Automated fetal heart rate analysis for baseline determination and acceleration/deceleration detection: A comparison of 11 methods versus expert consensus

Abstract Background The fetal heart rate (FHR) serves as a guide to fetal well-being during the first stage of delivery. The visual morphological analysis of the FHR during labor is subject to inter- and intra-observer variability – particularly when the FHR is abnormal. It has been suggested that automatic analysis of the FHR can reduce this variability. Objectives To compare 11 morphological FHR analyses (baseline computation, and detection of FHR decelerations and accelerations) produced by automatic analysis methods (AAMs) with an expert consensus. Materials and methods Eleven AAMs were reprogrammed (using the description published in the literature) and applied to 90 FHR recordings collected during the early phase of labor. Furthermore, the recordings were divided into three tertiles, according to the difficulty of analysis. The results of the morphological FHR analyses produced by the AAMs were compared with a consensus morphological analysis performed by four experts. In addition to standard discriminant criteria, a new morphological analysis discriminant index (MADI) was introduced; it provides an overall evaluation that collates all the individual criteria. Results The AAM developed by Lu and Wei's gave better results than the other AAMs for baseline computation. Regarding this method's detection of FHR decelerations and accelerations, the F-measure [95% confidence interval] was respectively 0.73 [0.67; 0.76] and 0.70 [0.64; 0.76]. The MADI indicated that Lu and Wei's AAM agreed best with the expert consensus (discordance: 7.3% [6.10; 8.60]). Conclusion Our study demonstrated the superiority of Lu and Wei's method for baseline computation and deceleration/acceleration detection, although there was still a significant degree of discordance versus expert consensus. The MADI appears to be a good overall index for evaluating AAMs with regard to the quality of baseline computation and acceleration/deceleration detection. The application of precise criteria and the methodology and software tools developed here should facilitate the evaluation of new AAMs and their comparison with other methods.

[1]  R D Keith,et al.  Development, evaluation and validation of an intelligent system for the management of labour. , 1994, Bailliere's clinical obstetrics and gynaecology.

[2]  A. Loundou,et al.  Intra- and interobserver agreement among obstetric experts in court regarding the review of abnormal fetal heart rate tracings and obstetrical management. , 2015, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[3]  J. Searle,et al.  Computerized analysis of resting fetal heart rate tracings. , 1988, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[4]  G S Dawes,et al.  System 8000: Computerized antenatal FHR analysis , 1991, Journal of perinatal medicine.

[5]  E. C. Ifeachor,et al.  Suitability of artificial neural networks for feature extraction from cardiotocogram during labour , 1994, Medical and Biological Engineering and Computing.

[6]  Hua Cao,et al.  BioSigPlot: An opensource tool for the visualization of multi-channel biomedical signals with Matlab , 2013, 2013 35th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC).

[7]  Yaosheng Lu,et al.  Fetal heart rate baseline estimation with analysis of fetal movement signal. , 2014, Bio-medical materials and engineering.

[8]  Bruno Aeyels,et al.  On-line processing of perinatal fetal heart rate and intra-uterine pressure , 1992, 1992 14th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[9]  J. P. Marques de Sá,et al.  The Porto system for automated cardiotocographic signal analysis , 1991, Journal of perinatal medicine.

[10]  R. González,et al.  Computerized algorithm for baseline estimation of fetal heart rate , 2002, Computers in Cardiology.

[11]  Kazuo Maeda,et al.  Central Computerized Automatic Fetal Heart Rate Diagnosis with a Rapid and Direct Alarm System , 2012 .

[12]  K J Dalton,et al.  Diurnal, respiratory, and other rhythms of fetal heart rate in lambs. , 1977, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[13]  K. Himmelmann,et al.  The changing panorama of cerebral palsy in Sweden. X. Prevalence and origin in the birth‐year period 1999–2002 , 2010, Acta paediatrica.

[14]  Yaosheng Lu,et al.  Nonlinear baseline estimation of FHR signal using empirical mode decomposition , 2012, 2012 IEEE 11th International Conference on Signal Processing.

[15]  G. M. Taylor,et al.  The development and validation of an algorithm for real‐time computerised fetal heart rate monitoring in labour , 2000, BJOG : an international journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[16]  Romain Demailly,et al.  Baseline fetal heart rate analysis: Eleven automatic methods versus expert consensus , 2016, 2016 38th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC).

[17]  D. Ayres-de-Campos,et al.  FIGO consensus guidelines on intrapartum fetal monitoring: Cardiotocography , 2015, International journal of gynaecology and obstetrics: the official organ of the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics.

[18]  P. Warrick,et al.  Neural network based detection of fetal heart rate patterns , 2005, Proceedings. 2005 IEEE International Joint Conference on Neural Networks, 2005..

[19]  João Bernardes,et al.  Comparison of fetal heart rate baseline estimation by SisPorto 2.01 and a consensus of clinicians. , 2004, European journal of obstetrics, gynecology, and reproductive biology.

[20]  Giovanni Magenes,et al.  2CTG2: A new system for the antepartum analysis of fetal heart rate , 2007 .

[21]  G S Dawes,et al.  Baseline in human fetal heart‐rate records , 1982, British journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[22]  João Bernardes,et al.  Comparison of a computer system evaluation of intrapartum cardiotocographic events and a consensus of clinicians , 2010, Journal of perinatal medicine.

[23]  Antoniya Georgieva,et al.  Automated Fetal Heart Rate Analysis in Labor: Decelerations and Overshoots , 2010 .

[24]  Goodlin Rc,et al.  A functional umbilical cord occlusion heart rate pattern. The significance of overshoot. , 1974 .

[25]  J. Waller,et al.  A comparison of visual analyses of intrapartum fetal heart rate tracings according to the new national institute of child health and human development guidelines with computer analyses by an automated fetal heart rate monitoring system. , 2000, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[26]  Antoniya Georgieva,et al.  Computerized fetal heart rate analysis in labor: detection of intervals with un-assignable baseline , 2011, Physiological measurement.

[27]  T. Chung,et al.  Computerised estimation of the baseline fetal heart rate in labour: the low frequency line , 1997, British journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[28]  Janusz Jezewski,et al.  Evaluating the fetal heart rate baseline estimation algorithms by their influence on detection of clinically important patterns , 2016 .

[29]  T. Todros,et al.  Fetal heart rate tracings: observers versus computer assessment. , 1996, European journal of obstetrics, gynecology, and reproductive biology.

[30]  Janusz Jezewski,et al.  Improving fetal heart rate signal interpretation by application of myriad filtering , 2013 .

[31]  Robert G. Orwin,et al.  EVALUATING CODING DECISIONS , 2019, The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis.

[32]  G S Dawes,et al.  Pattern of the normal human fetal heart rate , 1982, British journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[33]  J. Bernardes,et al.  A more objective fetal heart rate baseline estimation , 1996, British journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[34]  J. Low,et al.  Newborn complications after intrapartum asphyxia with metabolic acidosis in the preterm fetus. , 1994, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[35]  D. Ayres-de- Campos,et al.  SisPorto 2.0: a program for automated analysis of cardiotocograms. , 2000, The Journal of maternal-fetal medicine.

[36]  I. Krägeloh-Mann,et al.  Trends in prevalence of cerebral palsy in children born with a birthweight of 2,500 g or over in Europe from 1980 to 1998 , 2010, European Journal of Epidemiology.

[37]  Régis Beuscart,et al.  Fetal Heart Rate Signal Dataset for Training Morphological Analysis Methods and Evaluating them Against an Expert Consensus , 2019 .

[38]  R D Keith,et al.  A multicentre comparative study of 17 experts and an intelligent computer system for managing labour using the cardiotocogram , 1995, British journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[39]  J. M. Swartjes,et al.  Computer analysis of antepartum fetal heart rate: 1. Baseline determination. , 1990, International journal of bio-medical computing.

[40]  C. Van den Broeck,et al.  Prevalence, type, distribution, and severity of cerebral palsy in relation to gestational age: a meta‐analytic review , 2008, Developmental medicine and child neurology.

[41]  J. M. Swartjes,et al.  Computer analysis of antepartum fetal heart rate: 2. Detection of accelerations and decelerations. , 1990, International journal of bio-medical computing.

[42]  M. Delcroix,et al.  Real-time Analysis Of The Fetal Heart Rate , 1990, [1990] Proceedings of the Twelfth Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[43]  L. Tarassenko,et al.  Automated identification of abnormal cardiotocograms using neural network visualization techniques , 2001, 2001 Conference Proceedings of the 23rd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[44]  M. Moulden,et al.  A computer system for the numerical analysis of nonstress tests. , 2002, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[45]  Sarah McIntyre,et al.  A systematic review of risk factors for cerebral palsy in children born at term in developed countries , 2013, Developmental medicine and child neurology.

[46]  P. V. Nielsen,et al.  Computer Assessment of the Intrapartum Cardiotocogram , 1988 .

[47]  J. Higgins,et al.  Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions , 2010, International Coaching Psychology Review.