Empirical models based on the universal soil loss equation fail to predict sediment discharges from Chesapeake Bay catchments.

The Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE) and its derivatives are widely used for identifying watersheds with a high potential for degrading stream water quality. We compared sediment yields estimated from regional application of the USLE, the automated revised RUSLE2, and five sediment delivery ratio algorithms to measured annual average sediment delivery in 78 catchments of the Chesapeake Bay watershed. We did the same comparisons for another 23 catchments monitored by the USGS. Predictions exceeded observed sediment yields by more than 100% and were highly correlated with USLE erosion predictions (Pearson r range, 0.73-0.92; p < 0.001). RUSLE2-erosion estimates were highly correlated with USLE estimates (r = 0.87; p < 001), so the method of implementing the USLE model did not change the results. In ranked comparisons between observed and predicted sediment yields, the models failed to identify catchments with higher yields (r range, -0.28-0.00; p > 0.14). In a multiple regression analysis, soil erodibility, log (stream flow), basin shape (topographic relief ratio), the square-root transformed proportion of forest, and occurrence in the Appalachian Plateau province explained 55% of the observed variance in measured suspended sediment loads, but the model performed poorly (r(2) = 0.06) at predicting loads in the 23 USGS watersheds not used in fitting the model. The use of USLE or multiple regression models to predict sediment yields is not advisable despite their present widespread application. Integrated watershed models based on the USLE may also be unsuitable for making management decisions.

[1]  S. Goetz,et al.  IKONOS imagery for resource management: Tree cover, impervious surfaces, and riparian buffer analyses in the mid-Atlantic region , 2003 .

[2]  Donald E. Weller,et al.  Relating nutrient discharges from watersheds to land use and streamflow variability , 1997 .

[3]  David C. Garen,et al.  CURVE NUMBER HYDROLOGY IN WATER QUALITY MODELING: USES, ABUSES, AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS 1 , 2005 .

[4]  M. C. Chemelil,et al.  Estimation of Potential Soil Erosion for River Perkerra Catchment in Kenya , 2005 .

[5]  Sam B. Maner.  Factors affecting sediment delivery rates in the red hills physiographic area , 1958 .

[6]  P. L. Lietman,et al.  Synthesis of nutrient and sediment data for watersheds within the Chesapaeake Bay drainage basin , 1995 .

[7]  William S.L. Banks,et al.  Summary of suspended-sediment data for streams draining the Chesapeake Bay Watershed, water years 1952-2002 , 2004 .

[8]  J. Ritchie,et al.  Variations in sediment sources and yields in the Finger Lakes and Catskills regions of New York , 2007 .

[9]  W. Boynton,et al.  Sumberged aquatic vegetation in the mesohaline region of the Patuxent estuary: Past, present, and future status , 2003 .

[10]  Vito Ferro,et al.  Sediment Delivery Distributed (SEDD) Model , 2000 .

[11]  J. Desloges,et al.  SEDIMENT YIELD CONDITIONED BY GLACIATION IN A RURAL AGRICULTURAL BASIN OF SOUTHERN ONTARIO, CANADA , 1994 .

[12]  J. Finn,et al.  Rapid Assessment of Soil Erosion in the Rio Lempa Basin, Central America, Using the Universal Soil Loss Equation and Geographic Information Systems , 2005, Environmental management.

[13]  R. K. Hubbard,et al.  Transport of Solids in Streamflow from Coastal Plain Watersheds 1 , 1987 .

[14]  Douglas A. Haith,et al.  GENERALIZED WATERSHED LOADING FUNCTIONS FOR STREAM FLOW NUTRIENTS , 1987 .

[15]  Zhi-jun Liu,et al.  Effects of land-use change on nutrient discharges from the Patuxent River watershed , 2003 .

[16]  Luca Montanarella,et al.  VALIDATION OF SOIL EROSION ESTIMATES AT EUROPEAN SCALE , 2003 .

[17]  Limin Yang,et al.  COMPLETION OF THE 1990S NATIONAL LAND COVER DATA SET FOR THE CONTERMINOUS UNITED STATES FROM LANDSAT THEMATIC MAPPER DATA AND ANCILLARY DATA SOURCES , 2001 .

[18]  Darcy Boellstorff,et al.  Impacts of set-aside policy on the risk of soil erosion in central Spain , 2005 .

[19]  Mario Aristide Lenzi,et al.  Interannual variation of suspended sediment load and sediment yield in an alpine catchment , 2003 .

[20]  W. J. Young,et al.  Large-scale patterns of erosion and sediment transport in river networks, with examples from Australia , 2001 .

[21]  P. J. J. Desmet,et al.  Comparison of Routing Algorithms for Digital Elevation Models and Their Implications for Predicting Ephemeral Gullies , 1996, Int. J. Geogr. Inf. Sci..

[22]  J. Poesen,et al.  Factors controlling sediment yield from small intensively cultivated catchments in a temperate humid climate , 2001 .

[23]  D. Scott Mackay,et al.  Effects of distribution-based parameter aggregation on a spatially distributed agricultural nonpoint source pollution model , 2004 .

[24]  Michael R. Roman,et al.  Eutrophication of Chesapeake Bay: historical trends and ecological interactions , 2005 .

[25]  Trimble,et al.  Contribution of stream channel erosion to sediment yield from an urbanizing watershed , 1997, Science.

[26]  Robert M. Summers,et al.  The validity of a simple statistical model for estimating fluvial constituent loads: An Empirical study involving nutrient loads entering Chesapeake Bay , 1992 .

[27]  Donald E. Weller,et al.  Comparison of automated watershed delineations: effects on land cover areas, percentages, and relationships to nutrient discharge , 2006 .

[28]  R. Young,et al.  AGNPS: A nonpoint-source pollution model for evaluating agricultural watersheds , 1989 .

[29]  Mark A. Nearing,et al.  Error Assessment in the Universal Soil Loss Equation , 1993 .

[30]  Dengsheng Lu,et al.  Mapping soil erosion risk in Rondônia, Brazilian Amazonia: using RUSLE, remote sensing and GIS , 2004 .

[31]  D. Schluter,et al.  MICROCOSM EXPERIMENTS HAVE LIMITED RELEVANCE FOR COMMUNITY AND ECOSYSTEM ECOLOGY , 1996 .

[32]  J. L. Kittle,et al.  Hydrological simulation program: Fortran. User's manual for release 10 , 1993 .

[33]  Donald E. Weller,et al.  NONPOINT SOURCE DISCHARGES OF NUTRIENTS FROM PIEDMONT WATERSHEDS OF CHESAPEAKE BAY 1 , 1997 .

[34]  John R. Williams,et al.  SEDIMENT YIELD COMPUTED WITH UNIVERSAL EQUATION , 1972 .

[35]  T. Zeleke,et al.  Scaling Relationships between Saturated Hydraulic Conductivity and Soil Physical Properties , 2005 .

[36]  R. O'Neill,et al.  Predicting nutrient and sediment loadings to streams from landscape metrics: A multiple watershed study from the United States Mid-Atlantic Region , 2001, Landscape Ecology.

[37]  W. H. Wischmeier,et al.  Predicting rainfall erosion losses : a guide to conservation planning , 1978 .

[38]  Gilbert T. Bernhardt,et al.  A comprehensive surface-groundwater flow model , 1993 .

[39]  N. LeRoy Poff,et al.  Hydrologic variation with land use across the contiguous United States: Geomorphic and ecological consequences for stream ecosystems , 2006 .

[40]  John R. Williams.  Sediment-yield prediction with Universal Equation using runoff energy factor , 1975 .

[41]  B. Kjerfve,et al.  Factors controlling sediment yield in a major South American drainage basin: the Magdalena River, Colombia , 2006 .

[42]  Robert H. Fraser,et al.  Predicting Stream Pathogen Loading from Livestock using a Geographical Information System-Based Delivery Model , 1998 .

[43]  Stuart Downward,et al.  Working rivers: the geomorphological legacy of English freshwater mills , 2005 .

[44]  P. Kinnell.  Letter to the Editor on “The Mathematical Integrity of Some Universal Soil Loss Equation Variants” , 2004 .

[45]  D F Boesch,et al.  Chesapeake Bay eutrophication: scientific understanding, ecosystem restoration, and challenges for agriculture. , 2001, Journal of environmental quality.

[46]  S. Trimble,et al.  U.S. Soil Erosion Rates--Myth and Reality , 2000, Science.

[47]  S. Ali,et al.  EVALUATION OF THE UNIVERSAL SOIL LOSS EQUATION (USLE) IN SEMI-ARID AND SUB-HUMID CLIMATES OF INDIA , 2005 .

[48]  R. Hickey,et al.  The effect of slope algorithms on slope estimates within a GIS , 1998 .

[49]  G. R. Foster,et al.  Predicting soil erosion by water : a guide to conservation planning with the Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE) , 1997 .

[50]  R. Hickey,et al.  Estimating the LS Factor for RUSLE through Iterative Slope Length Processing of Digital Elevation Data within Arclnfo Grid , 2001 .

[51]  Mary Lynn Baeck,et al.  Field studies of the storm event hydrologic response in an urbanizing watershed , 2005 .

[52]  G. R. Buell,et al.  Contrasting soils and landscapes of the Piedmont and Coastal Plain, eastern United States. , 1990 .

[53]  Hubert Gulinck,et al.  Assessment of soil erosion at large watershed scale using RUSLE and GIS: a case study in the Loess Plateau of China , 2005 .

[54]  R. Hickey,et al.  Slope length calculations from a DEM within ARC/INFO grid , 1994 .

[55]  Michael J. Oimoen,et al.  The National Elevation Dataset , 2002 .

[56]  O. Slaymaker.  Towards the identification of scaling relations in drainage basin sediment budgets , 2006 .

[57]  Stephen R. Carpenter,et al.  MICROCOSM EXPERIMENTS HAVE LIMITED RELEVANCE FOR COMMUNITY AND ECOSYSTEM ECOLOGY: REPLY , 1999 .

[58]  Penny J Johnes,et al.  Evaluation and management of the impact of land use change on the nitrogen and phosphorus load delivered to surface waters: the export coefficient modelling approach , 1996 .

[59]  Zhi-jun Liu,et al.  EFFECTS OF LAND COVER AND GEOLOGY ON STREAM CHEMISTRY IN WATERSHEDS OF CHESAPEAKE BAY 1 , 2000 .

[60]  Donald E. Weller,et al.  Improved methods for quantifying potential nutrient interception by riparian buffers , 2006, Landscape Ecology.

[61]  J. L. Regens,et al.  Estimating erosion in a riverine watershed bayou liberty-tchefuncta river in louisiana , 2003, Environmental science and pollution research international.

[62]  D. Flanagan,et al.  Measurements and Models of Soil Loss Rates , 2000, Science.

[63]  P. Kinnell.  Sediment delivery ratios: a misaligned approach to determining sediment delivery from hillslopes , 2004 .

[64]  Lawrence D. Teeter,et al.  Relationships Between Landscape Characteristics and Nonpoint Source Pollution Inputs to Coastal Estuaries , 1999, Environmental management.

[65]  S. R. Carpenter,et al.  Microcosm experiments have limited relevance for community and ecosystem ecology : Microcosms , 1996 .

[66]  S. D. Angima,et al.  Soil erosion prediction using RUSLE for central Kenyan highland conditions , 2003 .

[67]  Fan,et al.  Spatial Distribution of Soil Erosion Sensitivity on the Tibet Plateau , 2005 .