Improving Patient Safety through Simulation Training in Anesthesiology: Where Are We?

There have been colossal technological advances in the use of simulation in anesthesiology in the past 2 decades. Over the years, the use of simulation has gone from low fidelity to high fidelity models that mimic human responses in a startlingly realistic manner, extremely life-like mannequin that breathes, generates E.K.G, and has pulses, heart sounds, and an airway that can be programmed for different degrees of obstruction. Simulation in anesthesiology is no longer a research fascination but an integral part of resident education and one of ACGME requirements for resident graduation. Simulation training has been objectively shown to increase the skill-set of anesthesiologists. Anesthesiology is leading the movement in patient safety. It is rational to assume a relationship between simulation training and patient safety. Nevertheless there has not been a demonstrable improvement in patient outcomes with simulation training. Larger prospective studies that evaluate the improvement in patient outcomes are needed to justify the integration of simulation training in resident education but ample number of studies in the past 5 years do show a definite benefit of using simulation in anesthesiology training. This paper gives a brief overview of the history and evolution of use of simulation in anesthesiology and highlights some of the more recent studies that have advanced simulation-based training.

[1]  R R Kennedy,et al.  Low-Cost High-Fidelity Anaesthetic Simulation , 2014, Anaesthesia and intensive care.

[2]  D. Cook,et al.  Simulation-based training in anaesthesiology: a systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2014, British journal of anaesthesia.

[3]  O. Kimberger,et al.  Validity and fidelity of the upper airway in two high-fidelity patient simulators. , 2015, Minerva anestesiologica.

[4]  Imran Aslam,et al.  Developments in Simulation Bronchoscopy Training , 2013 .

[5]  V. LeBlanc,et al.  Review article: Simulation in anesthesia: state of the science and looking forward , 2012, Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie.

[6]  Seshadri C. Mudumbai,et al.  External Validation of Simulation-Based Assessments With Other Performance Measures of Third-Year Anesthesiology Residents , 2012, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[7]  Robert J McCarthy,et al.  The effect of live and web-based education on the accuracy of blood-loss estimation in simulated obstetric scenarios. , 2010, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[8]  S. Brien,et al.  Review article: Simulation: a means to address and improve patient safety , 2013, Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie.

[9]  S. Hamstra,et al.  Fiberoptic Orotracheal Intubation on Anesthetized Patients: Do Manipulation Skills Learned on a Simple Model Transfer into the Operating Room? , 2001, Anesthesiology.

[10]  Pierre Pluye,et al.  A reflective learning framework to evaluate CME effects on practice reflection , 2010, The Journal of continuing education in the health professions.

[11]  A. Levine,et al.  Standardized patients: the "other" simulation. , 2008, Journal of critical care.

[12]  Masanori Haba,et al.  Effects of a simulation-based sedation training course on non-anesthesiologists’ attitudes toward sedation and analgesia , 2014, Journal of Anesthesia.

[13]  John R. Boulet,et al.  Simulation-based Assessment to Identify Critical Gaps in Safe Anesthesia Resident Performance , 2014, Anesthesiology.

[14]  William R. McIvor,et al.  Management of profound hypotension secondary to spinal anesthesia: simulation case scenario. , 2010, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[15]  T. Vetter,et al.  Airway management and vascular access simulation during a medical student rotation , 2011, The clinical teacher.

[16]  G. Enterlein,et al.  „Practice Guidelines for Management of the Difficult Airway“ , 2003, Der Anaesthesist.

[17]  J. Weller,et al.  Survey of use of end‐tidal carbon dioxide for confirming tracheal tube placement in intensive care units in the UK * , 2003, Anaesthesia.

[18]  Haider J. Warraich,et al.  Utility of a transesophageal echocardiographic simulator as a teaching tool. , 2011, Journal of cardiothoracic and vascular anesthesia.

[19]  R. Rowe,et al.  An Evaluation of a Virtual Reality Airway Simulator , 2002, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[20]  W. Grobman,et al.  Decay in Blood Loss Estimation Skills After Web-Based Didactic Training , 2012, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[21]  R. Katznelson,et al.  Clinical Impact of Epidural Anesthesia Simulation on Short- and Long-term Learning Curve: High- Versus Low-fidelity Model Training , 2008, Regional Anesthesia & Pain Medicine.

[22]  Akira Nishisaki,et al.  Does simulation improve patient safety? Self-efficacy, competence, operational performance, and patient safety. , 2007, Anesthesiology clinics.

[23]  R. Hesselfeldt,et al.  Evaluation of the airway of the SimMan™ full‐scale patient simulator , 2005, Acta anaesthesiologica Scandinavica.

[24]  Jennene Greenhill,et al.  Clinical simulation in maternity (CSiM): interprofessional learning through simulation team training , 2010, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[25]  S L Shafer,et al.  Hot air or full steam ahead? An empirical pharmacokinetic model of potent inhalational agents. , 2000, British journal of anaesthesia.

[26]  Viren N. Naik,et al.  Simulation-based Training Improves Physicians' Performance in Patient Care in High-stakes Clinical Setting of Cardiac Surgery , 2010, Anesthesiology.

[27]  K. Moorthy,et al.  Evaluation of Virtual Reality Bronchoscopy as a Learning and Assessment Tool , 2003, Respiration.

[28]  Matthew B. Weinger,et al.  This is NOT a Test , 2018 .

[29]  Ralf Krage,et al.  State-of-the-art usage of simulation in anesthesia: skills and teamwork , 2015, Current opinion in anaesthesiology.

[30]  J. Schaefer,et al.  Simulators and difficult airway management skills , 2004, Paediatric anaesthesia.

[31]  V. Chan,et al.  Ultrasound-Guided Regional Anesthesia Performance in the Early Learning Period: Effect of Simulation Training , 2011, Regional Anesthesia & Pain Medicine.

[32]  Martin P. Eason,et al.  A system to simulate arterial blood flow for cannulation in the human patient simulator. , 2005, Anesthesiology.

[33]  Lorri A. Lee,et al.  Closed claims' analysis. , 2011, Best practice & research. Clinical anaesthesiology.

[34]  M L Good,et al.  Anaesthesia simulators and training devices , 1990, Anaesthesia.

[35]  Matthew B Weinger,et al.  This is not a test!: Misconceptions surrounding the maintenance of certification in anesthesiology simulation course. , 2014, Anesthesiology.

[36]  Yi-Ping Hung,et al.  Validation of a computer-based bronchoscopy simulator developed in Taiwan. , 2006, Journal of the Formosan Medical Association = Taiwan yi zhi.

[37]  Tae Ho Lim,et al.  Survey on understanding after anesthetic induction simulation training in medical students' anesthesiology practice , 2013, Korean journal of anesthesiology.

[38]  Ayse P. Gürses,et al.  The Nature, Characteristics and Patterns of Perinatal Critical Events Teams , 2008 .

[39]  Yiqun Lin,et al.  The use of high-fidelity manikins for advanced life support training--A systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2015, Resuscitation.

[40]  John Bent,et al.  Flight Training and Simulation as Safety Generators , 2010 .

[41]  Jodi A. Berendzen,et al.  Fire in labor and delivery: simulation case scenario. , 2011, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[42]  J. Cooper,et al.  A brief history of the development of mannequin simulators for clinical education and training , 2004, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[43]  P S Colley,et al.  An aid to learning to use the fiberoptic bronchoscope for intubation. , 1997, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[44]  Toshiaki Minami,et al.  [Simulation-based sedation training in the operating room]. , 2014, Masui. The Japanese journal of anesthesiology.

[45]  Susan M. Martinelli,et al.  Simulator Training Enhances Resident Performance in Transesophageal Echocardiography , 2014, Anesthesiology.

[46]  C R Bainton,et al.  Models to Facilitate the Learning of Fiberoptic Technique , 1994, International anesthesiology clinics.

[47]  Alex Macario,et al.  Simulation-Based Mastery Learning with Deliberate Practice Improves Clinical Performance in Spinal Anesthesia , 2014, Anesthesiology research and practice.

[48]  D. Gaba,et al.  Anesthesia crisis resource management training: teaching anesthesiologists to handle critical incidents. , 1992, Aviation, space, and environmental medicine.

[49]  Carol L Lake,et al.  Simulation in Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia Education: Tool or Toy? , 2005, Seminars in cardiothoracic and vascular anesthesia.

[50]  Alin Schaumberg,et al.  The matter of 'fidelity': Keep it simple or complex? , 2015, Best practice & research. Clinical anaesthesiology.

[51]  M. Blum,et al.  Bronchoscopy simulator effectively prepares junior residents to competently perform basic clinical bronchoscopy. , 2004, The Annals of thoracic surgery.

[52]  A. Bowdle,et al.  High-fidelity simulation of lung isolation with double-lumen endotracheal tubes and bronchial blockers in anesthesiology resident training. , 2014, Journal of cardiothoracic and vascular anesthesia.

[53]  Steve Lipman,et al.  The demise of general anesthesia in obstetrics revisited: prescription for a cure. , 2005, International journal of obstetric anesthesia.

[54]  S. Hamstra,et al.  Nontechnical Skills in Anesthesia Crisis Management with Repeated Exposure to Simulation-based Education , 2005, Anesthesiology.

[55]  Samuel DeMaria,et al.  Human patient simulation and its role in endoscopic sedation training. , 2008, Gastrointestinal endoscopy clinics of North America.

[56]  Robert J McCarthy,et al.  A Randomized Controlled Trial of the Impact of Simulation-Based Training on Resident Performance During a Simulated Obstetric Anesthesia Emergency , 2010, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[57]  D. Cook,et al.  Advanced Airway Management Simulation Training in Medical Education: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis , 2014, Critical care medicine.

[58]  Rhona Flin,et al.  Basic concepts for crew resource management and non-technical skills. , 2015, Best practice & research. Clinical anaesthesiology.

[59]  D J Murray,et al.  Current trends in simulation training in anesthesia: a review. , 2011, Minerva anestesiologica.

[60]  Charles D Boucek,et al.  Simulation: a teaching tool for liver transplantation anesthesiology , 2012, Clinical transplantation.

[61]  J. Horn,et al.  Efficacy of computer-based video and simulation in ultrasound-guided regional anesthesia training. , 2014, Journal of clinical anesthesia.

[62]  Davinder Ramsingh,et al.  Transthoracic Echocardiography Simulation Is an Efficient Method to Train Anesthesiologists in Basic Transthoracic Echocardiography Skills , 2012, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[63]  K. Fish,et al.  Anaesthesia crisis resource management training: an intimidating concept, a rewarding experience , 1996, Canadian journal of anaesthesia = Journal canadien d'anesthesie.

[64]  J Spierdijk,et al.  Does training on an anaesthesia simulator lead to improvement in performance? , 1994, British journal of anaesthesia.

[65]  Steven K Howard,et al.  Simulation in teaching regional anesthesia: current perspectives , 2015, Local and regional anesthesia.

[66]  John C Magill,et al.  A Novel Actuator for Simulation of Epidural Anesthesia and Other Needle Insertion Procedures , 2010, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[67]  Anne-Sophie Nyssen,et al.  A Comparison of the Training Value of Two Types of Anesthesia Simulators: Computer Screen-Based and Mannequin-Based Simulators , 2002, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[68]  D. Gaba,et al.  Assessment of Clinical Performance during Simulated Crises Using Both Technical and Behavioral Ratings , 1998, Anesthesiology.

[69]  H A Schwid,et al.  Anesthesia simulators--technology and applications. , 2000, The Israel Medical Association journal : IMAJ.

[70]  Ryan Brydges,et al.  Patient Outcomes in Simulation-Based Medical Education: A Systematic Review , 2013, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[71]  K. Fish,et al.  Testing Internal Consistency and Construct Validity During Evaluation of Performance in a Patient Simulator , 1998, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[72]  A F Merry,et al.  Simulators for use in anaesthesia , 2007, Anaesthesia.

[73]  J. Hendrickx,et al.  Theoretical effect of hyperventilation on speed of recovery and risk of rehypnotization following recovery - a GasMan® simulation , 2012, BMC Anesthesiology.

[74]  D J Castanelli,et al.  The Rise of Simulation in Technical Skills Teaching and the Implications for Training Novices in Anaesthesia , 2009, Anaesthesia and intensive care.

[75]  R. Landau,et al.  Repeated simulation-based training for performing general anesthesia for emergency cesarean delivery: long-term retention and recurring mistakes. , 2014, International journal of obstetric anesthesia.

[76]  Martin P. Eason Simulation Devices in Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia , 2005, Seminars in cardiothoracic and vascular anesthesia.

[77]  Stephen D Pratt,et al.  Recent trends in simulation for obstetric anesthesia. , 2012, Current opinion in anaesthesiology.

[78]  Charlotte Ringsted,et al.  Simulation-based training in flexible fibreoptic intubation: A randomised study , 2015, European journal of anaesthesiology.

[79]  R. Flin,et al.  The role of non-technical skills in anaesthesia: a review of current literature. , 2002, British journal of anaesthesia.

[80]  Lili Ding,et al.  Novel real‐time feedback and integrated simulation model for teaching and evaluating ultrasound‐guided regional anesthesia skills in pediatric anesthesia trainees , 2012, Paediatric anaesthesia.

[81]  Marilia Bonifácio Baranauskas,et al.  Simulation of ultrasound-guided peripheral nerve block: learning curve of CET-SMA/HSL Anesthesiology residents. , 2008, Revista brasileira de anestesiologia.

[82]  V. Naik,et al.  Fiberoptic Oral Intubation: The Effect of Model Fidelity on Training for Transfer to Patient Care , 2008, Anesthesiology.

[83]  R. Helmreich On error management: lessons from aviation , 2000, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[84]  M. Cohen,et al.  The Validity of Performance Assessments Using Simulation , 2001, Anesthesiology.

[85]  Daniel S Hippe,et al.  Perceived Barriers to the Use of High-Fidelity Hands-On Simulation Training for Contrast Reaction Management: Why Programs are Not Using It. , 2015, Current problems in diagnostic radiology.

[86]  Jo Angouri,et al.  Team Communication With Patient Actors: Findings From a Multisite Simulation Study , 2011, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[87]  Vincent Hubert,et al.  Effect of Simulation Training on Compliance with Difficult Airway Management Algorithms, Technical Ability, and Skills Retention for Emergency Cricothyrotomy , 2014, Anesthesiology.

[88]  Brian D Sites,et al.  The American Society of Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine and the European Society of Regional Anaesthesia and Pain Therapy Joint Committee Recommendations for Education and Training in Ultrasound-Guided Regional Anesthesia , 2008, Regional Anesthesia & Pain Medicine.

[89]  D. Pöpping,et al.  Simulation for anesthesia in obstetrics. , 2015, Best practice & research. Clinical anaesthesiology.

[90]  R L Helmreich,et al.  Anaesthetic simulation and lessons to be learned from aviation , 1997, Canadian journal of anaesthesia = Journal canadien d'anesthesie.

[91]  Viva J. Siddall,et al.  Development of an Objective Scoring System for Measurement of Resident Performance on the Human Patient Simulator , 2006, Anesthesiology.

[92]  Valeriy Kozmenko,et al.  High-fidelity, simulation-based, interdisciplinary operating room team training at the point of care. , 2009, Surgery.

[93]  Jonas Nordquist,et al.  Institutional needs and faculty development for simulation. , 2015, Best practice & research. Clinical anaesthesiology.

[94]  A. Bowdle,et al.  The use of TEE simulation in teaching basic echocardiography skills to senior anesthesiology residents. , 2013, Journal of cardiothoracic and vascular anesthesia.

[95]  L. Henson,et al.  Simulators in Anesthesiology Education , 1998, Springer US.

[96]  Annette Aboulafia,et al.  Testing Haptic Sensations for Spinal Anesthesia , 2010, Regional Anesthesia & Pain Medicine.

[97]  Martin P Eason,et al.  A device to stimulate central venous cannulation in the human patient simulator. , 2003, Anesthesiology.

[98]  D. Gaba,et al.  A comprehensive anesthesia simulation environment: re-creating the operating room for research and training. , 1988, Anesthesiology.

[99]  K. Wernecke,et al.  [Simulation-based anaesthesia crisis resource management training. Results of a survey on learning success]. , 2009, Der Anaesthesist.

[100]  Vincent W. S. Chan,et al.  The ASRA Evidence-Based Medicine Assessment of Ultrasound-Guided Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine: Executive Summary , 2009, Regional Anesthesia & Pain Medicine.

[101]  Lorri A. Lee,et al.  Management of the difficult airway: a closed claims analysis. , 2005 .

[102]  J. Gravenstein,et al.  ANESTHESIA SIMULATORS AND TRAINING DEVICES , 1993, International anesthesiology clinics.

[103]  Grace Lim,et al.  Simulation-based Anesthesiology Education for Medical Students , 2015, International anesthesiology clinics.

[104]  Thomas Franzen,et al.  Effects of using simulation versus CD-ROM in the performance of ultrasound-guided regional anesthesia. , 2012, AANA journal.

[105]  P. Maurette [To err is human: building a safer health system]. , 2002, Annales francaises d'anesthesie et de reanimation.

[106]  Helmut Ringl,et al.  Degrees of Reality: Airway Anatomy of High-fidelity Human Patient Simulators and Airway Trainers , 2012, Anesthesiology.

[107]  Tod B. Sloan,et al.  Anesthesia Simulator Consultant: Improve Your Response to Anesthetic Emergencies , 1995 .

[108]  J. S. Denson,et al.  A computer-controlled patient simulator. , 1969, JAMA.

[109]  V. Naik,et al.  Complex procedural skills are retained for a minimum of 1 yr after a single high-fidelity simulation training session. , 2011, British journal of anaesthesia.

[110]  D M Gaba,et al.  Improving anesthesiologists' performance by simulating reality. , 1992, Anesthesiology.

[111]  Pascal Blondel,et al.  What Is the Accuracy of the High-Fidelity METI Human Patient Simulator Physiological Models During Oxygen Administration and Apnea Maneuvers? , 2013, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[112]  A W Sajid,et al.  Test of a cardiology patient simulator with students in fourth-year electives. , 1987, Journal of medical education.

[113]  Valeriy Kozmenko,et al.  From the flight deck to the operating room: an initial pilot study of the feasibility and potential impact of true interdisciplinary team training using high-fidelity simulation. , 2007, Journal of surgical education.

[114]  Maxime Cannesson,et al.  Comparison of the didactic lecture with the simulation/model approach for the teaching of a novel perioperative ultrasound curriculum to anesthesiology residents. , 2014, Journal of clinical anesthesia.

[115]  Noel O’Regan,et al.  The Comprehensive Textbook of Healthcare Simulation , 2014, Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie.

[116]  Patricia M. Murphy,et al.  Testing the raters: inter-rater reliability of standardized anaesthesia simulator performance , 1997, Canadian journal of anaesthesia = Journal canadien d'anesthesie.

[117]  C. Marano,et al.  To err is human. Building a safer health system , 2005 .

[118]  D. Siassakos,et al.  Content analysis of team communication in an obstetric emergency scenario , 2009, Journal of obstetrics and gynaecology : the journal of the Institute of Obstetrics and Gynaecology.

[119]  H. Schwid,et al.  The Anesthesia Simulator-Recorder: a device to train and evaluate anesthesiologists' responses to critical incidents. , 1990, Anesthesiology.

[120]  Kathryn E. McGoldrick,et al.  Simulation in Obstetric Anesthesia , 2012 .