Mathematically guided approaches to distinguish models of periodic patterning

How periodic patterns are generated is an open question. A number of mechanisms have been proposed – most famously, Turing's reaction-diffusion model. However, many theoretical and experimental studies focus on the Turing mechanism while ignoring other possible mechanisms. Here, we use a general model of periodic patterning to show that different types of mechanism (molecular, cellular, mechanical) can generate qualitatively similar final patterns. Observation of final patterns is therefore not sufficient to favour one mechanism over others. However, we propose that a mathematical approach can help to guide the design of experiments that can distinguish between different mechanisms, and illustrate the potential value of this approach with specific biological examples. Summary: This Hypothesis presents a mathematical approach to understanding periodic patterning during development, and suggests ways in which molecular, cellular or mechanical models can be tested.

[1]  J Raspopovic,et al.  Digit patterning is controlled by a Bmp-Sox9-Wnt Turing network modulated by morphogen gradients , 2014, Science.

[2]  C. Nüsslein-Volhard,et al.  Proliferation, dispersal and patterned aggregation of iridophores in the skin prefigure striped colouration of zebrafish , 2014, Nature Cell Biology.

[3]  Shigeru Kondo,et al.  In vitro analysis suggests that difference in cell movement during direct interaction can generate various pigment patterns in vivo , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[4]  Masakatsu Watanabe,et al.  Involvement of Delta/Notch signaling in zebrafish adult pigment stripe patterning , 2014, Development.

[5]  Donald E Ingber,et al.  Quantifying cell-generated mechanical forces within living embryonic tissues , 2013, Nature Methods.

[6]  David L. Kaplan,et al.  Villification: How the Gut Gets Its Villi , 2013, Science.

[7]  D. Mooney,et al.  Cell mediated contraction in 3D cell-matrix constructs leads to spatially regulated osteogenic differentiation. , 2013, Integrative biology : quantitative biosciences from nano to macro.

[8]  V. Shastri,et al.  Polysaccharide hydrogels with tunable stiffness and provasculogenic properties via α-helix to β-sheet switch in secondary structure , 2013, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[9]  C. Nüsslein-Volhard,et al.  Iridophores and their interactions with other chromatophores are required for stripe formation in zebrafish , 2013, Development.

[10]  Kristi S Anseth,et al.  Three-dimensional hMSC motility within peptide-functionalized PEG-based hydrogels of varying adhesivity and crosslinking density. , 2013, Acta biomaterialia.

[11]  Philipp J. Keller,et al.  Towards comprehensive cell lineage reconstructions in complex organisms using light‐sheet microscopy , 2013, Development, growth & differentiation.

[12]  L. Schaefer,et al.  Unilateral dampening of Bmp activity by nodal generates cardiac left-right asymmetry. , 2013, Developmental cell.

[13]  M. Mikkola,et al.  Fgf20 governs formation of primary and secondary dermal condensations in developing hair follicles. , 2013, Genes & development.

[14]  Le Cong,et al.  Multiplex Genome Engineering Using CRISPR/Cas Systems , 2013, Science.

[15]  Matthias Zwicker,et al.  Crocodile Head Scales Are Not Developmental Units But Emerge from Physical Cracking , 2013, Science.

[16]  Dagmar Iber,et al.  Digit patterning during limb development as a result of the BMP-receptor interaction , 2012, Scientific Reports.

[17]  J. Sharpe,et al.  Hox Genes Regulate Digit Patterning by Controlling the Wavelength of a Turing-Type Mechanism , 2012, Science.

[18]  James Sharpe,et al.  Turing patterns in development: what about the horse part? , 2012, Current opinion in genetics & development.

[19]  Kevin J. Painter,et al.  Towards an integrated experimental–theoretical approach for assessing the mechanistic basis of hair and feather morphogenesis , 2012, Interface Focus.

[20]  Katherine W. Rogers,et al.  Differential Diffusivity of Nodal and Lefty Underlies a Reaction-Diffusion Patterning System , 2012, Science.

[21]  Masakatsu Watanabe,et al.  Changing clothes easily: connexin41.8 regulates skin pattern variation , 2012, Pigment cell & melanoma research.

[22]  Luis G. Morelli,et al.  Patterning embryos with oscillations: structure, function and dynamics of the vertebrate segmentation clock , 2012, Development.

[23]  Shigeru Kondo,et al.  Pigment Pattern Formation by Contact-Dependent Depolarization , 2012, Science.

[24]  Dagmar Iber,et al.  Branch Mode Selection during Early Lung Development , 2012, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[25]  Paul T. Sharpe,et al.  Periodic stripe formation by a Turing-mechanism operating at growth zones in the mammalian palate , 2012, Nature Genetics.

[26]  T. Hwa,et al.  Sequential Establishment of Stripe Patterns in an Expanding Cell Population , 2011, Science.

[27]  L. Mahadevan,et al.  On the growth and form of the gut , 2011, Nature.

[28]  J. Esko,et al.  Heparan sulfate proteoglycans. , 2011, Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology.

[29]  Matthew W. Pennington,et al.  A dynamical model of ommatidial crystal formation , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[30]  Ryan S. Udan,et al.  Live imaging of mouse embryos. , 2011, Cold Spring Harbor protocols.

[31]  Brian Derby,et al.  Characterizing the elastic properties of tissues. , 2011, Materials today.

[32]  Shigeru Kondo,et al.  Reaction-Diffusion Model as a Framework for Understanding Biological Pattern Formation , 2010, Science.

[33]  Shigeru Kondo,et al.  Blending of animal colour patterns by hybridization , 2010, Nature communications.

[34]  M. Miodownik,et al.  Dynamic filopodia transmit intermittent Delta-Notch signaling to drive pattern refinement during lateral inhibition. , 2010, Developmental cell.

[35]  David A. Rand,et al.  Measurement of single-cell dynamics , 2010, Nature.

[36]  R. Zeller,et al.  Vertebrate limb bud development: moving towards integrative analysis of organogenesis , 2009, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[37]  Kristi S Anseth,et al.  Effects of PEG hydrogel crosslinking density on protein diffusion and encapsulated islet survival and function. , 2009, Journal of biomedical materials research. Part A.

[38]  A. Kicheva,et al.  Morphogen gradient formation. , 2009, Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology.

[39]  Shigeru Kondo,et al.  Interactions between zebrafish pigment cells responsible for the generation of Turing patterns , 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[40]  John A. Rogers,et al.  Mechanical Buckling: Mechanics, Metrology, and Stretchable Electronics , 2009 .

[41]  J. Demongeot,et al.  BMP2 and BMP7 play antagonistic roles in feather induction , 2008, Development.

[42]  J. Tobias,et al.  Activation of β-catenin signaling programs embryonic epidermis to hair follicle fate , 2008, Development.

[43]  J. Elisseeff.  Hydrogels: structure starts to gel. , 2008, Nature materials.

[44]  K. Anseth,et al.  Hydrogel Cell Cultures , 2007, Science.

[45]  Shigeru Kondo,et al.  Pattern regulation in the stripe of zebrafish suggests an underlying dynamic and autonomous mechanism , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[46]  J. Stark,et al.  Hairy Math: Insights into Hair-Follicle Spacing and Orientation , 2007, Cell.

[47]  A. Metters,et al.  Hydrogels in controlled release formulations: network design and mathematical modeling. , 2006, Advanced drug delivery reviews.

[48]  Stephen L. Johnson,et al.  Pigment Pattern in jaguar/obelix Zebrafish Is Caused by a Kir7.1 Mutation: Implications for the Regulation of Melanosome Movement , 2006, PLoS genetics.

[49]  Hiroshi Hamada,et al.  Generation of robust left-right asymmetry in the mouse embryo requires a self-enhancement and lateral-inhibition system. , 2006, Developmental cell.

[50]  Philip K Maini,et al.  Mixed-mode pattern in Doublefoot mutant mouse limb--Turing reaction-diffusion model on a growing domain during limb development. , 2006, Journal of theoretical biology.

[51]  Pascal Schneider,et al.  Generation of the primary hair follicle pattern. , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[52]  E. Knobloch,et al.  Localized states in the generalized Swift-Hohenberg equation. , 2006, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[53]  C. López.  Macroscopic description of particle systems with nonlocal density-dependent diffusivity. , 2006, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[54]  A. Üren,et al.  Wnt-3a-dependent Cell Motility Involves RhoA Activation and Is Specifically Regulated by Dishevelled-2*[boxs] , 2005, Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[55]  Philip K. Maini,et al.  Speed of pattern appearance in reaction-diffusion models: Implications in the pattern formation of limb bud mesenchyme cells , 2004, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[56]  James A. Glazier,et al.  Non-turing stripes and spots: a novel mechanism for biological cell clustering , 2004 .

[57]  J. Paulsson.  Summing up the noise in gene networks , 2004, Nature.

[58]  J. Murray,et al.  On the mechanochemical theory of biological pattern formation with application to vasculogenesis. , 2003, Comptes rendus biologies.

[59]  Takashi Miura,et al.  Depletion of FGF acts as a lateral inhibitory factor in lung branching morphogenesis in vitro , 2002, Mechanisms of Development.

[60]  Y. Saijoh,et al.  Determination of left–right patterning of the mouse embryo by artificial nodal flow , 2002, Nature.

[61]  Stephen L. Johnson,et al.  How the zebrafish gets its stripes. , 2001, Developmental biology.

[62]  J. Groenewold.  Wrinkling of plates coupled with soft elastic media , 2001 .

[63]  P. Maini,et al.  Turing instabilities in general systems , 2000, Journal of mathematical biology.

[64]  H. Meinhardt,et al.  Pattern formation by local self-activation and lateral inhibition. , 2000, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[65]  K. Shiota,et al.  TGFβ2 acts as an “Activator” molecule in reaction‐diffusion model and is involved in cell sorting phenomenon in mouse limb micromass culture , 2000, Developmental dynamics : an official publication of the American Association of Anatomists.

[66]  Rihito Asai,et al.  Zebrafish Leopard gene as a component of the putative reaction-diffusion system , 1999, Mechanisms of Development.

[67]  L Wolpert,et al.  Local inhibitory action of BMPs and their relationships with activators in feather formation: implications for periodic patterning. , 1998, Developmental biology.

[68]  S. Kondo,et al.  A reaction–diffusion wave on the skin of the marine angelfish Pomacanthus , 1995, Nature.

[69]  James D. Murray,et al.  Parameter domains for spots and stripes in mechanical models for biological pattern formation , 1995 .

[70]  M. Cross,et al.  Pattern formation outside of equilibrium , 1993 .

[71]  M. Levine,et al.  Regulation of a segmentation stripe by overlapping activators and repressors in the Drosophila embryo. , 1991, Science.

[72]  B. Ermentrout.  Stripes or spots? Nonlinear effects in bifurcation of reaction—diffusion equations on the square , 1991, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A: Mathematical and Physical Sciences.

[73]  G F Oster,et al.  Pattern formation models and developmental constraints. , 1989, The Journal of experimental zoology.

[74]  J. Murray.  How the Leopard Gets Its Spots. , 1988 .

[75]  D. Paulsen,et al.  Microtiter micromass cultures of limb-bud mesenchymal cells , 1988, In Vitro Cellular & Developmental Biology.

[76]  F. W. Cummings,et al.  A pattern-surface interactive model of morphogenesis , 1985 .

[77]  B. Nagorcka,et al.  The role of a reaction-diffusion system in the initiation of primary hair follicles. , 1985, Journal of theoretical biology.

[78]  J. Murray,et al.  Parameter space for turing instability in reaction diffusion mechanisms: a comparison of models. , 1982, Journal of theoretical biology.

[79]  H L Frisch,et al.  Dynamics of skeletal pattern formation in developing chick limb. , 1979, Science.

[80]  H. Meinhardt,et al.  Applications of a theory of biological pattern formation based on lateral inhibition. , 1974, Journal of cell science.

[81]  H. Meinhardt,et al.  A theory of biological pattern formation , 1972, Kybernetik.

[82]  A. M. Turing,et al.  The chemical basis of morphogenesis , 1952, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences.

[83]  E. Buckingham.  On Physically Similar Systems; Illustrations of the Use of Dimensional Equations , 1914 .

[84]  S. Megason,et al.  In toto imaging of embryogenesis with confocal time-lapse microscopy. , 2009, Methods in molecular biology.

[85]  Yong-Tao Zhang,et al.  Multiscale models for vertebrate limb development. , 2008, Current topics in developmental biology.

[86]  Kristi S Anseth,et al.  Materials science. Hydrogel cell cultures. , 2007, Science.

[87]  Cheryll Tickle,et al.  Developmental cell biology: Making digit patterns in the vertebrate limb , 2006, Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology.

[88]  Arjen Doelman,et al.  Homoclinic Stripe Patterns , 2002, SIAM J. Appl. Dyn. Syst..

[89]  K. Shiota,et al.  Extracellular matrix environment influences chondrogenic pattern formation in limb bud micromass culture: Experimental verification of theoretical models , 2000, The Anatomical record.

[90]  P K Maini,et al.  Bifurcating spatially heterogeneous solutions in a chemotaxis model for biological pattern generation. , 1991, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[91]  G F Oster,et al.  Generation of biological pattern and form. , 1984, IMA journal of mathematics applied in medicine and biology.

[92]  G. Oster,et al.  Cell traction models for generating pattern and form in morphogenesis , 1984, Journal of mathematical biology.

[93]  B. Nagorcka.  Evidence for a reaction-diffusion system as a mechanism controlling mammalian hair growth. , 1983, Bio Systems.

[94]  E. C. Zeeman,et al.  A clock and wavefront model for control of the number of repeated structures during animal morphogenesis. , 1976, Journal of theoretical biology.

[95]  Johannes Jaeger,et al.  Cellular and Molecular Life Sciences REVIEW The gap gene network , 2022 .