The evaluation of analysis methods for diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) remains challenging due to the lack of gold standards and validation frameworks. Significant work remains in developing metrics for comparing fiber bundles generated from streamline tractography. We propose a set of volumetric and tract oriented measures for evaluating tract differences. The different methodsdeveloped for this assessment work are: an overlap measurement, a point cloud distance and a quantification of the diffusion properties at similar locations between fiber bundles. The application of the measures in this paper is a comparison of atlas generated tractography to tractography generated in individual images. For the validation we used a database of 37 subject DTIs, and applied the measurements on five specific fiber bundles: uncinate, cingulum (left and right for both bundles) and genu. Each measurments is interesting for specific use: the overlap measure presents a simple and comprehensive metric but is sensitive to partial voluming and does not give consistent values depending on the bundle geometry. The point cloud distance associated with a quantile interpretation of the distribution gives a good intuition of how close and similar the bundles are. Finally, the functional difference is useful for a comparison of the diffusion properties since it is the focus of many DTI analysis to compare scalar invariants. The comparison demonstrated reasonable similarity of results. The tract difference measures are also applicable to comparison of tractography algorithms, quality control, reproducibility studies, and other validation problems.
[1]
Ross T. Whitaker,et al.
A Volumetric Approach to Quantifying Region-to-Region White Matter Connectivity in Diffusion Tensor MRI
,
2007,
IPMI.
[2]
Carl-Fredrik Westin,et al.
Nonlinear Registration of Diffusion MR Images Based on Fiber Bundles
,
2007,
MICCAI.
[3]
Paul A. Yushkevich,et al.
Deformable Registration of Diffusion Tensor MR Images with Explicit Orientation Optimization
,
2005,
MICCAI.
[4]
Guido Gerig,et al.
Towards a shape model of white matter fiber bundles using diffusion tensor MRI
,
2004,
2004 2nd IEEE International Symposium on Biomedical Imaging: Nano to Macro (IEEE Cat No. 04EX821).
[5]
Jan Sijbers,et al.
Nonrigid Coregistration of Diffusion Tensor Images Using a Viscous Fluid Model and Mutual Information
,
2007,
IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging.
[6]
Guido Gerig,et al.
Fiber tract-oriented statistics for quantitative diffusion tensor MRI analysis.
,
2006,
Medical image computing and computer-assisted intervention : MICCAI ... International Conference on Medical Image Computing and Computer-Assisted Intervention.
[7]
Marc Niethammer,et al.
Finsler Tractography for White Matter Connectivity Analysis of the Cingulum Bundle
,
2007,
MICCAI.
[8]
Guido Gerig,et al.
Valmet: A New Validation Tool for Assessing and Improving 3D Object Segmentation
,
2001,
MICCAI.
[9]
John H. Gilmore,et al.
Group analysis of DTI fiber tract statistics with application to neurodevelopment
,
2009,
NeuroImage.