Modeling the economics of greenhouse gas mitigation : summary of a workshop

Models are fundamental for estimating the possible costs and effectiveness of different policies for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. There is a wide array of models to perform such analysis, differing in the level of technological detail, treatment of technological progress, spatial and sector details, and representation of the interaction of the energy sector to the overall economy and environment. These differences impact model results, including cost estimates. More fundamentally, these models differ as to how they represent fundamental processes that have a large impact on policy analysis--such as how different models represent technological learning and cost reductions that come through increasing production volumes, or how different models represent baseline conditions. Reliable estimates of the costs and potential impacts on the United States economy of various emissions reduction and other mitigation strategies are critical to the development of the federal climate change research and development portfolio. At the request of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), the National Academies organized a workshop, summarized in this volume, to consider some of these types of modeling issues.

[1]  Karin Ibenholt Explaining learning curves for wind power , 2002 .

[2]  D. Hanson,et al.  Modeling Detailed Energy-Efficiency Technologies and Technology Policies within a CGE Framework , 2006 .

[3]  B. McCarl,et al.  Estimating Leakage from Forest Carbon Sequestration Programs , 2004, Land Economics.

[4]  Simon Buckle,et al.  Mitigation of climate change , 2009, The Daunting Climate Change.

[5]  John P. Weyant,et al.  Issues in modeling induced technological change in energy, environmental, and climate policy , 1999 .

[6]  Phillip F. Ostwald,et al.  Measurement of technology progress and capital cost for nuclear, coal-fired, and gas-fired power plants using the learning curve , 1979 .

[7]  James G. Hewlett Economic and Regulatory Factors Affecting the Maintenance of Nucleaer Power Plants , 1996 .

[8]  P. J. Parks,et al.  Least-Cost Forest Carbon Reserves: Cost-Effective Subsidies to Convert Marginal Agricultural Land to Forests , 1995 .

[9]  Lloyd C. Irland,et al.  Assessing sustainability for global forests: a proposed pathway to fill critical data gaps , 2010, European Journal of Forest Research.

[10]  Patrik Söderholm,et al.  Wind Power in Europe: A Simultaneous Innovation–Diffusion Model , 2007 .

[11]  R. Nelson The Simple Economics of Basic Scientific Research , 1959, Journal of Political Economy.

[12]  R. Beach,et al.  Methane and Nitrous Oxide Mitigation in Agriculture , 2006 .

[13]  Steven Klepper,et al.  The Evolution of New Industries and the Determinants of Market Structure , 1990 .

[14]  M. Wara,et al.  Is the global carbon market working? , 2007, Nature.

[15]  J. Edmonds,et al.  Scenarios of Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Atmospheric Concentrations , 2007 .

[16]  J. S. White EVALUATION OF INNOVATIVE FOSSIL CYCLES INCORPORATING CO2 REMOVAL , 2002 .

[17]  Roger Jones,et al.  Climate scenario development , 2001 .

[18]  Eric Hirst,et al.  Residential energy use: Analysis of disaggregate data☆ , 1982 .

[19]  Wim Turkenburg,et al.  Technological learning in bioenergy systems , 2006 .

[20]  John P. Weyant,et al.  On the sources of technological change: Assessing the evidence , 2006 .

[21]  J. E. Butler,et al.  The History of Progress Functions as a Managerial Technology , 1984, Business History Review.

[22]  S. Roberts,et al.  A rough guide to individual carbon trading - the ideas, the issues and the next steps , 2006 .

[23]  W. Golove,et al.  Market barriers to energy efficiency: A critical reappraisal of the rationale for public policies to promote energy efficiency , 1996 .

[24]  R. Cantor,et al.  The economics of nuclear power: Further evidence on learning, economies of scale, and regulatory effects , 1988 .

[25]  W. Nordhaus Managing the Global Commons: The Economics of Climate Change , 1994 .

[26]  Margaret R. Taylor,et al.  Effect of government actions on technological innovation for SO2 control. , 2003, Environmental science & technology.

[27]  Unfccc Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change , 1997 .

[28]  Alan S. Manne,et al.  On stabilizing CO 2 concentrations — cost-effective emission reduction strategies , 1997 .

[29]  B. Sohngen,et al.  An analysis of forestry carbon sequestration as a response to climate change. , 2009 .

[30]  B. Sohngen,et al.  Economics of Forest Ecosystem Carbon Sinks: A Review , 2007 .

[31]  F. Bass The Relationship between Diffusion Rates, Experience Curves, and Demand Elasticities for Consumer Durable Technological Innovations , 1980 .

[32]  R. Pindyck,et al.  The Learning Curve and Optimal Production Under Uncertainty , 1987 .

[33]  L. Schrattenholzer,et al.  Endogenous technological change in climate change modelling , 1999 .

[34]  J. D. Maxwell,et al.  Evaluation of the advanced low-Nox burner, Exxon, and Hitachi Zosen DeNox processes. Final report Nov 79-Jun 81 , 1981 .

[35]  R. Hahn,et al.  Where Did All the Markets Go? An Analysis of EPA's Emissions Trading Program , 1989 .

[36]  J. M. Callaway,et al.  Minimum Cost Strategies for Sequestering Carbon in Forests , 1999 .

[37]  Joseph H. Eto,et al.  A scoping study on energy-efficiency market transformation by California Utility DSM Programs , 1996 .

[38]  D. Jorgenson,et al.  Cap and trade climate policy and U.S. economic adjustments , 2009 .

[39]  Christopher E. Clarke A Question of Balance , 2008 .

[40]  Ulrika Claeson Colpier Using the experience curve to analyze the cost development of the combined cycle gas turbine , 1999 .

[41]  Jonathan Köhler,et al.  Decarbonizing the Global Economy with Induced Technological Change: Scenarios to 2100 using E3MG , 2006 .

[42]  Socrates Kypreos,et al.  Incorporating different endogenous learning formulations in MERGE , 2003 .

[43]  Lena Neij,et al.  Use of experience curves to analyse the prospects for diffusion and adoption of renewable energy technology , 1997 .

[44]  Kenneth R. Richards,et al.  A Review of Forest Carbon Sequestration Cost Studies: A Dozen Years of Research , 2004 .

[45]  Gerrit Jan Schaeffer Experience curves as policy tool - The case of PV , 2003 .

[46]  Amulya K. N. Reddy,et al.  Barriers to improvements in energy efficiency , 1991 .

[47]  Gerard J Kleywegt,et al.  Déjà vu all over again: finding and analyzing protein structure similarities. , 2004, Structure.

[48]  Gernot Wagner,et al.  Docking into a Global Carbon Market: Clean Investment Budgets to Finance Low-Carbon Economic Development , 2009 .

[49]  David G. Victor,et al.  A Madisonian Approach to Climate Policy , 2005, Science.

[50]  Edward S. Rubin,et al.  Evaluation of potential cost reductions from improved amine-based CO2 capture systems , 2006 .

[51]  A. Jaffe,et al.  The energy-efficiency gap What does it mean? , 1994 .

[52]  Gregory P. Asner,et al.  Tropical forest carbon assessment: integrating satellite and airborne mapping approaches , 2009 .

[53]  T. Iwamura,et al.  Global-scale mapping of economic benefits from agricultural lands: Implications for conservation priorities , 2007 .

[54]  Richard G. Newell,et al.  Energy-Efficient Technologies and Climate Change Policies: Issues and Evidence , 1999 .

[55]  Martin Weiss,et al.  Market diffusion, technological learning, and cost-benefit dynamics of condensing gas boilers in the Netherlands , 2009 .

[56]  Leonardo Barreto,et al.  Emission trading and the role of learning-by-doing spillovers in the "bottom-up" energy-system ERIS model , 2004 .

[57]  Edward S. Rubin,et al.  The Effect of Government Actions on Environmental Technology Innovation: Applications to the Integrated Assessment of Carbon Sequestration Technologies , 2004 .

[58]  B. Sohngen,et al.  The optimal choice of residue management, crop rotations, and cost of carbon sequestration: empirical results in the Midwest US , 2010 .

[59]  Robert Stavins,et al.  Linkage of Tradable Permit Systems in International Climate Policy Architecture , 2008 .

[60]  David Wheeler,et al.  Less Smoke, More Mirrors: Where India Really Stands on Solar Power and Other Renewables , 2010 .

[61]  John M. Reilly,et al.  Human-induced climate change : an interdisciplinary assessment , 2007 .

[62]  Michael E. Green,et al.  Technological Optimism , 1982, IEEE Technology and Society Magazine.

[63]  Robert N. Stavins,et al.  The Costs of Carbon Sequestration: A Revealed-Preference Approach , 1999 .

[64]  S. Sorrell The Evidence for Direct Rebound Effects , 2009 .

[65]  Dennis Anderson,et al.  Induced Technical Change in Energy and Environmental Modeling: Analytic Approaches and Policy Implications , 2002 .

[66]  Kenneth L. Denman Canada Couplings between changes in the climate system and biogeochemistry , 2008 .

[67]  Wesley M. Cohen,et al.  What's Experience Got to Do With It? Sources of Cost Reduction in a Large Specialty Chemicals Producer , 2000 .

[68]  C. L. Benkard Learning and Forgetting: the Dynamics of Aircraft Production , 1999 .

[69]  P. Thompson,et al.  Learning from Experience and Learning from Others: An Exploration of Learning and Spillovers in Wartime Shipbuilding , 2001 .

[70]  Edward S. Rubin,et al.  Use of experience curves to estimate the future cost of power plants with CO2 capture , 2007 .

[71]  John M. Antle,et al.  Estimating the economic potential for agricultural soil carbon sequestration in the Central United States using an aggregate econometric-process simulation model , 2007 .

[72]  Chihiro Watanabe,et al.  Industrial dynamism and the creation of a “virtuous cycle” between R&D, market growth and price reduction: The case of photovoltaic power generation (PV) development in Japan , 2000 .

[73]  Ernst R. Berndt,et al.  The Practice of Econometrics: Classic and Contemporary. , 1992 .

[74]  W. Patterson Nuclear Power , 1976 .

[75]  L. Lipper,et al.  Climate Change Mitigation Measures in the Agro-forestry Sector and Biodiversity Futures Abatement and Transaction Costs of Carbon-sink Projects Involving Smallholders Abatement and Transaction Costs of Carbon-sink Projects Involving Smallholders , 2022 .

[76]  Stelios Kafandaris,et al.  Buying Greenhouse Insurance: The Economic Costs of CO2 Emission Limits , 1992 .

[77]  Robert N. Stavins,et al.  Land-Use Change and Carbon Sinks: Econometric Estimation of the Carbon Sequestration Supply Function , 2005 .

[78]  Mark Peters,et al.  Economics of Sequestering Carbon in the U.S. Agricultural Sector , 2004 .

[79]  Hadi Dowlatabadi,et al.  A REVIEW OF TECHNICAL CHANGE IN ASSESSMENT OF CLIMATE POLICY , 1999 .

[80]  P. Romer Endogenous Technological Change , 1989, Journal of Political Economy.

[81]  O. Lucon,et al.  Ethanol learning curve—the Brazilian experience , 2004 .

[82]  Sandra Brown,et al.  Measuring leakage from carbon projects in open economies: a stop timber harvesting project in Bolivia as a case study , 2004 .

[83]  Louis E. Yelle THE LEARNING CURVE: HISTORICAL REVIEW AND COMPREHENSIVE SURVEY , 1979 .

[84]  Mark Jaccard,et al.  Modeling the cost of climate policy: Distinguishing between alternative cost definitions and long-run cost dynamics , 2003 .

[85]  Wesley M. Cohen,et al.  Firm Size and the Nature of Innovation within Industries: The Case of Process and Product R&D , 1996 .

[86]  Jean-Pascal van Ypersele de Strihou,et al.  Towards New Scenarios for Analysis of Emissions, Climate Change, Impacts, and Response Strategies , 2008 .

[87]  C. C. von Weizsäcker,et al.  Tentative Notes on a Two Sector Model with Induced Technical Progress , 1966 .

[88]  Pau Klein,et al.  San Francisco, California , 2007 .

[89]  Richard G. Newell,et al.  Modeling endogenous technological change for climate policy analysis , 2008 .

[90]  V. Ruttan Technology, Growth, and Development: An Induced Innovation Perspective , 2000 .

[91]  A. Grainger Difficulties in tracking the long-term global trend in tropical forest area , 2008, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[92]  R. Baron,et al.  Sectoral Market Mechanisms: Issues for Negotiation and Domestic Implementation , 2009 .

[93]  B. Sohngen,et al.  An Optimal Control Model of Forest Carbon Sequestration , 2003 .

[94]  Arnulf Grubler,et al.  A Model of Endogenous Technological Change Through Uncertain Returns on Learning (R&D and Investments) , 1997 .

[95]  H. Asher Cost-quantity relationships in the airframe industry , 1956 .

[96]  Steven Klepper,et al.  The Making of an Oligopoly: Firm Survival and Technological Change in the Evolution of the U.S. Tire Industry , 2000, Journal of Political Economy.

[97]  A. Skopp Fluid Bed Studies of the Limestone Based Flue Gas Desulfurization Process , 1969 .

[98]  Ulrika Claeson Colpier,et al.  The economics of the combined cycle gas turbine - an experience curve analysis , 2002 .

[99]  John M. Antle,et al.  Spatial heterogeneity, contract design, and the efficiency of carbon sequestration policies for agriculture , 2003 .

[100]  Sergey Paltsev,et al.  The cost of climate policy in the United States , 2009 .

[101]  S. Kypreos,et al.  CO2 Emission Control In Switzerland Using Mathematical Programming , 1992 .

[102]  B. Fine New Growth Theory , 2003 .

[103]  Edward S. Rubin,et al.  Experience curves for power plant emission control technologies , 2004 .

[104]  C. Wene,et al.  Energy Technology Learning Through Deployment in Competitive Markets , 2008 .

[105]  M. Spence,et al.  Learning Curve Spillovers and Market Performance , 1985 .

[106]  F. Ferioli,et al.  Use and limitations of learning curves for energy technology policy: A component-learning hypothesis , 2009 .

[107]  David G. Victor,et al.  The Collapse of the Kyoto Protocol and the Struggle to Slow Global Warming , 2001 .

[108]  Patrik Söderholm,et al.  Empirical challenges in the use of learning curves for assessing the economic prospects of renewable energy technologies , 2007 .

[109]  Derek Vollmer Assessing Economic Impacts of Greenhouse Gas Mitigation: Summary of a Workshop , 2009 .

[110]  Henry D. Jacoby,et al.  Integrated Global System Model for Climate Policy Assessment: Feedbacks and Sensitivity Studies , 1999 .

[111]  Maya Papineau,et al.  An economic perspective on experience curves and dynamic economies in renewable energy technologies , 2006 .

[112]  B. Sohngen,et al.  Set-asides for carbon sequestration: implications for permanence and leakage , 2009 .

[113]  Nebojsa Nakicenovic,et al.  Developing and applying scenarios , 2001 .

[114]  Socrates Kypreos,et al.  Emissions trading and technology deployment in an energy-systems "bottom-up" model with technology learning , 2004, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[115]  William D. Nordhaus,et al.  Modeling Induced Innovation in Climate Change Policy , 2002 .

[116]  Valentina Bosetti,et al.  Forestry and the Carbon Market Response to Stabilize Climate , 2007 .

[117]  Aviel Verbruggen,et al.  Barriers , Opportunities , and Market Potential of Technologies and Practices , 2001 .

[118]  Fatih Birol,et al.  Technical Change Theory and Learning Curves : Patterns of Progress in Electricity Generation Technologies , 2007 .

[119]  David Popp,et al.  Entice: Endogenous Technological Change in the Dice Model of Global Warming , 2003 .

[120]  Gang He,et al.  Making Carbon Offsets Work in the Developing World: Lessons from the Chinese Wind Controversy , 2010 .

[121]  William A. Levinson CLIMATE-CHANGE LEGISLATION , 2006 .

[122]  Martin T. Ross,et al.  U.S. climate mitigation pathways post-2012: Transition scenarios in ADAGE , 2009 .

[123]  Edward S. Rubin,et al.  A centurial history of technological change and learning curves for pulverized coal-fired utility boilers , 2007 .

[124]  Thomas Mauldin,et al.  An Econometric Analysis of the Costs of Sequestering Carbon in Forests , 1999 .

[125]  B. Sohngen,et al.  Extending timber rotations: carbon and cost implications , 2008 .

[126]  Stewart J. Cohen,et al.  Making local futures tangible - synthesizing, downscaling, and visualizing climate change scenarios for participatory capacity building. , 2009 .

[127]  Donald A. Hanson,et al.  An integrated analysis of policies that increase investments in advanced energy-efficient/low-carbon technologies , 2004 .

[128]  T. Kram,et al.  Endogenous learning and technology clustering: analysis with MARKAL model of the Western European energy system , 2000 .

[129]  Richard G. Newell,et al.  Environmental and Technology Policies for Climate Mitigation , 2008 .

[130]  R. Benedick Ozone Diplomacy: New Directions in Safeguarding the Planet , 1991 .

[131]  William D. Nordhaus,et al.  The Perils of the Learning Model for Modeling Endogenous Technological Change , 2009 .

[132]  Thomas Henrichs,et al.  Linking scenarios across geographical scales in international environmental assessments , 2007 .

[133]  N. H. Ravindranath,et al.  The Copenhagen accord. , 2010 .

[134]  R. Sturm,et al.  Nuclear power in Eastern Europe: Learning or forgetting curves? , 1993 .

[135]  D. Jorgenson Technology in growth theory , 1996 .

[136]  Ernst Worrell,et al.  Productivity benefits of industrial energy efficiency measures , 2003 .

[137]  D. Victor Post-Kyoto International Climate Policy: Climate accession deals: new strategies for taming growth of greenhouse gases in developing countries , 2009 .

[138]  J. Dutton,et al.  Treating Progress Functions as a Managerial Opportunity , 1984 .

[139]  B. McCarl,et al.  Permanence discounting for land-based carbon sequestration , 2008 .

[140]  A. Manne,et al.  On stabilizing CO2 concentrations – cost‐effective emission reduction strategies , 1997 .

[141]  Evelina M. Tainer National Income and Product Accounts , 2012 .

[142]  B. Sohngen,et al.  Human-Induced Climate Change: A sensitivity analysis of forest carbon sequestration , 2007 .

[143]  Ari Rabl,et al.  Prospects for PV: a learning curve analysis , 2003 .

[144]  S. Rose,et al.  Global forest carbon sequestration and climate policy design , 2011, Environment and Development Economics.

[145]  J. Sathaye,et al.  Bottom-up Representation of Industrial Energy Efficiency Technologies in Integrated Assessment Models for the Cement Sector , 2011 .

[146]  Allen A. Fawcett,et al.  The structural effects of cap and trade climate policy , 2009 .

[147]  P. Ramchandani,et al.  A question of balance , 2004, Nature.

[148]  N. Stanietsky,et al.  The interaction of TIGIT with PVR and PVRL2 inhibits human NK cell cytotoxicity , 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[149]  M. Bell,et al.  The mythology of learning-by-doing in World War II airframe and ship production , 2010 .

[150]  Douglas W. Dwyer,et al.  A Bayesian Learning Model Fitted to a Variety of Empirical Learning Curves , 1995 .

[151]  Robert N. Stavins,et al.  Land-Use Change and Carbon Sinks: Econometric Estimation of the Carbon Sequestration Supply Function , 2001 .

[152]  C. Kling,et al.  Efficiency of Sequestering Carbon in Agricultural Soils (The) , 2000 .

[153]  Margaret R. Taylor The influence of government actions on innovative activities in the development of environmental technologies to control sulfur dioxide emissions from stationary sources , 2001 .

[154]  L. Argote Organizational Learning: Creating, Retaining and Transferring Knowledge , 1999 .

[155]  Margaret R. Taylor,et al.  Control of SO2 emissions from power plants: A case of induced technological innovation in the U.S. , 2005 .

[156]  F Ferioli,et al.  Learning in times of change: a dynamic explanation for technological progress. , 2009, Environmental science & technology.

[157]  Asami Miketa,et al.  The impact of R&D on innovation for wind energy in Denmark, Germany and the United Kingdom , 2005 .

[158]  E. N. Lawrence Clean Air Act , 1971, Nature.

[159]  Alan Meier,et al.  Supply Curves of Conserved Energy , 1982 .

[160]  D. G. Chapel,et al.  Recovery of CO 2 from Flue Gases : Commercial Trends , 2001 .

[161]  André Caillé Deciding the Future: Energy Policy Scenarios to 2050 , 2007 .

[162]  Robert J. Moulton,et al.  Costs of sequestering carbon through tree planting and forest management in the United States , 1990 .

[163]  D. King,et al.  Feasibility and economics of by-product CO/sub 2/ supply for enhanced oil recovery. Final report , 1982 .

[164]  R. F. Hughes,et al.  The Kyoto protocol and payments for tropical forest: An interdisciplinary method for estimating carbon-offset supply and increasing the feasibility of a carbon market under the CDM , 2000 .

[165]  G. Meehl,et al.  A strategy for climate change stabilization experiments , 2007 .

[166]  Edward A. Parson,et al.  Protecting the Ozone Layer: Science and Strategy , 2003 .

[167]  Lena Neij,et al.  Experience curves for wind power , 2004 .

[168]  Robert J. Nicholls,et al.  Climate and socio-economic scenarios for global-scale climate change impacts assessments: characterising the SRES storylines , 2004 .

[169]  Andrew J. McAloon,et al.  Understanding the reductions in US corn ethanol production costs: an experience curve approach , 2009 .

[170]  Ian McCallum,et al.  Predicting the deforestation-trend under different carbon-prices , 2006, Carbon balance and management.

[171]  A. B. Rao,et al.  A technical, economic, and environmental assessment of amine-based CO2 capture technology for power plant greenhouse gas control. , 2002 .

[172]  Lowe Bryan William,et al.  Studies on the telegraphic language: The acquisition of a hierarchy of habits. , 1899 .

[173]  Gregory F. Nemet,et al.  Beyond the learning curve: factors influencing cost reductions in photovoltaics , 2006 .

[174]  Martin Kumar Patel,et al.  A review of experience curve analyses for energy demand technologies , 2010 .

[175]  P. Waggoner,et al.  Forest inventories: discrepancies and uncertainties. , 2009 .

[176]  D. Jorgenson,et al.  The Economic Costs of a Market-based Climate Policy , 2008 .

[177]  S. Rose,et al.  The Opportunity Cost of Land Use and the Global Potential for Greenhouse Gas Mitigation in Agriculture and Forestry , 2006, GTAP Working Paper.

[178]  K. Arrow Economic Welfare and the Allocation of Resources for Invention , 1962 .

[179]  Edward S. Rubin,et al.  Technological Learning for Carbon Capture and Sequestration Technologies , 2004 .

[180]  Socrates Kypreos,et al.  Endogenizing R&D and Market Experience in the "Bottom-Up" Energy-Systems ERIS Model , 2004 .

[181]  John F. B. Mitchell,et al.  The next generation of scenarios for climate change research and assessment , 2010, Nature.

[182]  Michael Obersteiner,et al.  Global cost estimates of reducing carbon emissions through avoided deforestation , 2008, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[183]  Scott J. Goetz,et al.  New Satellites Help Quantify Carbon Sources and Sinks , 2008 .

[184]  T. P. Wright,et al.  Factors affecting the cost of airplanes , 1936 .

[185]  Brian C. Murray,et al.  Economic consequences of consideration of permanence, leakage and additionality for soil carbon sequestration projects , 2007 .

[186]  Colleen V. Chien Race to the Bottom , 2012 .

[187]  Irene Peters,et al.  Incorporating Behavioural, Social, and Organizational Phenomena in the Assessment of Climate Change Mitigation Options , 2000 .

[188]  Alan S. Manne,et al.  Learn-by-doing and carbon dioxide abatement , 2004 .

[189]  Andrea Gregg,et al.  Learning From Doing: Lessons Learned From Designing and Developing an Educational Software Within a Heterogeneous Group , 2021, Int. J. Web Based Learn. Teach. Technol..

[190]  K. Arrow The Economic Implications of Learning by Doing , 1962 .

[191]  Paul L. Joskow,et al.  The Effects of Technological Change, Experience, and Environmental Regulation on the Construction Cost of Coal-Burning Generating Units , 1985 .

[192]  K. Schoots,et al.  Learning curves for hydrogen production technology: An assessment of observed cost reductions , 2008 .

[193]  Edward S. Rubin,et al.  Towards fossil-based electricity systems with integrated CO2 capture: Implications of an illustrative long-term technology policy , 2005 .