Comparison of Analytical Models of Transformer Leakage Inductance: Accuracy Versus Computational Effort

A fast and accurate model of the transformer leakage inductance is crucial for optimization-based design of galvanically isolated converters. Analytical models are fastly executable, and therefore, especially suitable for such optimizations. This article compares several analytical leakage inductance per unit length models with respect to the accuracy and computational effort. The considered models are applicable to E-Core and U-Core transformers. 2D FEM simulations are used as a benchmark to evaluate the model accuracy, whereas the computation time is extracted as an indicator for computational effort. Six different transformer prototypes provide the geometries for the comparison. Based on the conducted comparisons, Roth's model is the most accurate. Rogowski's model is the fastest low-error model. Margueron's model is the most versatile as it takes the finite permeability of the core into account. The conducted comparisons lay the foundation for accurate and fast Double-2D modeling of the transformer leakage inductance as it is executed for the two main cross sections of E-core and U-core transformers: inside the transformer window, and outside the transformer window. This article is accompanied by a supplementary document summarizing the equations of Roth's and Margueron's model.