Decision ambiguity is mediated by a late positive potential originating from cingulate cortex

&NA; People often make decisions in the face of ambiguous information, but it remains unclear how ambiguity is represented in the brain. We used three types of ambiguous stimuli and combined EEG and fMRI to examine the neural representation of perceptual decisions under ambiguity. We identified a late positive potential, the LPP, which differentiated levels of ambiguity, and which was specifically associated with behavioral judgments about choices that were ambiguous, rather than passive perception of ambiguous stimuli. Mediation analyses together with two further control experiments confirmed that the LPP was generated only when decisions are made (not during mere perception of ambiguous stimuli), and only when those decisions involved choices on a dimension that is ambiguous. A further control experiment showed that a stronger LPP arose in the presence of ambiguous stimuli compared to when only unambiguous stimuli were present. Source modeling suggested that the LPP originated from multiple loci in cingulate cortex, a finding we further confirmed using fMRI and fMRI‐guided ERP source prediction. Taken together, our findings argue for a role of an LPP originating from cingulate cortex in encoding decisions based on task‐relevant perceptual ambiguity, a process that may in turn influence confidence judgment, response conflict, and error correction. HighlightsA late positive potential encodes levels of perceptual ambiguity.The LPP is associated with ambiguity of decisions rather than identification.The LPP only arises in the context of ambiguous stimuli.fMRI‐informed EEG revealed a network of brain regions encoding ambiguity.

[1]  Alexandre Pouget,et al.  Confidence and certainty: distinct probabilistic quantities for different goals , 2016, Nature Neuroscience.

[2]  S. Kelly,et al.  Internal and External Influences on the Rate of Sensory Evidence Accumulation in the Human Brain , 2013, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[3]  Stephan Moratti,et al.  Prefrontal-Occipitoparietal Coupling Underlies Late Latency Human Neuronal Responses to Emotion , 2011, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[4]  Mark A. Straccia,et al.  Anterior Cingulate Engagement in a Foraging Context Reflects Choice Difficulty, Not Foraging Value , 2014, Nature Neuroscience.

[5]  Evan M. Gordon,et al.  Neural Signatures of Economic Preferences for Risk and Ambiguity , 2006, Neuron.

[6]  Axel Schäfer,et al.  Source localization of late electrocortical positivity during symptom provocation in spider phobia: An sLORETA study , 2011, Brain Research.

[7]  William A. Cunningham,et al.  Attitudes to the right- and left: Frontal ERP asymmetries associated with stimulus valence and processing goals , 2005, NeuroImage.

[8]  W. D. Penny,et al.  Random-Effects Analysis , 2002 .

[9]  J. Daunizeau,et al.  Automatic integration of confidence in the brain valuation signal , 2015, Nature Neuroscience.

[10]  Murray B. Stein,et al.  Intolerance of uncertainty correlates with insula activation during affective ambiguity , 2008, Neuroscience Letters.

[11]  Vinh Thai Nguyen,et al.  The superior temporal sulcus and the N170 during face processing: Single trial analysis of concurrent EEG–fMRI , 2014, NeuroImage.

[12]  Vera Ferrari,et al.  Directed and Motivated Attention during Processing of Natural Scenes , 2008, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[13]  William H. Alexander,et al.  Computational Models of Performance Monitoring and Cognitive Control , 2010, Top. Cogn. Sci..

[14]  R. Dolan,et al.  Confidence in value-based choice , 2012, Nature Neuroscience.

[15]  Jorge Alves,et al.  Affective picture modulation: valence, arousal, attention allocation and motivational significance. , 2012, International journal of psychophysiology : official journal of the International Organization of Psychophysiology.

[16]  R. O’Connell,et al.  Neural evidence accumulation persists after choice to inform metacognitive judgments , 2015, eLife.

[17]  T. Johnstone,et al.  Perceived Controllability Modulates the Neural Response to Pain , 2004, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[18]  A. Nobre,et al.  Temporal Expectation Enhances Contrast Sensitivity by Phase Entrainment of Low-Frequency Oscillations in Visual Cortex , 2013, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[19]  P. H. Lindsay,et al.  Evoked Potential Correlates of Auditory Signal Detection , 1971, Science.

[20]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  The Expected Value of Control: An Integrative Theory of Anterior Cingulate Cortex Function , 2013, Neuron.

[21]  Shuo Wang,et al.  The human amygdala parametrically encodes the intensity of specific facial emotions and their categorical ambiguity , 2017, Nature Communications.

[22]  J. Cacioppo,et al.  Bioelectrical echoes from evaluative categorizations: I. A late positive brain potential that varies as a function of trait negativity and extremity. , 1994, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[23]  J. Fermaglich Electric Fields of the Brain: The Neurophysics of EEG , 1982 .

[24]  M. Bradley,et al.  Affective picture processing: the late positive potential is modulated by motivational relevance. , 2000, Psychophysiology.

[25]  S. Ishii,et al.  Resolution of Uncertainty in Prefrontal Cortex , 2006, Neuron.

[26]  Steven J. Luck,et al.  ERPLAB: an open-source toolbox for the analysis of event-related potentials , 2014, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[27]  Ben Seymour,et al.  Neural Activity Associated with the Passive Prediction of Ambiguity and Risk for Aversive Events , 2009, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[28]  M. Scherg Fundamentals if dipole source potential analysis , 1990 .

[29]  Shaun R. Patel,et al.  Human Dorsal Anterior Cingulate Cortex Neurons Mediate Ongoing Behavioral Adaptation , 2012, Nature.

[30]  Philipp Sterzer,et al.  A neural basis for inference in perceptual ambiguity , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[31]  A. Engel,et al.  Single-trial EEG–fMRI reveals the dynamics of cognitive function , 2006, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[32]  Dustin Scheinost,et al.  Real-time fMRI links subjective experience with brain activity during focused attention , 2013, NeuroImage.

[33]  Colin Camerer,et al.  Neural Systems Responding to Degrees of Uncertainty in Human Decision-Making , 2005, Science.

[34]  Dan Foti,et al.  Motivated and controlled attention to emotion: Time-course of the late positive potential , 2009, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[35]  Christian Grillon,et al.  Phasic and sustained fear in humans elicits distinct patterns of brain activity , 2011, NeuroImage.

[36]  Yong Hu,et al.  Causality in the Association between P300 and Alpha Event-Related Desynchronization , 2012, PloS one.

[37]  T. Egner,et al.  Emotional processing in anterior cingulate and medial prefrontal cortex , 2011, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[38]  Y. Benjamini,et al.  Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing , 1995 .

[39]  Czeslaw Stepniak Expected Value , 2011, International Encyclopedia of Statistical Science.

[40]  A. Keil,et al.  Neural Substrate of the Late Positive Potential in Emotional Processing , 2012, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[41]  R. Davidson,et al.  The integration of negative affect, pain and cognitive control in the cingulate cortex , 2011, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[42]  E. John,et al.  Evoked-Potential Correlates of Stimulus Uncertainty , 1965, Science.

[43]  G. McCarthy,et al.  Augmenting mental chronometry: the P300 as a measure of stimulus evaluation time. , 1977, Science.

[44]  Joseph W. Kable,et al.  The valuation system: A coordinate-based meta-analysis of BOLD fMRI experiments examining neural correlates of subjective value , 2013, NeuroImage.

[45]  Greg O. Horne,et al.  Controlling low-level image properties: The SHINE toolbox , 2010, Behavior research methods.

[46]  Josep Marco-Pallarés,et al.  Modulation of spectral power and of phase resetting of EEG contributes differentially to the generation of auditory event-related potentials , 2006, NeuroImage.

[47]  Paul Pauli,et al.  Enhanced functional connectivity between sensorimotor and visual cortex predicts covariation bias in spider phobia , 2016, Biological Psychology.

[48]  T. Ito,et al.  Ambiguity and the Timecourse of Racial Perception , 2006 .

[49]  Saul Sternberg,et al.  The discovery of processing stages: Extensions of Donders' method , 1969 .

[50]  H G Vaughan,et al.  Association cortex potentials and reaction time in auditory discrimination. , 1972, Electroencephalography and clinical neurophysiology.

[51]  David J. Freedman,et al.  Categorical representation of visual stimuli in the primate prefrontal cortex. , 2001, Science.

[52]  M. Shadlen,et al.  Choice Certainty Is Informed by Both Evidence and Decision Time , 2014, Neuron.

[53]  P. Glimcher,et al.  Title: the Neural Representation of Subjective Value under Risk and Ambiguity 1 2 , 2009 .

[54]  D. Lehmann,et al.  Low resolution electromagnetic tomography: a new method for localizing electrical activity in the brain. , 1994, International journal of psychophysiology : official journal of the International Organization of Psychophysiology.

[55]  Timothy E. J. Behrens,et al.  Optimal decision making and the anterior cingulate cortex , 2006, Nature Neuroscience.

[56]  J. Polich Updating P300: An integrative theory of P3a and P3b , 2007, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[57]  Matthew S. Fritz,et al.  Mediation analysis. , 2019, Annual review of psychology.

[58]  Anna Weinberg,et al.  Event‐related potential activity in the basal ganglia differentiates rewards from nonrewards: Temporospatial principal components analysis and source localization of the feedback negativity , 2011, Human brain mapping.

[59]  Jean Decety,et al.  Spatiotemporal neural dynamics of moral judgment: A high-density ERP study , 2014, Neuropsychologia.

[60]  D. Perrett,et al.  Facial expression megamix: Tests of dimensional and category accounts of emotion recognition , 1997, Cognition.

[61]  Markus Ullsperger,et al.  Real and Fictive Outcomes Are Processed Differently but Converge on a Common Adaptive Mechanism , 2013, Neuron.

[62]  C. Büchel,et al.  The neural bases of emotion regulation , 2015, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[63]  Heleen A Slagter,et al.  Event‐related potential activity in the basal ganglia differentiates rewards from nonrewards: Temporospatial principal components analysis and source localization of the feedback negativity: Commentary , 2011, Human brain mapping.

[64]  Anna Weinberg,et al.  Interactions between attention and emotion: insights from the late positive potential , 2013 .

[65]  Claus Lamm,et al.  P300 amplitude variation is related to ventral striatum BOLD response during gain and loss anticipation: An EEG and fMRI experiment , 2014, NeuroImage.

[66]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Human Brain Function , 1997 .

[67]  Pascal Belin,et al.  A dynamic facial expression database , 2010 .

[68]  Francesco Versace,et al.  Affective picture perception: Emotion, context, and the late positive potential , 2008, Brain Research.

[69]  S. Luck,et al.  How inappropriate high-pass filters can produce artifactual effects and incorrect conclusions in ERP studies of language and cognition. , 2015, Psychophysiology.

[70]  Marina Schmid,et al.  An Introduction To The Event Related Potential Technique , 2016 .

[71]  Johannes J. Fahrenfort,et al.  Neuronal integration in visual cortex elevates face category tuning to conscious face perception , 2013 .

[72]  S. Kelly,et al.  The neural processes underlying perceptual decision making in humans: Recent progress and future directions , 2015, Journal of Physiology-Paris.

[73]  Timothy E. J. Behrens,et al.  Choice, uncertainty and value in prefrontal and cingulate cortex , 2008, Nature Neuroscience.

[74]  T. Iidaka,et al.  Frontal lobe networks for effective processing of ambiguously expressed emotions in humans , 2003, Neuroscience Letters.

[75]  M. Bradley,et al.  Brain potentials in affective picture processing: covariation with autonomic arousal and affective report , 2000, Biological Psychology.

[76]  Matthew D. Lieberman,et al.  A pain by any other name (rejection, exclusion, ostracism) still hurts the same: The role of dorsal anterior cingulate cortex in social and physical pain , 2006 .

[77]  David Beltrán,et al.  When does the brain distinguish between genuine and ambiguous smiles? An ERP study , 2013, Brain and Cognition.

[78]  Michael P. Milham,et al.  Distinct neural mechanisms of risk and ambiguity: A meta-analysis of decision-making , 2006, NeuroImage.

[79]  Arnaud Delorme,et al.  EEGLAB: an open source toolbox for analysis of single-trial EEG dynamics including independent component analysis , 2004, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[80]  Michael W. Cole,et al.  Cingulate cortex: Diverging data from humans and monkeys , 2009, Trends in Neurosciences.

[81]  Z. Nahas,et al.  Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex Stimulation Modulates Electrocortical Measures of Visual Attention: Evidence from Direct Bilateral Epidural Cortical Stimulation in Treatment-resistant Mood Disorder Ine Regional Specificity of Pfc Stimulation on the Parietally- Maximal Late Positive Potential (lpp), a , 2022 .

[82]  A. Lüthi,et al.  Processing of Temporal Unpredictability in Human and Animal Amygdala , 2007, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[83]  S. Kelly,et al.  A supramodal accumulation-to-bound signal that determines perceptual decisions in humans , 2012, Nature Neuroscience.

[84]  M. Bradley,et al.  Emotional perception: correlation of functional MRI and event-related potentials. , 2006, Cerebral cortex.

[85]  Philip R. Blue,et al.  Low social status decreases the neural salience of unfairness , 2014, Front. Behav. Neurosci..

[86]  M. Gazzaniga,et al.  Combined spatial and temporal imaging of brain activity during visual selective attention in humans , 1994, Nature.

[87]  E. Harth,et al.  Electric Fields of the Brain: The Neurophysics of Eeg , 2005 .

[88]  Murray B. Stein,et al.  Affective ambiguity for a group recruits ventromedial prefrontal cortex , 2006, NeuroImage.