The case for estimating carbon return on investment (CROI) for CCUS platforms

Abstract Development of CO2 capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) platforms has been deemed crucial for achievement of the Paris Agreement goals. Life-cycle assessment (LCA) is an important tool for assessing the efficacy of these technologies in achieving true net-carbon reduction. Critical review of previously published LCA-based evaluations of CCUS technologies reveals that there is an urgent need for more transparent accounting of carbon removal efficiency. Updated methods should incorporate better focus on the CO2 uptake as the primary objective and better differentiate apportionment between “avoided emissions” and true net sequestration. We posit that widespread, uniform application of a standardized ratio metric, carbon return on investment (CROI), will improve the usefulness of LCA to articulate true CO2 sequestration by candidate CCUS platforms. We present two case studies to illustrate the value of this metric for diverse CCS and CCU applications. We also provide several recommendations to make future CROI results as unambiguous as possible and boost their usefulness. These recommendations pertain to conventional LCA concepts, including: choice of functional unit (or declared unit) and system boundaries, application of system expansion, and proper mathematical formulation of the proposed metric. Future work should aim at carrying forward our work on proposed minimum CROI and incorporating the time-value of CO2 fluxes.

[1]  Lisa M. Colosi,et al.  Practical ambiguities during calculation of energy ratios and their impacts on life cycle assessment calculations , 2013 .

[2]  Siming You,et al.  Optimal design of negative emission hybrid renewable energy systems with biochar production , 2019, Applied Energy.

[3]  André Bardow,et al.  Life-cycle assessment of carbon dioxide capture and utilization: avoiding the pitfalls , 2013 .

[4]  M. Wright,et al.  Negative Emission Energy Production Technologies: A Techno‐Economic and Life Cycle Analyses Review , 2020, Energy Technology.

[5]  S. Mawalkar,et al.  Large CO2 Storage Volumes Result in Net Negative Emissions for Greenhouse Gas Life Cycle Analysis Based on Records from 22 Years of CO2-Enhanced Oil Recovery Operations , 2020 .

[6]  H. Herzog,et al.  An Issue of Permanence: Assessing the Effectiveness of Temporary Carbon Storage , 2002 .

[7]  Adam R. Brandt,et al.  A General Mathematical Framework for Calculating Systems-Scale Efficiency of Energy Extraction and Conversion: Energy Return on Investment (EROI) and Other Energy Return Ratios , 2011 .

[8]  I. Capellán-Pérez,et al.  Dynamic Energy Return on Energy Investment (EROI) and material requirements in scenarios of global transition to renewable energies , 2019, Energy Strategy Reviews.

[9]  Peter Viebahn,et al.  The Potential Role of Direct Air Capture in the German Energy Research Program—Results of a Multi-Dimensional Analysis , 2019, Energies.

[10]  Paul Wolfram,et al.  Assessing electric vehicle policy with region-specific carbon footprints , 2019 .

[11]  Peter Psarras,et al.  Assessment of reasonable opportunities for direct air capture , 2017 .

[12]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  Energy, EROI and quality of life , 2014 .

[13]  David William Keith,et al.  A Process for Capturing CO2 from the Atmosphere , 2018, Joule.

[14]  A. Ramírez,et al.  When are negative emissions negative emissions? , 2019, Energy & Environmental Science.

[15]  Katy Armstrong,et al.  Assessing the Potential of Utilization and Storage Strategies for Post-Combustion CO2 Emissions Reduction , 2015, Front. Energy Res..

[16]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  EROI of different fuels and the implications for society , 2014 .

[17]  C. Rösch,et al.  Critical Review of Microalgae LCA Studies for Bioenergy Production , 2018, BioEnergy Research.

[18]  M. Sharmina,et al.  What if negative emission technologies fail at scale? Implications of the Paris Agreement for big emitting nations , 2018 .

[19]  Timothy J Skone,et al.  Evaluating the climate benefits of CO2-enhanced oil recovery using life cycle analysis. , 2015, Environmental science & technology.

[20]  Shelie A. Miller,et al.  The environmental opportunity cost of using renewable energy for carbon capture and utilization for methanol production , 2020, Applied Energy.

[21]  C. Greene,et al.  Integrating Algae with Bioenergy Carbon Capture and Storage (ABECCS) Increases Sustainability , 2018 .

[22]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  What is the Minimum EROI that a Sustainable Society Must Have , 2009 .

[23]  N. M. Dowell,et al.  The energy return on investment of BECCS: is BECCS a threat to energy security? , 2018 .

[24]  Jennifer R Stokes-Draut,et al.  Mitigation Life Cycle Assessment: Best Practices from LCA of Energy and Water Infrastructure That Incurs Impacts to Mitigate Harm , 2020, Energies.

[25]  John E. Hermansen,et al.  System expansion for handling co-products in LCA of sugar cane bio-energy systems: GHG consequences of using molasses for ethanol production , 2012 .

[26]  N. Nakicenovic,et al.  Biophysical and economic limits to negative CO2 emissions , 2016 .

[27]  Zoran J. N. Steinmann,et al.  Life cycle carbon efficiency of Direct Air Capture systems with strong hydroxide sorbents , 2019, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control.

[28]  C. Nyandiere,et al.  Nairobi , 2020, The Global Governed?.

[29]  Felix Creutzig,et al.  Negative emissions—Part 1: Research landscape and synthesis , 2018 .

[30]  S. Bringezu,et al.  Life Cycle Assessment of Carbon Dioxide–Based Production of Methane and Methanol and Derived Polymers , 2018 .

[31]  M. Margallo,et al.  Bringing value to the chemical industry from capture, storage and use of CO2: A dynamic LCA of formic acid production. , 2019, The Science of the total environment.

[32]  Hyung Chul Kim,et al.  Life Cycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Crystalline Silicon Photovoltaic Electricity Generation , 2012 .

[33]  Nathan Lewis,et al.  Direct Air Capture of CO2 with Chemicals: A Technology Assessment for the APS Panel on Public Affairs , 2011 .

[34]  U. Singh,et al.  Is aquatic bioenergy with carbon capture and storage a sustainable negative emission technology? Insights from a spatially explicit environmental life-cycle assessment , 2020 .

[35]  Peter Viebahn,et al.  Integrated assessment of carbon capture and storage (CCS) in the German power sector and comparison with the deployment of renewable energies , 2012 .

[36]  Masato Takagi,et al.  Life cycle assessment performed on a CCS model case in Japan and evaluation of improvement facilitated by heat integration , 2011 .

[37]  Leon E. Clarke,et al.  Carbon capture and storage across fuels and sectors in energy system transformation pathways , 2017 .

[38]  M. Tavoni,et al.  An inter-model assessment of the role of direct air capture in deep mitigation pathways , 2019, Nature Communications.

[39]  Michael Q. Wang,et al.  Life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions of shale gas, natural gas, coal, and petroleum. , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[40]  A. Hawkes,et al.  An assessment of CCS costs, barriers and potential , 2018, Energy Strategy Reviews.

[41]  Andrea Ramírez,et al.  Environmental impact assessment of CCS chains – Lessons learned and limitations from LCA literature , 2013 .

[42]  P. Webley,et al.  Opportunities for application of BECCS in the Australian power sector , 2018 .

[43]  Lina I. Brand-Correa,et al.  Estimation of global final-stage energy-return-on-investment for fossil fuels with comparison to renewable energy sources , 2019, Nature Energy.

[44]  R. Haszeldine,et al.  UK grid electricity carbon intensity can be reduced by enhanced oil recovery with CO2 sequestration , 2018 .

[45]  P. Kyle,et al.  Global economic consequences of deploying bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) , 2016 .

[46]  D. Huisingh,et al.  Advances and challenges of life cycle assessment (LCA) of greenhouse gas removal technologies to fight climate changes , 2020 .

[47]  G. Guillén‐Gosálbez,et al.  BECCS based on bioethanol from wood residues: Potential towards a carbon-negative transport and side-effects , 2020 .

[48]  P. Webley,et al.  Potential for using municipal solid waste as a resource for bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) , 2018 .

[49]  Fengqi You,et al.  Integrating Hybrid Life Cycle Assessment with Multiobjective Optimization: A Modeling Framework. , 2016, Environmental science & technology.

[50]  Michael D. Porter,et al.  Is hydrothermal treatment coupled with carbon capture and storage an energy-producing negative emissions technology? , 2020 .

[51]  N. Vladimir,et al.  Life-cycle cost assessment of alternative marine fuels to reduce the carbon footprint in short-sea shipping: A case study of Croatia , 2020 .

[52]  William F. Lamb,et al.  Negative emissions—Part 2: Costs, potentials and side effects , 2018 .