The harmful dysfunction model of alcohol use disorder: revised criteria to improve the validity of diagnosis and prevalence estimates.

AIMS To formulate harmful dysfunction (HD) diagnostic criteria for alcohol use disorder (AUD) and test whether they increase validity relative to standard DSM criteria, as evidenced by lowered prevalence, increased validator levels including service use, severity and family history and enhanced specificity. DESIGN DSM-IV AUD, DSM-IV dependence, DSM-5 AUD and HD AUD definitions were compared on eight validity related tests using nationally representative community data. SETTING United States. PARTICIPANTS National Epidemiologic Survey of Alcoholism and Related Conditions (NESARC) respondents, aged 18-54 years (wave 1, n = 29 673; wave 2, n = 24 244). MEASURES NESARC DSM-IV and DSM-5 criteria were taken from published studies. Whereas DSM-5 diagnosis requires any two AUD symptoms, HD criteria were constructed from NESARC items to require symptoms of both impaired-control dysfunction [withdrawal, drink to prevent/stop withdrawal, cannot stop/reduce drinking, or craving (wave 2 only)] and harm (sacrificed important activities, problems caring for home/family, job/school problems, health problems, psychological problems or problems with family/friends). Validators included service use, severity and family history, among others. Specificity was tested using a teen transient drinker criterion group. FINDINGS Compared with DSM-5 AUD (DSM-IV results were similar), HD criteria yielded lower prevalence (95% confidence intervals): HD life-time 6.7% (6.2, 7.2%), 1-year 2.3% (2.0, 2.5%); and DSM-5 life-time 38.2% (36.5, 39.9%), 1-year 12.4% (11.7, 13.1%). HD AUD was higher than DSM-5 on pathology validators, including: life-time alcohol-related service use: HD 41.0% (38.1, 43.9%), DSM-5 11.5% (10.7, 12.3%); severity (number of life-time alcohol symptoms): HD 20.8 (20.4, 21.2), DSM-5 10.6 (10.4, 10.8); and family history of alcohol problems: HD 50.1% (47.3, 52.9), DSM-5 32.8% (31.6, 34.0). HD criteria eliminated 83% of a DSM-5 teen transient drinker false-positives criterion group. CONCLUSIONS Prevalence estimates of alcohol use disorder are lowered and diagnostic validity improved when using 'harmful dysfunction' diagnostic criteria compared with standard DSM criteria, partly by reducing misdiagnosis of teenage transient drinkers.

[1]  J. Wakefield.  False positives in psychiatric diagnosis: implications for human freedom , 2010, Theoretical medicine and bioethics.

[2]  Tammy Chung,et al.  What were they thinking? Adolescents' interpretations of DSM-IV alcohol dependence symptom queries and implications for diagnostic validity. , 2005, Drug and alcohol dependence.

[3]  D. Hasin.  Classification of Alcohol Use Disorders , 2003, Alcohol research & health : the journal of the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.

[4]  J. Wakefield.  Misdiagnosing normality: Psychiatry's failure to address the problem of false positive diagnoses of mental disorder in a changing professional environment , 2010, Journal of mental health.

[5]  R. de Graaf,et al.  The three year course of alcohol use disorders in the general population: DSM-IV, ICD-10 and the Craving Withdrawal Model. , 2006, Addiction.

[6]  M. First,et al.  Placing symptoms in context: the role of contextual criteria in reducing false positives in Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders diagnoses. , 2012, Comprehensive psychiatry.

[7]  Carla Cannizzaro,et al.  Effect of Acetaldehyde Intoxication and Withdrawal on NPY Expression: Focus on Endocannabinoidergic System Involvement , 2014, Front. Psychiatry.

[8]  C. Diclemente,et al.  Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity , 1998 .

[9]  Kenneth J Sher,et al.  It's the algorithm! Why differential rates of chronicity and comorbidity are not evidence for the validity of the abuse-dependence distinction. , 2010, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[10]  J. Zoellner,et al.  Improvements in Blood Pressure Among Undiagnosed Hypertensive Participants in a Community-Based Lifestyle Intervention, Mississippi, 2010 , 2014, Preventing chronic disease.

[11]  K. Dar.  Alcohol use disorders in elderly people: fact or fiction? , 2006 .

[12]  Tammy Chung,et al.  How should we revise diagnostic criteria for substance use disorders in the DSM-V? , 2008, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[13]  D. Regier,et al.  Revised prevalence estimates of mental disorders in the United States: using a clinical significance criterion to reconcile 2 surveys' estimates. , 2002, Archives of general psychiatry.

[14]  John R Hughes.  Defining dependence: describing symptom clusters versus central constructs. , 2007, Addiction.

[15]  A. Zellner.  An Efficient Method of Estimating Seemingly Unrelated Regressions and Tests for Aggregation Bias , 1962 .

[16]  C. Martin,et al.  Toward the DSM-V: the Withdrawal-Gate Model versus the DSM-IV in the diagnosis of alcohol abuse and dependence. , 2000, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[17]  J. Wakefield,et al.  The concept of mental disorder. On the boundary between biological facts and social values. , 1992, The American psychologist.

[18]  Elizabeth L. Ogburn,et al.  Prevalence, correlates, disability, and comorbidity of DSM-IV alcohol abuse and dependence in the United States: results from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions. , 2007, Archives of general psychiatry.

[19]  Carman S. Gill,et al.  Review of the Proposed DSM‐5 Substance Use Disorder , 2012 .

[20]  S. Hyman,et al.  The diagnosis of mental disorders: the problem of reification. , 2010, Annual review of clinical psychology.

[21]  J. Wakefield.  Mental Disorder and Moral Responsibility: Disorders of Personhood as Harmful Dysfunctions, With Special Reference to Alcoholism , 2009 .

[22]  Elizabeth L. Ogburn,et al.  Substance use disorders: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition (DSM-IV) and International Classification of Diseases, tenth edition (ICD-10). , 2006, Addiction.

[23]  Kenneth J Sher,et al.  Truth or consequences in the diagnosis of substance use disorders. , 2014, Addiction.

[24]  G. Edwards.  "The evil genius of the habit": DSM-5 seen in historical context. , 2012, Journal of studies on alcohol and drugs.

[25]  C. Clogg,et al.  Statistical Methods for Comparing Regression Coefficients Between Models , 1995, American Journal of Sociology.

[26]  Kenneth J Sher,et al.  The proposed 2/11 symptom algorithm for DSM-5 substance-use disorders is too lenient. , 2011, Psychological medicine.

[27]  J. Wakefield,et al.  Corrigendum: How many People have Alcohol Use Disorders? Using the Harmful Dysfunction Analysis to Rectify Prevalence Rates in Two Community Surveys , 2014, Front. Psychiatry.

[28]  J. Wakefield.  Limits of operationalization: a critique of Spitzer and Endicott's (1978) proposed operational criteria for mental disorder. , 1993, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[29]  Ken C Winters,et al.  Substance use disorders in DSM-V when applied to adolescents. , 2011, Addiction.

[30]  R. Kessler,et al.  Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of DSM-III-R psychiatric disorders in the United States. Results from the National Comorbidity Survey. , 1994, Archives of general psychiatry.

[31]  J. Wakefield,et al.  Evolutionary versus prototype analyses of the concept of disorder. , 1999, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[32]  J. Endicott,et al.  The validity of DSM-IV alcohol abuse: drunk drivers versus all others. , 1999, Journal of studies on alcohol.

[33]  T. Babor,et al.  The trouble with alcohol abuse: what are we trying to measure, diagnose, count and prevent? , 2008, Addiction.

[34]  J. Wakefield.  Diagnosing DSM-IV--Part I: DSM-IV and the concept of disorder. , 1997, Behaviour research and therapy.

[35]  Jerome C. Wakefield,et al.  How Many People have Alcohol Use Disorders? Using the Harmful Dysfunction Analysis to Reconcile Prevalence Estimates in Two Community Surveys , 2014, Front. Psychiatry.

[36]  G. Edwards.  The alcohol dependence syndrome: a concept as stimulus to enquiry. , 1986, British journal of addiction.

[37]  A. Heath,et al.  DSM-IV to DSM-5: the impact of proposed revisions on diagnosis of alcohol use disorders. , 2011, Addiction.

[38]  J. Wakefield,et al.  Disorder as harmful dysfunction: a conceptual critique of DSM-III-R's definition of mental disorder. , 1992, Psychological review.

[39]  J. Endicott,et al.  Differentiating DSM-IV alcohol dependence and abuse by course: community heavy drinkers. , 1997, Journal of substance abuse.

[40]  R. Room.  Substance use disorders--a conceptual and terminological muddle. , 2011, Addiction.

[41]  Katherine M Keyes,et al.  Socio-economic status and problem alcohol use: the positive relationship between income and the DSM-IV alcohol abuse diagnosis. , 2008, Addiction.

[42]  Robert D. Brewer,et al.  Contribution of Excessive Alcohol Consumption to Deaths and Years of Potential Life Lost in the United States , 2014, Preventing chronic disease.

[43]  G Gmel,et al.  Defining substance use disorders: do we really need more than heavy use? , 2013, Alcohol and alcoholism.

[44]  M. First,et al.  Diagnostic Criteria as Dysfunction Indicators: Bridging the Chasm between the Definition of Mental Disorder and Diagnostic Criteria for Specific Disorders , 2013, Canadian journal of psychiatry. Revue canadienne de psychiatrie.

[45]  A. Caspi,et al.  How common are common mental disorders? Evidence that lifetime prevalence rates are doubled by prospective versus retrospective ascertainment , 2009, Psychological Medicine.

[46]  J. Wakefield.  The concept of mental disorder: diagnostic implications of the harmful dysfunction analysis. , 2007, World psychiatry : official journal of the World Psychiatric Association.

[47]  C. Drummond.  The end of the dependence syndrome as we know it? , 2011, Addiction.

[48]  M. M. Gross,et al.  Alcohol dependence: provisional description of a clinical syndrome. , 1976, British medical journal.

[49]  J. Nurnberger,et al.  Clinical relevance of the distinction between alcohol dependence with and without a physiological component. , 1998, The American journal of psychiatry.

[50]  D S Rae,et al.  Limitations of diagnostic criteria and assessment instruments for mental disorders. Implications for research and policy. , 1998, Archives of general psychiatry.

[51]  J. Wakefield.  Mental disorder as a black box essentialist concept. , 1999, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[52]  B. Grant,et al.  Prevalence and Co-Occurrence of Substance Use Disorders and Independent Mood and Anxiety Disorders , 2004, Archives of general psychiatry.

[53]  T. Babor,et al.  Diagnosis of alcohol dependence in epidemiological surveys: an epidemic of youthful alcohol dependence or a case of measurement error? , 2006, Addiction.

[54]  What is the purpose of diagnosing addiction or dependence and what does this mean for establishing diagnostic criteria? , 2011, Addiction.