How we use rules to select actions: A review of evidence from cognitive neuroscience

Much of our behavior is guided by rules, or prescribed guides for action. In this review, I consider the current state of knowledge of how rules are learned, stored in the brain, and retrieved and used as the need arises. The focus is primarily on studies in humans, but the review is informed by relevant studies in nonhuman primates. Ventrolateral prefrontal cortex (VLPFC) has been implicated in rule learning, retrieval from long-term memory, and on-line maintenance during task preparation. Interactions between VLPFC and temporal cortex are required for rule retrieval in nonhuman primates, and brain imaging findings in humans suggest that rule knowledge is stored in the posterior middle temporal gyrus. Dorsolateral PFC appears to be more closely related to rule-based response selection than to rule retrieval. An important task for the future is to explain how PFC, basal ganglia, and temporal, parietal, and motor cortices interact to produce rule-guided behavior.

[1]  B. Milner Effects of Different Brain Lesions on Card Sorting: The Role of the Frontal Lobes , 1963 .

[2]  H. Spinnler The prefrontal cortex, Anatomy, physiology, and neuropsychology of the frontal lobe, J.M. Fuster. Raven Press, New York (1980), IX-222 pages , 1981 .

[3]  Merriam-Webster,et al.  The Merriam Webster Dictionary , 1983 .

[4]  P. Goldman-Rakic,et al.  Mnemonic coding of visual space in the monkey's dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. , 1989, Journal of neurophysiology.

[5]  T. Shallice,et al.  Deficits in strategy application following frontal lobe damage in man. , 1991, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[6]  E. Cabanis,et al.  The Human Brain: Surface, Three-Dimensional Sectional Anatomy and Mri , 1991 .

[7]  M. Goodale,et al.  Separate visual pathways for perception and action , 1992, Trends in Neurosciences.

[8]  J. Cohen,et al.  Context, cortex, and dopamine: a connectionist approach to behavior and biology in schizophrenia. , 1992, Psychological review.

[9]  M. J. Eacott,et al.  Inferotemporal‐frontal Disconnection: The Uncinate Fascicle and Visual Associative Learning in Monkeys , 1992, The European journal of neuroscience.

[10]  J. Fuster,et al.  Mnemonic and predictive functions of cortical neurons in a memory task , 1992, Neuroreport.

[11]  M. Gluck,et al.  Probabilistic classification learning in amnesia. , 1994, Learning & memory.

[12]  D. Perani,et al.  Different neural systems for the recognition of animals and man‐made tools , 1995, Neuroreport.

[13]  A. Shimamura,et al.  Impaired use of organizational strategies in free recall following frontal lobe damage , 1995, Neuropsychologia.

[14]  P. Strick,et al.  Motor areas of the medial wall: a review of their location and functional activation. , 1996, Cerebral cortex.

[15]  D. Pandya,et al.  Comparison of prefrontal architecture and connections. , 1996, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[16]  Jennifer A. Mangels,et al.  A Neostriatal Habit Learning System in Humans , 1996, Science.

[17]  P. Zelazo,et al.  An age-related dissociation between knowing rules and using them ☆ , 1996 .

[18]  M. Hallett,et al.  Frontal and parietal networks for conditional motor learning: a positron emission tomography study. , 1997, Journal of neurophysiology.

[19]  M. Farah,et al.  Role of left inferior prefrontal cortex in retrieval of semantic knowledge: a reevaluation. , 1997, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[20]  M. Petrides Visuo-motor conditional associative learning after frontal and temporal lesions in the human brain , 1997, Neuropsychologia.

[21]  Amanda Parker,et al.  Memory after frontal/temporal disconnection in monkeys: conditional and non-conditional tasks, unilateral and bilateral frontal lesions , 1998, Neuropsychologia.

[22]  E. Miller,et al.  Neural Activity in the Primate Prefrontal Cortex during Associative Learning , 1998, Neuron.

[23]  J. Jonides,et al.  Inhibition in verbal working memory revealed by brain activation. , 1998, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[24]  R. Passingham,et al.  The Time Course of Changes during Motor Sequence Learning: A Whole-Brain fMRI Study , 1998, NeuroImage.

[25]  J. Desmond,et al.  The role of left prefrontal cortex in language and memory. , 1998, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[26]  J. Haxby,et al.  Attribute-based neural substrates in temporal cortex for perceiving and knowing about objects , 1999, Nature Neuroscience.

[27]  S. Wise,et al.  Rule-dependent neuronal activity in the prefrontal cortex , 1999, Experimental Brain Research.

[28]  E. Koechlin,et al.  The role of the anterior prefrontal cortex in human cognition , 1999, Nature.

[29]  J. Desmond,et al.  Functional Specialization for Semantic and Phonological Processing in the Left Inferior Prefrontal Cortex , 1999, NeuroImage.

[30]  Y. Miyashita,et al.  Common inhibitory mechanism in human inferior prefrontal cortex revealed by event-related functional MRI. , 1999, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[31]  Ivan Toni,et al.  Prefrontal-basal ganglia pathways are involved in the learning of arbitrary visuomotor associations: a PET study , 1999, Experimental Brain Research.

[32]  J. Jonides,et al.  Storage and executive processes in the frontal lobes. , 1999, Science.

[33]  K Friston,et al.  Signal-, set- and movement-related activity in the human brain: an event-related fMRI study. , 1999, Cerebral cortex.

[34]  E. Stein,et al.  Right hemispheric dominance of inhibitory control: an event-related functional MRI study. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[35]  E. Miller,et al.  Prospective Coding for Objects in Primate Prefrontal Cortex , 1999, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[36]  Irene P. Kan,et al.  Effects of Repetition and Competition on Activity in Left Prefrontal Cortex during Word Generation , 1999, Neuron.

[37]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Learning-related neuronal responses in prefrontal cortex studied with functional neuroimaging. , 1999, Cerebral cortex.

[38]  R. Passingham,et al.  Specialisation within the prefrontal cortex: the ventral prefrontal cortex and associative learning , 2000, Experimental Brain Research.

[39]  Russell A Poldrack,et al.  Hemispheric asymmetries and individual differences in visual concept learning as measured by functional MRI , 2000, Neuropsychologia.

[40]  E. Zarahn,et al.  The Role of Prefrontal Cortex in Sensory Memory and Motor Preparation: An Event-Related fMRI Study , 2000, NeuroImage.

[41]  T. Bussey,et al.  Role of prefrontal cortex in a network for arbitrary visuomotor mapping , 2000, Experimental Brain Research.

[42]  R. Andersen,et al.  Intention-related activity in the posterior parietal cortex: a review , 2000, Vision Research.

[43]  O. Andreassen,et al.  Mice Deficient in Cellular Glutathione Peroxidase Show Increased Vulnerability to Malonate, 3-Nitropropionic Acid, and 1-Methyl-4-Phenyl-1,2,5,6-Tetrahydropyridine , 2000, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[44]  Marcia K. Johnson,et al.  Left Anterior Prefrontal Activation Increases with Demands to Recall Specific Perceptual Information , 2000, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[45]  J. Cohen,et al.  Dissociating the role of the dorsolateral prefrontal and anterior cingulate cortex in cognitive control. , 2000, Science.

[46]  A. Dove,et al.  Prefrontal cortex activation in task switching: an event-related fMRI study. , 2000, Brain research. Cognitive brain research.

[47]  J. Fuster,et al.  Prefrontal neurons in networks of executive memory , 2000, Brain Research Bulletin.

[48]  J. Gabrieli,et al.  The frontopolar cortex and human cognition: Evidence for a rostrocaudal hierarchical organization within the human prefrontal cortex , 2000, Psychobiology.

[49]  E. Miller,et al.  THE PREFRONTAL CORTEX AND COGNITIVE CONTROL , 2000 .

[50]  E. Miller,et al.  Task-specific neural activity in the primate prefrontal cortex. , 2000, Journal of neurophysiology.

[51]  Y. Miyashita,et al.  Neural representation of visual objects: encoding and top-down activation , 2000, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[52]  James K. Kroger,et al.  Cross-modal and cross-temporal association in neurons of frontal cortex , 2000, Nature.

[53]  R. Passingham,et al.  The prefrontal cortex: response selection or maintenance within working memory? , 2000, 5th IEEE EMBS International Summer School on Biomedical Imaging, 2002..

[54]  J. Tanji,et al.  Neuronal activity in the primate prefrontal cortex in the process of motor selection based on two behavioral rules. , 2000, Journal of neurophysiology.

[55]  E. Miller,et al.  The prefontral cortex and cognitive control , 2000, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[56]  D. Stuss,et al.  Wisconsin Card Sorting Test performance in patients with focal frontal and posterior brain damage: effects of lesion location and test structure on separable cognitive processes , 2000, Neuropsychologia.

[57]  John R. Anderson,et al.  The role of prefrontal cortex and posterior parietal cortex in task switching. , 2000, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[58]  T. Shallice,et al.  The cognitive and neuroanatomical correlates of multitasking , 2000, Neuropsychologia.

[59]  R. Poldrack,et al.  Neural Activation During Response Competition , 2000, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[60]  J. Driver,et al.  Control of Cognitive Processes: Attention and Performance XVIII , 2000 .

[61]  M. Rushworth,et al.  Complementary localization and lateralization of orienting and motor attention , 2001, Nature Neuroscience.

[62]  R. Passingham,et al.  Learning Arbitrary Visuomotor Associations: Temporal Dynamic of Brain Activity , 2001, NeuroImage.

[63]  E. Miller,et al.  An integrative theory of prefrontal cortex function. , 2001, Annual review of neuroscience.

[64]  A. Damasio,et al.  Neural Correlates of Naming Actions and of Naming Spatial Relations , 2001, NeuroImage.

[65]  James B. Rowe,et al.  Working Memory for Location and Time: Activity in Prefrontal Area 46 Relates to Selection Rather than Maintenance in Memory , 2001, NeuroImage.

[66]  P. Strick,et al.  Imaging the premotor areas , 2001, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[67]  N. Cohen,et al.  General and task-specific frontal lobe recruitment in older adults during executive processes: A fMRI investigation of task-switching , 2001, Neuroreport.

[68]  M. Gluck,et al.  Interactive memory systems in the human brain , 2001, Nature.

[69]  A R Damasio,et al.  A Neural Basis for the Retrieval of Words for Actions , 2001, Cognitive neuropsychology.

[70]  Christos Constantinidis,et al.  The sensory nature of mnemonic representation in the primate prefrontal cortex , 2001, Nature Neuroscience.

[71]  C. Frith,et al.  Brain regions involved in prospective memory as determined by positron emission tomography , 2001, Neuropsychologia.

[72]  R. Poldrack,et al.  Recovering Meaning Left Prefrontal Cortex Guides Controlled Semantic Retrieval , 2001, Neuron.

[73]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Anterior prefrontal cortex mediates rule learning in humans. , 2001, Cerebral cortex.

[74]  D. Na,et al.  Functional magnetic resonance imaging during pantomiming tool-use gestures , 2001, Experimental Brain Research.

[75]  L. Squire,et al.  Neuronal representations of stimulus associations develop in the temporal lobe during learning , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[76]  K. C. Anderson,et al.  Single neurons in prefrontal cortex encode abstract rules , 2001, Nature.

[77]  S P Wise,et al.  The role of ventral and orbital prefrontal cortex in conditional visuomotor learning and strategy use in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta). , 2001, Behavioral neuroscience.

[78]  Alex Martin,et al.  Semantic memory and the brain: structure and processes , 2001, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[79]  James B. Rowe,et al.  Dorsal Prefrontal Cortex: Maintenance in Memory or Attentional Selection? , 2002 .

[80]  K. A. Hadland,et al.  Role of the human medial frontal cortex in task switching: a combined fMRI and TMS study. , 2002, Journal of neurophysiology.

[81]  Ching-Yune C. Sylvester,et al.  Evidence for intact semantic representations in patients with frontal lobe lesions. , 2002, Neuropsychology.

[82]  Shintaro Funahashi,et al.  Prefrontal task-related activity representing visual cue location or saccade direction in spatial working memory tasks. , 2002, Journal of neurophysiology.

[83]  B. Knowlton,et al.  Learning and memory functions of the Basal Ganglia. , 2002, Annual review of neuroscience.

[84]  Matthew H. Davis,et al.  Is there an anatomical basis for category-specificity? Semantic memory studies in PET and fMRI , 2002, Neuropsychologia.

[85]  T. Braver,et al.  The Role of Frontopolar Cortex in Subgoal Processing during Working Memory , 2002, NeuroImage.

[86]  Murray Grossman,et al.  The Neural Basis for Category-Specific Knowledge: An fMRI Study , 2002, NeuroImage.

[87]  T. Bussey,et al.  Interaction of ventral and orbital prefrontal cortex with inferotemporal cortex in conditional visuomotor learning. , 2002, Behavioral neuroscience.

[88]  R. Passingham,et al.  Changes of cortico-striatal effective connectivity during visuomotor learning. , 2002, Cerebral cortex.

[89]  K. Berman,et al.  Fractionating the neural substrate of cognitive control processes , 2002, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[90]  T. Braver,et al.  A theory of cognitive control, aging cognition, and neuromodulation , 2002, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews.

[91]  Robert T Knight,et al.  Both random and perseverative errors underlie WCST deficits in prefrontal patients , 2002, Neuropsychologia.

[92]  J. Haxby,et al.  Parallel Visual Motion Processing Streams for Manipulable Objects and Human Movements , 2002, Neuron.

[93]  Eliot Hazeltine,et al.  Dissociable Contributions of Prefrontal and Parietal Cortices to Response Selection , 2002, NeuroImage.

[94]  P. Zelazo,et al.  The balance beam in the balance: reflections on rules, relational complexity, and developmental processes. , 2002, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[95]  M. Brass,et al.  The role of the frontal cortex in task preparation. , 2002, Cerebral cortex.

[96]  Paul J. Reber,et al.  Neural Correlates of Artificial Grammar Learning , 2002, NeuroImage.

[97]  Shintaro Funahashi,et al.  Information Processes in the Primate Prefrontal Cortex in Relation to Working Memory Processes , 2002, Reviews in the neurosciences.

[98]  M. D’Esposito,et al.  Neural implementation of response selection in humans as revealed by localized effects of stimulus–response compatibility on brain activation , 2002, Human brain mapping.

[99]  J. Gabrieli,et al.  Immature Frontal Lobe Contributions to Cognitive Control in Children Evidence from fMRI , 2002, Neuron.

[100]  Marcel Brass,et al.  When the same response has different meanings: recoding the response meaning in the lateral prefrontal cortex , 2003, NeuroImage.

[101]  J. Kounios,et al.  Category-specific medial temporal lobe activation and the consolidation of semantic memory: evidence from fMRI. , 2003, Brain research. Cognitive brain research.

[102]  Jeremy R. Reynolds,et al.  Neural Mechanisms of Transient and Sustained Cognitive Control during Task Switching , 2003, Neuron.

[103]  T. Robbins,et al.  Stop-signal inhibition disrupted by damage to right inferior frontal gyrus in humans , 2003, Nature Neuroscience.

[104]  C. Price,et al.  Functional imaging of the semantic system: Retrieval of sensory-experienced and verbally learned knowledge , 2003, Brain and Language.

[105]  E. Miller,et al.  Neuronal activity in primate dorsolateral and orbital prefrontal cortex during performance of a reward preference task , 2003, The European journal of neuroscience.

[106]  J. Haxby,et al.  fMRI Responses to Video and Point-Light Displays of Moving Humans and Manipulable Objects , 2003, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[107]  M. D’Esposito,et al.  Neural Evidence for Representation-Specific Response Selection , 2003, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[108]  Marcia K. Johnson,et al.  FMRI evidence for an organization of prefrontal cortex by both type of process and type of information. , 2003, Cerebral cortex.

[109]  E. Miller,et al.  Neural circuits subserving the retrieval and maintenance of abstract rules. , 2003, Journal of neurophysiology.

[110]  Lorraine K. Tyler,et al.  Objects and their actions: evidence for a neurally distributed semantic system , 2003, NeuroImage.

[111]  M. Brett,et al.  Actions Speak Louder Than Functions: The Importance of Manipulability and Action in Tool Representation , 2003, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[112]  C. Curtis,et al.  Persistent activity in the prefrontal cortex during working memory , 2003, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[113]  C. Pierrot-Deseilligny,et al.  Decisional role of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in ocular motor behaviour. , 2003, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[114]  John Jonides,et al.  Dissociable neural mechanisms underlying response-based and familiarity-based conflict in working memory , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[115]  S. Thompson-Schill Neuroimaging studies of semantic memory: inferring “how” from “where” , 2003, Neuropsychologia.

[116]  Thomas E. Nichols,et al.  Switching attention and resolving interference: fMRI measures of executive functions , 2003, Neuropsychologia.

[117]  Bertram Opitz,et al.  Interactions of the hippocampal system and the prefrontal cortex in learning language-like rules , 2003, NeuroImage.

[118]  R. Passingham,et al.  Prefrontal interactions reflect future task operations , 2003, Nature Neuroscience.

[119]  A. Wagner,et al.  Prefrontal and hippocampal contributions to visual associative recognition: Interactions between cognitive control and episodic retrieval , 2004, Brain and Cognition.

[120]  Karen Emmorey,et al.  Motor-iconicity of sign language does not alter the neural systems underlying tool and action naming , 2004, Brain and Language.

[121]  T. Robbins,et al.  Inhibition and the right inferior frontal cortex , 2004, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[122]  John J. Foxe,et al.  Predicting Success: Patterns of Cortical Activation and Deactivation Prior to Response Inhibition , 2004, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[123]  M. Brass,et al.  Decomposing Components of Task Preparation with Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging , 2004, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[124]  K. R. Ridderinkhof,et al.  Neurocognitive mechanisms of cognitive control: The role of prefrontal cortex in action selection, response inhibition, performance monitoring, and reward-based learning , 2004, Brain and Cognition.

[125]  Jan Derrfuss,et al.  Cognitive control in the posterior frontolateral cortex: evidence from common activations in task coordination, interference control, and working memory , 2004, NeuroImage.

[126]  M. Gluck,et al.  Cortico-striatal contributions to feedback-based learning: converging data from neuroimaging and neuropsychology. , 2004, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[127]  P. Goldman-Rakic,et al.  Comparison of human infants and rhesus monkeys on Piaget's AB task: evidence for dependence on dorsolateral prefrontal cortex , 2004, Experimental Brain Research.

[128]  Vinod Goel,et al.  Asymmetrical involvement of frontal lobes in social reasoning. , 2004, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[129]  A. Owen,et al.  Anterior prefrontal cortex: insights into function from anatomy and neuroimaging , 2004, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[130]  R. Adolphs,et al.  Neural systems behind word and concept retrieval , 2004, Cognition.

[131]  Anthony D. Wagner,et al.  Cognitive Control, Semantic Memory, and Priming: Contributions from Prefrontal Cortex. , 2004 .

[132]  Joan Y. Chiao,et al.  An Event-related fMRI Study of Artificial Grammar Learning in a Balanced Chunk Strength Design , 2004, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[133]  D. Plaut,et al.  Doing without schema hierarchies: a recurrent connectionist approach to normal and impaired routine sequential action. , 2004, Psychological review.

[134]  Eveline A. Crone,et al.  Retrieving rules for behavior from long-term memory , 2005, NeuroImage.

[135]  David Badre,et al.  Analogical reasoning and prefrontal cortex: evidence for separable retrieval and integration mechanisms. , 2004, Cerebral cortex.

[136]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  The prefrontal cortex shows context-specific changes in effective connectivity to motor or visual cortex during the selection of action or colour. , 2004, Cerebral cortex.