Reliability of treadmill testing in peripheral arterial disease: a meta-regression analysis.

OBJECTIVE A meta-regression analysis was conducted to identify the most reliable treadmill protocol for the assessment of patients with peripheral arterial disease (PAD). BACKGROUND Treadmill testing is the main assessment method to evaluate walking ability in patients with PAD in clinical studies. Reported treadmill protocols are continuous (C) and graded (G) protocols and outcome measurements are initial claudication distance (ICD) and absolute claudication distance (ACD). Variety in protocols might hamper the ability to compare results of different studies. Ideally, future studies should use a protocol with highest reliability. METHODS We searched PubMed and EMBASE (until February 2008) and we hand searched the reference lists. Trials assessing reliability of treadmill testing were identified. Inclusion criteria were the use of a C- or G-protocol, repetition of this protocol, and a retrievable intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). We identified eight studies in which 658 patients were included. RESULTS For ICD, the estimated reliabilities of the C- and G-protocol (as assessed by the ICC) were 0.85 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.82-0.88) and 0.83 (95% CI: 0.80-0.85), respectively, without dependency of the reliability on velocity or grade. For ACD, the reliability was significantly better for the G-protocol (0.95, 95% CI: 0.94-0.96) than for the C-protocol. Moreover, the reliability of the C-protocol was dependent on grade of the treadmill (0%, 10%, and 12%) with a mean ICC of 0.76 (95% CI: 0.54-0.88), 0.89 (95% CI: 0.86-0.91), and 0.91 (95% CI 0.88-0.92), respectively. CONCLUSION Treadmill assessment has the highest reliability when using a G-protocol together with the ACD as the primary outcome measure.

[1]  S. Rosfors,et al.  Transcutaneous oxygen pressure measurements in patients with intermittent claudication. , 1994, Clinical physiology.

[2]  J. Skinner,et al.  Effects of handrail support on claudication and hemodynamic responses to single-stage and progressive treadmill protocols in peripheral vascular occlusive disease. , 1991, The American journal of cardiology.

[3]  M. Aschwanden,et al.  Reproducibility of constant-load treadmill testing with various treadmill protocols and predictability of treadmill test results in patients with intermittent claudication. , 2002, Journal of vascular surgery.

[4]  A. Gardner,et al.  The Clinical Utility of a Six‐Minute Walk Test in Peripheral Arterial Occlusive Disease Patients , 1998, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[5]  J. Skinner,et al.  Comparison of Three Progressive Exercise Protocols in Peripheral Vascular Occlusive Disease , 1992, Angiology.

[6]  A. Gardner.  Reliability of Transcutaneous Oximeter Electrode Heating Power During Exercise in Patients with Intermittent Claudication , 1997, Angiology.

[7]  J. Colt.  A Reproducible Treadmill Test for Intermittent Claudication , 1971, Angiology.

[8]  J. Siggaard-Andersen,et al.  Intermittent Claudication , 1968, Angiology.

[9]  K. McGraw,et al.  Forming inferences about some intraclass correlation coefficients. , 1996 .

[10]  R. Greenhalgh,et al.  Treadmill testing in the assessment of peripheral arterial disease. , 1986, International angiology : a journal of the International Union of Angiology.

[11]  J. Skinner,et al.  Comparison of Treadmill Walking and Stair Climbing Over a Range of Exercise Intensities in Peripheral Vascular Occlusive Disease , 1993, Angiology.

[12]  C. Clyne,et al.  The reproducibility of the treadmill walking test for claudication. , 1979, Surgery, gynecology & obstetrics.

[13]  Allan Donner,et al.  Testing the equality of dependent intraclass correlation coefficients , 2002 .

[14]  M. Cachovan,et al.  Guidelines for therapeutic studies in Fontaine's stages II-IV peripheral arterial occlusive disease. German Society of Angiology. , 1995, VASA. Zeitschrift fur Gefasskrankheiten.

[15]  L. Hillestad.  The peripheral blood flow in intermittent claudication. IV. The significance of the claudication distance. , 2009, Acta medica Scandinavica.

[16]  I. Kirchberger,et al.  Relevance of claudication pain distance in patients with peripheral arterial occlusive disease. , 1999, VASA. Zeitschrift fur Gefasskrankheiten.

[17]  D. Duprez,et al.  Estimation of walking distance in intermittent claudication: need for standardization. , 1999, European heart journal.

[18]  L. Hands,et al.  A comparative study of treadmill tests and heel raising exercise for peripheral arterial disease. , 1997, European journal of vascular and endovascular surgery : the official journal of the European Society for Vascular Surgery.

[19]  A. Gardner,et al.  Exercise performance in patients with peripheral arterial disease who have different types of exertional leg pain. , 2007, Journal of vascular surgery.

[20]  J. Guralnik,et al.  Measurement of walking endurance and walking velocity with questionnaire: validation of the walking impairment questionnaire in men and women with peripheral arterial disease. , 1998, Journal of vascular surgery.

[21]  L. Hands,et al.  Claudication distance is poorly estimated and inappropriately measured , 1997, The British journal of surgery.

[22]  K. Jaeger,et al.  Transatlantic Conference on Clinical Trial Guidelines in Peripheral Arterial Disease: clinical trial methodology. Basel PAD Clinical Trial Methodology Group. , 1999, Circulation.

[23]  R. Hamman,et al.  Effect of diagnostic criteria on the prevalence of peripheral arterial disease. The San Luis Valley Diabetes Study. , 1995, Circulation.

[24]  W. Hiatt,et al.  Optimal assessment of baseline treadmill walking performance in claudication clinical trials , 2007, Vascular medicine.

[25]  F. Kajiya,et al.  Prolonged diastolic time fraction protects myocardial perfusion when coronary blood flow is reduced. , 1999, Circulation.

[26]  M. Prins,et al.  The walking impairment questionnaire: an effective tool to assess the effect of treatment in patients with intermittent claudication. , 2009, Journal of vascular surgery.

[27]  D. Hosmer,et al.  Maximal oxygen intake and nomographic assessment of functional aerobic impairment in cardiovascular disease. , 1973, American heart journal.

[28]  F. Lindgärde,et al.  The Pentoxifylline Experience: Exercise Testing Reconsidered , 1996, Vascular medicine.

[29]  A. Dyer,et al.  Corridor-based functional performance measures correlate better with physical activity during daily life than treadmill measures in persons with peripheral arterial disease. , 2008, Journal of vascular surgery.

[30]  B. Berglund,et al.  Reproducibility of treadmill exercise in patients with intermittent claudication. , 1981, Clinical physiology.

[31]  H. Tikkanen,et al.  Poor reproducibility of exercise test in assessment of claudication. , 1998, Clinical physiology.

[32]  Petersen Fb.  The effects of varying walking speeds when measuring the claudication distance on horizontal and sloping levels. , 1967 .

[33]  J. Dormandy,et al.  Comparison of Graded versus Constant Treadmill Test Protocols for Quantifying Intermittent Claudication , 1997, Vascular medicine.

[34]  M C Lancaster,et al.  A comparison of the reproducibility and physiologic response to three maximal treadmill exercise protocols. , 1974, Chest.

[35]  J. Skinner,et al.  Progressive vs single-stage treadmill tests for evaluation of claudication. , 1991, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[36]  Pierre Abraham,et al.  Measurement of Walking Distance and Speed in Patients With Peripheral Arterial Disease: A Novel Method Using a Global Positioning System , 2008, Circulation.

[37]  H. Figulla,et al.  Exercise capacity and Doppler pressure measurements in symptomatic peripheral arterial obstructive disease. , 2002, VASA. Zeitschrift fur Gefasskrankheiten.

[38]  K. Jaeger,et al.  Reliability of treadmill testing in peripheral arterial disease: a comparison of a constant load with a graded load treadmill protocol , 1999, Vascular medicine.

[39]  The Stresst'er ergometer as an alternative to treadmill testing in patients with claudication. , 1997, European journal of vascular and endovascular surgery : the official journal of the European Society for Vascular Surgery.

[40]  C E Metz,et al.  Critical evaluation of stress testing in the diagnosis of peripheral vascular disease. , 1982, Surgery.

[41]  R. Fisher.  Statistical methods for research workers , 1927, Protoplasma.

[42]  M. Cachovan,et al.  Randomized Reliability Study Evaluating Constant-load and Graded-exercise Treadmill Test for Intermittent Claudication , 1999, Angiology.

[43]  K. Harris,et al.  A single treadmill exercise test does not accurately quantitate claudication. , 1987, Canadian journal of surgery. Journal canadien de chirurgie.

[44]  D. A. Pereira,et al.  The Reliability of Walking Tests in People with Claudication , 2007, American journal of physical medicine & rehabilitation.

[45]  P. Thompson,et al.  ACSM's Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription , 1995 .

[46]  L. Hillestad.  THE PERIPHERAL BLOOD FLOW IN INTERMITTENT CLAUDICATION. VI. PLETHYSMOGRAPHIC STUDIES. THE BLOOD FLOW RESPONSE TO EXERCISE WITH ARRESTED AND WITH FREE CIRCULATION. , 2009, Acta medica Scandinavica.

[47]  R. Lee Kirby,et al.  Reliability of Walking Endurance with an Incremental Treadmill Test , 1987, Angiology.

[48]  K. Johnston,et al.  Reproducibility of noninvasive vascular laboratory measurements of the peripheral circulation. , 1987, Journal of vascular surgery.

[49]  J. Regensteiner,et al.  The Evaluation of Exercise Performance in Patients with Peripheral Vascular Disease , 1988 .

[50]  Comparison of ramp versus step protocols for exercise testing in patients > or = 60 years of age. , 1999, The American journal of cardiology.

[51]  A. Gardner,et al.  Practical Equations to Predict Claudication Pain Distances from a Graded Treadmill Test , 1996, Vascular medicine.

[52]  Comparison of two progressive treadmill tests in patients with peripheral arterial disease , 2001, Vascular medicine.

[53]  J. Saxton,et al.  Treadmill versus shuttle walk tests of walking ability in intermittent claudication. , 2004, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[54]  R Cristol,et al.  [Evaluation of intermittent claudication using a treadmill with measurement of systolic pressure at the ankle following exercise]. , 1985, Journal des maladies vasculaires.

[55]  R. Kester,et al.  A new device for the measurement of disease severity in patients with intermittent claudication. , 2001, European journal of vascular and endovascular surgery : the official journal of the European Society for Vascular Surgery.