Factors Determining the Agreement between Aerobic Threshold and Point of Maximal Fat Oxidation: Follow-Up on a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on Association

Regular exercise at the intensity matching maximal fat oxidation (FATmax) has been proposed as a key element in both athletes and clinical populations when aiming to enhance the body’s ability to oxidize fat. In order to allow a more standardized and tailored training approach, the connection between FATmax and the individual aerobic thresholds (AerT) has been examined. Although recent findings strongly suggest that a relationship exists between these two intensities, correlation alone is not sufficient to confirm that the intensities necessarily coincide and that the error between the two measures is small. Thus, this systematic review and meta-analysis aim to examine the agreement levels between the exercise intensities matching FATmax and AerT by pooling limits of agreement in a function of three parameters: (i) the average difference, (ii) the average within-study variation, and (iii) the variation in bias across studies, and to examine the influence of clinical and methodological inter- and intra-study differences on agreement levels. This study was registered with PROSPERO (CRD42021239351) and ClinicalTrials (NCT03789045). PubMed and Google Scholar were searched for studies examining FATmax and AerT connection. Overall, 12 studies with forty-five effect sizes and a total of 774 subjects fulfilled the inclusion criteria. The ROBIS tool for risk of bias assessment was used to determine the quality of included studies. In conclusion, the overall 95% limits of agreement of the differences between FATmax and AerT exercise intensities were larger than the a priori determined acceptable agreement due to the large variance caused by clinical and methodological differences among the studies. Therefore, we recommend that future studies follow a strict standardization of data collection and analysis of FATmax- and AerT-related outcomes.

[1]  C. Bouchard,et al.  Effect of individual characteristics and aerobic training on the %HRR-%V̇O2R relationship , 2022, European journal of sport science.

[2]  F. Amaro-Gahete,et al.  A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on the Association and Differences between Aerobic Threshold and Point of Optimal Fat Oxidation , 2022, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[3]  A. Ramos-Jiménez,et al.  Association Among Different Aerobic Threshold Markers and FATmax in Men With Obesity , 2022, Research quarterly for exercise and sport.

[4]  S. Collier,et al.  Correlation Between Heart Rate at Maximal Fat Oxidation and Aerobic Threshold in Healthy Adolescent Boys and Girls. , 2021, Pediatric Exercise Science.

[5]  E. Mayo-Wilson,et al.  The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews , 2021, BMJ.

[6]  G. Brooks,et al.  The anaerobic threshold: 50+ years of controversy , 2020, The Journal of physiology.

[7]  J. Pérez-León,et al.  Chronic Effect of Fatmax Training on Body Weight, Fat Mass, and Cardiorespiratory Fitness in Obese Subjects: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials , 2020, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[8]  Elizabeth Tipton,et al.  Meta-analysis with Robust Variance Estimation: Expanding the Range of Working Models , 2020, Prevention Science.

[9]  L. Spriet,et al.  Skeletal muscle energy metabolism during exercise , 2020, Nature Metabolism.

[10]  V. Macefield,et al.  Recent advances in exercise pressor reflex function in health and disease , 2020, Autonomic Neuroscience.

[11]  C. Bouchard,et al.  HRR and V˙O2R Fractions Are Not Equivalent: Is It Time to Rethink Aerobic Exercise Prescription Methods? , 2020, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[12]  B. Gojanovic,et al.  Fat Oxidation Kinetics Is Related to Muscle Deoxygenation Kinetics During Exercise , 2020, Frontiers in Physiology.

[13]  James R Carpenter,et al.  Sensitivity analysis for clinical trials with missing continuous outcome data using controlled multiple imputation: A practical guide , 2020, Statistics in medicine.

[14]  J. Murias,et al.  A Critical Evaluation of Current Methods for Exercise Prescription in Women and Men. , 2020, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[15]  Guillaume P. Ducrocq,et al.  Inorganic phosphate and lactate potentiate the pressor response to acidic stimuli in rats , 2020, Experimental physiology.

[16]  S. Barbaresi,et al.  Evaluating the influence of differences in methodological approach on metabolic thresholds and fat oxidation points relationship , 2020, European journal of sport science.

[17]  J. Higgins,et al.  Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions , 2010, International Coaching Psychology Review.

[18]  J. Helge,et al.  Assessment of maximal fat oxidation during exercise: A systematic review , 2019, Scandinavian journal of medicine & science in sports.

[19]  A. Lenzi,et al.  Relationship between individual ventilatory threshold and maximal fat oxidation (MFO) over different obesity classes in women , 2019, PloS one.

[20]  P. Bourdon,et al.  Does the aerobic threshold correlate with the maximal fat oxidation rate in short stage treadmill tests? , 2018, Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness.

[21]  D. Bishop,et al.  Manipulating graded exercise test variables affects the validity of the lactate threshold and V˙O2peak , 2018, PloS one.

[22]  L. Kravitz,et al.  Understanding the factors that effect maximal fat oxidation , 2018, Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition.

[23]  Elizabeth Tipton,et al.  A framework for the meta‐analysis of Bland–Altman studies based on a limits of agreement approach , 2017, Statistics in medicine.

[24]  Nicholas M Beltz,et al.  Graded Exercise Testing Protocols for the Determination of VO2max: Historical Perspectives, Progress, and Future Considerations , 2016, Journal of sports medicine.

[25]  Jesús G. Pallarés,et al.  Validity and Reliability of Ventilatory and Blood Lactate Thresholds in Well-Trained Cyclists , 2016, PloS one.

[26]  Rachel Churchill,et al.  ROBIS: A new tool to assess risk of bias in systematic reviews was developed , 2016, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[27]  Jianxiong Wang,et al.  Exercise training at the maximal fat oxidation intensity improved health-related physical fitness in overweight middle-aged women. , 2015, Journal of exercise science and fitness.

[28]  D. Jensen,et al.  Physiological and perceptual responses to incremental exercise testing in healthy men: effect of exercise test modality. , 2015, Applied physiology, nutrition, and metabolism = Physiologie appliquee, nutrition et metabolisme.

[29]  L. Donini,et al.  Effects of Aerobic Exercise Based upon Heart Rate at Aerobic Threshold in Obese Elderly Subjects with Type 2 Diabetes , 2015, International journal of endocrinology.

[30]  D. Ball Metabolic and endocrine response to exercise: sympathoadrenal integration with skeletal muscle. , 2015, The Journal of endocrinology.

[31]  D. Malatesta,et al.  Reproducibility of Fatmax and Fat Oxidation Rates during Exercise in Recreationally Trained Males , 2014, PloS one.

[32]  L. Spriet New Insights into the Interaction of Carbohydrate and Fat Metabolism During Exercise , 2014, Sports Medicine.

[33]  S. Kuhnt,et al.  Tests on Outliers , 2014 .

[34]  R. Shephard,et al.  Relative and absolute reliability of the crossover and maximum fat oxidation points and their relationship to ventilatory threshold , 2013 .

[35]  W. Van den Noortgate,et al.  Three-level meta-analysis of dependent effect sizes , 2013, Behavior research methods.

[36]  Michael Ian Lambert,et al.  Methods of Prescribing Relative Exercise Intensity: Physiological and Practical Considerations , 2013, Sports Medicine.

[37]  J. Brun,et al.  Physical Activity Targeted at Maximal Lipid Oxidation: A Meta-Analysis , 2012, Journal of nutrition and metabolism.

[38]  C. González-Haro,et al.  Maximal Fat Oxidation Rate and Cross-Over Point with Respect to Lactate Thresholds do not Have Good Agreement , 2011, International journal of sports medicine.

[39]  S. Angadi,et al.  Oxygen uptake and ratings of perceived exertion at the lactate threshold and maximal fat oxidation rate in untrained adults , 2011, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[40]  Wolfgang Viechtbauer,et al.  Conducting Meta-Analyses in R with the metafor Package , 2010 .

[41]  A. Jeukendrup,et al.  Group- and individual-level coincidence of the ‘Fatmax’ and lactate accumulation in adolescents , 2010, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[42]  Elizabeth Tipton,et al.  Robust variance estimation in meta‐regression with dependent effect size estimates , 2010, Research synthesis methods.

[43]  K. Sahlin,et al.  Turning down lipid oxidation during heavy exercise--what is the mechanism? , 2008, Journal of physiology and pharmacology : an official journal of the Polish Physiological Society.

[44]  A. Cohen-Solal,et al.  Methodological approach to the first and second lactate threshold in incremental cardiopulmonary exercise testing , 2008, European journal of cardiovascular prevention and rehabilitation : official journal of the European Society of Cardiology, Working Groups on Epidemiology & Prevention and Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology.

[45]  B. Wuyam,et al.  Methodological aspects of crossover and maximum fat-oxidation rate point determination. , 2008, Diabetes & metabolism.

[46]  G. Guyatt,et al.  GRADE: an emerging consensus on rating quality of evidence and strength of recommendations , 2008, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[47]  Paul A. Fontelo,et al.  Utilization of the PICO framework to improve searching PubMed for clinical questions , 2007, BMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak..

[48]  B. Knechtle,et al.  Is the highest fat oxidation rate coincident with the anaerobic threshold in obese women and men? , 2005 .

[49]  C. Earnest,et al.  A conceptual framework for performance diagnosis and training prescription from submaximal gas exchange parameters--theory and application. , 2005, International journal of sports medicine.

[50]  B. Knechtle,et al.  Relationship between Fat Oxidation and Lactate Threshold in Athletes and Obese Women and Men. , 2004, Journal of sports science & medicine.

[51]  A. Jeukendrup,et al.  Maximal fat oxidation during exercise in trained men. , 2003, International journal of sports medicine.

[52]  A. Jeukendrup,et al.  Fatmax : A new concept to optimize fat oxidation during exercise? , 2001 .

[53]  B R Londeree,et al.  Effect of training on lactate/ventilatory thresholds: a meta-analysis. , 1997, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[54]  F. E. Grubbs Sample Criteria for Testing Outlying Observations , 1950 .

[55]  Elizabeth Tipton,et al.  Small sample adjustments for robust variance estimation with meta-regression. , 2015, Psychological methods.

[56]  A. Jeukendrup,et al.  Determinants of fat oxidation during exercise in healthy men and women: a cross-sectional study. , 2005, Journal of applied physiology.

[57]  A. Jeukendrup,et al.  Determination of the exercise intensity that elicits maximal fat oxidation. , 2002, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[58]  Jack L. Vevea,et al.  Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis. , 1998 .