Comparison of Fresh-Frozen Cadaver and High-Fidelity Virtual Reality Simulator as Methods of Laparoscopic Training

BackgroundThe aim of this study was to compare fresh-frozen cadavers (FFC) with a high-fidelity virtual reality simulator (VRS) as training tools in minimal access surgery for complex and relatively simple procedures.MethodsA prospective comparative face validity study between FFC and VRS (LAP Mentor™) was performed. Surgeons were recruited to perform tasks on both FFC and VRS appropriately paired to their experience level. Group A (senior) performed a laparoscopic sigmoid colectomy, Group B (intermediate) performed a laparoscopic incisional hernia repair, and Group C (junior) performed basic laparoscopic tasks (BLT) (camera manipulation, hand-eye coordination, tissue dissection and hand-transferring skills). Each subject completed a 5-point Likert-type questionnaire rating the training modalities in nine domains. Data were analysed using nonparametric tests.ResultsForty-five surgeons were recruited to participate (15 per skill group). Median scores for subjects in Group A were significantly higher for evaluation of FFC in all nine domains compared to VRS (p < 0.01). Group B scored FFC significantly better (p < 0.05) in all domains except task replication (p = 0.06). Group C scored FFC significantly better (p < 0.01) in eight domains but not on performance feedback (p = 0.09). When compared across groups, juniors accepted VRS as a training model more than did intermediate and senior groups on most domains (p < 0.01) except team work.ConclusionsFresh-frozen cadaver is perceived as a significantly overall better model for laparoscopic training than the high-fidelity VRS by all training grades, irrespective of the complexity of the operative procedure performed. VRS is still useful when training junior trainees in BLT.

[1]  Pablo Lamata,et al.  Study of laparoscopic forces perception for defining simulation fidelity. , 2006, Studies in health technology and informatics.

[2]  A. G. Gallagher,et al.  Construct validation of the ProMIS simulator using a novel laparoscopic suturing task , 2005, Surgical Endoscopy And Other Interventional Techniques.

[3]  G. Maddern,et al.  A Systematic Review of Skills Transfer After Surgical Simulation Training , 2008, Annals of surgery.

[4]  Marie K Stelzer,et al.  Dry lab practice leads to improved laparoscopic performance in the operating room. , 2009, The Journal of surgical research.

[5]  Leif Hedman,et al.  Proficiency-based virtual reality training significantly reduces the error rate for residents during their first 10 laparoscopic cholecystectomies. , 2007, American journal of surgery.

[6]  T. Grantcharov,et al.  Randomized clinical trial of virtual reality simulation for laparoscopic skills training , 2004, The British journal of surgery.

[7]  A. Duffy,et al.  Evolution of surgical skills training. , 2006, World journal of gastroenterology.

[8]  Mandayam A Srinivasan,et al.  Virtual-reality-based laparoscopic surgical training: The role of simulation fidelity in haptic feedback , 2004, Computer aided surgery : official journal of the International Society for Computer Aided Surgery.

[9]  Christos Trantakis,et al.  Fundamentals of Force Feedback and Application to a Surgery Simulator , 2003, Computer aided surgery : official journal of the International Society for Computer Aided Surgery.

[10]  J. Fleshman,et al.  Adoption of Laparoscopic Colectomy: Results and Implications of ASCRS Hands-On Course Participation , 2008, Surgical innovation.

[11]  G. Ahlberg,et al.  Does training in a virtual reality simulator improve surgical performance? , 2001, Surgical Endoscopy And Other Interventional Techniques.

[12]  Glenn Regehr,et al.  Teaching cognitive skills improves learning in surgical skills courses: a blinded, prospective, randomized study. , 2004, Canadian journal of surgery. Journal canadien de chirurgie.

[13]  F. Leblanc,et al.  A comparison of human cadaver and augmented reality simulator models for straight laparoscopic colorectal skills acquisition training. , 2010, Journal of the American College of Surgeons.

[14]  A. Cuschieri,et al.  Time for evidence-based minimal access surgery training—simulate or sink , 2005, Surgical Endoscopy And Other Interventional Techniques.

[15]  R. Satava,et al.  Virtual Reality Training Improves Operating Room Performance: Results of a Randomized, Double-Blinded Study , 2002, Annals of surgery.