The chapter is about visual arguments. I address the relationships among these three: rhetoric, argument, and the visual. How can there be visual arguments when arguments as we usually know them are verbal? And if there can be visual arguments, what is their rhetorical aspect? Since arguments are supposed to be tools of persuasion and rhetoric is often thought of as including (but not exhausted by) the study and use of the instruments of persuasion, I first explore the relationships among rhetoric, argument and persuasion. Then I turn to the difficulties and opportunities that present themselves when considering visual argument in particular. The chapter ends by taking up the question: What does being visual add to arguments? It adds drama and force of a much greater order. Beyond that it can use such devices as references to cultural icons and other kinds of symbolism, dramatization and narrative to make a powerfully compelling case for its conclusion. The visual has an immediacy, a verisimilitude, and a concreteness that help influence acceptance and that are not available to the verbal. When argument is visual, it is, above all, visual rhetoric.
[1]
S. Morris Engel.
Analyzing informal fallacies
,
1980
.
[2]
Leo Groarke,et al.
Logic, Art and Argument)
,
1996
.
[3]
J. Blair,et al.
The Possibility and Actuality of Visual Arguments
,
2012
.
[4]
Robert Trapp,et al.
Contemporary Perspectives on Rhetoric
,
1990
.
[5]
Leo Groarke,et al.
Toward a Theory of Visual Argument.
,
1996
.
[6]
Scott Jacobs,et al.
Rhetoric and Dialectic from the Standpoint of Normative Pragmatics
,
2000
.
[7]
Charles A. Hill,et al.
Echoes of Camelot: How Images construct Cultural Memory Through Rhetorical Framing
,
2012
.
[8]
D. Fleming,et al.
Can Pictures Be Arguments
,
1996
.
[9]
Charles A. Hill,et al.
Defining visual rhetorics
,
2004
.
[10]
S. M. Holzer,et al.
Book Reviews : SYSTEM DYNAMICS Katsuhiko Ogata Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1978
,
1980
.
[11]
Carine Duteil-Mougel.
Introduction à la Rhétorique
,
2005
.
[12]
Ralph H. Johnson.
Manifest Rationality: A Pragmatic Theory of Argument
,
2000
.