A comparison of radio-frequency biomotion sensors and actigraphy versus polysomnography for the assessment of sleep in normal subjects

PurposeThis paper aims to compare the absolute performance of three noncontact sleep measurement devices for measuring sleep parameters in normal subjects against polysomnography and to assess their relative performance.MethodsThe devices investigated were two noncontact radio-frequency biomotion sensors (SleepMinder (SM) and SleepDesign (HSL-101)) and an actigraphy-based system (Actiwatch). Overnight polysomnography measurements were carried out in 20 normal subjects, with simultaneous assessment of sleep parameters using the three devices. The parameters measured included total sleep time (TST), sleep efficiency (SE), sleep-onset latency (SOL), and wake-after-sleep onset (WASO). The per-epoch agreement level for sleep/wake distinction was evaluated.ResultsThe TSTs reported by the three devices were 426 ± 34, 434 ± 22, and 441 ± 16 min, for the SM, HSL-101, and Actiwatch, respectively, against polysomnogram (PSG)-reported TST of 391 ± 49 min. The SOLs were 10 ± 10, 5 ± 6, and 3 ± 2 min for the SM, HSL-101 and Actiwatch, respectively against PSG SOL of 19 ± 13 min. The WASO times were 46 ± 33, 43 ± 22, and 38 ± 17 min, as against PSG-reported 69 ± 46 min. All three devices had a statistically significant bias to overestimate sleep time and underestimate WASO and SOL compared with PSG. The performance of the three devices was basically equivalent, with only minor interdevice differences. The overall per-epoch agreement levels were 86 % for the SM, 86 % for the HSL-101, and 85 % for the Actiwatch.ConclusionsNoncontact biomotion approaches to sleep measurement provided reasonable estimates of TST, but with a bias to over-estimation of sleep. The radio-frequency biomotion sensors provided similar accuracies for sleep/wake determination in normal subjects as the actigraph used in this study and slightly improved estimates of TST, SOL, and WASO.

[1]  Conor Heneghan,et al.  Real time breathing rate estimation from a non contact biosensor , 2010, 2010 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology.

[2]  J. Krouwer.  Why Bland–Altman plots should use X, not (Y+X)/2 when X is a reference method , 2008, Statistics in medicine.

[3]  Sonia Ancoli-Israel,et al.  Comparison of sleep parameters from actigraphy and polysomnography in older women: the SOF study. , 2008, Sleep.

[4]  D. White,et al.  A novel adaptive wrist actigraphy algorithm for sleep-wake assessment in sleep apnea patients. , 2004, Sleep.

[5]  C. Guilleminault,et al.  Comparison of actigraphic, polysomnographic, and subjective assessment of sleep parameters in sleep-disordered patients. , 2001, Sleep medicine.

[6]  David Murray,et al.  Actigraphy validation with insomnia. , 2006, Sleep.

[7]  Ståle Pallesen,et al.  A comparison of actigraphy and polysomnography in older adults treated for chronic primary insomnia. , 2006, Sleep.

[8]  R. Sack,et al.  A comparison of sleep detection by wrist actigraphy, behavioral response, and polysomnography. , 1997, Sleep.

[9]  A. Chesson,et al.  The AASM Manual for the Scoring of Sleep and Associated Events: Rules, Terminology, and Techinical Specifications , 2007 .

[10]  Luciane L. de Souza,et al.  Further validation of actigraphy for sleep studies. , 2003, Sleep.

[11]  Warren W Tryon,et al.  Issues of validity in actigraphic sleep assessment. , 2004, Sleep.

[12]  B. Fleury,et al.  Wrist-actigraphic estimation of sleep time under nCPAP treatment in sleep apnoea patients , 2004, European Respiratory Journal.

[13]  Susan Redline,et al.  Factors that may influence the classification of sleep-wake by wrist actigraphy: the MrOS Sleep Study. , 2011, Journal of clinical sleep medicine : JCSM : official publication of the American Academy of Sleep Medicine.

[14]  H. Montgomery-Downs,et al.  Movement toward a novel activity monitoring device , 2012, Sleep and Breathing.

[15]  J. Carrier,et al.  Wake detection capacity of actigraphy during sleep. , 2007, Sleep.

[16]  C. Heneghan,et al.  Sleep/wake measurement using a non‐contact biomotion sensor , 2011, Journal of sleep research.

[17]  A. Chesson,et al.  Practice parameters for the use of actigraphy in the assessment of sleep and sleep disorders: an update for 2007. , 2007, Sleep.

[18]  A. Chesson,et al.  The American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) Manual for the Scoring of Sleep and Associated Events: Rules, Terminology and Technical Specifications , 2007 .