A Survey of Systematic Evidence Mapping Practice and the Case for Knowledge Graphs in Environmental Health and Toxicology

Abstract Systematic evidence mapping offers a robust and transparent methodology for facilitating evidence-based approaches to decision-making in chemicals policy and wider environmental health (EH). Interest in the methodology is growing; however, its application in EH is still novel. To facilitate the production of effective systematic evidence maps for EH use cases, we survey the successful application of evidence mapping in other fields where the methodology is more established. Focusing on issues of “data storage technology,” “data integrity,” “data accessibility,” and “transparency,” we characterize current evidence mapping practice and critically review its potential value for EH contexts. We note that rigid, flat data tables and schema-first approaches dominate current mapping methods and highlight how this practice is ill-suited to the highly connected, heterogeneous, and complex nature of EH data. We propose this challenge is overcome by storing and structuring data as “knowledge graphs.” Knowledge graphs offer a flexible, schemaless, and scalable model for systematically mapping the EH literature. Associated technologies, such as ontologies, are well-suited to the long-term goals of systematic mapping methodology in promoting resource-efficient access to the wider EH evidence base. Several graph storage implementations are readily available, with a variety of proven use cases in other fields. Thus, developing and adapting systematic evidence mapping for EH should utilize these graph-based resources to ensure the production of scalable, interoperable, and robust maps to aid decision-making processes in chemicals policy and wider EH.

[1]  Jimmy J. Lin,et al.  WTF: the who to follow service at Twitter , 2013, WWW.

[2]  P D Karp,et al.  Database links are a foundation for interoperability. , 1996, Trends in biotechnology.

[3]  Dieter Gawlick,et al.  Management of Flexible Schema Data in RDBMSs - Opportunities and Limitations for NoSQL - , 2015, CIDR.

[4]  David Makowski,et al.  Weight of Evidence for Hazard Identification: A Critical Review of the Literature , 2018, Environmental health perspectives.

[5]  Snezana Mladenovic,et al.  Schema on Read Modeling Approach as a Basis of Big Data Analytics Integration with EIS , 2017 .

[6]  Ken Sexton,et al.  Assessing Cumulative Health Risks from Exposure to Environmental Mixtures—Three Fundamental Questions , 2007, Environmental health perspectives.

[7]  Yu-Mei Tan,et al.  Adverse Outcome Pathways—Organizing Toxicological Information to Improve Decision Making , 2016, The Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics.

[8]  Lars Juhl Jensen,et al.  Are graph databases ready for bioinformatics? , 2013, Bioinform..

[9]  Reinhard Schneider,et al.  Using graph theory to analyze biological networks , 2011, BioData Mining.

[10]  Michel C. A. Klein,et al.  Ontology Evolution: Not the Same as Schema Evolution , 2004, Knowledge and Information Systems.

[11]  V. Johnson,et al.  WHAT IS THE EVIDENCE THAT SCARCITY AND SHOCKS IN FRESHWATER RESOURCES CAUSE CONFLICT INSTEAD OF PROMOTING COLLABORATION , 2011 .

[12]  David Styles,et al.  Evidence on the environmental impacts of farm land abandonment in high altitude/mountain regions: a systematic map , 2014, Environmental Evidence.

[13]  M. Lindvall,et al.  Knowledge management in software engineering , 2002, IEEE Software.

[14]  T Hartung,et al.  Toward an evidence-based toxicology , 2006, Human & experimental toxicology.

[15]  Andrew S. Pullin,et al.  ROSES RepOrting standards for Systematic Evidence Syntheses: pro forma, flow-diagram and descriptive summary of the plan and conduct of environmental systematic reviews and systematic maps , 2018, Environmental Evidence.

[16]  Leah H. Samberg,et al.  Does the gender composition of forest and fishery management groups affect resource governance and conservation outcomes? A systematic map , 2016, Environmental Evidence.

[17]  A. Green,et al.  An international database for pesticide risk assessments and management , 2016 .

[18]  Leah H. Samberg,et al.  Does the gender composition of forest and fishery management groups affect resource governance and conservation outcomes: a systematic map protocol , 2015, Environmental Evidence.

[19]  Terry Burke,et al.  The fitness consequences of inbreeding in natural populations and their implications for species conservation – a systematic map , 2015, Environmental Evidence.

[20]  Louise M. Donnison,et al.  How effective are on-farm mitigation measures for delivering an improved water environment? A systematic map , 2015, Environmental Evidence.

[21]  Emanuele Lugato,et al.  What are the effects of agricultural management on soil organic carbon in boreo-temperate systems? , 2015, Environmental Evidence.

[22]  Jesse Weaver,et al.  Facebook Linked Data via the Graph API , 2013, Semantic Web.

[23]  Neal R Haddaway,et al.  The benefits of systematic mapping to evidence-based environmental management , 2016, Ambio.

[24]  Nicola Randall,et al.  The effectiveness of integrated farm management, organic farming and agri-environment schemes for conserving biodiversity in temperate Europe - A systematic map , 2012, Environmental Evidence.

[25]  M. Ashburner,et al.  Gene Ontology: tool for the unification of biology , 2000, Nature Genetics.

[26]  John D. Walker,et al.  Quantitative structure–activity relationships (QSARs) in toxicology: a historical perspective , 2003 .

[27]  S. Oliver,et al.  Policy-Relevant Systematic Reviews to Strengthen Health Systems: Models and Mechanisms to Support Their Production. , 2016 .

[28]  What evidence exists for the effectiveness of on-farm conservation land management strategies for preserving ecosystem services in developing countries? A systematic map , 2016, Environmental Evidence.

[29]  Vera Rogiers,et al.  Adverse outcome pathways: hype or hope? , 2013, Archives of Toxicology.

[30]  Imran Shah,et al.  Toxicology ontology perspectives. , 2012, ALTEX.

[31]  J. Müller,et al.  What is the impact of active management on biodiversity in boreal and temperate forests set aside for conservation or restoration? A systematic map , 2015, Environmental Evidence.

[32]  Neal R. Haddaway,et al.  A methodology for systematic mapping in environmental sciences , 2016, Environmental Evidence.

[33]  A. Pullin,et al.  What evidence exists on the impact of governance type on the conservation effectiveness of forest protected areas? Knowledge base and evidence gaps , 2015, Environmental Evidence.

[34]  Tharam S. Dillon,et al.  Differentiating Conceptual Modelling from Data Modelling, Knowledge Modelling and Ontology Modelling and a Notation for Ontology Modelling , 2008, APCCM.

[35]  Katherine E Pelch,et al.  Environmental Chemicals and Autism: A Scoping Review of the Human and Animal Research , 2019, Environmental health perspectives.

[36]  Antonio Finizio,et al.  A New Online Database on Chemicals in Accordance with REACH Regulation , 2013 .

[37]  Ocspp,et al.  The Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act , 2016 .

[38]  Doina Caragea,et al.  Graph Databases , 2019, Encyclopedia of Big Data Technologies.

[39]  Esteban Zimányi,et al.  GRAD: On Graph Database Modeling , 2016, ArXiv.

[40]  Gábor L. Lövei,et al.  Application of Systematic Review Methodology to Food and Feed Safety Assessments to Support Decision Making , 2010 .

[41]  Neal R Haddaway,et al.  The multifunctional roles of vegetated strips around and within agricultural fields , 2018, Environmental Evidence.

[42]  Anne Laurent,et al.  Rogue behavior detection in NoSQL graph databases , 2016, J. Innov. Digit. Ecosyst..

[43]  Julie E Goodman,et al.  A primer on systematic reviews in toxicology , 2017, Archives of Toxicology.

[44]  Mary L. Lyndon Information Economics and Chemical Toxicity: Designing Laws to Produce and Use Data , 1989 .

[45]  Laura N. Vandenberg,et al.  A proposed framework for the systematic review and integrated assessment (SYRINA) of endocrine disrupting chemicals , 2016, Environmental Health.

[46]  Marlene Ågerstrand,et al.  Transparency of chemical risk assessment data under REACH. , 2016, Environmental science. Processes & impacts.

[47]  R. Watt,et al.  Rethinking communication: integrating storytelling for increased stakeholder engagement in environmental evidence synthesis , 2018, Environmental Evidence.

[48]  Melissa Rodriguez Zynda The first killer app: a history of spreadsheets , 2013, INTR.

[49]  Bruce Blumberg,et al.  Endocrine disrupting chemicals , 2011, The Journal of Steroid Biochemistry and Molecular Biology.

[51]  Katherine E Pelch,et al.  Human and animal evidence of potential transgenerational inheritance of health effects: An evidence map and state-of-the-science evaluation. , 2018, Environment international.

[52]  D. Green,et al.  Misled about lead: an assessment of online public health education material from Australia’s lead mining and smelting towns , 2016, Environmental Health.

[53]  Jean-Paul A. Barthès,et al.  Knowledge Management , 1994, Encyclopedia of Database Systems.

[54]  Peng Liang,et al.  Knowledge-based approaches in software documentation: A systematic literature review , 2014, Inf. Softw. Technol..

[55]  Ruth Garside,et al.  What are the effects of nature conservation on human well-being? A systematic map of empirical evidence from developing countries , 2016, Environmental Evidence.

[56]  Richard A. Becker,et al.  A survey of frameworks for best practices in weight-of-evidence analyses , 2013, Critical reviews in toxicology.

[57]  R. Pool,et al.  Identifying and reducing environmental health risks of chemicals in our society. Workshop Summary. , 2014 .

[58]  Paul Whaley,et al.  Systematic evidence maps as a novel tool to support evidence-based decision-making in chemicals policy and risk management , 2019, Environment international.

[59]  B. Ádám,et al.  WHO/ILO work-related burden of disease and injury: Protocol for systematic reviews of occupational exposure to dusts and/or fibres and of the effect of occupational exposure to dusts and/or fibres on pneumoconiosis. , 2018, Environment international.

[60]  James E. Rumbaugh,et al.  Relational database design using an object-oriented methodology , 1988, CACM.

[61]  Katherine E Pelch,et al.  PFAS health effects database: Protocol for a systematic evidence map. , 2019, Environment international.

[62]  Charu C. Aggarwal,et al.  Managing and Mining Graph Data , 2010, Managing and Mining Graph Data.