The Details in the Distributions: Why and How to Study Phenotypic Variability This Review Comes from a Themed Issue on Systems Biology Experimental Methods for Studying Phenotypic Variability within Genotype Variability between Genotype Variation between Plate Technical Variation between Environment

Phenotypic variability is present even when genetic and environmental differences between cells are reduced to the greatest possible extent. For example, genetically identical bacteria display differing levels of resistance to antibiotics, clonal yeast populations demonstrate morphological and growth-rate heterogeneity, and mouse blastomeres from the same embryo have stochastic differences in gene expression. However, the distributions of phenotypes present among isogenic organisms are often overlooked; instead, many studies focus on population aggregates such as the mean. The details of these distributions are relevant to major questions in diverse fields, including the evolution of antimicrobial-drug and chemotherapy resistance. We review emerging experimental and statistical techniques that allow rigorous analysis of phenotypic variability and thereby may lead to advances across the biological sciences.

[1]  Sasha F. Levy,et al.  Network Hubs Buffer Environmental Variation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae , 2008, PLoS biology.

[2]  Orkun S. Soyer,et al.  Bistability in feedback circuits as a byproduct of evolution of evolvability , 2012, Molecular systems biology.

[3]  R. Milo,et al.  Dynamic Proteomics of Individual Cancer Cells in Response to a Drug , 2008, Science.

[4]  Davis J. McCarthy,et al.  Differential expression analysis of multifactor RNA-Seq experiments with respect to biological variation , 2012, Nucleic acids research.

[5]  Joel Eriksson,et al.  FTO genotype is associated with phenotypic variability of body mass index , 2012, Nature.

[6]  S. Lindquist,et al.  Hsp90 as a capacitor of phenotypic variation , 2002, Nature.

[7]  Yoshikazu Ohya,et al.  Multidimensional quantification of subcellular morphology of Saccharomyces cerevisiae using CalMorph, the high-throughput image-processing program. , 2009, Journal of biotechnology.

[8]  David A. Rand,et al.  Measurement of single-cell dynamics , 2010, Nature.

[9]  E. O’Shea,et al.  Living with noisy genes: how cells function reliably with inherent variability in gene expression. , 2007, Annual review of biophysics and biomolecular structure.

[10]  Sasha F. Levy,et al.  The robustness continuum. , 2012, Advances in experimental medicine and biology.

[11]  Shinichi Nakagawa,et al.  Repeatability for Gaussian and non‐Gaussian data: a practical guide for biologists , 2010, Biological reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society.

[12]  W. Valdar,et al.  Detecting Major Genetic Loci Controlling Phenotypic Variability in Experimental Crosses , 2011, Genetics.

[13]  M. Thattai,et al.  Stochastic Gene Expression in Fluctuating Environments , 2004, Genetics.

[14]  R. Carvalheiro,et al.  Genetic and environmental heterogeneity of residual variance of weight traits in Nellore beef cattle , 2012, Genetics Selection Evolution.

[15]  Bo Kara,et al.  Studies related to antibody fragment (Fab) production in Escherichia coli W3110 fed‐batch fermentation processes using multiparameter flow cytometry , 2009, Cytometry. Part A : the journal of the International Society for Analytical Cytology.

[16]  J. Giovannoni,et al.  Uniform ripening Encodes a Golden 2-like Transcription Factor Regulating Tomato Fruit Chloroplast Development , 2012, Science.

[17]  J. Derisi,et al.  Single-cell proteomic analysis of S. cerevisiae reveals the architecture of biological noise , 2006, Nature.

[18]  M. Feldman,et al.  Evolution of Stochastic Switching Rates in Asymmetric Fitness Landscapes , 2009, Genetics.

[19]  Thomas Bley,et al.  Origin and analysis of microbial population heterogeneity in bioprocesses. , 2010, Current opinion in biotechnology.

[20]  William Valdar,et al.  Recent developments in statistical methods for detecting genetic loci affecting phenotypic variability , 2012, BMC Genetics.

[21]  Maya Schuldiner,et al.  Getting the whole picture: combining throughput with content in microscopy , 2011, Journal of Cell Science.

[22]  J. Marioni,et al.  Inferring the kinetics of stochastic gene expression from single-cell RNA-sequencing data , 2013, Genome Biology.

[23]  S. Leibler,et al.  Phenotypic Diversity, Population Growth, and Information in Fluctuating Environments , 2005, Science.

[24]  P. Sorger,et al.  Non-genetic origins of cell-to-cell variability in TRAIL-induced apoptosis , 2009, Nature.

[25]  Alexander van Oudenaarden,et al.  Variability in gene expression underlies incomplete penetrance , 2009, Nature.

[26]  Guy S. Salvesen,et al.  SnapShot: Caspases , 2011, Cell.

[27]  A. Oudenaarden,et al.  Nature, Nurture, or Chance: Stochastic Gene Expression and Its Consequences , 2008, Cell.

[28]  S. Collins,et al.  Comprehensive Characterization of Genes Required for Protein Folding in the Endoplasmic Reticulum , 2009, Science.

[29]  Nir Friedman,et al.  Exploring transcription regulation through cell-to-cell variability , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[30]  Jan Vijg,et al.  Increased cell-to-cell variation in gene expression in ageing mouse heart , 2006, Nature.

[31]  G. H. Jacobs.  Evolution of colour vision in mammals , 2009, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[32]  P. Benfey,et al.  High-throughput phenotyping of multicellular organisms: finding the link between genotype and phenotype , 2011, Genome Biology.

[33]  Hana El-Samad,et al.  Cellular noise regulons underlie fluctuations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. , 2012, Molecular cell.

[34]  Steven A. Frank,et al.  Nonheritable Cellular Variability Accelerates the Evolutionary Processes of Cancer , 2012, PLoS biology.

[35]  S. Frank,et al.  Genotypically diverse cultivar mixtures for insect pest management and increased crop yields , 2012 .

[36]  J. François,et al.  Cell-to-Cell Stochastic Variation in Gene Expression Is a Complex Genetic Trait , 2008, PLoS genetics.

[37]  Daniel J. Kliebenstein,et al.  Genomic Analysis of QTLs and Genes Altering Natural Variation in Stochastic Noise , 2011, PLoS genetics.

[38]  W. Ratcliff,et al.  Individual-Level Bet Hedging in the Bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti , 2010, Current Biology.

[39]  T. Mackay,et al.  Drosophila bristles and the nature of quantitative genetic variation , 2005, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[40]  P. Liberali,et al.  Population context determines cell-to-cell variability in endocytosis and virus infection , 2009, Nature.

[41]  Arun K. Ramani,et al.  The Majority of Animal Genes Are Required for Wild-Type Fitness , 2012, Cell.

[42]  Robert P. St.Onge,et al.  The Chemical Genomic Portrait of Yeast: Uncovering a Phenotype for All Genes , 2008, Science.

[43]  Mats E. Pettersson,et al.  Inheritance Beyond Plain Heritability: Variance-Controlling Genes in Arabidopsis thaliana , 2012, PLoS genetics.

[44]  C. Conrad,et al.  Automated microscopy for high-content RNAi screening , 2010, The Journal of cell biology.

[45]  S. Pääbo,et al.  Gene expression becomes heterogeneous with age , 2006, Current Biology.

[46]  Joanna Masel,et al.  The evolution of bet-hedging adaptations to rare scenarios. , 2007, Theoretical population biology.

[47]  T. Mikkelsen,et al.  Genome-wide maps of chromatin state in pluripotent and lineage-committed cells , 2007, Nature.

[48]  Caroline Lee,et al.  Deterministic and Stochastic Allele Specific Gene Expression in Single Mouse Blastomeres , 2011, PloS one.

[49]  Greg Gibson,et al.  Decanalization and the origin of complex disease , 2009, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[50]  R. Barlow,et al.  Heterogeneity of Genetic Modifiers Ensures Normal Cardiac Development , 2010, Circulation.

[51]  Catalin C. Barbacioru,et al.  Tracing the Derivation of Embryonic Stem Cells from the Inner Cell Mass by Single-Cell RNA-Seq Analysis , 2010, Cell stem cell.

[52]  Gordon K. Smyth,et al.  Generalized linear models with varying dispersion , 1989 .

[53]  E. O’Shea,et al.  Noise in protein expression scales with natural protein abundance , 2006, Nature Genetics.

[54]  Sasha F. Levy,et al.  Bet Hedging in Yeast by Heterogeneous, Age-Correlated Expression of a Stress Protectant , 2012, PLoS biology.

[55]  I. Dworkin.  Canalization, Cryptic Variation, and Developmental Buffering: A Critical Examination and Analytical Perspective , 2005 .

[56]  Claude Desplan,et al.  Stochasticity and Cell Fate , 2008, Science.

[57]  Moudud Alam,et al.  hglm: A Package for Fitting Hierarchical Generalized Linear Models , 2010, R J..

[58]  Catalin C. Barbacioru,et al.  RNA-Seq analysis to capture the transcriptome landscape of a single cell , 2010, Nature Protocols.

[59]  Edward R Sumner,et al.  Phenotypic heterogeneity can enhance rare‐cell survival in ‘stress‐sensitive’ yeast populations , 2007, Molecular microbiology.

[60]  I. Cleasby,et al.  A behavioural ecologist's guide to co-operating with heteroscedasticity , 2011 .

[61]  Mehmet Toner,et al.  Asymmetry and Aging of Mycobacterial Cells Lead to Variable Growth and Antibiotic Susceptibility , 2012, Science.

[62]  Jerome T. Mettetal,et al.  Stochastic switching as a survival strategy in fluctuating environments , 2008, Nature Genetics.

[63]  Alexander Roesch,et al.  A Temporarily Distinct Subpopulation of Slow-Cycling Melanoma Cells Is Required for Continuous Tumor Growth , 2010, Cell.

[64]  Pawel Zajac,et al.  Highly multiplexed and strand-specific single-cell RNA 5′ end sequencing , 2012, Nature Protocols.

[65]  Shinichi Nakagawa,et al.  Neglected biological patterns in the residuals , 2011, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology.

[66]  Timothy K Lee,et al.  Single-cell NF-κB dynamics reveal digital activation and analogue information processing , 2010, Nature.

[67]  M. Kanter.  Review: statistical issues that commonly arise in studying Wood group serology , 1996, Immunohematology.

[68]  Ben S. Wittner,et al.  A Chromatin-Mediated Reversible Drug-Tolerant State in Cancer Cell Subpopulations , 2010, Cell.

[69]  James J. Cai,et al.  Genetic Variants Contribute to Gene Expression Variability in Humans , 2013, Genetics.

[70]  M. Purugganan,et al.  Genetics of microenvironmental canalization in Arabidopsis thaliana , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[71]  Mollie E. Brooks,et al.  Generalized linear mixed models: a practical guide for ecology and evolution. , 2009, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[72]  M. Elowitz,et al.  Functional roles for noise in genetic circuits , 2010, Nature.

[73]  Eric E. Schadt,et al.  The Quantitative Genetics of Phenotypic Robustness , 2010, PloS one.

[74]  A. Blomberg.  Measuring growth rate in high-throughput growth phenotyping. , 2011, Current opinion in biotechnology.

[75]  H. Vehviläinen,et al.  Genetics of Microenvironmental Sensitivity of Body Weight in Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) Selected for Improved Growth , 2012, PloS one.

[76]  Y. Okada,et al.  DEFICIENCY SCREENING FOR GENOMIC REGIONS WITH EFFECTS ON ENVIRONMENTAL SENSITIVITY OF THE SENSORY BRISTLES OF DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER , 2012, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[77]  Sean C. Bendall,et al.  From single cells to deep phenotypes in cancer , 2012, Nature Biotechnology.

[78]  Jeffrey W. Smith,et al.  Stochastic Gene Expression in a Single Cell , 2022 .

[79]  Paul M. Ridker,et al.  On the Use of Variance per Genotype as a Tool to Identify Quantitative Trait Interaction Effects: A Report from the Women's Genome Health Study , 2010, PLoS genetics.