

[157]  S. Carpenter,et al.  Planetary boundaries: Guiding human development on a changing planet , 2015, Science.

[158]  Barbara S. Ballew Elsevier's Scopus® Database , 2009 .

[159]  Enrico Sciubba,et al.  Emergy and exergy analyses: Complementary methods or irreducible ideological options? , 2005 .

[160]  G. Vicente,et al.  Application of the factorial design of experiments and response surface methodology to optimize biodiesel production , 1998 .

[161]  J. Alcamo IMAGE 2.0 : integrated modeling of global climate change , 1994 .

[162]  D. Tilman,et al.  Carbon-Negative Biofuels from Low-Input High-Diversity Grassland Biomass , 2006, Science.

[163]  Martin Hermy,et al.  Energy potential for combustion and anaerobic digestion of biomass from low‐input high‐diversity systems in conservation areas , 2015 .

[164]  Vikas Khanna,et al.  Assessing the critical role of ecological goods and services in microalgal biofuel life cycles , 2014 .

[165]  D. Darnoko,et al.  Kinetics of palm oil transesterification in a batch reactor , 2000 .

[166]  Ki-Joo Kim,et al.  Systematic procedure for designing processes with multiple environmental objectives. , 2005, Environmental science & technology.

[167]  B. Weidema Market information in life cycle assessment , 2003 .

[168]  Bhavik R. Bakshi,et al.  Process to planet: A multiscale modeling framework toward sustainable engineering , 2015 .

[169]  F. You,et al.  Optimal design of sustainable cellulosic biofuel supply chains: Multiobjective optimization coupled with life cycle assessment and input–output analysis , 2012 .

[170]  H. Sieverding,et al.  Meta-Analysis of Soybean-based Biodiesel. , 2015, Journal of environmental quality.

[171]  Nilay Shah,et al.  Spatially Explicit Static Model for the Strategic Design of Future Bioethanol Production Systems. 2. Multi-Objective Environmental Optimization , 2009 .

[172]  Manuel Delgado-Restituto,et al.  Review of the State of the Art , 2013 .

[173]  Daren E. Daugaard,et al.  Techno-Economic Analysis of Biomass Fast Pyrolysis to Transportation Fuels , 2010 .